Smarter to pay off CC and stop putting money in 401k? Doing both isn’t working.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Do what is best for you. Might be hard to figure out but take the advice and see how it feels. My cc debt was consuming me. I actually pulled from my 401k and paid it off. I was about 30 then and getting married in 2 years. Then I had a fresh start and less stress. Now I’ve doubled down on my 401k contributions and am debt free. I feel great. Yeah I was taxed for it but it was worth it to me

likesmart

OMG... as someone who works in Finance who just stumbled upon this post - some of the advice on here is frightening... Never - and I can’t say this more emphatically - NEVER - pull money from your 401k to pay off credit card debt. This is the WORST advice I have ever heard. I have heard this misconception before from people who take loans from their 401k and literally just do not understand what they’re doing. This could turn into a really long post - but please talk to a Finance professional to help you. When you take a loan out of a traditional 401k - you pay taxes TWICE - yes twice! So estimate 20-25% when you retire and 25% or so when you repay the loan with after tax dollars. The first post is correct when they say save up to the match. Free money is free money. Not sure what your credit looks like, but a great way to save on interest is to move the debt to a zero percent offer with another credit card - and just make sure to never use that card for any purchases. There are ways around paying a lot of interest - but it depends on your credit history.

likehelpfulsmart
Recent IconRecent

^they just said that doing both isn’t working.

Unlike most people on here, I understand the struggle. In general yes it’s better to pay off debt than save if you’re in a lot of debt, which I am too! Don’t let the trust fund kids of this industry tell you you’re losing money by not saving. You’re losing more in interest by not paying off your CCs.

And, btw, we’re human. When you feel like you’re making no progress on your debt it’s REALLY easy to just take from savings. Then you’re in a worse place than you started.

like

Dear god you are all so dumb

It’s not just the 401k vs cc

If you’re struggling to make your payments and carrying any revolving debt, you’re a lay-off away from defaulting on a loan and wrecking your credit. Which will make every loan you ever apply for dramatically more expensive, which then further increases financial pressure on your secured assets that you really need (house, car)

And you’ll lose your job in a downturn in which case your 401k is fucked as is your match

Don’t listen to these idiots. It’s not just about returns. It’s about risk adjusted returns and a margin of safety.

Get safe first.

Sincerely,
A former investment banker who is way better off than all the other people in this thread and doesn’t take it for granted for one second

likesmart

Rule of thumb is to pay off bad debt before you invest. Ideally, yes, put away as much as the company matches, but if you can’t do both, get rid of the debt.

like

The math (and CC interest calculator) says...

If you put $250/month into a 401k with a 50% match, you'll get a $125/month ($1,500/year) return. That's without figuring in investment growth or tax benefits.

That same $250/month put toward a credit card balance at a 20%APR will save you somewhere around $400/year in interest.

$400 vs. $1,500.

Always. Take. The. Company. Match.

From someone who paid off a lot of debt, while contributing to get the maximum company match. I ate a lot of ramen, drank a lot of really cheap beer, and bought super-cheap clothes for about 3 years to do it.

like

EDELMAN1 Da real MVP 💰

likefunny

In what respect is it not working?

Ultimately you have to do what works for you. But the reason the received wisdom is to always contribute to your 401k, assuming your employer matches, is that the rate of return on your contributions is likely between 50-100%.

That will be much higher than the interest in your credit card debt. So by saving into your 401k you’ll pay off your debt slower, but overal you’re finances will improve more.

In contrast you can pay nothing into your 401k and throw all your money at the CC debt. That’ll pay off your debt quicker and cost less interest as a result. But you’ll end up worse off overall.

Don’t listen to people who think you have to have a trust fund to think that saving is the better option.

This only applies if your employer matches your contributions. If they don’t, then chuck it all at the debt.

likehelpful

Put as much into your 401k as your company will match, otherwise you’re literally turning down free money. Usually that’s 6-7%, but based on company’s policy.

Paying off CCs/debt in general is tough, but as long as you’re paying more than the minimum due, you’re productively chipping away at it. Obviously, stop putting new charges on it.

like

Maybe a better question for Finanshbowl

like

Keep in mind you often only actually get the 401k match once you’re vested, which can be ~3 years with the company. If you’re planning on leaving earlier you still get the tax benefits but not the 50-100% return that’s usually cited in these calculations.

likehelpful

Pay off the debt first. Assess why you are in debt that is difficult to pay off. Make a budget for yourself. Every dollar should have a home. Consider using cash for any play money to help you build discipline. I’m of the camp that you should also have a liquid emergency fund before investing anything. It’s your own insurance policy to prevent more debt.
1. Budget
2. Pay off debt
3. Build 3-6 mo expenses as liquid emergency fund
4. Contribute to 401k

Even though logically it makes sense to pay 401k for company match ASAP - the approach above will lead to more peace of mind, less debt, and more empowered approach to your financial life. Follow the steps and you will be maxing your 401k in no time

like

Usually you can take a loan from your 401k that's very low interest. It comes automatically out of your paycheck. Might be something to consider to wipe out high interest CC debt.

like

@edelman1 I’m confused - the OP isn’t talking about taking money out of the current 401k, just not contributing to it until CC debt is paid off. Or am I totally reading this wrong (which is usually the case on here 🙇🏽‍♀️)

like

The interest is way higher than SD1 lined out. I think it’s more like 1200-1500 a year in interest. I agree free cash from company is good but getting rid of the worry is almost worth it.

like

Pay off the CC! Never carry a balance!

like

Agreeing with Director 2. Also, before you contribute to a 401k, you not only need to get your debt paid off, but you also really need to having an emergency savings of at least 3 months built up. If you lose your job you'll need it to get by while you look for something else, you don't want to have to borrow it from your 401k, because as the finance person above said, you'll pay taxes twice on it. Saving for the long term is important, but you have to take care of the short term first.

like

I was in a lot of debt a few years back, and through sacrifice and making good money freelancing - I managed to get back on track financially.

First thing I did was paying off all debt, credit cards, student loans, car loans, my parents - every bit off it. The feeling of doing the last payment is amazing. Best day ever.

Second thing was to save up an emergency fund. Now I can survive for 5-6 months if anything happens.

Thirdly, with $750-1000 saved a month in just debt payments, I’ve ramped up my savings from nearly nothing to around 20-25% of my earnings in 401k, stocks, IRAs, crypto and cash.

The lesson of paying off your debt the hard way, makes me extremely cautious of ever accruing new debt. Now I always read the fine print. I do the interest rate math to see how much it will really cost me. I pay yearly fees instead of monthlies. I try to keep track of where all my money goes. I always ask myself if I really need something, or if I should save the money towards a house instead. I know I sound like an accountant, but it feels infinitely better.

The moral of the story is that for me, paying off debt was the best place to start. It taught me lessons I wouldn’t have learned, and without the monthly debt payments I’m saving at a much more rapid pace. I feel somewhat in control of my finances for the first time in my life, and it’s a good feeling.

Good luck!

like

TBH nobody knows who’s correct without the actual figures to make the calculation.

like

Bootstrap kid here, the advice that i haven't seen yet seems the most practical and least popular to me, but have you thought of getting a second job and using the income from that to pay down your debt?

likehelpful

Related Posts

Does Deloitte offer any fitness fund reimbursement and if so, how much is it? Can we purchase home office equipment with it? Would I be able to get stuff reimbursed this calendar year (my start date is Nov. 8th)?

likesmart

Best consulting companies for Healthcare related projects ?

Anyone over 70 still teaching? If so, why and how is it going?

likehelpful

Hello, I am a new grad with a doctorate in OT. I just got an offer for a job working at a private school. The offer is 58K with benefits. 15 days PTO. Do you guys think I can negotiate the salary to 70K, which based on my research is the average pay for my level of experience and education? Or is that too much to ask?

like

Hi Guys, Please help in which one to select from the following, I'm really confused

Eli Lilly and Company - X CTC (~13% variable) + 2 lac joining bonus, location Bangalore

Thoughtworks - X CTC (including 1.5L other benefits) + 1 lac joining bonus, location Pune

Gap Inc. - X+1 CTC(~8% variable) + 2 lac joining bonus, location Hyderabad

Priority is learning and wlb
Notice remaining- 1+ month
YOE- 2 yr Skills- Node.js, Vue.js, AWS

Eli Lilly and Company Thoughtworks Gap Inc.

like

How’s WLB, Benefits, and Compensation for ISR/Account Manager at VMware?

like

What are the benefits of going the FDD route over audit other than “higher pay”? Note that in Toronto, audit pays higher than FDD at the senior level

like

Looking for recommendation - books, blogs, podcasts etc to learn about investment in stocks, bonds, options, commodities etc? TIA!

like

Product Design Engineer, interviewing at Apple (Cupertino) and at Meta (Seattle/Redmond). Not at the offer stage yet, but I'm contemplating where I would relocate with family.
No idea about team/culture/stability differences yet.

The non-work factors I'm debating are:
1. Cost-of-living (housing!). Could probably afford a nice ~$1.25M SFH in Seattle suburbs sooner than a fair $1.5-2M near Cupertino.
2. Public School quality. Unsure private will be affordable.
3. Weather/region: activities

like

Trying to save up for a down payment on an investment property. Would it make sense to remove my 401K contribution for about 6 months to gain an extra $4K or is that stupid? I’m 23 and have no experience, just wanted opinions

like

Anyone at Deloitte working within healthcare regulatory willing to chat?

I keep getting contract offers on LinkedIn (think self-employed consultant). The rates seem really good ($120-$150/hr). I have around 5 years exp and a CISSP. I’m highly considering leaving big4 to become a contractor/self-employed consultant. From a risk perspective I’m young and have no kids and low debt.
Anyone did it? Any feedback?

like

What % of your FT salary is benefits? I’m trying to figure out how to convert my freelance rate to a FT rate if I get converted. I’m a junior creative in NYC, btw.

like

I’m contributing post-tax 401k offered by my employer to take advantage of the mega backdoor Roth. How often do people roll it over to their Roth IRA account? Like every month? I understand that any gains rolled over would be subject to tax but don’t expect it much given the market is down currently.

like

I moved back in with my parents in August, and my mom and stepfather have demanded monthly rent. They are in no way poor at this moment in time, and in my opinion it’s f*cked up to demand your child pay rent. I bought a VR headset a couple weeks back and my mom increased the rent because “I can afford it.” Is this normal? I honestly feel used. Fwiw I’ve worked since I was 13, and hustled my entire life.

likefunny

Hello guys.. what are the benefits like in Wells Fargo?. And the number of leaves. Will they change our shift timings post joining?

like

I’m a healthcare recruiter that specializes in physician and CRNA recruitment across multiple specialties. I’m curious from the other side of the same nickel, what do you want in a new job? Are you interested in travel contract work?

like

Offers in Finance Transformation with Deloitte VS PI- Finance with EY, SC level, almost the same pay n benefits. Thoughts on which one to pursue? Thanks 🙏

like

What are some benefits that would entice you to work over 40 hours a week if it wasn’t a requirement?

like

Are there any executives out there who have recently negotiated with their CEO for an updated compensation package? I know I'm being underpaid as a CFO who has also handled all of the HR responsibilities for the past 3 years. Currently at $130K with $30K bonus at the end of the year. I don't take the insurance through the company either. Currently no 401K match program available.

More Posts

Admin of the bowl please change the name to MINDTREE

like

Who to put in my Flex?

Theo Riddick
L. McCoy
Jarvis Landry

Anybody know an employee at John Deere?

like
like

Recent college graduate searching for entry-level journalism jobs in DC.

I have two years of writing experience. Any advice would be appreciated.

likesmart

Looking for reccos on sports photographers in Mexico City. Any suggestions from the fishies??

like

If I’m looking at relocating across the country, do agencies normally offer some relocation money as part of the offer? What would be the standard to ask for?

like

Looking for recommendation - books, blogs, podcasts etc to learn about investment in stocks, bonds, options, commodities etc? TIA!

like

Larsen & Toubro Infotech I’m looking for fullstack developer role.
Skills: Angular,Node.js , MS SQL , AWS Larsen & Toubro Infotech kindly refer. YOE: 3 years

like

Average salary for Account/Project Director w/10yrs experience in NYC?

like

Anyone have any insight on the Goldman Sachs Early Careers program? Just had a virtual interview but can’t see my submitted roles and was told I’d be reached out to for next steps in the future. Anyone have any insight to this program and how recruiting works?

like

Product Design Engineer, interviewing at Apple (Cupertino) and at Meta (Seattle/Redmond). Not at the offer stage yet, but I'm contemplating where I would relocate with family.
No idea about team/culture/stability differences yet.

The non-work factors I'm debating are:
1. Cost-of-living (housing!). Could probably afford a nice ~$1.25M SFH in Seattle suburbs sooner than a fair $1.5-2M near Cupertino.
2. Public School quality. Unsure private will be affordable.
3. Weather/region: activities

like

Failed reg, studying for it again, dont want to. Talk me out of quitting.

like

My Twitch community grew quickly so I got brave and put originals on youtube and spotify. They have gone nowhere and I’m feeling so discouraged. How do amateur musicians gain traction?

like

Any good restaurant in San Diego? Just moved here. Wanted some recommendation

like

What gift did you get your spouse on your wedding day?

like

Thoughts on CrowdStrike? Hold/buy/sell 🤔

like

Tax sucks. Bleah.

likefunny

I recently joined JPMc Blr in risk CCB and contrary to all the good reviews of wlb in JPMc my wlb is Shit. Just joined 45 days back and on most if the days I am working till 12 or 1 in the night. Most of the work that I do is creating 'urgent ' dashboards on excel. Since I do not get enough sleep, most of the days I have pain in my head. My work is only going to increase in future, already thinking to switch. Only problem is I will have to repay relocation money which is 2L. What should I do?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Anyone have a recommendation for books or resources on upping my sales game? Open to in person class, online class, books, etc!

like
like

It's layoff city here in Southfield.

like

What companies have in-house agencies?
I know of Netflix, Verizon, Casper and Intel. But can anyone help me out with some other good examples?

like

know cool places to do wood work, cooking, pottery class in Chicago? need a new hobby

like

Pretty quiet around here today. Looking forward to the evening/drunken hours when all the trenchant snark comes to life.

likefunny

What's with the JWT discrimination suit and what's that all about it? Is discrimination really a thing in our industry? 🤔

like

Which is most important to you: Interesting content, great location, or fun team?

like

Iprospect New York ... what’s the culture like ? What’s leadership like ? Good place to work? Average ? Just like everything else?

like

What’s blasting through your headphones?

like

laid off in Oct but ended Jan with 4 in-persons and good feedback. fast forward a month - ghosted twice, one put on hold, and one no. ~1 month of unemployment left - f@&k i feel worthless.

like

I’m anticipating 2 offers and need some opinions. A) ACD role @ not exciting agency doing potentially great work, significant commute. B) AD role in house at a great company. Minimal commute. Both SF.

like

CCO and art partner are really close, only talk to each other in meetings. They even send each other emails and texts about this project and leave me out. But I end up doing all the work. What to do?

like

I’m looking for some new things to read or listen to — doesn’t need to be ad-related. Books, podcasts, whaddya got?
I’m not really into fiction, but open to anything. Last books I enjoyed were Junior and Moonwalking with Einstein, last podcast I binged was Startup (Gimlet).

like

Looking for practical advice on improving my attitude to work.

So imagine an imaginary scale where 0 is the worst piece of work a studio could produce and 10 is the best possible outcome.

As an animator working in an agency, I normally end up involved in projects towards the end, so by the time I get my hands on a project I can add between 1 and 3 depending on how much effort I put in.

If a project is a 3 when I get it, how do I summon the energy to make it a 6 that I could to make a 7 a 10?

like

Which agencies have sabbatical programs for years of service?

like

Why does the 3% Conference get so much money from agencies & clients when they have a history of showcasing toxic, abusive to female employees underneath them, women in advertising? Every year, people are shocked at who gets featured there. The idea is not just to celebrate women, it’s to celebrate aspirational women. Maybe they ran out of speakers and are dipping down too much. But agencies and clients should take a hard look at who is speaking before giving money.

likesmart

Follow-up email to a recruiter or accept defeat?
5 days since last contact which was supposed to be “ASAP.

like

Lots of respect for the staffers at Spotify if they end up walking out of their jobs for something they believe in. That said what a sad mess we have gotten ourselves into when we try and censor every dissenting opinion as hate speech, especially when Joe Rogan has exhibited more journalistic value than most major news networks.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal