Posting your or your team’s One Club short listing in the time of COVID layoffs. Inspiring or insensitive?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Send a note to the team that worked on the project. Recognition is good. Positivity is good. Public bragging is a bit tone deaf.

like

Good lord. The US needs to get their head out of their asses and stop worrying about offending other people. Your feelings are your responsibility. If you get offended by someone else celebrating an achievement, you're the one who needs to get their life together.

like
Recent IconRecent

Send notes to the teams and the people that did the work. No need to post to the world

likesmart

I’ve been let go and I say post, especially if someone on the team either got let go at the agency they got the shortlist with (yea that’s shitty) or moved to a different agency and you know they got let go there.

Little bit of PR and exposure from different sources can’t hurt those that need it.

like

It’s called marketing. In a time when you could lose your job at any moment, pretty good thing for a marketer to do.

like

It’s not about offending people. It’s about the fact that a shortlist is a worthless commodity that are a dime a dozen. It’s like bragging that you got a stimulus check. Congratulations.

likesmartfunny

LB2, that’s fair. My question was a general query and not applicable to me as I’ve already congratulated those who deserved it personally. For some, it’s something.

A shortlist is nothing to brag about. When they announce the awards then do it. It’s only 3 weeks away.

like

a shortlist is something when it’s your first shortlist, and a shortlist is also more than most people have

likesmarthelpful

A lot of pretentious, self righteous people on this thread. If you think you are so much better than a shortlist than congrats you sound like an ass. If you're somehow upset that people who've spent months, and in some cases years working their ass off and are happy to finally be recognized are being insensitive to you by posting about it than you sound like you've got some serious personal issues to deal with. Promoting yourself in a time when you could be looking for a new job at any moment shouldn't be something anyone in here finds insensitive. C'mon now.

likesmart

It's amazing how insecurity doesn't see it's own entitlement.

like

You’ve got to take the opportunities while you can in this this industry. It’s hard to make work let alone get short listed. And If a shortlist is a window to expose your work to your peers then why not post it. Sure, most of those shortlists won’t convert, so celebrating 10 shortlists now sounds is better than posting about 1 bronze in 3 weeks time.

like

Post it internally, not externally. But not if you’ve had layoffs.

like

It’s a shortlist for Pete’s sake. Not worth posting.

like

Go for it.

likesmart

Thoughts and prayers

like

I agree that people can be a bit over sensitive and that we should celebrate each other and stay positive in times like these. Why don’t we build a community/ public forum where we can celebrate and share each others work right now in lieu of Cannes and award shows. We can add an engagement/ public polling feature. I didn’t see the One club messaging but it can go both ways- tone is everything.

like

This just shows how in a bubble some ad people live. Is totally off and it makes me feel bad. Everyone saying, “A good news in the middle of a bad moment in the history...” 🙄

like

In general, why cant we just be happy for people who are feeling happy?

like

I think people could use the acknowledgement and encouragement. But on the other hand award shows risk being seen as irrelevant or worse self serving.

🙄 You just posted it. Congrats btw.

I mean naturally of course you want to be able to express your achievements to your network. But I’ve noticed every single one of them starts out the post with something like “it’s hard to be excited about something during these times, but blah blah blah”

But I’m sure many people who won these might still be facing losing their jobs, so it probably is worth it to have people notice your achievements in case you need to start looking for a job in a couple weeks, or a couple days

It sounds like every covid response ad from brands. Advertising people can’t help it

Read the room and let that inform your decision

It’s not an accomplishment. Rookie move.

Related Posts

Thinking about starting an OF... since we aren’t getting raises this year. In all seriousness, I like being watched. But I’m too afraid to be found and get fired. My husband has a job now so maybe I can finally live my dream. Thoughts?

like

I was recently laid off and I am actively search for a new role. I am mainly targeting Business Analyst, ScrumMaster, Product Analyst, roles but I am open to others.

Must be located in Austin, Texas or fully remote.

EXP
5 Mo- Business Analyst 3
1.5 Y- Venture Capital Associate
1.5 Y- Strategic Planning Analyst

Certifications
ScrumMaster
Specialist Accounting and Finance
Specialist Business Intelligence

Contact
737-707-5156
ajaspercannon@gmail(dot)com
www.linkedin(dot)com/in/jcstrategy

like

There is almost nowhere to find reliable bonus information on Canadian firms. I’ve heard of year end bonuses ranging from 10-50% this year (not including Covid bonuses). Let’s start a thread posting year of call, rough billable hours worked and bonus as a percent of salary.

5 year call. 1850 hours. 10%.

Lol shots fired

Post Photo
likefunny

Any insights on bonus and hike? What should be the expectation considering recession and layoffs?

like

Looking for jobs in media! I was a casualty of covid-19 and have been looking for jobs over the past 8 months. Is anyone’s company hiring?

like
like

Will EY let me transfer offices during this COVID-19 craziness? Trying to transfer from SF to LA

like

One issue with the work from home revolution will be the offshoring of jobs. I got laid off and my replacement will be from Mexico City. One time zone away and probably half my salary. It is what it is.

likesmart

Which agencies are going through layoffs

like

I'm thinking I won't be getting promoted if not laid off at the end Q2 or sooner. What are some good exit ops for an associate with 2 yoe in tech consulting? Exp in Cloud, PMO, IT Risk, and SoD.

like

Blue shield of CA fired 375 people. Any other insurance companies having massive layoffs?

like

We’re in such a vicious business. You give your heart & soul to an agency, a client, a brand. Then the wind changes & you’re laid off, reassigned, chewed up, spit out, on to the next. I’m tired.

like

Anyone expecting layoffs due to COVID-19? There’s an indefinite hiring freeze and most promotions and have been paused. 👀

like

Which agencies in San Francisco are weathering the storm the best? I haven’t seen much about layoffs or furloughs. It seems like the bigger agencies in NY have been hit harder.

like

Hi Sharks,

I got an offer from FTD for permanent work from home. But i am not sure about the company.. Also the market conditions are bad too.. There are many layoffs from various companies.. Looking for suggestions..

like

Was laid off in Sept. Unfortunately we will be seeing many more coming. It's what happens in a recession. Unfortunately I now also have my age against me. Not in a mentally good place at the moment.

Hot take: if it’s actually a stealth layoff then everyone else got the same speech as you and outing the firm won’t identify you.

like

If you were an Uber employee that got laid off, how have you been faring?

like

More Posts

Anyone know if CVS Health drug tests for remote roles?

funnylike

Hi Folks, I am working in infy and planning to drop paper this week. As I don't have offer in hand but 90 days NP impacting to get new job. Also my compansation is not good as per exp. So that is the first reason and no new tech learning and project change happening with me. Also in last cycle they didn't give good rating bcoz i was asking for new project ..??
So is sept is good time to drop paper at infy.... Should I dropped or wait ??
Can you guys suggest

like

“have fun with this brief” they say before telling you the client is pretty conservative and needs to have safer options.

i know we don’t always work on stuff we’re thrilled about but i’ve never dreaded reviews for a client before until now

like

Guys how is Tata Cliq project in Nagarro, how about WLB and timings

like

Whether you're a father by choice or by mistake, HAPPY FATHER'S DAY TO YOU! 😎

like

Best consulting firms to work for in Hartford CT area?

like

Does CSR earn 3x points at bars on drinks?

like

Hi Everyone,

TCS asks for all semrester results??.. or Final semester results with all semester grade is enough??

Thanks in advance

like

Are the google salaries listed on levels.fyi show yearly stock of is the stock part split across multiple years?

like

My boss asked me what id like to do moving forward at work. The department im in has gone under many changes the past few months. I was really hoping the business would put me in a place they “need” me but instead it’s up to me…
My goal is to reach the top, climb the ladder and one day be CEO. I have a lot of outside influences that make this a possible venture.
I’m currently in sales but don’t know if the right path is to continue in.
What should I say to my boss, knowing I’m on right path?

like

Looking for honest opinions: would you trust career advice from someone who doesn’t necessarily have a background in career coaching but has always been “that friend” that everyone calls for career advice, resumes, salary negotiations etc?
I have a long background in management and have been very successful in climbing the ladder but I would love to start career coaching on the side. Any feedback is helpful!

likeuplifting

Any insight into clerkship bonuses at BakerHostetler?

like

Hello Fishes,

Has anyone have idea about Kyndryl in Brno (Czech Republic)? What is the salary they provide to overseas techie? I have total 7 YOE in networking domain. What are the pro and cons? Is it good to move from India to Czech Republic?

like

Safe weekend getaways right now? Meeting a guy for the weekend, can’t stay indoors since my family is with me.

like

Generally curious about this years incoming batch of undergrads. What is your role and starting salary? Lots of HR laws ( CA, NY) and inflation this year so curious to see if people were able to use this to their advantage etc.

like

Mind sharing your GMAT study schedule, for those working full time (especially those with long hours)?

like

What are reasonable target schools? 3.7 gpa with a business degree from top 25 university, 720 gmat, and 4 years tech consulting.

like

Has anyone worked with Sia Admissions? If so, what’s your perception?

like

Is it true that Sloan typically gives application fee waivers if you attend some events?

like

Anyone familiar with SmartHop?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Putting my two weeks in today. Any tips on how to do it gracefully?

like

Cool job offer for AD

Post Photo
like

Have you ever seen a client fired in mid-production?

likefunny

It’s Friday who’s partying

like

Which agencies are going through layoffs

like

We’re in such a vicious business. You give your heart & soul to an agency, a client, a brand. Then the wind changes & you’re laid off, reassigned, chewed up, spit out, on to the next. I’m tired.

like

Creatives who left for tech. What is it exactly that you do now? Is it still writing or art directing? Or a different creative role? Hearing about people leaving for tech so I want to know what it means exactly aside from the benefits.

like

Chicken wing wearing a seatbelt.

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

This showed up on my Facebook feed. Is it because I put the blackout square (I didn’t use that incorrect hashtag, by the way).

Post Photo
likefunny

What does this even mean?!

Post Photo
likefunny

Most won't give a shit but what work do you think will win this year at Cannes?

like
like

In a typical advertising creative team structure, who vets the new hires? ECD? CD? Trying to get some clarity as I work at a small shop with CD being the highest title.

like

I guess it’s common now to not bring a laptop to show your work at an interview? We’ve had 10 art director candidates come through and maybe 7 of them did not come with any way of showing their work.

like

Laid off, 10 years exp, tired of acct management. Feel so lost. Don't want to go back to agency side. What should I do? I feel like 💩

like

Anyone here knows agency/in-house that do O1 Visa? for JAD with one year experience.. My next jump would make me an AD possibly.

like

Tired of this constant grind and constant layoff situation in NYC. Thinking of making the move to LA. Any thoughts? Yay or nay?

like

Anyone in-house in the Bay Area and loving it? Where are you working?

like

I was furloughed yet it doesn’t start until Friday. Per the VPs, this week we have to “transfer our knowledge” to our bosses. Bosses who haven’t been on these projects. Any advice?

like

Has anyone tried LinkedIn Premium while on a job search? Is it worth it, would you recommend, and why?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal