SEEKING ADVICE: I received an offer (see redacted photo) from a private insurance defense & commercial litigation law firm. My five years of practicing law have solely been in criminal law (both as a Prosecutor and defense attorney in TX, CA, CO), plus 1.5 years in Family/Appellate law.

I know nothing about this sector other than what I've read. I’m not familiar with billable hours or how they would reflect on my work-life balance. I have three kids, the oldest is six ..(continued below)..

Post Photo
like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

2000 billable hours is not easy to hit, with young children, that would be very difficult to have a work life balance. 2000 hours is 40 hours per week of billable work, and not everything you do will be billable. This is a high billing requirement and will mean that you work significantly more than 40 hours per week.

like

Stay away and run. It’s not what it’s portrayed to be. Stress and demands are unreal. These insurance people care nothing about you and will grind you down til you snap. The billing is always cut and you have non lawyers telling you how long it takes to research or prepare. It’s borderline malpractice.

like

Transitioned from prosecutor to ID. Other firms will pay more money for less billable hours

like

If your concerns are billable hours & the job being lucrative, you’re on the wrong side of the table; the money is in plaintiff’s side PI (especially if you’re able to bring in your own business) and there aren’t any billable requirements.

Defense side has a cap & is more of a traditional attorney role (i.e. set billable hours, set bonus structure, etc) whereas plaintiffs side is almost entirely commission based - you’ll get a base salary, but the bulk of your money comes from settlements/verdicts/origination.

If i were you, I’d use the trial experience you have on plaintiffs side.

like

Second this

like

A few years ago, I interviewed with a defense firm and received an offer of $110K for 1,850 hours of billable work.

I declined the offer, switched sides, and accepted a deal very similar to your friend’s deal and cleared $200K that year. The following year, I made significantly more than $200K. I very rarely worked more than 40 hours per week. Plaintiff side personal injury work is where it’s at. Just find a reputable firm to work for if you can do so.

like

Theres a running joke that you can work for 9 hours straight and still somehow end up with only 2.9 billable hours, and it’s only funny bc its so unfortunately true. Many young/new associates work 60-80 hours to hit 40 billables, especially when starting out in a new practice area. But if you are efficient and learn quickly it may not be as tough.

There’s also the issue of ability to find work. If your firm is a volume firm, that might not be as much of an issue, but if there are lulls in work available, then that will also impact your ability to consistently hit your hours.

like

I am confused by the language that the firm does not guarantee insurability for health insurance. I get life/ disability, but health?!

like

[Continued]..

While I'm aware of the increased paperwork, I'm more interested in gathering advice and insights from others who have made a similar transition:

Does anyone have experience, for better or worse, transitioning into insurance defense litigation? The Firm mentioned 2,000 billable hours, claiming it’s easy to hit, but I have no idea.

Can insurance defense work turn out to be fairly lucrative? I have a friend who does pre-litigation on the plaintiff side, salary is $75K, but with commission/settlement bonuses, he makes over $250K annually.

One of the partners mentioned a pathway to shareholder status, but I’m not entirely sure what that entails. What follow-up questions should I ask? Does becoming a shareholder significantly increase pay ?

I'm curious about potential challenges, expectations, strategies, or specific questions I should ask my partners. Online resources seem to paint a less-than-positive picture of the field, so I'm hoping for some firsthand perspectives.

Any guidance, tips, or experiences would be greatly appreciated

What state will you practice in?

I'm not trying to rain on your parade, but "expect you to devote your full time to the practice of law" is a wild thing to put in an offer letter. 2000 is a LOT of billable hours, and if you have three young kids, this is going to be a nightmare, unless you just really like working 60+ hour weeks and never seeing your family. I've done both Ins Defense and am currently in Plaintiff's PI, and the work life balance is so much better. Also, I make more money. Idk man, people who did defense work can chime in if they don't agree, but this letter is a crazy red flag to me.

I know your 5 YOE is in a different area of law, but $110k at 2000 is a terrible offer for your experience. I wouldn’t settle for anything less than 150k at 2000 hours.

This should be a hard no. I make more than this as a plaintiffs PI paralegal in CA with no billable requirement.

Related Posts

Anyone have any insight into Success Manager roles at Salesforce? Trying to get a sense of comp, wlb, etc. Specifically looking at a position in the national security sector. TIA!

like

When your leadership team raves about work life balance at happy hours after 3 drinks in.

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi! how is PwC India’s Management Consulting- Finance Transformation aka Finance Effectiveness practice? In terms of career growth, WLB, leadership team? Thanks! PwC PwC India Deloitte USI Deloitte India

like

Anyone made a switch to health tech companies? Do you like it?

like

I got that coveted big law job.

But I would much rather want a family of my own and someone to hug and kiss, something I feel really sad about around christmas.

Never had much contact with my dad, and two years ago, I broke off contact with my mother because I realized that she had been a manipulative narcissist my entire childhood.

Working 50-60h weeks on average doesn’t help your dating life though, and who would want to date someone with no family anyway

likeuplifting

*Keeping an eye open for new opportunities*
I have my Bachelor's degree in Healthcare Administration along with 13 years of experience in healthcare. My experience ranges from medical coding, biller/AR specialist, patient financial advocate, and since 2019 my role is in the Quality department as a health care data analyst.

like

COO’s & previous SR. account executives…

I made it to regional manager for a franchise by age 22. Ran a successful financial practice & sold by the age of 33. Took 2 years off and built a health & wellness coaching platform for my wife (medical provider). Then, the last 2.5 yrs, have been a top producer in Saas sales as a senior account executive. I’ve been told I would make a great COO someday and I’m ready to take the next step into leadership. Who/what should I be targeting next?

like

Is it just me or the average billable work in infrastructure transactions has blown off steam in the last couple of weeks?

Citiustech Healthcare Technologies

How is Citiustech to work with and how is the work Life balance and security aspects here?

Looking for some advice as I am considering relocating to US. How difficult is for HR professionals to get a work visa? I think from what I read I qualify under eb3 (no master yet) or h1b. How do for do about looking for positions that sponsor your visa? I'm in the defense sector and have previously healthcare and financial services experience. Also worked in global matrix organisations with US teams so know the culture quite well. Any help is greatly appreciated.

like

How is HSBC Client in terms of WLB and work culture

like
likeuplifting

Hi fishes,
How is the wlb in Amex?

likefunny

Anyone work for Wells Fargo Corporate and Investment Banking? Have upcoming interviews for two teams (industrials and healthcare) for corporate banking analyst positions and wanted to know what kind of questions to expect. Thanks!

like

Hi All,
One of my friends has recently joined capgemini and has following doubts related to tax proof.
Can we edit the tax declarations in HGS portal every month any day?
Does Capgemini asks for rent agreement along with rent receipts as a part of tax proof submission?
Also which proofs needed for,
80c - elss lic
80d - insurance for senior citizen parents
80ccd1b - nps

I have a MHA, MBA, and BSHA. I’m wanting to get into a supervisor or manger role but I don’t have the experience. Does anyone have any suggestions on how I dive in and start getting the experience I need? I live in Washington and work in Oregon. Also, anything using my MBA would be favored as well, this degree is not healthcare specific. Thank you!

like

How does anyone keep time well for prayer and meditation while fully giving yourself to family and work in this economy?

One can imagine work here as meant in the maximum of work vs life here.

I know people who are constantly crashing and that’s without the set time for prayer. And despite hearts or gold, obvious piety and a high work ethic.

like

Does anyone here work for the custom or express underwriting department at Liberty Mutual? Wondering how you like it and the differences between the two as far as work life balance goes. Appreciate any insight.

like

Hi guys!

I have an offer from wipro for B3 band.

Below is the salary breakage. Could anyone tell me what is going to be my in-hand salary per month.

Basic       :1020000

HRA        :510000

BONUS       :56800

WIPRO BENEFIT PLAN :399840

ADDITION ALLOWNACE :186660

PROVIDENT FUND   :122400

GRATUITY      :54162

HEALTH BENEFIT   :9800

VARIABLE PAY    :191760

Thanks,

Prem 

like
like

More Posts

Where’s everyone based and what are some of the topics you guys would like to discuss?

like

Local Prometric has 3 test slots per day (830 AM, 1 PM, and 5:30 PM). Proctor was telling me that someone come in Wednesday and took three sections consecutively. And I was proud of finishing one...

like

I am from PwC AC. I am interested in an opportunity in PwC India. Can I apply for it externally? PwC India PwC

like

Guys.... I need some help
I returned back from Germany this year and now my current fixed CTC in India is 25 LPA and my in hand salary after deduction was 1.4 LPM, I was not sure what to opt in the Tax regime and selected new tax regime. Can someone shed some light how can I increase my in hand salary and reduce the tax. Also can I change my tax regime while filing Tax returns?

Is it normal to have 60k deductions(Tax and PF) for 2 Lakh salary per month?

like

Hi fishes, I joined as Senior Consultant at deloitte on 6th June.
Is it better to go Deloitte internal project or wait for client project?
Skills: Full stack developer java

like

Anyone have tips for industry interviews for a tax role, but with folks from cross functional teams (e.g., corporate development and legal)? What kind of questions should I expect?

like

Got offered a role at a Middle East office at BCG - haven't accepted yet.
Anyway that I can transfer to a north American office (my current location) before I join? SO can't move to Dubai and while applying they didn't interview me for my current location just for the Dubai one.

I understand this may be a big ask, and I'm happy to interview again if need be.

like

I have an offer from Ey Gds and Bdo for audit assistant manager role, my target is to get secondment to USA, please let me know if BDO provides secondment to audit seniors/assistant managers?

like

How can one overcome anxiety when presenting?

like

Any tips to sleep better? Had problems falling asleep since I was a kid and started talking Adderall. Have tried both Ambien and lunesta and they work for a while but eventually your body adapts and..

like

Sometimes I think.. I could have been an English teacher in ruta Japan.. but now I’m stuck in insurance defense selling my soul.. what could have been

likefunny

I joined Nagarro as a trainee at 3.5 LPA how much hike could i expect??

like

Who is ready to kick some bulldog @$$??

like

Does anyone know what the Twitter DM threats to I believe a female strategist were about? Seen a ton of tweets about it but have no context.

like

Idk, maybe it’s time we bring these engineers and techs down. If my 🧠 links to a 💻 , all of my non-billable work will come to light. 😤

Post Photo
like

How much does BGSW Bosch gives for a Functional Software Developer with 2.9 YOE ? No other offers in hand.

like

Looking to do some case prep in the coming weeks - DM me if interested

like

help I literally never learned to properly case and have an interview coming up with BCG, what are the best resources for me to use?

like

About to join BNY Mellon this month pune location as a Technical Lead. I am eligible for bonus in Jan 2023 or not ?

Everything's a toy when you're a kitten!

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

Hello All,
I am finishing up my second year of practice as a lawyer. I transitioned to plaintiffs pi work from a boutique commercial litigation firm. I like the work and not having to bill. The issue I am having is managing volume. I have about 150 active files some pre-lit and the rest are in litigation. Cases range in value from very small to low six figures. I also take the driver seat for the grunt work on the firms bigger cases which are at or near 7 figure value. I constantly feel (cont.)

like

What are good KPIs for personal injury support staff?

like

In an auto accident trial, can you inform the jury in any way that the at-fault driver had insurance? I have a hard time believing a jury would award 7-figure damages if they thought the little old lady defendant had to personally pay. I’m just starting to do PI on the side by myself at my firm, so this is probably a very dumb and obvious question.

like

Thoughts on purchasing leads?

like

I currently work at a small PI firm in Atlanta were EVERYTHING is settled presuit. If we’re unable to settle, then it’s referred to another firm for litigation. This whole process seems very atypical to me and the attorneys rarely touch a file until the first liability offer is received. The paralegals handle everything from intake to drafting the demands. The attorney briefly skims (does NOT read) the demand packages and signs. Is this ethical?? Anyone else work at a firm that is run this way??

like

We lost an interim payment application for a client who has Steven Johnson's disease from a negligent prescription

Disappointed we lost

What's your preference for plaintiff's side? Steady pay at approximately $120k with no bonuses, or a base salary of $70k plus a cut of what you close over a minimum threashold? Midwest-ish market. In both situations, you get a cut of what you bring in.

like

What metrics do you think are most important to measure for success of a Plaintiff’s firm? Obviously revenue, but what else is at the top of the list for you?

like

What does compensation look like for a second year associate at a personal injury law firm? Please comment if you practice in Los Angeles.

like

For Plaintiff's attorneys, how big is your caseload? What kind of cases are the majority of them and are they in suit? I am currently handling 150+ mostly MVAs and premise liability cases, just about all in suit, (on top of about 10 DUIs and other small traffic matters) and I feel like I'm drowning and looking to jump ship. What is normal/to be expected? In NYC area if that matters

like

What’s a good LA or NY business litigation firm and salary to expect? I’m a 2yr with quite frankly a lot of experience across civ rights, PI, excessive force, wrongful death, employment defense, K dispute, corp. structure dispute, professional licensure. Write every kind of brief, appeals, argue motions, take depos. Am the only associate working directly under partner on all cases. In house or M&A/Real Estate Transactional are likely the end goal but want to get the litigation out of me first.

funny

What do you guys send as gifts to referral sources for attorneys and/or former client referral sources?

*Assume in my jurisdiction there are no ethical issues associated with this

likehelpful

I give my cell phone to all clients routinely. However, there are always 1 to 2 clients who abuse this and it seems as soon as their cases are over I find a new one and it is making me rethink. I hate to do this because 98% do not abuse it and I like being connected to my people. Thoughts??

like

Hello all, I'm a very green attorney, never tried a single case or even was second or third chair, but managed to land a litigation associate position at a Plaintiff's firm. Does anyone remember their first trial? How did you feel and how did it turn out by comparison? Anything you wish you did differently?
I know in THEORY what the process of trials are but thanks to COVID I haven't been able to observe them in real life so I'm very nervous for the day I finally enter a courtroom.

like

Hello. Does anybody have a CA loss of consortium demand they are willing to share.

like

4th year at a mid size PI firm. Got pulled from litigating MVAs to help this solo we hired start a med Mal/nursing home practice. 1 year in and it looks like I’m two steps backwards in terms of getting paid because we’re a year or more out from a lot of the fees hitting. I respect the solo a lot, he’s a mentor, but I’ve got kids and I gotta get paid. Trying not to burn bridges, but I can’t wait years to get cut in. Advice?

like

Definitely going to be a noobie question!

My client's medical provider asked for his PIP ledger: how do I get that? Just send a LOR to the carrier and ask?

like

I’m a 3L applying in NYC for post grad employment. Which plaintiffs PI/Med firms have the best opportunities for a junior? Everything I find, including my past summer job, is a small shop with 3 partners max and a handful of established associates. I would really like plaintiffs side.

likesmart

I want to start my own PI firm. What should I know? What should I do? What should I read? Thanks!

like

I'm a 6th year attorney in NYC. Strictly defense work; started out with the City Law Dept, did a year and a half of med mal/construction, and for past year and a half have been at a well known defense firm working on high exposure construction accident cases. Contemplating taking a couple interviews at plaintiff's firms to see if there is a good fit. Does anyone have any advice on how approach discussions about compensation and what a market level comp package would or should look like?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal