I already know this is going to sound pretentious so I apologize in advance but am genuinely curious. When I was applying, I only really considered MBB (and less so Bain because of focus areas since I'm not that interested in PE) - for those at other firms, what drove that decision?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Agreed with BCG1. This is incredibly tone deaf.

like

The vast majority of consultants went to schools where MBB doesn’t even recruit, and even then, the majority of people who apply don’t get the job. Your question is basically like asking someone who went to Boston College why they went there instead of Harvard or MIT

like

That wasn't my intention. I know people who chose state schools over Ivy Leagues for a variety of reasons (often financial) so was wondering if there was something similar. Again, I know it comes across that way though, which is why I noted that in the original post.

That’s a valid question - there may be many drivers for applying to other firms
1) It may be a matter of whether one was trying to get a job in consulting or only MBB. MBBs are obviously extremely competitive to get into and if one is aiming to make a career in consulting, it just makes sense to apply to other firms as well - the life is comparable (relative to switching professions obviously) and different firms offer different values. Travel vs. no travel / type of work / size of the organization - all lead to very different experiences

2) as it was pointed out earlier - depending on the school you’re from, options may be limited

3) work life balance - MBBs have a very specific appeal but there is a work life balance consideration that comes with it. Other firms may offer you an option of being able to have more flexibility in hours / projects.

4) title / position - again depending on your background, you can aim for a higher title in some specialized firms vs. generalist tracks at MBB

5) previous networks - this might be not a big factor alone but combined with others mentioned above, could play a big role since networks are quite beneficial to further your professional goals faster

like

Didn’t have high enough GPA (3.2) to due to engineering background to be competitive for MBB for a target state school so only focused on T2 and B4 and didn’t want to do engineering work

like

Out of undergrad I was in a different firm. I didn’t go with my initial MBB offer because of location. I went to a T2 firm in a different geography.

like

I think you should answer what drove you to apply only to MBB. That’s the real question. Diversifying the amount of firms one applies to is probably the standard.

What else were you doing/before?

Related Posts

McKinsey & Company Any advice to help prepare for data science analyst role at top consulting firms (McKinsey & Company EY Boston Consulting Group etc)? Any materials, open source platform recommended to take on freelance data science project? When should I start actively looking and applying? I am a new grad who is working in tech as a marketing analyst I’m looking to pivot to marketing& sales data science consulting next year. Would like someone with similar backgrounds offer some practical tips.

like

How possible is it to build a US-based career doing global public sector work while not being in New York or DC?

Currently a Manager at Accenture in Public Sector. Living in a progressive US city with a few direct flights to Europe, but definitely not New York or DC. PhD in public affairs. Actually I'm on the hiring roster for a P3 role at the UN.

Considering some life choices that would keep me living where I am though. Debating if this would kill hope of global work.

like

Hey,
I am at a crossroads where I need to decide between a generic program manager role or specialise in digital marketing? Need advise on how to decide! What has betting future growth??
I have an experience of 5 years

like

What’s the norm and expectation for client interactions at MBB for juniors (pre-manager levels)? Do you never talk in client meetings? Talk through select slides? Run the meeting end to end? Does the client generally interact with you outside of meetings?

like

26 male, been offered a Corp dev role for about 140 comp incl. bonus (about 40% raise), F500. Currently been doing FDD since out of college. Smart career move or too early to jump Corp dev?

like

I started interviewing early Oct with a company that reached out via recruiter. The hiring manager was very straight forward with me that I was his top candidate and I was told all other interviews were very positive incl CMO. The recruiter said they'd be making an offer but it's now been three weeks. Anyone else had the process drag on like this? Meanwhile I'm taking other interviews and was offered a promotion at current company, but was very interested in this one. What would you do?

like

How does everyone feel about the online SHRM learning for SHRM-CP and SHRM-SCP for Certification?
Do you skip around? Do you follow the path? Where does one start?

like
like

What are reasonable exit opportunities from transaction advisory/fdd? I am considering a position in this but am concerned with getting stuck too far down the road.

like

Any advice or thoughts on the experience required to get hired at Salesforce as a Solution Engineer vs Sr Solution Engineer?

