1/2

Am I being selfish?

My girlfriend of 2 years (known her for 3) has visa issues. We had an amazing relationship, and I truly consider her the girl of my dreams.

I had always known that she missed her family back at home, and that every other month she would cry because she misses them a lot.

2 nights ago was one of those nights. She started tearing up when I said I’m thinking of taking a trip back to our home country to visit her family (and let them know I’m looking to propose).

likeupliftingsmartfunnyhelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Yes, I think you might be selfish a bit. Not sure if you know what it’s like to have visa issues in a foreign country and not be able to see your own family for years. It took me 13 years to get my green card and finally see my family. At times it was so soul-crushing that I contemplated same as your girlfriend - just paying someone to marry me so I can finally see my family. That didn’t mean that I viewed marriage casually - I was just desperately trying to solve a problem that was weighing on me for years. Put yourself in her shoes. She is away from her family, misses them terribly and here you are telling her how you are going to see her family while she is wishing that it could be her going to see them. If you are serious about her and you are sure you want to marry her then just take her to the town hall and do it so she can start her green card process and you can both go see her family together. If you want to marry her anyway why not speed it up to take that weight of her chest?

likehelpfulsmart

100% this. I’ve been in a similar situation and you can tell from a lot of comments on this thread, people just do not understand the struggle of visa issues.

like

I was confused when you said you were taking a trip to see her family, because isn't the whole problem that she can't visit them? Then I realzied you mean you told her you were going to go visit her family... without her. Knowing how hard it's been for her to go so long without seeing them, not knowing when she'll see them again, yet you're planning to leave her behind and go see them alone? You didn't even tell her about the proposal so she thinks you're just casually going to visit her family while she's in so much pain being separated from them and has no idea when they'll be reunited.

I can see why she reacted the way she did. What reaction did you think you would get from telling her you're now going to see her family she's missed so much while she's left behind with the pain of years of separation...

How could you not see sooner that she misses her family that much? Marrying a stranger so she could see her finally see her family again says nothing about her views on marriage. It would not be a real marriage, it'd purely be a legal transaction. A piece of paper that'd allow her to get another piece of paper so she can finally leave the country to see her family. Marriage in the way I assume you mean it is *a lot* more than a piece of paper and legal transaction. She could have done that a while ago instead of being with you for years seeing your relationship through. It's unfair to discount her dedication to your relationship over that comment.

Why go in person to ask them? Under other circumstances in-person can be a nice gesture. In this case it's a lot more meaningful to reunite your wife with her family after years apart, than for you to leave her behind and see them alone for a mere formality. You know you want to marry her, so talk to her family on the phone or on video chat and propose. You don't need drag it out longer than necessary. Have a courthouse wedding and go see her family together, you could even have a wedding ceremony with her family and friends from home.

likesmart

This!

Recent IconRecent

Speak to your girlfriend. This is the time she needs you most. Put yourself in her shoes.

Ask her now! Don’t let her get away if she’s your one!

“Now” lol you’re about 3+ months late my friend. Pretty sure OP didn’t make it. RIP

funnylike

Would marrying you get her the green card she so desperately needs? Or are you also on a visa?

Related Posts

Does anyone have any tips to maximize miles when getting married? We currently only have one card that is the same. Does it make sense to add her to all of my other cards as an authorized user? Any tips appreciated

like

How much is the range for CTC offered to Analyst in Data Science in Credit and Fraud Analytics at Amex . Band is 30 . Yoe ~1 ye . College is BIT Mesra .Any advice would be appreciated here🙂.

like

About to file 485 in 3 months, is it worth it to do H1b stamping now or just wait??

Hi all, has anyone temporarily transferred to the Canadian office of their firm and done the Canadian PR application while they were there on work visa?

like
like

if my PERM is filed in 6th year and approved , i140 pending and h1b maxing out ..can i extend h1b to 7th year?

like
like

Approaching the 1 year mark of my career and taking some time to reflect. What advice would you have for your 23 year old self?

like
like

Hi Everyone - Need some insights. My PERM process was started by company in Feb’22 (currently awaiting wage determination, submitted to DOL in May’22). Its been months and DOL is working on requests from Jan’22. My H1B expires for good in Oct’23 (with all the recapture). Is there any chance I’ll have my PERM completed by then? For those of you who have been through this process, what was the overall timeline like?. Appreciate any insights you can help provide! TY!

Hey folks for UK which Visa is worth to ask for? Skilled Worker or Specialist Worker (formerly known as ICT). Pros and cons please?

PS : I lived in UK on ICT for 3 years and in India since last 2 years.

like

Advice or Book recommendations on how not to get bothered by others/ friends/ peers? What they think or what they do!
Been struggling lately

like

So I have been seeing a guy for 4 months. We have a pay disparity.. he earns less than I do (by quite a bit). He has mentioned a few times that he’s worried I’ll get bored of him when I know he can’t afford the same things I can. I think we are beginning to move past this, but now he’s starting to mention things like ‘I am really broke this month’, and last weekend he told me his mum has lost her job and he’ll have to probably pay her rent. I have a lot of sympathy for his situation … tbc

like

JPMorgan Chase folks, how long does it take after accepting the offer/contract to getting contacted by the premployment screening team ? I have been waiting for a week now but I was told it is triggered automatically after 24hrs to 48 business hours after the acceptance. I have called my recruiter and they said I should check my spam folder which had nothing. Any indications here ?

like

GF is 32 and I’m 28. She wants kids within 2 years, understandably. I never envisioned having kids that early (more like late 30s), but I like her a lot. Anyone else gone through something similar?

like

Frustrated my fiancé keeps talking about raising our future kids in the way he was raised. We’re from different cultures. He wants to name them based on his culture, send them to schools with dual immersion in his language so “they don’t get too American,” and has even mentioned moving so they’re exposed to his homeland and culture. Religiously he is fine raising with both our relig but def wants them to participate in some of the orthodoxy of his more so (cont)

like

I hate that I still want to hear from him. I just have no idea what I want him to say or what I want to say. I feel like if I get anywhere near him he’ll be able to sense my pain. Are we sure the no contact rule is only 21 days? I feel like I need 21 months.

like

How long did you date your SO before moving in with them?

like

Any success stories with EB5? Who did you use? How were the investment terms? Been on H1b 9 years now and no end in sight with eb2 wait. Concerned with risk of outright fraud not 500k investment amnt.

like

Such a pain to file LCA and amend H1B every time I travel somewhere for projects...sigh (working remotely sucks during this process)...

More Posts

I NEED A SYNONYM FOR “EXPERIENCE". As in, “experience amazing bullshit innovation like never before.” -it’s a luxury product no one needs but needs to be “elevated”. I’ve used experience too much.

I have an offer of John Deere and Ezest of same package which one is better
I have 2.6YoE

like

I think I'm breaking even in my portfolio since September of last year... Any thoughts on taking the loss on certain crypto in order to recognize the short term loss to offset my overall ST gain?

I am not that smart. Got a very low score on ACT (below average). Should I even consider getting a MBA? My firm does offer sponsorship, but taking/studying for GMAT/GRE is already stressing me out.

like

What is the starting salary of an employee in legal team in pwc.

How long did you date your SO before moving in with them?

like

Best part about being single: Not having to hold in my gas ! What is the best part of it for you??

likefunny

I have applied for Wells Fargo for more than 15 positions I'm not even getting the status of those applied positions. All are in review stage.How will be the hiring process in Wells Fargo?Wells Fargo

like

I’m potentially moving from a senior social role to an account management position. I feel I’ve capped my growth in social and want to explore other sides of the business. Any tips to set myself up for success?

like

Is freelancing paid media or social media lucrative in Toronto? Looking to make the jump to that

like

Best late night car service in town (that isn’t lyft or uber)?

Has anyone here every taken a community tour from Almaty out to the lakes or mountains nearby?

like

McKinsey & Company Is McKinsey still a feeder into the C-Suite? Or has that changed?McKinsey & Company

like

(I’m not really sure since I’m a first generation lawyer) I know clerking is generally considered a great opportunity and learning experience and prestigious (?) Is it also the case working for a Senator?

like

5”5 125 pounds. Max weight I reached 138 then dropped again when I stopped working out. Plan is to hit 150 pounds by July 2019? Realistic ? Pls help me with a workout and diet plan 🙋🏽‍♂️

likeuplifting

🇲🇦 🇮🇶 LETS GO

Post Photo
like

Any success stories with EB5? Who did you use? How were the investment terms? Been on H1b 9 years now and no end in sight with eb2 wait. Concerned with risk of outright fraud not 500k investment amnt.

like

I've been approached to advise a SAAS startup, series B roundwise, with a 4-5 hours per week expectation max. How would you figure out how much equity ask for (company is valued at 54m USD)?

like

Hi any openings in Trade finance currently doing lc booking import, import collections ( Hongkong, manila and Sri lanka), Payments (MT202 and MT103) and i have done ky MBA in University of Northampton, UK Please helpe me out. Thanks in advance

Additional Posts in Confession

I’ve never worked at a firm, only public interest and have no idea how to do billable hours.

like

Chick Fil A is 🔥🔥 but in certain circles/cities it’s a bummer that some label this as the same as being homophobic.

likesmart

How many of you do some bicep curls before going out on a date?

Sunday topics ( males only): Anybody thinks of penile derma filler?

like

Frustrated my fiancé keeps talking about raising our future kids in the way he was raised. We’re from different cultures. He wants to name them based on his culture, send them to schools with dual immersion in his language so “they don’t get too American,” and has even mentioned moving so they’re exposed to his homeland and culture. Religiously he is fine raising with both our relig but def wants them to participate in some of the orthodoxy of his more so (cont)

like

I’ve never been more inspired in my life.

Post Photo
funnylikeuplifting

Hot take - nuclear > wind/solar. It’s the only renewable energy source with enough potential to meet the energy needs. Uses less land, makes energy more efficiently, and the technology is already there and proven. Nuclear wastes are no fun but wind and solar have their own waste problems too. Thoughts?

like

Pretty new here! Great news ..JOB offer …however the company is lowballing salary ..I informed recruiter Amount was not acceptable …sent off the salary requirement letter …. Nail biting ..Why waste my time again …she didn’t know the budget… so we proceeded forward, her reply ..advised me to talk w hiring team but in final interview there was no opportunity to speak abt salary w hiring team ….Have to say I enjoy the posts & it’s a decent networking site!!

Work sucks and I just wanna cuddle 🥺

like

PSA, you can transfer your car loan to an interest free credit card. Got 18 months interest free with BOA and a 20k credit limit. Transferred my car loan and I am no longer paying interest

likehelpful

Why can’t my exes leave me alone

like

When I dropped my kids off at daycare this morning, the car next to me had a #milflife car tramp stamp, and I have just so many questions.

funnylike

Happy Beach - Bench Day

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

Hello fam! Hope you’ll are enjoying your Sunday!

I faked my resume I mean my contracting firm did and I didn’t have choice and I got the job. Now my client wants to offer me a full time position. I kind of feel like they trust me with the work I’m doing and also considering my past experiences to offer me a full time and moreover it’s only been 3 months.

I know it’s a little unusual but what do you guys think/suggest me to do in this situation?!

like

Rant: my boyfriend is so annoying with this diet! I GET IT. You want to eat healthy! But when you have your friends at our place every other weekend they order pizza and you devour most of 2 boxes! But when I want pizza or wings or burgers I have to hear a whole spiel. “Can we pick something healthier?” “You can order ___ but can I choose something else on the menu?” “I don’t knowwww” like MY GOD. Then if I order something for me he wants half or bites! Sick of it!!!

likefunny

What are some good bowls besides this one?

like

BCG > Bain or Bain > BCG?

like

Follow up of another confession: what was your experience with backstabbing?
When did you do it?
When did you received it?

like

I’m never satisfied with what I have and it makes me feel like sh*t because I know I’m so fortunate to have what I what have

like

Anyone else on here use the app ‘iFunny’ to look at memes daily?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal