Undergrad decision - My son was accepted for mechanical engineering to these schools:

Northeastern
Lehigh
Villanova
Case Western Reserve
University of Minnesota

Which would you choose and why?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Northeastern for sure. Their co-op program is incredibly unique and valuable especially for engineering

like

North eastern has a coop program and honestly it is so valuable. I got my first coop my sophomore year at a fortune 50 company in the engineering space. They offered to keep me part time through college paying me $30 an hour. Before I graduated they signed me on for 70k plus stocks and sign on bonus. 1 year out of college I had 4 years of experience on my resume and came over to consulting making 120.
Coop is a huge advantage and gives students all the soft skills like how to write emails, set up calendar invites. It also teaches you real tools used in the industry.

like

Sounds like a winne

like
Recent IconRecent

Case or Minnesota

like

Definitely Lehigh, just look at job placement and earning potential after graduation. It’s on the pricey end of that list though

like

Minnesota, urban campus with easy on campus recruiting for f500, 3m, Medtronic, gen mills

likesmart

Lehigh, selectivity

like

Saying Cornell is the same level as UNC and UVA is a pretty big stretch...

like

I was a meche and looked/got into most of those schools as well. Does your son have a preference where he wants to live after college? Nova/Lehigh place ppl in PA, NY, DC while northeastern for example has more connections in Boston. I don’t think the prestige at the schools is different enough to play a role in this decision....especially for someone who wants to be an engineer. Does he want city/rural? Big/small? Greek life/no Greek? This is what I would care about

like

These are all great. Also look at schools that have other good programs besides just Mech E. As someone who chose a school for cost and engineering, but then hated engineering it was nice getting lucky with a decent, but not great, business school

UMN - great academics, beautiful campus, Big 10 sports and facilities + Minneapolis is a great city to live in with lots to do and many great companies

I think you should also consider if he wants a big school vs a small school and public vs private since the U is very different than the other 4 schools on his list

like

Iowa State University

like

@M2
Iowa State #43 Engineering
Lehigh #63
Villanova # NR
Northeastern #31
Case # #51
Minnesota #31
Pretty up there in the rankings 🤷‍♂️

helpful

Minnesota

like

Northeastern is an up and coming school, I'd expect it to be better than Case in the next 10 years. It's definitely not as prestigious at the moment but their research portfolio is skyrocketing.

I'd look at where the students exit to and make sure that aligns with what your son is thinking about. I'd expect NE sends most eng to industry and Case probably is a much better feeder into grad programs.

likesmart

Lehigh-one of the best engineering firms in the country

likefunny

I didn’t know they went into the private sector ? I thought they stuck to providing 2nd class education

Had he visited all of them prior to C19 closures?

I'd eliminate Villanova from the list, not a differentiated choice, nor as good as the others.

NE is great, and others have mentioned the co-op program. Most schools can do co-op, but none are as strong as NE, Drexel or UDM. Experience of co-op isn't only to make money, but to learn what real engineering is like. Summer internships are NOT close to this.

CWRU & UMN are stronger in midwest, but back to my first question. If he hasn't visited, there is no way to explain the difference between smallish private tech focused and Big 10 broad variety of strong programs.

Does he want a city. Or hate cities? Nothing more urban than NE. Nor more rural than Lehigh on his list.

like

After time in the Twin Cities and Rochester I moved to Boston. Didn't need a winter coat though people that grew up there did. Coming from CHI he will find it much more mild. Philly is much warmer still.

UMN is a gem for all the reasons already mentioned above if one can withstand the cold

like

CWRU

like

Case, one of the best respected in Ohio and US for private (but why would you pay for that when a public option is so much better, i.e. University of Cincinnati).

like

UC is so overlooked, especially for industrial. And then if you're engineering minded with a creative leaning there's DAAP, #1 Industrial design program *in the world*.

NE

like

I would look more into culture fit vs caliber of degree IMO. Remembering back to my college days (4 years so not too long ago???), freshmen changed majors and interests like diapers. But I would’ve been so miserable if I hadn’t loved about what I was doing outside of school (clubs, sports) and who I was hanging out with. And most of them came from my major

like

It’s very possible he will switch majors, he was basically firmly undecided on major going into the process. We ended up deciding on ME because he did like engineering and it’s generally much easier to switch out of engineering than into it.

That doesn’t necessarily help us with the final selection though—we pretty much only applied to schools with decent engineering, business, and liberal arts programs.

Any money from any of these schools?

like

Yes, but we have a lot saved for his college and don’t want to base the decision primarily on cost.

like

Case has co-ops too. My wife is a Case grad and did a one year co-op in the middle that was key to her getting job offers during a recession.
Case is a great school, as are some others. But if you're not incorporating other factors such as total cost to attend and "fit", and location the decision methodology is incomplete at best.

like

Thanks. We are considering fit of course, but it’s a bit harder given that with COVID we cannot go on site for visits.

My older son is a junior at Case (Comp Sci) so as a family we are quite familiar with it, but my younger son isn’t excited about following in his brother’s footsteps, so that may end up being factor against Case in his mind.

like

Related Posts

like

How do you choose between Exec Education programs at b-schools? Does hybrid matter? Writing an article…

ZS 🐠 - can you receive sponsorship for MBA prior to having tenure of 3 years? If not, what is the downside of applying after 1 or 2 years? I am coming in with 3+ YOE in consulting, so my application would be competitive for next fall (or ‘23)

like

What looks better for mba applications... management consulting or strategy consulting?

like

McKinsey & Company Does MBB have a minimum GRE score they look at when recruiting MBA candidates (like 320+)? McKinsey & Company

likehelpful

Hi folks - which consulting firms provide sponsorships for EMBA, I’m 12 years experience planning to do EMBA in 2020. Currently in the process of changing jobs and have offers from Deloitte and ACN.

like

Looking for advice on tips and tricks for landing PE MBA internship, coming from consulting. What were the game changers for you?

like

SPHR exam- has anyone ever been “randomly selected” for an application audit? This just happened to me and the sheer amount of effort that is going to go into collecting all the documents almost makes me not want to follow through. Since I didn’t finish undergrad, they’re asking for a copy of my high school diploma or transcript and that itself is going to be an absolute nightmare to get hold of. Guess I’m not really looking for a solution here, just venting.

like

Phr vs waiting for sphr?
Taking the credential and want to prep.

Not sure if this is the right bowl, but how can international students effectively apply for paid internships or jobs ( public health ) with the hope of securing sponsorship to stay in the United States Post graduation and OPT?

like

Does anyone talk about economic diversity? You know middle class and economically challenged people who cannot afford art schools and expensive private colleges?

likeuplifting

Let's say through a combination of aggressive saving, high income, and savvy investments, I manage to save several million by the time I'm 40.

If at that time I decided to pursue my passion and go to law school so that I can be an affordable attorney for worthy causes, will my age hold me back from getting into law school?

likeupliftinghelpful

Hi
I am working in Amazon from June 2020 as L3 HR Generalist. My current CTC is 5.2 LPA. I have a post graduation degree in English.
I was wondering if doing an MBA distance course from Symbiosis would help me get a better position and salary?
Can anyone please suggest? If not symbiosis then can I choose any other University for doing the MBA?

Did any PM or PMM get into b-schools like CBS or NYU to make the transition? Would love to chat!

like

Hi Picking schools right now, any tips? CBS is my dream school. Any chances at M7?

Education:
GPA: 3.0 (2.997) in CS from Northwestern
(1.8 GPA freshman year, 3.67 last 3 years)
GMAT: 770/800 (51Q, 42V, 8IR, 6 AWA)

Work Ex: Started Agri tech company junior year college and sold senior year for a 6 figure sum.

Data Consulting (3.5 years at attendance). Early promotion, and multiple management roles in projects. 2 clubs leader at work. 3 years Volunteer ex in community. Any tips?

like

What's current the market value of someone working in analytics on the agency side in NYC, has 4 years of experience and has a Data Science masters?

like

I have a 700 GMAT score, is Wharton out of reach with this score? Should I retake it?

Has anyone made the jump from TAS to IB? Is it possible with no MBA? Any insight appreciated

like

Does anyone know what meta offers in terms of tuition reimbursement to partner/principal level?

like

Hello Everyone. Please does anyone know where I can go for practicum(kind of like clinical) to conclude my MSN in Nursing informatics. I am located in houston and I am currently attending Chamberlain university. Thanks in-advance.

like

More Posts

Hello all there is an opening for business analyst/SQL DBA in HSBC can anyone refer me please.
or anyone part of SQL DBA team can give some input on this would be great help


Job ID : 0000HEPW
Location : Hyderabad, India

Job link in Comment section

like

Just joined a 300 person startup as a mid-level manager. Is it appropriate to send email to C suite to say hi and introduce myself?

like

How big does an agency have to be to justify a CCO title?

like

So how much money did Jim Carey get for his Super Bowl spot? Guesses?

like

This shouldn’t be news to people but it is.

Post Photo
likeupliftingsmart
like

I'm working with EPAM, 7.8 yoe as dot net full stack with ctc 26LPA.
Fed up with my current tech stack now project want on call support over weekend. no one knows project. No one is supporting.
Thinking abt current situation I'm bit worrying.
Somehow given interview in EY and selected. HR ask me CTC, NP and expected CTC. I told 20% and 60 days NP. She said, will check with business and get back to me.
It's been 3 days no response, when I called her today she didn't pick. Is it normal in EY?

like

Hi fishes,
Any jobs Mining industries, supply chain management and purchase. I have 12 years experience in this domain.

like

Sometimes when two memes collide, the results are annoying. (Sourced from the grams).

Post Photo
likefunny

Hello Everyone,
I am a fresher with over 9+ months of experience as a Data Engineer at
Tata Consultancy .

I just needed some suggestions from you experienced folks.🙏

In my current project my colleagues have over 6+ years of experience and are not very supportive and scold me for unnecessary reasons, which is effecting my mental health.😔
Also I am not getting to learn anything.

Continued 👇

like

Any opening for marketing? I have 10 years of experience in marketing strategy & implementation. My precious firms include law firms and a public company. Any recommendations/referrals are greatly appreciated.

like

For every Logistics Manager:
What are the top 3 red flags when evaluating hiring a new provider?

like

Any good books to read this winter break? On leadership, digital, or any autobiographies?

like

Hi Fishes,

Currently I am a software developer and I wanted to become an software Architect ... What steps I need to follow to achieve the same...

Please let me know your suggestion...

like

I want to know whether the Medical Policy of 3 Lac which is given by the company by default in which along with me my immediate dependents like my spouse and children are covered or not?

like

Considering obtaining a CFE certification. Can anyone share their experience vs experience obtaining CPA? I’m already a CPA. I just want a comparison of study time requirement and difficulty of exam.

like

Walking into the office with a big smile and saying good morning to everyone you pass on the way to your desk sets a positive tone that lasts all day!

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Any good book recommendations for new Managers in consulting ?

like

What are the work hours like for EY infrastructure advisors (part of SaT)?

like

I’ve been phished so many times (due to checking emails while on client calls, or while my kids are screaming my name) that I do not even know how and when to fully distinguish if I am being phished or not.

funnylike

I left KPMG about a month ago to be a senior leader in a smaller tech company's finance function. It isn't bad, get pretty great flexibility... but I don't think I like it overall. How long do I have to stay until I can boomerang to consulting without it looking bad? Given the crazy hiring right now, can I do it sooner rather than later?

like

On my resume, I have listed senior engineer as my title for my time at a company because it was the most recent title when I left, though I had been promoted two months before I left. For a background check, should I put the most recent title or all titles I had at the company (i.e, Sr Data Engineer and Data Engineer, or just the most recent)?

like

What are your covid travel essentials / tips? Traveling next week to meet the team and I’m feeling like a noob. Double mask or kn95 on the full plane? Are planes handing out wipes or do I gotta bring my own? Have kids and elders at home so want to be careful

like

Weird American thing. Friends usually love to have us over but not over Thanksgiving b/c they are nervous around their family. So weird.

like

Officially made Diamond status with Uber! 🙌

likeupliftinghelpfulfunny

Anyone here work at Riveron? Wondering what comp and wlb are like at the senior associate level in nyc.

like

SM’s - how easy or hard was it to exit into industry at Sr director or VP roles. Did you see a big jump in your Salary + Perks?

like

Alright, fishies, let’s try this again. Name drop boutique firms that have offices in San Francisco Bay Area. Big 4 is not my future (as many many MANY of you have repeatedly said I’m not good enough for). So, I’m taking the hint and crossing MBB and Big 4 off my list but still hoping a smaller firm will consider me.

like

How long ago was your firm profile/LinkedIn photo actually taken?

Post Photo
likefunny

Discussion post: I feel almost all consulting firms are the same. Mbb, big 4 etc. if you are paid enough there is probably less wlb. If there is good wlb there is not much money. Can you single out a company that you can confidently say pays very well and also has good wlb and also has good opportunities etc.?

like

Hey all, just wondering if anyone here has been through the referral process with McKinsey? An associate partner referred me two weeks ago and I haven't heard back yet. Trying to align McKinsey with my other interviews so hoping people here can give me a better idea. Also spoke with a senior partner a few days ago who said timeline shouldn't be an issue (after I explained everything) , but not sure if they actually looked into it or not.

like

Looking for book recommendations; any favorites? Interested in both fiction and educational/self-improvement (for example, investment / finance books, time management, etc). I feel my vocab is...

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Where is the best place to sell 1-2 year old GMAT books?

like

I’m exhausted 😓

like

Got hired as a digital strategy consultant. I have over 10 years of industry experience but I’m new to consulting. What courses, workshops or books would you recommend to build a solid toolkit?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal