From your perspective as <your role>, what are the qualities of a great Art Director?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

1) You have to be great at conceptual thinking
2) You have to understand advertising and what a great work stands for. For clients and for the industry itself.
3) you have to be great in your kraft.
4) you have to be hands on and fast
5) you have to study the best art directors in the world to know what’s the highest level of art direction.
6) you have to bring fresh visual insights.

It has been working for me.

likesmarthelpful

Yes. The industry is truly falling for this reason.

Recent IconRecent

Knows how to write headlines, copy and dialogue even though it’s not their assigned specialty.

like

You all continually take what I say out of context. I literally said “[advertising] is a dual effort between art and language,” which is fundamentally the same thing as a “symbiotic relationship.” You simply said it better because that is what you are specialized in: writing. I have never once stated I think that an AD should be ignorant to copy, far from it. I simply have always stated that if we are using copy to determine whether someone is a great AD then this industry is in a rough spot. You want me to “write visually,” totally, that is my job, but I am not going to expect my filler title to make it into our pitch deck. I’m not going to proof read your paragraph blocks. Someone out there is far better at those things than me. It’s a partnership, and yah maybe I’ll come up with a good word from time to time, but that isn’t what should portray my abilities as a creative.

Same as the qualities of a great copywriter - confidence that stops well short of hubris. Decisiveness. The ability to treat production and postproduction artists as collaborators rather than servants.

like

Execution is everything.

I’ve seen great strategies become mediocre campaigns because of poor art direction. I’ve seen poor strategies become award winners because of great art direction.

I have to fight every week with resourcing to work with the best in our agency. It’s worth it.

likesmart

The best ADs for me, as a producer, are ones that have some idea of costs and feasibility. They don’t present stuff that’s so amazingly far out of budget or just near impossible. Example: the least talented guy I had the misfortune of working with would hang his idea on something that wasn’t possible in the time or budget, and would then get really snippy when someone pointed that out- like custom manufacturing something in China for a qty of 500 and in 2 weeks, or shooting something that involved hundreds of props, or controlling the weather... You’d offer workarounds and he’d flip out that it wasn’t what he had in mind.

likehelpful

The best Art Directors I have worked with are flexible and interested in every form of visual style and expression. The worst thing in the world, as a writer, is to feel like some of my ideas are off the table because my AD doesn't understand/like an entire genre of design.

likesmart

Have actual ideas, not “let’s do this one cool thing I saw in a comic book movie recently.”

like

Ah, I’ve been working with a freelance AD just like that for the past couple weeks... Random tactics that look cool with only a tenuous conceptual link to the strategy. The CD literally sighs every time they open their mouth lol

Knowing the adobe creative suite inside and out.

In my opinion, a great art director doesn’t get in his/her own way. They keep it simple.

Would love to hear more about what you mean by getting in their own way!

Related Posts

Anyone with luck in London at the Economist, Amnesty International, IRC, or Human Rights Watch? Curious if the hiring process typically happens through referrals

like

Hello. I have a final round interview for Business Intelligence Engineer position. My final interview is scheduled for 4.5 hours long. That’s long. I know I need to follow the STAR. Besides that, what should I expect and be prepared for?

The previous round covered SQL whiteboard and few behavioral questions.

I appreciate your help and insights. Thanks.

like

Currently wrapping up my first year as a investment banking analyst. Have ~10 or so interviews the next couple of weeks for strategic finance, corp dev, and corp strat. What are exits like for each of these and how do they compare? Is there one role that is typically seen as more prestigious, etc?

like
like

Anyone with luck in London at the Economist, Amnesty International, IRC, or Human Rights Watch? Curious if the hiring process typically happens through referrals

like

Hi! I have an interview for the role of financial consultant/financial planning and analysis @ computershare.. please share words of advise for me please... This is the highest role I have ever interview for.. I am currently a credit analyst! Any tips help. Thank you in advance.

like

Hello All, Office Sup. for a major hospital, w/ 15 years experience. I have lots of experience in every position in the office, especially in training. I recently applied for an EPIC trainer position within the company and according to Glassdoor the average pay is about 23k more than what I currently make. I’m afraid of getting a lowball offer since 1. they obviously know my current salary and 2. I’d be new at this particular role, although I meet qualifications. Any advice if that’s the case?

like

Would anyone from Newsela be able to give me a referral for a couple of positions? Happy to connect to provide more info on my background ☺️

For IP Litigation folks in life sciences/pharma - what are the likely exit options? The boutique patent lit firms don’t seem to have a lighter workload and it seems like most in house positions require tech transaction and patent persecution experience, which is not easy to get while in big law (since different groups). I am a junior associate and any advice is appreciated.

like

I'm trying to choose between IBM Corporate Strategy and Innosight. I like both opportunities. Innosight pays more, but I've never had a big brand like IBM on my resume. Additionally, I'm worried whether Innosight's exit opportunities are slimmer than IBM. Would anyone have some advice on what I should pick / how I should think about this?

like

Does anyone here work at Ameriprise financial? If so, would you recommend it? What is the work life balance like? I have an interview for a Advisory trading specialist role. Thanks!

likehelpful

Hello fishes, looking for a Business Analyst role in Mumbai/Pune or Bangalore location. Have 1+ experience in Business Analytics and 6+ overall experience. Any referrals kindly DM.

like

Got an offer as a Senior 2 in EY’s FAAS practice for $117,500 base and $12,500 bonus. Home office is San Francisco. Is this expected for that position? Any insights?

like

I have total 9 years of experience. 7 years in India and 2 years in Germany. I have been contacted for Test Lead position by TietoEvry for India location. What salary should I expect for the role ?

like

Got an offer to work at a boutique PE fund as an intern for the next few months. The role is however unpaid and the fund is new.

For some background, I’m going to be starting at a T-2 firm doing CDD for PE funds in January. Wondering if getting this kind of experience looks good when I apply to analyst roles 1-2 years out? Don’t want to work without getting paid unless the experience is valuable. Would love any perspective on this.

like

Does anyone know some companies that are hiring part-time and full remote for data entry, customer service, or anything that can help to make some extra money?
I have been applying on Linkedin for a while but never got an answer.

likeuplifting

Hello. Need some advice on the salary range I should be seeking for a Student Recruiter position at a non-profit in nyc. I have 3.5 years of experience mainly in project management. Is 75K too high?

like

Amazon Web Services Who here has been interviewed orhired by Amazon Web Services/Amazon for a marketing role? A recruiter just reached out to me on LinkedIn and it sounds like a very intense process, but it could be worth it for my professional growth (and wallet). Any suggestions?

likehelpful

I am currently an HR professinal of 3 years with past background as a teacher/advisor in higher ed. I am aiming to pivot to a more L&D, training specialist type role in order to leverage the skills obtained in both areas. It would be the perfect career for me. Any openings or hiring at your company? I am not super concerned about the title as long as there is room for growth and I can pay for my 3 kids' daycare tuitions. ;)

like

More Posts

I am a life-long bibliophile. I think this is because my parents read books to me all the time. Do you think this is common anymore?

like
like

Which would you choose:
1. Director/Chief Privacy Officer: B2B. healthcare global company. $240K total comp + sign-on bonus. Move to the Midwest. Go to the office 3x week. Immediate senior leader. Team of 10 to manager + the entire company’s data processing.
2. Senior manager: B2C. big name tech company. $300K - $350K total comp. Ladder to climb. You’re assigned a lane. Remote. Individual contributor.

like

How do you manage the long hours M&A can have at times?

like

I’m interviewing for a HR Tech support analyst role. I have 7 years of relevant experience. What salary range do you all think I should ask for??? The recruiter stated that they are offering 83K base salary. Is that good?? PLEASE HELP

like

Lol non lawyer just said “i mean imagine if lawyers didn’t get drug tested, it just would never happen.”

funnylike

Can someone help me with the review cycle process?
this would be my second review.
Which all month’s performance would be reviewed in coming cycle?

like

How to transition from IT/Consultancy to PE or Fintech/ Banking without a huge pay cut? Anyone have done that?
Have been in IT for 20+ years, last 15 in Management. Good exposure to different industries and C-level management with holistic view and hands-on from operations, delivery, sales and some tech.

like

Has anyone joined recently at Cisco. Is the onboarding virtual or do we need to go to office ?

What’s going on at Sapient Razorfish NYC?

likefunny

Now start getting the vermin out of the WH...

likefunny

Sorry, not sorry for helping keep clients and agencies from being sued. (Also a bit lazy to use a meme rather than come up with an original idea IMO)

LinkedIn post:

Post Photo
like

Anyone have a recommendation for books or resources on upping my sales game? Open to in person class, online class, books, etc!

like

How do y’all stay motivated at work when you’re going to leave for school?

like

For sterling background check, did you list high school jobs? It says to include all employment over past 7 years, including part time but seems like that would be excessive

like

Would love to get some advice. I am currently a program manger and lead two amazing female project managers. I am looking into make a career change and hoping to either get into data analytics or finally bitting the bullet and doing a coding boot camp to get into software engineering. I know I want to be a people manger in the future, does anyone have advice on being a data lead vs Eng lead ? I worry I’ll constantly feel undermined since it tends to be heavily male dominated

like

It may not be relevant question for this bowl, but looking for help. Planning to buy Audi Q7 and my dealer says there are no rebates now and offering the car at MSRP. I know sale price should be much lesser. Any tips on how to negotiate?

like
like

Guys, ditch your briefs and trunks.

Switch to boxer briefs. They're the best.

Someone recommended me them 2 days back and I wonder why did I not know about this since past 7-8 years.

Thank me later 😂😂

like

Hey guys,

Can anyone refer me for Opportunity in MS, if I give you guys the Job Id.
YOE: 9 years

Skills: Microservices Development using spring boot, JAVA 8, DOCKER, KUBERNETES, SPARK, KAFKA, NOSQL Db, ElasticSearch etc

NP: serving notice period (45days left)

Additional Posts in Advertising

How hard is it to move from freelance to full time in an agency? Chatting about a freelance strategist position at R/GA but don’t really want to give up the benefits of full time

like

Second time in my career I've seen this: we send client lengthy manuscript to review. Client says she'll need a few days, and sends us some additional stuff (research) that could be helpful (cont'd)

like

What was your worst / most pathetic experience with recruiters (external or HR?) ?

like

Interesting discussion with agency CFO recently. Client-agency contracts are becoming performance based, less execution. Looks like if your spot won't bring in 💰💰 for the client, it's dead on pitch.

like

know cool places to do wood work, cooking, pottery class in Chicago? need a new hobby

like

For those of you who have fled LA, NY, SF for smaller markets — how on earth did you deal with the pay cut?!

like

What are the good accounts at Grey NY?

like

Has anyone gotten a university teaching gig without a grad degree? How?

like

I’m looking for some new things to read or listen to — doesn’t need to be ad-related. Books, podcasts, whaddya got?
I’m not really into fiction, but open to anything. Last books I enjoyed were Junior and Moonwalking with Einstein, last podcast I binged was Startup (Gimlet).

like

Just got a one year contract to work in London UK for 1 year. Where should I live in the city? (30y.o woman)

like

Saving for a down payment vs. aggressively paying down student loans vs. retirement...what are your strategies?

like

Man that United Healthcare Chuck Norris spot... ouch.

like
like

Iprospect New York ... what’s the culture like ? What’s leadership like ? Good place to work? Average ? Just like everything else?

like

Stop shaming people for leaving on time. Working overtime every nite benefits no one if you’re exhausted. It’s not a badge of honor either. Work on your time management skills.

likeupliftingsmarthelpfulfunny

It just hit me I havent heard any UGC ideas in forever. Have we collectively given up on the idea that people will make our videos for us (and other people will watch them) or have I just been lucky?

likefunny

Got laid off. Got a new offer two weeks later. It’s not remotely what I see myself doing for long. but the team leader is great. I’m in early stages with my dream companies. Not sure what to do.

like

I’ve been laid off and, as I embark on my job search, I’d like to keep my marketing skills sharp. Any recommendations on must read books, or resources?

like

Follow-up email to a recruiter or accept defeat?
5 days since last contact which was supposed to be “ASAP.

like

Is anyone at a job they really, truly enjoy that also pays competitively (and has good benefits)? In my experience, I haven’t found anything that satisfies both. Either I love the job and I’m grossly underpaid or the job is totally mediocre but the money is great. Is it really possible to have it all or do I need to lower my standards? Maybe it’s just the way this industry is?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal