Do you tell your parents your exact salary?

I recently switched jobs in Bangalore, earning about 1L per month. I've used all my savings to build a house for my parents, and they keep asking my exact salary to decide how much I should send monthly, including construction and maintenance costs. My father wants us to construct the home in less than 2 years without any loan, using cash from our salaries. They keep asking me to either send a fixed amount monthly --------------------------
Continued

likesmartfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I have a home loan where my parents and my younger brother family stays.... I am in Bangalore on rent....And my complete family knows my monthly take home....

1. No Parents and Family are the same so it would be fair for anyone to advise you on such a anonymous portal

2. If family needs your support you should do to what extent possible.

3. There is no harm in sharing your salary with your parents they have the right to know.

4. If you feel you are contributing more towards your parents and less for yourself, then explain your situation to your parents and tell them exactly what you can do for them.

#Note: Your Parents raise you and if they are asking for monthly expenses then it's not wrong, they have the right to ask you for this.

like

I had the exact same mentality and mindset before I got married. Because till then I had never seen how toxic and manipulative parents can be ....
My spouse's parents changed my entire idea or idolisation of parenthood ....
If 90% parents are good and real parents , there are atleast 10% parents who are highly toxic . Parents who consider children as fixed deposits in banks and tell that so. Parents who hold the child against each and every penny spent on them till 18 yrs .... And demands it back with 200% interest....
So please don't advise if you have seen only the good part of the world like I had seen till late 20s...
After that I have seen both boys and girls parents in different situations and families to be extremely toxic , greedy and emotionally abusive ....
The world has all type . Let the OP decide the course as per his/her parents type.

like

My grandparents always asked my father for the exact salary. My father used to send money home every month, which was used for the education of my uncle and aunt (my father's younger brother and sister). Grandparents even upgraded the family home at my Village with the help of my father's salary.

Years later my father lost his job and none of his business hustle worked out for him. No one in my entire family neither my grandparents nor my uncle came ahead to help us. For almost a decade we struggled with our daily bills. My mother didn't buy decent clothes neither did I during this period. We lived in such small house which use to leak in rainy season and heat eas unbearable in summers.

All families are not as honest and nice as they should be ideally.
Learn my father's mistake and save for your well being as well.

likesmart

I had a Bangladeshi colleague who went through a similar situation and finally fell into deep depression!
Eldest in the brood of 6 children , he worked outside the country from a very young age. Started doing odd jobs before rising to a respectable position and salary in a coveted western country. Used to sent everything home for family . After all siblings' marriage and stuff he used to sent money in the assumption his parents are building home and creating assets back in their hometown .
They did so, but not for him. His money , but his parents put everything in his younger brother name . He didn't even marry while the younger bro married , gave birth to a brood and finally ousted him from the home .

like
Recent IconRecent

or directly pay for the house construction expenses. They won't cover my marriage expenses or my brother's (who doesn't have a good job). My father fears stop giving them money once have debts. To be honest, came to Bangalore to escape their daily quarrels and my father's toxic, controlling behavior. They keep asking my exact salary; I know it's a trap. Feels like shouldn't have been born.

like

I was in the same situation, spent close to 50 lakhs in the construction of house for my parents. This gave me a financial blow and ruined all my early retirement plans but the smile on their faces is priceless and worth dedicating few years of my life. But few suggestions to keep monetary things in your control, just don't send a lumpsum amount every month rather tell them to get you in touch with contractor or the sellers and pay directly online. Plan your expenses in advance and don't feel embarassed to say no when you are loosing your financial control.
They are also getting old and scared of their financial instability as they are hearing all sorts of news like children abandoned their parents and so on, keep open conversation and try to understand their point of view.
If you still feel any toxicity, it's your money so blindly say no and ask them to stay with you or stay on rent.

like

Stop thinking so much and give a fake number that suites your interest

likeuplifting

Just say it is 60k, your rent and expenses will go around 25 k..and you can send around 35k monthly. It should not be a problem.

After your parents, the house is going to be yours and your brothers anyways. If you can have that conversation now it will be better to say it upfront what percent each will own . Because your brother is not contributing same as you.But based on what you have said looks like your father won't be in a mood to listen .
Just say a fake salary which you can afford to send. Even show a fake salary slip if they ask.
Save up your remaining.

likeuplifting

I think this is best advice

like

This u r personal..how we can involve u need to handle on u r own...

likefunny

That's why it was asked in a anonymous platform

like

When I started working, I didn't know the scenario and told my mom my exact salary. She then proceeded to take everything and give me an allowance for my daily commute. Me being a girl and my house being conservative, I am not allowed to have social life, so only commute costs are allowed.

Not just this, she also shared my salary package to my whole extended family and distant relatives. They knew all about our finances.

Eventually, I couldn't survive it. So after 13 years my solution is to tell her a lesser figure and still let her give me allowance out of it. Sometimes you can't win people. You just survive by doing whatever you can without hurting them and most importantly, yourself.

likesmart

Just stating my position after 13 years.. didn't take that long to figure out the solution. Possibly 5 years is all it took.

like

Never tell the exact salary to parents or family otherwise they expect more from you. Even if you don't have money they will think you are ambani. If they are asking or anybody asked just tell them it's around 50 or 60k. Trust me I am telling you from real life experience.

like

Don't agree at all to this !

Hey don't think too much, I also faced the same situation in the past. Parents are not aware of the financial situation of the market, they think if said 1L means 1L. They don't know the taxes behind it, they don't know your own expenses, they don't know your own planning for the future.

Do one thing either clearly talk to them about what is going on in your mind, tell them that you are earning this much but according to the current market situation this is the standard and it also includes 30% tax. Tell them you want to save money for your future plans. Tell them salaries have been raised directly proportional to inflation, that means 5 years ago if the avg salary for a person was 40K, now it is 70K or 80K. Well this all will be too much of a headache to deal with and I also don't know your parents mindset. So I don't know how impactful this thought is going to be.

Second and the best option in my opinion tell them you are getting 60k in your account after all deductions.
I'm getting around 2.5 in my account and note down my suggestion don't expose your actual salary to anyone not even to your shadow. If you don't want to regret it in the future. As much as people will get to know they will automatically start making their mind that this person is gone be helpful or he is earning that much so he should help me. After all you might be a son, brother, friend, husband .... etc for them.

like

I will suggest you to try looking out for onsite opportunities and then never return back .
Meanwhile,you can also give money to build their house.

likefunny

You can claim any house which is your own by rights via property lawyers ,you don't have to come back to the country.
That's how a lot of multi millionaire are handling it .

like

Just one word, “Don’t “
My parents took around 20 lakhs from me to renovate the family house , 2 years later they gave it away to my younger brother who wasn’t even earning but had debts , I got 0 rs back from them

likesmart

You can tell your parents your exact salary only if they are not toxic and only selfishly thinking about themselves. If they are utilising your salary to safeguard your future , please go ahead . Else NO.
Initially we used to tell our both sides family each and every financial earning . What it entailed was my spouse's parents ALWAYS asking for more and more money . When their home needs are fulfilled they wasted that money on clothes or on relatives.
Even now we have to take care of 3 elderly relatives along with both set of parents.
My in laws have not invested or utilized in any asset any of our money rather my mother in law spent lakhs in own sarees and another 10 L for her side of family members when we were living off on personal loans and abject poverty in Bangalore with not having money for public transport also ( after joint earning close to 50-60L ) !!! The situation is still 70% same.
They take money every month from spouse and waste that. Never utilise their own pension ( 60 kpm) and takes money from spouse for daily needs.
After a lot of fights I have been able to stop telling my earnings to in laws . Spouse still tell everything but it's spouse side . And I have stopped giving money from my earnings for them to waste .
My inlaws had demanded for spouse not to marry , never wanted us to have kids as that would dry up the money flow for them to waste.
You need to understand your parents type and decide accordingly.
There is a difference between responsibility and dancing to the tune of selfish toxic manipulative parents .
Those who have not seen toxic parents will never understand this.

like

How does it matter ? One of my friends has 70% similar situation and that's a opposite gender thus family role than myself. Toxic parents can be of any gender's .
I specifically omitted that to remove any bias from the reader.

like

My parents never asked me my salary or package. It’s upto you if you want to share with them. You should also plan for your future along with the house construction. May be you can set a fix amount that will go to your parents from your salary and remaining amount you decide where to invest and save

like

They way Vodafone is calling out by using words like shame on you on for trying to hide salary with your family/parents seems like he/ she will grow up to be nosy parents and demand their kids to tell their full true income and spend lavishly on them as a return gift for raising the kids

like

That's why parents consider giving birth to boy as future investment

like

I agree there are many parents who think like that . And it's highly highly toxic. I cannot even began to start on where all its wrong .
Especially boys born eldest to such mentality parents. GOD !!! They are truly cursed ....
On the other hand let me tell you this is very much people and mentality specific.
Some would sell their kidney willingly and lovingly instead of bothering their son for stuff that he needs to bother about . I have seen parents like that too.
And on the other hand are these type. For them even if they doesn't get an eldest son they will make do with the sole Son or the eldest daughter. Whoever they can put up at the sacrificial alter.
With my very close cousin , I have seen this happening with the youngest son even because the youngest son was the high earning engineer while the eldest is good for nothing .
After the parents it was the eldest sons wife who still continued with the emotional manipulation and abuse till the youngest sons death . As a result the youngest became the most hated in his own family of wife and kids , an emotion that didn't change even after his death.
The eldest son & his wife , son still illegally occupies and earns from the younger brother's property!

likesmart

Start deducting 15% voluntary pf from your salary and tell them 20% less from your in hand salary. Never let them know about your bonus if you are getting one. And rest you can also show some fake expenses every month.

like

My father's a small business owner , by this I mean he's a very practical person and knows really well how to save money and I am also in a similar situation. This year we have to get our house built without any loan and also I have to get married by next year's March and I want to fund it completely even if I have to take a small loan for it(my father is against loan, he says he will manage).

I earn as much as you do. But I don't share my actual salary , I have lied to him that I earn around 65k after I switched. And I don't see anything wrong with it.

Reason being it's my money to manage , not my parents'also. I should also learn how to do that.
And my parents don't understand my expenses. I love to travel and If I tell them how much I spend on travelling , it will become a daily quarrel. Why do I want to travel , it's difficult to make them understand cause they never spend money on their wishes , so they won't understand. Alongside I am saving money for my marriage also.
I have been doing it for 3 years and it's going well for me.

And taking care of my parents, I plan to make my father retire after 5 years. I am a girl and no matter where I am, I will take care of their livelihoods.

You can tell your parents that you earn less, keep 20-30k , decide on this amount, and next time you switch, tell accordingly. It might help you. NO GUILTS. There's no problem.

likesmart

Dont tell the correct number, Always say less and say you are in debt in case if you feel like that.
Toxic parents need to be handled delicately.
Its better to not tell the exact number.

like

Would suggest to give a less numbered salary. So u can send a less or ok amount.
Save some money for your own.

Tell them the expenses also, mostly rent and cost of living.

like

Your Salary, Your Business, Your Money, Your Savings, Your Revenue. All these words start with "Your" which means it's Yours and it belongs to Yours. No one has any right on it, nor someone can demand it from you. All anyone can do is Request and Seek from you by your permission. You want to tell someone how much you earn or not is up to you. How safe you feel around them. Whoever the person may be. But After All being said, Remember you are a Human, born from a Human and Will give birth to a Human, and Live in relationship with Humans, So you are obliged to spend on each relationship appropriately and Humanely. Nothing else. Someone else is building the house, Someone else is having trouble, You ain't feeling to give lumsums for their Debts, all these are completely your decisions to carry forward. Remember to be Responsible with Money. I see a lot of people being careless and reckless with money. Don't be among them. Treat Money like your Good friend whom you don't wanna lose, cause it will help you in times when you need. Otherwise we all know what relatives & friends come up with when we are in need.

upliftingsmart

I understand. If you think they are narcissistic, then tell them exactly how you feel and reduce contact. May be allot some 20-25k and the rest Tell them you want to purchase a house in Bangalore or are saving up for your marriage or the future. If they are not narcs, they treat you well but are just in need of money to May be fulfill a dream or want that house for your security, it they think along those lines, that could mean they want it for your future and they love you, in that case you could give more but it all comes down to your choice. Your mental peace is most important.

like

Leave your father buddy.Your mom is in a toxic relationship.Run for your life.

like

Related Posts

Why cant we trade UWMC right now???

like

What are some books that have absolutely helped you either working in the investment management space or even just personal investing?

like

Does anyone have family members who constantly demand money because they feel like you’re rich now because you’re a lawyer? I’ve always wanted to be in a position to help my family but we all live in the high COL city so my salary doesn’t carry me as far as it would elsewhere. I’ve given a detailed summary of all of my expenses yet every month one family member in particular comes to me for rent money (not some, the full amount, and they refuse to get a job). It has become quite the burden.

like

Why do people accrue prepaid expenses?

I heard from my head that there is a lot of slowdown in VW Germany... There is Hiring freeze, level freeze and all ... And soon that will spillover to india. So be prepared for very less hikes in coming cycle :( Also automotive sector in general is struggling with tesla laying off 10% workforce recently. Maybe time to make a move? What do you say fishes?

like

I have 3 yrs of experience in Java, Springboot, Microservices, have cleared all rounds in Deloitte and KPMG, i'm asked to send required documents, I have 10.5lpa offer in hand, can I ask 11.5 lpa saying I have so and so offer in hand....?
Will they give that much?

like

Current:
15 LPA for 11 years experience
Brand & Marketing Role - Edutech industry

How do I scale up? And where do I need to be? How do I make it happen without switching jobs?

Hi Friends,

I am in discussion with MNC Service based organization based out of Sweden and wanted to know the salary I can expect. Although they have dropped a hint of around 45000 SEK per month.

I am an Oracle SQL and PL/SQL developer with around 10 years of experience and my CTC in India is around 32 LPA.....

like

I got an offer of 10.4 LPA (fixed) + 70K joining bonus from Amdocs, later received an offer of 13 LPA (fixed) + 1L joining bonus from another organisation. But I'm willing to join Amdocs.
Does Amdocs considers counter offer to renegotiate the offer amount?
YoE: 2.4
Role: UI Developer
Tech: ReactJs

helpful

Trying to get some insight (for comparison purposes) regarding the starting salary for a newly minted JD/LLM role Grant Thornton Baker Tilly RSM and like firm
Location/service line will do.

like

Guys, I had very less HRA for April 2022 till August 2022. I was showing 1 lac annual rent .I joined new organisation in sept and now HRA is 43000 per month. Would that be okay to show high rent as 30000 per month to my wife as landlord. Earlier I was paying 9000 rs per month to different landlord. @ IBM

like

Wha t‘s the average bonus for director in transaction tax group?

What salary range should I ask for senior engineer role in tiger analytics ?

like

I am investing as a beginner. What is a good company to start a brokerage account with ? Fidelity, Ameri E Trade, ML? I’m looking to put my money in index funds.

like

That Carlos Matos Bitconnect video still makes me laugh.. hope everyone stayed away from anything that tried to combine crypto and lending.

Best ETF to invest in? I’m 24 looking to invest about $50k and don’t know where to put it. Nothing that’s super high cost or risky please

like

UHG vs Legato, which will be a better company to join for similar package?

like

What is the standard salary range for a full time, staff senior producer at an agency? NYC

Hey, how often do we get hikes in EXL? And average hike?

like

Im ready to take a pay cut t this point to get my life back.

like

More Posts

Why do clients always think I should be able to double their ROI right away... it takes time folks, and putting extra pressure on the marketing team does not make us faster

like

Lately I’ve been seriously considering making the transition to product marketing. Current PMMs please weigh in — on average, how many hours do you actively work in a day?

like

Wondering if anyone can share the approximate timeline after applying to Target Corp. to hearing something from them. Applied 9/1 and on the applicant portal the status still says “in progress.” I got a great internal referral, but I’ve not reached out to the hiring manager. 😬 I know there were a few hundred applicants — what’s a realistic timeline and what could I say to the hiring manager if I reach out to them. Many thanks.

like

Im 21, recently got a project manager job in a big media group, I still have about one year to do in my degree. Where would you recommend I take my career next, what would be the logical next jobs I could explore in that field?

like

Honest question, Democrats always complain about the economy and that Trump is doing a bad job. I’m a little confused how they then support Biden who will repeal the Trump tax cuts? Pls no hostility

like

I have a wee crush on one of the partners in my firm and I thought he liked me too, but neither of us did anything about it (which is entirely appropriate). That was all pre-Rona. Now I’m leaving the firm and pursuing another opportunity and staying in the same city. Since he’ll no longer be my boss, is there a way to find out if my feeling was correct? How should I go about this? (Especially given Rona?)

like

Have a really good relationship with current company, but got an amazing offer and very likely gonna leave (signed the offer, waiting for all the background checks to come back). How do you tell your boss you are leaving the company (if boss is not a dick lol) and not ruin relationship?

like

I'm a cashier. We just got a new manager, and she's making things really hard for us. She starts work at 4:30am and leaves around 2:30pm, but she still expects us to stay until 6pm and work on the weekends! She gives us really long shifts and doesn't give us much time for breaks. And when we ask her about it, she gets mad.

I'm worried that if I speak up, she'll make my life even harder. I don't want to lose my job because of this—do you guys have any advice?

like

Family member saw me working out hard and called me a "retard" for pushing myself being at max speed and "making faces". Seriously? When you push hard, it's supposed to be - hard. No?

like

I need contacts who are into bank instrument and MT103 transfers within USA and Europe. If you are a good sender or receiver let me know.

like

When are promotions due in ACs

like

I feel special.

Post Photo
likeuplifting

She loves blankets doesn’t care it is 90 plus she will burrow. At night she is under the covers on my leg breathing heavy lol

Post Photo
likefunny

I am leaning towards declining a role change that comes with a 1-2 level bump for less stress (no daily/weekly firedrills) and not having to work 55+ weeks..known for fixing problem areas...ughh

like

Is there any advice for networking into projects when you don’t know many people at the firm yet? I always to help on BD work when I’m on the bench, but it never turns into any billable work. Every time I have talked to a partner/senior manager I was told I don’t have the skill set they’re looking for, but I don’t know how to build up from there. Feeing very lost but I want to improve my approach.

likehelpful

How much discretionary cash do you keep around?

like

IB Analyst, want to move banks. Searching via my contacts but want to expand my network with cold outreach. Should I reach out to MD's or VP/Directors?

like

Can someone connect me to a business analyst role that doesn’t require a ton of prior business analyst experience? I have ~1.5 YOE in valuation (modeling, financial statement analysis) and am looking to make a switch. Mainly looking for a role with less hours than I’m currently working (60-70). Thank you I’m advance

like

Does having a CVA (certified valuation analyst) useful? have heard mixed reviews

like

Additional Posts in Consulting India

Hi guys,
I received an offer from TCS a year back and I had accepted the offer but didn't join them.
But few days back I got a call from TCS and got selected in the technical rounds.
HR discussion is yet to happen, will they consider my candidature as I had accepted the offer once and didn't join them?

If anyone who joined TCS with this scenario, please confirm. Then I'll keep hope.

Tata Consultancy Services TCS

like

Can anyone please tell me what exactly they are asking and the reason? I want to transfer PF amount from previous company's PF to current PF. They are asking to file grievance against my first employer and share EPS Annexure K.

Post Photo
like

Is anyone travelling from Mumbai to Pune?
If Yes, Meri Activa Padi hai Mumbai me lete aaoge kya drive karke? Please 🥺🙏🏻.

funnylike

globallogic vs publicis sapient.

which one to choose ?

like

Guys I received a revised offer letter from XYZ MNC, in this offer letter they have mentioned "Agreeing to terms and conditions in the workforce of iTap is as good as signing of physical contract form on mutual agreement between you and company. It has legal binding as per law if mutual trust is breached."

Currently am not planning this company, but will this impact me anyway legally? Please consult

How is work culture, WLB, job security in OFSS(Oracle Financial Services Software)?
How about perks and benefits?
Got an offer of 21 LPA fixed with total YOE 6.10.
Hired for the role of PL/SQL and Java developer in product development team.

Hii.. i had my Director round Deloitte India. After thisi got call from HR regarding salary expectation. Is there any more round exist?

Is it ok to show just a snapshot of the compensation (Salary Breakup) which I have received from another employer to my current employer if they ask me in order for them to match or better that offer? I am not comfortable sharing the entire offer letter basically, is it ok for me to not provide that?

like

Hi Fishes, what should i get paid with below technologies

.net core
Mvc
Vb net
Vue js
Knockout js
Chart js
Sql server
Api
Wcf services
C#
Azure basics
6 yoe

What is the CTC of Senior Consultant in EY after promotion?

Hey guys.


I have two questions..

1. Are there any vacancies for SDFC testing in Capgemini? How's the streamline of projects?

Also, is there a scope for onsite opportunities?

2. How is the work life balance there ?

Any input will be highly appreciated!

like

Hello sharks

Any idea how much infosys is offering to Senior associate consultants?

Just need a rough idea for negotiations.

like

Guys, how to uninstall YouTube app from mobile.
For me now YouTube is the major distraction.

like

What is MBB?

like

There are few openings in Deloitte USI. Please DM me with your skill-set, resume and YOE so that I can check for referral in the portal. Also kindly like so that it can reach others who are in need.

like

Hi guys, has anyone ghosted a company on their joining date? What are the repurcussions, if any? Apart from bridges burnt.

like

11 YOE .Net
COMPANY CTC FIXED VARIABLE LOCATION
Wellsfargo 32.7 30 2.7 Bangalore
TCS 32 24 8 Pune
Barclays 32.5 32.5 0 Pune
Looking for Barclays to join-
Need advice-
Should I counter wellsfargo to Barclays to increase the CTC or current CTC of Barclays are good enough?

like

HR1(recruiter): Hey we offer you X LPA.
HR2(Candidate): Bhai apne baap ko mat seekha. I know budget is 1.5x of what's offered first
HR1: Sahi khel Gaye Bhai. Chalo na tera na mera X pe done karte hai.
HR2: nahi 1.3X se mein neeche nahi aaunga. Aur waise bhi mein bohot bacha lunga tech salary negotiations mein
HR1: ok I need to discuss with sr management.
HR2: Bhai ye bakchodi band kar. I know kuch nahi discuss hota with sr management. Just done karde
HR1: kafi pohoche hue Khiladi ho. Chalo done

funny

Hi,
I joined new company today with more than 200 percent hike.
The project I was in my previous organization was on tool( not much future scope) but supposed to get onsite next yr.
As I got this opportunity which is in java with bank captives n great hike I took it.
But feels very anxious about this ..just having thought of should have stayed in previous organization.
It was a comfort zone moreover...any thoughts on this guys?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal