Related Posts
Hi fishes,
How is the wlb in Amex?
More Posts
How can one overcome anxiety when presenting?
Who is ready to kick some bulldog @$$??
Everything's a toy when you're a kitten!

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers
Thoughts on purchasing leads?
New to Fishbowl?
Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.






2000 billable hours is not easy to hit, with young children, that would be very difficult to have a work life balance. 2000 hours is 40 hours per week of billable work, and not everything you do will be billable. This is a high billing requirement and will mean that you work significantly more than 40 hours per week.
Stay away and run. It’s not what it’s portrayed to be. Stress and demands are unreal. These insurance people care nothing about you and will grind you down til you snap. The billing is always cut and you have non lawyers telling you how long it takes to research or prepare. It’s borderline malpractice.
Transitioned from prosecutor to ID. Other firms will pay more money for less billable hours
If your concerns are billable hours & the job being lucrative, you’re on the wrong side of the table; the money is in plaintiff’s side PI (especially if you’re able to bring in your own business) and there aren’t any billable requirements.
Defense side has a cap & is more of a traditional attorney role (i.e. set billable hours, set bonus structure, etc) whereas plaintiffs side is almost entirely commission based - you’ll get a base salary, but the bulk of your money comes from settlements/verdicts/origination.
If i were you, I’d use the trial experience you have on plaintiffs side.
Second this
A few years ago, I interviewed with a defense firm and received an offer of $110K for 1,850 hours of billable work.
I declined the offer, switched sides, and accepted a deal very similar to your friend’s deal and cleared $200K that year. The following year, I made significantly more than $200K. I very rarely worked more than 40 hours per week. Plaintiff side personal injury work is where it’s at. Just find a reputable firm to work for if you can do so.
Theres a running joke that you can work for 9 hours straight and still somehow end up with only 2.9 billable hours, and it’s only funny bc its so unfortunately true. Many young/new associates work 60-80 hours to hit 40 billables, especially when starting out in a new practice area. But if you are efficient and learn quickly it may not be as tough.
There’s also the issue of ability to find work. If your firm is a volume firm, that might not be as much of an issue, but if there are lulls in work available, then that will also impact your ability to consistently hit your hours.
I am confused by the language that the firm does not guarantee insurability for health insurance. I get life/ disability, but health?!
[Continued]..
While I'm aware of the increased paperwork, I'm more interested in gathering advice and insights from others who have made a similar transition:
Does anyone have experience, for better or worse, transitioning into insurance defense litigation? The Firm mentioned 2,000 billable hours, claiming it’s easy to hit, but I have no idea.
Can insurance defense work turn out to be fairly lucrative? I have a friend who does pre-litigation on the plaintiff side, salary is $75K, but with commission/settlement bonuses, he makes over $250K annually.
One of the partners mentioned a pathway to shareholder status, but I’m not entirely sure what that entails. What follow-up questions should I ask? Does becoming a shareholder significantly increase pay ?
I'm curious about potential challenges, expectations, strategies, or specific questions I should ask my partners. Online resources seem to paint a less-than-positive picture of the field, so I'm hoping for some firsthand perspectives.
Any guidance, tips, or experiences would be greatly appreciated
What state will you practice in?
I'm not trying to rain on your parade, but "expect you to devote your full time to the practice of law" is a wild thing to put in an offer letter. 2000 is a LOT of billable hours, and if you have three young kids, this is going to be a nightmare, unless you just really like working 60+ hour weeks and never seeing your family. I've done both Ins Defense and am currently in Plaintiff's PI, and the work life balance is so much better. Also, I make more money. Idk man, people who did defense work can chime in if they don't agree, but this letter is a crazy red flag to me.
I know your 5 YOE is in a different area of law, but $110k at 2000 is a terrible offer for your experience. I wouldn’t settle for anything less than 150k at 2000 hours.
This should be a hard no. I make more than this as a plaintiffs PI paralegal in CA with no billable requirement.