Yoe: 3
Experience type: Functional Consultant

like

Which engineering is the best and why? I am an electrical engineer and I am sure that my engineering is the best career because it is the most difficult to study and at the same time we are the ones in charge of moving the world.

like

I am currently an EH&S/AP associate for Walmart Supple Chain. I am a team lead in the department making $31.35 an hour working Fri-Sun from 5:30-17:30 (12hr). I am interviewing for EH&S/AP manager and I am searching for how much the managers are making on here but I can’t find any post about it. If I get an offer for the manager position, how much should I ask for my salary? Please let me know how much you are making as an EHS manager and please include your company as well.

Hi guys :) Glad to join fishbowl and this community. Guys I have an offer of 14.41 ctc from a big 4 (11 is fixed).
Technology-Microsoft Dynamics 365(I am a functional consultant in SCM and HR; Relevant exp: 3 yrs & Total exp: 4 yrs).
My interviews in
IBM are done and I am waiting for the salary discussion with HR.
What is the likely offer that I am going to get? Any idea? (My expectation is 16.5 lpa ctc). I will adjust my expectations as per replies here.
Any response is highly appreciated :)

like

My first time applying and getting an offer for a job posting without a salary on it, aka non-government job. $21k below what I currently make and $3k below the minimum I told them- I went for a job with a bigger title and more responsibility. Other companies need to learn from government jobs. Today I’m loving that my current government job appreciates my worth.

like

currently tossing up between staying at a global company (who is in the process of some positive changes) with an amazing manager who supports my career and flexible working … however comes with the inherit issues that come with a long standing global company

compared with a role at a smaller mga, higher salary (around 30%) more , more visibility career wise and some great employee benefits , management seem to be supportive and low staff turnover

which would you choose here

like

Starting conversation with an EY recruiter on an opportunity. I am an experienced Manager with Deloitte, can someone provide an insight into what level in EY I can get into/ negotiate?

like

Dear Fishes.

Can you comment on the current market trend for QA Automation using Cypress / Java Selenium.

I am planning to search for a switch from next month. Is it a good idea considering the recession in the IT market?

My experience is 9yrs, lead role. Thanks.

Coming from audit... when do you plan to leave the big 4 and what is your hope to do after public accounting? Particularly interested to hear different non-accounting roles

like

Has anyone signed a contract to work for X amount of years with the government and then broken that contract? Are there repercussions? The contract was two sentences that said I would work for X years. That’s it. I cannot find any information online about what happens if you hate your new job so much that you quit. Anyone?

More Posts

Any good books to read this winter break? On leadership, digital, or any autobiographies?

like

I am looking for someone or company , creative, challenging, moving forward with innovation. I am fullstack web developer, have more than 6 years of experience. I am very intrinsic and motivated and get involved into something what i like. what is motivate me most, this is something creative and non repeatable thing.

here is my skill

framwork: Laravel. wordpress, Mern stack, Mean stack based on node.js

programming language::javascript, php, css, html, python

CMS::WordPress, Shopify, Dupal

like

MBA? / yoe consulting / title / company / age / salary

like

Anyone in Chicago have recommendations for places to watch shop? Looking in the few hundred $ range. In the city today and disappointed by the selection at Nordstrom and I’m pretty sure Macy’s closed.

like

To the moon

like

How’s everyone’s portfolios looking?

like

Saving for a house down payment in the next 20-24 months. Where should I put my savings. Just in a savings account right now. Was thinking about ibonds, but is my timeframe too short?

like

Anyone here read “Die with Zero”? What are your thoughts on the principles from the book?

like

Fixed offered as 36 lpa. What shall be the inhand in CBA. TIA

like

Robotics / automation / bitcoin impact on the future of PA? Is there a place for us or should we start looking at other career paths? Thoughts?

like

I am a Sr. Designer in DC looking for a position as an Art Director with experience in brand strategy, alignment, print, motion & digital design. Interested in all openings. Thanks!

Anyone got H1B interview appointment? I am still waiting for the HR to confirm that I can go ahead and take an appointment. What is the process , why to still keep on waiting when I can see the appointments are available now.

like

I am interviewing at Apple for Worldwide Readiness Program Manager position. I am looking for base 200K and TC 230-250K. Would this position offer me that? Glassdoor, levels and transparent don’t seem to have any info on this role

like

Has anyone found success developing business or building their book? Specifically businesses (not individuals)? Looking for new ideas to get clients in the door.

like

I have an offer from first American and harman shared services . Which one will be better to join considering work life balance .

How much in hand I'll get in Harman shared services?

Post Photo
like

It has been 2+ weeks since I completed the Interview & Psychometric Assessment rounds with Macquarie Group , but yet to hear anything from them. I also followed up with HR but with no response. For the record, the interview went well. Any idea if they usually take this amount of time to get back? If I got rejected, why not communicate directly?

like

We have 5 attorneys (3 partners; 2 associates). Senior associate (who is being promoted to non-equity partner) is pregnant. We don’t have any sort of maternity policy but she will have 3 weeks of PTO to cash in. How do other firms handle cost of insurance premiums while ee is out? We currently cover ee portion and she pays for 100% of dependent cost. Is it reasonable to ask her to write check back to firm for her portion of dependent premiums? Assume she is taking full 4 mos off.

likefunny
like

Anyone have slow months where you burn through a lot of your allotted pro bono/professional development hours to keep hitting minimum daily hours? The past few weeks have been like this for me. Should I be concerned (I.e., will this reflect poorly on me, come review time? Will I have dug myself too much of a hole if I keep burning my non-billable hours?) I’ve been asking partners if I can assist in any projects so I can fill my plate, but I’ve only gotten small (4-6 hour) tasks handed my way.

like

How do people keep themselves awake...reading this shit is so boring

likefunnysmart

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Anyone in their case prep pay for crafting cases market sizing? Would be happy to Venmo you in order to use for a bit! Got my final round next week and just want to brush up

like

I've a question on what sections to put on a regular resume. I see some people are using consulting style resume for outside companies as well. Do you think it's a good idea to devide work experience by projets? Or is it better to have "projects highlights" separate from work experience.. something like: intro>functional expertise> project highlights>work experience>education?

like

Any business casual shoe recommendations? Looking to buy a pair of shoes to go into the office. TIA!

like

McKinsey & Company Starting in the McKinsey London office soon and essentially need to buy a new wardrobe. Any advice on what I should prioritise?? Was going to buy a couple nice suits and shirts etc, but someone told me no one wears suits anymore and to buy chinos and quarter zips instead?

McKinsey & Company

like

Anyone worked in Econ consulting before (eg., Cornerstone Research, Analysis Group, etc.)? Or pick Econ consulting over MBB? Would love to learn about the pay vs MBB and long term career path/exit opportunities. Thanks!

like

I have a non business background, and I often noticed that to go a bit further on certain cases or distinguish yourself from others, some knowledge about the industry/sector can be good. Do you have a website/ressource where I can have an overview of the most frequent industries? Thank you in advance :)

like

If you are already in biotech R&D, been in hardcore engineering/ research is it worthwhile to pivot to data science?

like

How’s experienced hire (PL/EM+) forecasting into 2023? Thinking of back up plans if things go haywire in the next 2 months.

like

Hello! Any one in here who can give me a referral for a position at McKinsey and BCG? Thanks in advance!!

Hello!
How should I go about applying as a generalist Associate to McKinsey's TMT practice as an experienced hire? Current SW tech lead at Square looking to switch into consulting but in TMT only.
Any tips / McK folks open to DMs?

like

Can Mck fish please advise on the role of a sponsor? How is different from role of mentor? TIA

like

Anyone willing to give a referral for a McKinsey?

like

Is it worth to move from Oliver Wyman to Bain? Is there a big difference? Talking about Europe/Asia

like

What are the career levels at BCG? Specially trying to understand where does the Product Manager role fit in

like

For those who have gone through Mck First Round/Final Round - could you talk about how the interview took place? I am a bit worried as it might be hard to connect with the interviewer when the process is not in-person. Did you have a phone call or a Zoom call with video, and did it feel awkward? Thanks for your help!

like

What level should I apply to if I’m a manager at B4? Considering applying

like

For those of you 🐠 who worked at another consulting firm before joining MBB, what would you say are the biggest differences between them?

like

Does anyone have any insight on what is entailed during an “expertise chat” at McK? I spoke to a recruiter and made it through to the next step. The next step is the expertise chat before progressing to the official first round interview. For reference, this is for their Healthcare Services & Technology practice. TIA

like

Anyone willing to share their access to casecoach? Any help would be appreciated!

like

How much does the EM equivalent at MBB make? And the Associate Partner equivalent? Salary and bonus breakdown would be appreciated.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal