Is Medicare for all a good idea? Does the USA have a viable path to universal coverage? What major changes are needed to change the fact that we spend the largest share of our GDP on healthcare whil

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yes it’s a good idea. Untying insurance from employment is desperately needed. Public option will be more expensive as private insurers will just use it as an excuse to offload everyone high risk to the public one.

like

Fundamentally, insurance lowers costs to individuals by spreading risk across as large a group as possible. At the most basic level you miss the opportunity to spread the risk out to its maximum size. On top of that, you won’t get the savings from consolidating administrative costs to a single entity and you miss out of leverage for negotiating prices with healthcare providers.

After that it depends a little more on implementation. Due to the increased competition, the private insurers would respond by raising prices and seeking to limit higher risk individuals, relegating them to the public option. If you treat the public option like a state run enterprise (i.e. funded by premiums instead of taxes) and don’t untether insurance from employment, you can potentially get the scenario where the private plans continue to raise prices, but the employee subsidy still keeps most people on them, and the public option essentially becomes a very expensive high risk pool, since it won’t be able to deny people. Then it would either need to fund by increasing premiums (potentially losing the savings of a public option) or by federal subsidies.

You can go with the other method where everyone is automatically enrolled in a public option that everyone pays for if they don’t get in private insurance. But this would essentially just put private insurers into an expensive death spiral until they collapse, or it would create a two tiered system where some healthcare providers only accept the expensive private option and everyone on the public option is stuck with fewer options and worse service. Better to rip off the band aid and enact single payer healthcare.

Single payer needs to happen. It will, however, take many years to deal with the underlying infrastructure changes. Expanding public options now while working towards a single payer system is the best path imo

like

The only viable path is to convince 80% of the Americans that it’s a good idea. So far, it’s failing.

like

On the surface it sounds great, but there are a lot of considerations. The private insurance sector employs millions of people. Secondly, hospitals systems will be hit really hard because the rates they receive from Medicare are significantly lower than what they get through private insurers. That in turn could have rippling effects, might push people away from the medical field at a time where we have a shortage of doctors. And lastly, more of a moral question - if you can afford a higher quality of care (shorter wait times, advanced treatments, etc) should you be able to buy it over others?

like

Like any Us gov program. Implementation will be tough but policy makes sense. We’re lagging behind other developed economies in terms of health equity.

like

I like a public option first.

I realize and agree that europe is able to do healthcare better than the US. However, the US govt cant even figure out how to deliver mail on Sundays, and would rather see them out compete private healthcare models before I give up my insurance

like

I’m super liberal, but Medicare for all is too big a change to implement on the time scale discussed during the primaries. I think Warren and Sanders we’re discussing making it policy within a couple years?? That’s just ludicrous. Our healthcare system is so complex and intertwined with private insurance, that the only way we can really make changes is gradually. Start with a public option that is subsidized so that everyone has access. Then in 5-10 years make it illegal to have health insurance through your employer (or something similar). Improve step by step from there. Too bad that will never happen either. I’m pretty sure even this crisis won’t make Americans agree enough to hold politicians’ feet to the fire and make real changes.

like

E being ranked 34th on overall healthcare outcomes?

No. I like public option better.

Related Posts

Hey! Just interviewed for an attorney position at an insurance litigation firm (Chicago). I have my offer convo w/ HR next week. This is career two for me so I have a ton of previous professional & public speaking/synthesizing data experience. Wondering about my salary ask.

Is it okay to go higher than average?

like

Any tips for organizing a bedroom, closet, dresser & bathroom? My teen has IADHD, and low executive functioning. Her room looks like a land mine. Clean clothes are mixed in with dirty, her desk is a disaster, she won’t let go of clothes she’s outgrown, drawers are open with clothes hanging out. A therapist said to close her door if we don’t want to see it but it’s more than that. She needs this important life skill & I don’t know how to help. Easier to organize w/o her but that’s not a solution.

like

Anyone have gallstones or cholestasis during pregnancy? I was diagnosed this weekend at 28 weeks. Going through a gallbladder attack as I type this 😢

like

Any Insurance Broker Account Managers in Oklahoma (Health/Life/ Employee Benefits)? Would you be willing to share your salary information and any information about your work load/the amount of groups you manage and their size as well as your years of experience? I’m trying to determine if mine is comparable to what others receive. Thanks for any insight!

like

Happy fly day. Did you work out this morning?

For those of you in healthcare related account management, what is your healthcare background? I am clinical and getting ready to hire a higher level account manager. I am really biased toward people with clinical/in hospital experience because, quite frankly, healthcare is a different beast - lots of hand holding and change management. I don’t want to miss the right person because of my bias, so im wondering how many healthcare related AMs have healthcare/clinical experience… thanks in advance!

like

Joining Accenture Strategy in the Fall – any notable benefits I should be aware of?

Amerisourcebergen doesn't care about its employees. We have no mental health awareness. Leadership only promotes people who kiss ass the most qho have no managerial experience and pass people who actually have experience in a manager role. Leadership never helps you with anything. Managers write you up for no reason amd threaton your job constantly. Ive have leasherip threaten my job while on FMLA and write me up for taking too much time off

like

Hi Fishes. Just got the following offer and would like to know in hand salary. Please let me know.

Fixed: 30 LPA
Bonus: 3.33 LPA
Gratuity: 72130
Stocks: 2 LPA every year for 4 years
Benefits: 91k Broadband, meals and insurance
Total: 37 LPA plus joining bonus of Rs. 2 lakh

like

I hope that they swabbed that plexiglass for droplets and then send it to a lab for Covid testing.

like

Does any firm have HH this Friday? F/25/NYC

Anyone here use or know anyone who has used Vet Comp and Pen to get/increase VA disability benefits? Wondering if they’re reputable.

like

Experience/success/insights with an “endometrial scratch” before first FET?

like

If it’s true that you can gain full immunity after recovering from COVID (when science says so ofc), will the plan be to antibody test people and let them resume daily life if they have immunity?

like

With this WFH life & the pandemic I’ve barely been moving. I started walking daily since a few days ago and it kicks my butt. My legs are actually sore from walking? It’s really sad but I’m glad I’ve taken in this initiative and wanted to share 😂

like

I’m 8.5 weeks pregnant and throwing up once per day, mostly after the majority of my lunch has been digested and sometimes after all of it has digested so I’m gagging and nothing coming up. It’s so hard to see the end of this road, I feel miserable.

like

Hello Verizon fellows, In Deloitte, there's a facility to claim a certain reimbursement for purchasing mobile devices through their portal or something. Similarly, do VDSI employees have any discounts or reimbursement for purchasing devices through Verizon? If so, kindly let me know how to check it out. Thanks in advance.

like

Does EY provide tuition reimbursement / MBA sponsorship? I know Deloitte has GSAP, but I wasn’t sure if EY has something similar. If so, what are the requirements?

like

Best place to research salaries? I’m getting a wide range. Glassdoor is “highly confident.” Should I be highly confident in their range? I’m researching a Sr. Director Corporate Communications role in a major health care org. HELP!

like

More Posts

Friendly reminder that depression is a protected disability. File paperwork with your company and they legally cannot destroy your health by overworking you.

like

I am currently in Retail Project Management (coming up on 2 years) right now and am looking to make a shift into real estate finance. My degree is in finance, and I am really looking to pair that degree with my passion for real estate investment. Any suggestions on how to make the transition? I am just concerned on how to sell my current experience to a finance-specific role. Any thoughts and comments are greatly appreciated!

like

I joined infosys on may 19, from when shall i expect variable payout start? Month?

like

Ladies, did you change your last name after getting married? I’m worried about the impact it will have on my publications.

like

What is Amazon's dress code at HQ2? In the finance Dept if that matters

like

Cleared Accenture Skill interview by answering almost all the questions and received congratulatory mail for HR round and submitting all documents. Then after a week received a call from HR saying that due to some technical issue, the skills round will happen again and an online assessment was set up. In the assessment, questions which were not directly related to the profile were asked and then a rejection mail was received. Does this happen a lot?

like

Anyone else get shafted on promotions?

like

What would be band 9 (senior managing consultant) salary range at IBM digital strategy and iX for NYC?

like

Hello everyone! I am so interested in developing centers for my 5th grade math classroom. I'd you are a math center guru, I would love any suggestions, recommendations, or examples of what works and what doesn't work! Thanks!

likehelpful

Any one looked at the budget hours and think they were unreal? I am updating the actual hours compared to budget, feel stupid & inefficient when I see I'm so over budget. Or maybe I should eat hours?

like

Hi folks, I noticed Mastercard is actively hiring for Analytics role. Really appreciate if someone can refer me for that role? Thanks!

like

Senpais, looking back, if you had known more about your specialty, would you still have chosen it? If not, which specialty would you have preferred to enter? And why?

like

Any thoughts on the debt finance teams in the Chicago offices of the following firms: DLA, Winston, Polsinelli, Holland & Knight, McGuireWoods, Blank Rome? Thank you.

What is scaring you this spooky season?

Post Photo
likefunny

any avid readers? genres you enjoy & its corresponding book?

like

Can we all agree that gender reveal parties are an annoying thing to subject your friends to?

likefunny

How much do clinic nurses at VUMC get paid? 6 years experience

like

Considering buying Breitling Navitimer 41. Thoughts?

Post Photo
like

Should I apply for Account Manager LCS or Product Marketing Manager role? Which will give me better career opportunities and progress? Which job is more prestigious within Google?

like
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

How do I say to my counselor, "be prepared to see a big fall of my utilization because of things out of my control" without sounding like complaining or having a lot of negativity?

like

What are your expenses/time horror stories? Has anyone gotten fired in relation to expenses? Compensation withheld?

Anyone involved in pro bono consulting? Particularly interested in opportunities for junior level consultants.

like

Any story to share if you are caught knowingly or unknowingly trading on a non approved broker platform for stocks

like

Sharing if useful: I forget what (minor) IT help I need between being at client site and in office. Solved it today! Get error > take a screenshot > save with descriptive title to “IT help” folder.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Any book recommendations for philosophy, psychology, and business? Or any book you read last year changed your values? Going to fly international, gonna read it on flight. 😍

like

Thoughts on Prosci or SHRM-SCP certification? Which would be considered more valuable or highly regarded? Currently focused on Change Management but have a HR background (industry experience / area of study in college).

likehelpful

Anyone have a mask for sale in the DC area? Family member is lab staff conducting COVID testing and their facility ran out of masks a while ago.

likehelpful

Looking for some book recommendations :)

like

What percentage of your money do you save, invest, allocate to retirement, & spend?

like

Justifying the Sheraton's painful bed to yourself because the Four Seasons don't recognize your loyalty

like

Best computer Lenovo X1 or X?
For a partner so I don’t need all the horse power a consultant would but I still do a decent amount of excel.

like

Anybody else taking midday/2pm naps?!? Not going to lie, those power naps are game changers!!!

likehelpful

Do consultants get fired from a client for moving furniture around? (like a stand alone monitor) from an unused room he was given to sit, supposedly reserved for auditors. Asking for a friend 🙃

funnylike

Investment gurus - Appreciate pointers for resources (books, blogs, videos etc.) to read up on investment strategies. Just getting started and could use all the help. 🙏

like

Last minute mileage run for Diamond status on Delta. Any ideas for 5000+ MQM trips from DC??

like

I feel stuck as a Strategy Manager and want to make a career pivot at 35. But have no idea what i should do? Any suggestions, resources or books that I should read to help with my existential mid thirties crisis? I have experience in technology consulting, corporate strategy, freelance consulting and law. Do I go back to being an Attorney, or do I retrain and become a financial advisor or something else?

like

What are the BCG ring fences and how is each one? Can you join any of them or are you required to do the one closest to your home office

like

Have a bunch of emirates skyward miles that I won't be using anytime soon. Can I transfer it/use it someplace else?

like

Anyone been to the Harvard Extension School - Consultant’s Toolkit program? Any insights to share?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal