Should a strategist do an MBA?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

No. You’re not learning many business skills in an MBA program (aside from a few technical areas like financial modeling). Most of the curriculum is group projects and presentations. The real value of an MBA is in building your network, not your education.

In my opinion, an MBA is only worth it if you get into a T15 program (since those have the strongest networks), and if you’re looking to switch into a field that actively recruits MBAs, like consulting, tech, or finance.

Don’t get an MBA just to stay in marketing or advertising. This industry doesn’t pay well enough to justify the $80k+ in loans you’ll have to take out to attend the program.

likesmart

Unfortunately I don’t have a good answer for you other than go brand side and try to learn on the job. Or do an online course.

Yes. Useful to actually have some business skills

My experience working with MBAs is that it’s about the network and the importance of the credential in corporate settings. The latter may actually hurt you in advertising (agencies don’t trust corpo biz guys, and clients are hiring you specifically *not* to replicate the perspective of their team) and the former will help you, but less as a strategist as more as a connected new biz generator.

My unfair opinion is that the financial management and modeling stuff is useful but rarely your job, and the famous case studies that get regurgitated in the place of ideas or insight are available for a lot less - subscribe to HBR and take up golf and you’ve basically gotten the same value for less time and money.

Nah not needed!!

This industry doesn’t pay enough to justify the expense. Even if you went to B school, I’m willing to bet you’d end up at a consultancy by the end of it instead of an agency. I feel bad for people who felt the need to get an advanced degree or go to a strategy “boot camp” or similar programs. Didn’t do any of that.

Focus on honing your creative sensibilities instead. That’s what’ll fast-track a strategist in a creative agency—being good at evaluating, building on and selling the work. If creatives love you and you’re making the creative product better, you’ll climb quickly.

Now, whether that’s the kind of work that appeals to you—especially long term—is another story…

How old are you and what did you study in undergrad?

Wow, I’ve never heard of such a problem! That’s a no brainer, you should 100% get your MBA.

I would also say its really not needed. I would probably only do it if it was being paid for by the company you are working for.

I suggest pursuing a Master's in any Social Science (sociology, anthropology, psychology, etc.

Do it if it doesn’t cost you an arm and a leg. I have one. The conversation with clients and other c-level are smarter. You would also be different than all the planners because you can have a business, money making, margin and share growing conversation than just tweaking an ad. They way the industry is going a business understanding will serve you well. If you are a go-getter hustler type, adding an MBA would super charge your growth. Strategy is about making smart choices and increasing the odds of success. This will help you.

But, like, why get an MBA and stay in brand strategy when it can open doors to higher paying careers, sooner? I’d try working a brand strategy angle while in a role at a consulting firm, instead of staying in agency-world. But maybe I’m not thinking about this the right way

Related Posts

Looking to take the CISA exam. I have over 5 years of audit experience. How long do you think it’d take to study? Also, what study material should I use? Any good boot camps you’d recommend?

Any current MBA students on here? Any wisdom/things you wish you knew before starting??

Hi Sharks,

I have 2.5 years of experience after completing MBA and want to get into consulting. If someone can please give me referral in IBM, it would be incredibly helpful.

like

Wonder if anyone can offer advice on which cert to pursue next? I obtained my CompTIA Security+ last year and wondering if I should go for the CySA+ or Pentest+ next. I also have my AWS CCP and will be sitting for the Solutions Architect soon as well. Currently not doing security stuff at work but would love to keep my skills going. I was hoping one of these next certs will help me finally break into a security role and love the idea of pentesting but not sure if the CySA+ is more beneficial.

like

Anyone here has taken the PMP certification ? Is it worth it over MBA and if you're managing projects in Advisory?

like

Hello fishes,

Can someone help me with the review of ETO E-Business Services at
Goldman Sachs.

I am interested in joining but I am getting a feeling it is a helpdesk L1 job.

I am an MBA finance from new IIM

Thanks in advance

What industries is the CFE certification used for? How does it compare to CPA in the length of the material and difficulty? Do most firms pay for It?

like

To those of you who are planning to apply to MBA: Make sure you choose your recommender CAREFULLY. Really evaluate the person you’re requesting the letter from, their personality, and their relationship with you. You don’t want to be back stabbed like me 🙃

likefunny

Hi Fishes, I need your help to make a decision.

I am being offered 17lpa fixed + 1.7lpa variable by Mckinsey Bangalore and 14.5lpa fixed + 1.5lpa Joining bonus by Deutsche Telekom WFH.

Both are offering me a SDE 1 position.

I want to know the better company keeping in mind WLB, Perks and Benefits, Culture, also with the thought that in the future I want to pursue an MBA in the future.
I will be relocating to Bangalore so I also want to know the cost of loving in Bangalore.
Thanks

like

Hi fishes,
I need guidance for EY GDS SaT_Strategy Hub_Senior Analyst. I have 1.5 Yoe but the role mentioned 3-6 yoe.
Is it still worth applying or is there any analyst role for this?
PS: experience post Tier 2 MBA

like

Hi all, I have the Sales Cloud Consultant exam coming up , Any tips on online study (besides trailhead) from those who already got the cert? Or any Deloitte resources?

L6 strategy & ops offer - what do you recommend for base, salary and equity in SF? ~10 yrs of experience and MBA.

like

Advice for studying for CISA? I’ve purchased the CRM, QAE, and Hemang Doshi’s book. So far I’m having trouble reading through the CRM because it’s so detailed that everything seems important and difficult to retain. I’m an incoming new hire so I think I should read the book even though I know people who have passed with only QAE (they were previous b4 interns)

like

If I reject Accenture Technology offer, will I be able to appear for Accenture Strategy interview later on? I have an MBA.

like

What are the salaries like at level 9 & 10 for management consulting in digital commerce at Accenture strategy? My profile: 4 years tech experience in e-commerce and data + MBA from tier 2 bschool + ecommerce BA experience at Capgemini

like

Hey Fishes ,
I am a QA/SDET with 8 YOE , good in building framework for UI and API Testing , right now working on improving coding (DSA) and AWS (SAA certification). I am at 25 LPA now and my aim is to get in FAANG what all i need to get in my bucket to crack that (or atleast improve my chance of getting in ), please guide me .

like

What are realistic expectations for 3rd Year Analyst / Direct Promote Associate bonus range at a BB? Note that at MS, 2nd year bonuses in my group last year were 90-115K, while MBA associates received a pro-rated 90K stub (~40k). Personally would be pretty unhappy to take a pay cut between 2nd and 3rd year…

like

(1/2) For those w/ technical backgrounds: how did you develop executive communication skills? I’m a year into MBB (post MBA) and have had really great reviews on client, problem, and team

Can someone give a time sense for an average prep time for CSCP certification versus CPIM? I think CPIM takes much longer but not sure

like

Does anyone want 2016 APICS CSCP exam materials? Totally free, asking for the shipping cost tho. They haven’t been used, someone gave me their version and I used those to study

like

More Posts

L6 strategy & ops offer - what do you recommend for base, salary and equity in SF? ~10 yrs of experience and MBA.

like

Are there any roles at Google that would consider someone coming from Private Equity Ops (with consulting background) or is that too far removed? About to take a PE position but would like to know if it hurts my chances at moving to Big Tech one day - thank you

Can I use design tasks as a project brief and work on my portfolio? I’m working on my portfolio and have design tasks shared by 2 companies through my friends. Can I work on these tasks as projects and add it in my portfolio?

like

My Salary growth over a total of 8 years of experience may be helpful to some career aspirants as a reference in the software Industry (Key for success is always upskill as per market needs and your passion)

Post Photo
likesmartupliftinghelpful

Side hustle or startup ideas for someone who isn’t technical/doesn’t code? Where should I look or where to begin? I don’t have any strong passions or specific skills that I’m confident in. What books, articles, blogs, orgs, events, people I should follow for inspiration that has helped you? I have some cash to invest and am looking for a part time hustle that can cash flow at least a little bit of money on the side.

like

Have lost so many loved ones in this pandemic. Just cannot get over it!

like

With the latest Southwest Visa cc, you get 4 upgraded boardings a year. I’ve used 1. My question is this. What is a “year”? Is it calendar year or your anniversary date of when card was issued?

like

I know that the economy is troublesome and it is causing mental health issues- is anyone else afraid of social distancing being lifted too soon?

like

How do you effectively plan for retirement?

like

I heard food is free in exl is that true

like

Hello Sharks,
I have recently got an offer from a real estate IPC for associate consultant, offering 7 LPA which is 33% hike Approximately on my current CTC,
Is it worth taking this offer?
Location is Gurgaon, can I survive easily in such a place with this pkg?
Please help!

like

I finally plan on quitting in two weeks. I’m so overwhelmed with emotions. I don’t even have a job lined up. I can’t wait to reclaim my life!

likeuplifting

Do you ever just stop and think how we’ve made up this society with items and things of monetary value rather than live peacefully and the fact that we’re too absorbed with our own lives to stop and think of how if we did it together we could actually do it? 🙃

like

I just want to retire

like

Is there special experience or knowledge you'd need to be effective at a GCD level in Pharma? Or is it like any other account, just different products? I'm considering making the switch from general market advertising.

like

£200 for WFH equipment , what are you fishes getting

Advice for studying for CISA? I’ve purchased the CRM, QAE, and Hemang Doshi’s book. So far I’m having trouble reading through the CRM because it’s so detailed that everything seems important and difficult to retain. I’m an incoming new hire so I think I should read the book even though I know people who have passed with only QAE (they were previous b4 interns)

like

Interested in healthcare consulting roles at Deloitte S&O, I’m in KPMG’s healthcare practice.

like

Hi everyone! I’ve been working as a product manager in an internal consulting department at Kaiser Permanente a on software product that maps and automates clinical workflows. Although my title is a consultant, my role entails the usual responsibilities of a PM (prioritizing builds and features, identifying business requirements, mapping user journeys and stakeholder management). Does anyone have any advice on ways to break into tech or suggestions of companies to look into?

like

Additional Posts in Strategy & Planning

Has anyone ever worked with Mark Pollard or Julian Cole? Are they as great as they seem?

likefunny

What’s is like going from social strategy to brand strategy? Advice for making that career jump?

like

Salary range for a Strategist (mid level) in NYC?

like

What brands are you really into at the moment? Would be great to think about and be inspired by those doing a great job!

Brand planners, how much time do you typically get when you’re on a new account writing a brief for a new integrated campaign? Do you find yourself having to negotiate/push back with account folks so you have the time to do it properly? Curious with shortening timelines these days how long you all have to think about a brand brief.

like

What is a go-to-market strategy?

funnylike

What have you found most helpful in training up a very green junior brand planner or junior strategist? Any particular trainings or resources that are great at teaching foundational skills? I’ll be pulling them into projects and teaching through doing but I need some assistance in building up their core skills/training the strategy muscle.

like

Looking to bring on a experiential marketing specialist (FT) with 5 years of experience - any idea of the average salary range for such position these days?

like

Has anyone worked at a smaller branding agency? Would love to switch from big agency to actually creating brands but not sure how to start there.

like

What is the best way to find out if a career in Strategy is right for you?

like

Digital strategist with tons of experience soup-to-nuts. At this for more years than I care to think. Any tips on finding opportunities client side? It’s only a matter of time before layoffs start

like

If Arya Stark from GOT worked in advertising, she would be a strategist...

like

What blogs, podcasts, twitter accounts, newsletters etc. should ever planner follow?

like

Any good examples of mid-level resumes?

like

I'm new to marketing and I am not formally educated in it. I have just been learning through experience with the business. I'm supposed to put together a Market report for our sales team to refer to but I have been stuck on what I even include. I have an expensive subscription to a reporting database and I am supposed to translate these technical reports into 20-30 slides. I can't figure out if I am overthinking something simple or lacking some knowledge that people formally learn in school.

like

Amazon should act as Santa during the holidays and deliver one gift fully wrapped from your wish list for free every year to everyone with Prime just to say thank you for choosing us. Bad idea or good

like

Planning director vs strategy director. Whats the diff? Is there a diff?

I feel like a planning director wouldnt know how to manage digital strgy while a strgy dir would be much more well rounded

like

Top agencies to complete an internship in Detroit area?

Anyone have any good diversity training resources?

like

Does anyone have a good lead on where to find research backed customer journeys? Either generic for an industry (like restaurant) or for major players in an industry (like chili's). I am fairly new to planning, and this keeps coming up as something and that would be helpful.
Thank you!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal