27 years old and considering leaving consulting to join the military. I have a great career and amazing life, however I've always had the itch and figure time is running out. Considering dropping everything and enlisting with the 18x program (special forces). I've talked to a recruiter and am very aware of the risks, I physically am fit enough to excel however who knows what could happen....am I an idiot? Also considering certain 3 letter agencies....

likesmartfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

It doesn’t work that way. Yes you are an idiot for even considering this. Your recruiter will happily take advantage of your ignorance. There is no 18x program. What does exist is 11B (Bravo) school down in GA. It’s basic training and AIT all in one. You go there first and pass. Congrats, you are a grunt. You are “needs of the army”. Maybe just maybe, you get streamlined. So you go to airborne and don’t mess up your knees (spoiler alert: you will mess up your knees). You will have to wait for selection. Training isn’t going on year round. So you will be assigned to a basic infantry unit to call home while waiting for your TDY/ship date. I cannot stress how unglamorous a life 11 bang bangs have. However, I would rather have a conversation with any one of them than stuck up egotistical military intelligence guys who plan on joining a “3 letter agency” and yet don’t even know how to keep their weapon clean or what a firing pin is for or that they are “better” because they scored higher on the ASVAB and got a non infantry job. Wear the light blue rope proudly.

Let’s say everything goes according to plan. Congrats you passed. Welcome to the world where you are one bad commander away from being ordered to die in country for some stupid reason. And there are plenty of bad commanders.

Life is not a video game. There are people crawling on their bellies in the mud right now who hope to get where you are already. Feel free to take several steps back in your autonomy but understand the US military is terribly organized. Despite this, it is literally the best military on the face of the earth. You are in for a freaking shock of a lifetime. Enjoy cutting grass with scissors, “hurry up and wait”, piss tests at 4AM and general buffoonery despite being considered a “professional”. And at 27 you are definitely the “old man” with the highest PT standards necessary to make 100. I cannot stress enough how disorganized it all is despite what movies, video games and TV portray. But go see for yourself. Remember though, you can’t just quit. You signed a contract and there are definitely more places for you to be deployed to than what is talked about on the news. My guess is the 100% lack of self direction and autonomy will be the biggest culture shock. And boy, don’t tell anyone you had a job in the real world, the inferiority complexes are real.

likesmarthelpfuluplifting

same here! In my concise time in the military, I enjoyed both sides of the equation. It can be great or absolute tyranny depending on your higher-ups. It is not based "solely" on you, because you have no say in what unit you are assigned to most of the time. Nonetheless, I am glad that I served. It has changed my perspective on life and opened many doors I thought were non-existent.

like

Just do it. Don’t listen to these haters and these POGs.

Join the National Guard pipeline. If it works, it works. If it doesn’t, you still have a good job. If it’s war you seek, then when the great Indo-China war of Taiwanese oppression happens, you will go. I promise. And the NG will be winning that one as well.

The National Guard has 20th and 19th groups. Walk into the armory and find the recruiter. If you are in DC, the armory for 20th Group is an hour away at Gunpowder Military Reservation and the recruiters name is Ryan. If you make it, you will always have the opportunity for a deployment.

No matter what, the National Guard writ large is an Elite Community - so even if you don’t make it in SF selection, you will find a good home of oper8ors. I have E4s who are in med school right now. I have an E4 that is a manager at Deloitte. I have E7s managing 9 figure business units. And I have soldiers working for every 3 letter agency. It’s not like these dirty active duty units with bad leaders that hate their lives… we all have day jobs and most making >$100k a year. Many in the $500s+. The ones of us that are unmarried have better selections of hot, attractive mating partners. Active Doody has HORRIBLE selection wherever you get stationed. Another thing, ALL Guard members’ spouses are incredibly attractive, and all of our children love us. You will find the opposite in AD.

And as the Active Doody bois who hate The Elite Guard Community chime in, by all metrics, my National Guard infantry unit outperformed all AD bois in MND-North when we were in Iraq in 07. And I’ve never seen more soft shoe profiles than getting food at an off base subway near a large AD Infantry post - looking at you Fort Stewart.

So, OP, join. And follow The Fratty Guard on Instagram for more career advice.

likefunny

PPML 1 - that’s the BDE I would expect from a fellow elite oper8or. Active Duty SF is the only AD I actually respect. Maybe sometimes I’ll acknowledge a Ranger or two, but only in instances of extreme valor. But I respect AD SF because you, too, come from an elite community - you boiz know how to punch out and go to work. And the wives comments was really about those Regular Army folks with their lack of beautiful flowing hair and beards at least 28 days a month.

Anyway, yeah you can see how upset the RA Active Doody bois get. I would be mad too if clipping grass was my full time job and then some sales guy making $500k a year comes in, outperforms me in every metric, wins my wars for me, and goes home to a beautiful wife and three exact replica sons. Meanwhile his stock vested while he was gone and has >$200k more in the bank.

As opposed to going back to Fort Riley, a divorce, estranged children and no money.

Recent IconRecent

I think it's a commendable goal, but I do agree with others. There is a smarter way to go about challenging yourself and getting into public service, if that is your aim. I don't think you're an idiot. Everyone has different goals in life and some of us need more of a challenge (physically and mentally) than others.

like

Join the reserves. You can play Soldier / Airmen / Sailor / Marine / Guardian on weekends and during the summer. Plus, you can volunteer for mobilizations / deployments if you get the itch.

like

I wouldn’t - was active and was NG. Glad I did it but I wouldn’t ever recommend someone doing it at age 27 who’s in a successful career

Also be prepared for what happens if you don’t pass. Physically fit outside of the military is one thing. Being physically fit for SF is another. Breaking you down physically is what they do to really see who you are and how mentally tough you are at your very worst. Whatever you imagine, it’s going to be 1000x worse than you expect

like

These are excellent points. Working a dead end/menial low paying job > military could upgrade your life. Consulting > military will absolutely be a downgrade in quality of life, and quality of the people you work with.

Also agree half of what you do physically is breaking your body, not training it.

Let all this “you’ll become an 82nd 11b” fuel you. If you want to be SF, go become SF. Plus side of SF (if you make it), you’ll live a rich life doing crazy shit with good people in bad places, possibly being seriously maimed or killed. And you’ll love it. Plus side of consulting, you’ll make some money and pretty badass PowerPoints.
In all seriousness, if you want to do SF find and talk to SF guys. If you’re making a such a drastic life decision you owe it to yourself to thoroughly investigate all options. People get confused when your personal paradigm of ‘success’ doesn’t meet their conventional understanding.

like

I concur, and I left my SOF career to spend more time at home. My point being, doing SOF work is incredibly fulfilling and irreplaceable, especially relative to “consulting”. Those who have experienced combat, the highs and the lowest lows will have a difficult time replacing those feelings professionally (and likely struggle with PTSD). To leave that environment you have to find something that fills the void and gives you greater fulfillment. It sounds like for both of us, that is our family. If OP is interested in this career path, they owe it to themselves to have conversations friends/family and get guidance from mentors. Not random people in an app…and definitely not recruiters!

I can’t speak on SF, but I enlisted well into my established career leaving an amazing job (and right at the age cut off), and I will honestly say it was hands down the best decision I ever made. Full stop. That is CERTAINLY not everyone’s experience, but I’d say give it a shot if you feel you’re well informed enough to understand the pros and cons, and are doing it for the right reasons. Good luck!

like

Are you married yet? If yes, no. If no, maybe.

like

I was in the military for 8 years. Loved it and had a good combat MOS, but, being an engineer is so much better.

like

I would never trust a recruiter. I would keep in mind the attrition rate for special operations is off the charts high so you might wind up an ordinary grunt or worse. Also.. You're quite old for this... Like it or not.

On the other hand. You won't know unless you try. There's no reason why you can't. But do it because you want it and only because you want it. Nothing else. And if you don't do this, that's okay too. Plenty of other ways to serve.

And whatever you do. Don't be the guy later on who talks about what he was going to do. Good luck.

like

Only join if you’re going in an as officer. Being 27 and completely switching to the army after being a civilian so long is going to be tough especially when you’re coming in with 18-22 year olds. They talk to you crazy and it’s all about rank so if you think something is wrong or should be done differently, no one cares, do it and shut up.

Want a new career path try the FBI or DEA

like

It seems to me that you're interested in public service. That's why you're not only interested in the military but also certain 3-letter agencies. But it also seems like you're interested in something else. You want to go special forces. You're only interested in certain 3-letter agencies, presumably the clandestine types. Are you after the clout and prestige that comes with being associated with these things? I'm not attacking you. Be honest with yourself.

Not necessarily the clandestine types, just the thought of some type of service as you say. Good point about being honest with what I want, I'm not really concerned with the clout aspect though.

This is extremely short sighted and not smart - signed, a dude who wasted 5 years before getting into consulting

I'm 37F, great consulting career and going back into the Reserve (after a 10y hiatus after active duty).
Army Civil Affairs currently has Reserve direct commissions (if you have a masters) and regular commissioning routes if you don't. Civil Affairs falls under the "special" umbrella. Come in, see if you like it, then drop packets for the hooah schools.
Navy has a DC program too, I just don't have as much info on it.

Hey, this is an awesome, I didn't even know about it. Don't have my masters, but what would reserve CA look like for someone enlisting?

You could always check out 19th and 20th Group (Airborne). It's kinda' the best of both worlds. Let's you dip your toes in without going all in.

If money isn’t important to you, I am sure you will be very satisfied and find fulfillment. At least initially or short-term. I would def do a short contract if they have it.

OP has provided zero context of their physical fitness state too lol

I say go for it! If you think you are ready, go get that slice of humble pie before it expires. Only you know what you are capable of, but good luck in whatever you decide.

like

Trust everyone and don’t do it. Just take a the pay cut and do 3 letter agency.

So, a word of advice on the "three letter agency":

It is a monster of a bureaucracy. You will encounter some of the same work scenarios you would experience in any other large organization.

Of the various directorates, only one does the "cool guy/gal stuff," and the tip of that spear is composed of the top 10% of the military, with a few exceptions.

The various directorates each specialize in support, analysis, IT, or technology matters. More often than not, unless you have been identified as case officer material, you will land in a non-operations role (the more brainy ones tend go to analysis, which is a fairly large organization itself).

Also, understand that you will be subject to the General Schedule (GS) system. If you start out in the operations directorate after having retired as a Special Forces fella (or a SEAL, for example), they will start you at GS 10, Step 9, which is just over $76k/year. But, if you just showed up from a non-specialty career source, it will be likely GS 10, Step 1... just over $60k/year. Of course, there will be an adjustment based on your location.

There is significantly more money thrown in when you go overseas on deployment. But, as a new employee, you are generally not sent overseas for about three years.

When you do get posted abroad the first time, remember that the nicer, more career enhancing locations go to the more senior, more proven folks (as well as those who have mastered the internal politics of the place). For your first forays into "the real world," they send you to places where you shouldn't probably drink the local water. In the end, it's not Tom Clancy stuff. Some really good people there (some real heroes too), and some total idiots as well... like any job. Don't ask me how I know.

18x was a program designed to recruit smarter than average people into the 11B infantry world. Literally put in place because the washout rate was so high that the infantry would get smart leftovers.

Do not listen to these haters and do not trust your recruiters (but ask for everything and get in writing prior to singing). Do your research in full, understand the commitment, understand if you do not make it SF, can you accept that and the outcome. Remember you need mental fortitude and not just being physically fit. If you think this is just a good idea at the time you are going to have a bad time while enlisted.

Yes, you are an idiot. USAF EOD Craftsman here, having put in ten plus years, served in Operations Desert Shield/Storm and Operations Joint Endeavor/Guard. When you serve in the military, you are left with potentially four choices, two initial choices and two additional contingent choices. Your first two choices are to slack or bust ass. If you slack, you will be punished. If you bust ass, you WILL damage your body (I’m not talking about the pain aspect, I’m talking about tissue that is no longer working properly without at least time to heal, or possibly surgery, if that even works). If you bust ass and damage your body, you are left with the choices of going to sick call (and if you go as much as you need to, you will get punished for malingering) or sucking it up.

Now, here’s the fun part: you bust ass and suck it up, because you are born again hard. THEN, when you get out, and decide to file for VA compensation (it may be right after you get out, or, you may be a stubborn bastard, like I was, and wait over a decade), only to find them saying that there is no record of the claims you are making - DENIED. It took my an additional 11 years to finally get the 100% Total & Permanent rating I should have had from the get go, and that was only taking into account about half the things wrong with me, since they kept denying the rest. And this is for a guy that went in right after high school and was in great shape, but, managed to destroy his body doing range clearance operations, of all things. And you want to throw away what you call a, “great career and an amazing life,” to do a military job that is GUARANTEED to fuck up your body?! Yup, you’re an idiot.

Do it.

Related Posts

Do I really need the lectures (Becker) to pass the exams? I really just want to do everything else besides that.

like

I’m an L6 SDM at Amazon but a Meta recruiter sent me an M2 sdm job description. I have all the XP I need from previous job experience but does Meta keep your same level as Amazon? Meaning if I am an L6 at Amazon am I automatically interviewing at M1 or can I jump to an M2?Amazon Facebook (Meta)

like

I am looking to get into UX/UI. I am a recent graduate (graphic design) but have just been exposed to UX so I am taking classes. Does anyone have any tips or advice for someone just starting out in UX

like
like

Those of you that have left retail, what would it take for you to go back? I’m hearing about 50k sign on bonuses at the corner locally (up from 20/25k in February). I’ve been unemployed/underemployed for over a year and am still holding out for anything else.

like

Hi Fishes,

Need your help and suggestions to select from below offers:

PWC AC: 22.5 fix+ 2.5 JB+ Variable as per policy
Globant: 26.5 fix
Yoe: 5.10
Tech stack: SAP Native Hana+ BODS

Please suggest in terms of Wlb, career progression, job security,others.

Pwc AC Globant

like

What are main reason/'s, we see people choose to stay in SAP for as long as 10 years or more. We see lot of them have 15+ year experience and never switched.

Does SAP do market correction often or hike is good? SAP

likesmarthelpful

I left Audit at a midsize firm to join KPMG erp implementation consulting about 6 months ago. So far they seem to only want to staff me on projects with a heavy focus on technical accounting and audit. Spoke to a lot of others who have left and seems like being pigeonholed or staffed on projects not related to the actual core work of the practice is the common reason. I've been on the fence about whether I should stay and hope to be staffed on better projects in the future or leave soon...

like

Anyone in TAAG? How are the hours? Have you seen anyone transfer from TAAG into core FAAS?

like

Does Google value FAANG experience over consulting? Say if a person is trying to get into Google from Apple, will it be considered easier?

like

Recently got my CPA license in August & considering leaving public accounting for Industry. Should I expect my new role to pay for my CPA license renewals/AICPA membership/CPE classes? These things add up &I feel like should be considered when transitioning. Thoughts?

like

Anyone here broken into real estate private equity from big 4 consulting? What steps did you take to jump into RE PE? What gaps in knowledge did you have and how did you fill them? Outside of the knowledge gaps what other things do you think you needed in order to get into RE PE?

like

Hi Fishes,

I am currently having an experience of 3 years. I want to get into Data Science field. Have been preparing with the concepts mostly through self study. Will I get a job without any experience in Data Science field

like

Is it worth becoming certified in compensation? I have 5 years of benefits and my new employer wants me to move into Total Rewards. Is this a better career move than just remaining in Benefits?

like

I feel bad because I love my teams and they are the best mentors but this field is just not for me. Should I stick it through 4 projects I know the need me on for another busy season or leave.

like

I’m currently doing portfolio opps at a solid UMM shop, but exploring making a change (potentially to a bigger firm where there’s more career progression). I was recruited to my current role, and am wondering how others in portfolio opps are finding new opportunities. It seems like most of them recruit vs. post jobs. Any insights are appreciated!

like

I have an offer from Capco, it was much lower then I expected for the SC level EA at £80k. I'm at a stable role at a bank with a great WLB. My wife is a front line work. So I can take care of the baby, with the next coming soon. My dilemma is, become a consultant or stay where I am at. Consulting looks attractive as I would be speed up my career progression. Though the travel costs and child care does not warrant the base salary Capco Should I take the hit and join capco?

like

Hello, I have 4.5 years of NYS WC authorizations for orthopedic. I also have experience as a front office supervisor at a hotel. Any suggestions on a career move? I feel really stagnant where I am right now and I feel very under paid for the amount of labor I have to put in. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thank You

like

Privacy fish - Anyone taken the CIPM and can share what the exam is like?

Content outline seems like application of standard consulting approach, so how do they test it on an exam?

More Posts

Hi everyone! Could Blizzard get a few likes to help unlock my DMs? Very much appreciated😊

Post Photo
likeupliftingsmart

Pretty short notice but is anyone able to recommend for Slalom today?

like

I feel bad because I love my teams and they are the best mentors but this field is just not for me. Should I stick it through 4 projects I know the need me on for another busy season or leave.

like

I’m currently doing portfolio opps at a solid UMM shop, but exploring making a change (potentially to a bigger firm where there’s more career progression). I was recruited to my current role, and am wondering how others in portfolio opps are finding new opportunities. It seems like most of them recruit vs. post jobs. Any insights are appreciated!

like

I have an offer from Capco, it was much lower then I expected for the SC level EA at £80k. I'm at a stable role at a bank with a great WLB. My wife is a front line work. So I can take care of the baby, with the next coming soon. My dilemma is, become a consultant or stay where I am at. Consulting looks attractive as I would be speed up my career progression. Though the travel costs and child care does not warrant the base salary Capco Should I take the hit and join capco?

like

🐠 - Recommendations for a small black shoulder/crossbody. Looking to spend between 2-3k.

like

What are some websites you use to find commercial directors? Hoping there’s a more searchable one out there instead of bouncing around from one production company site to the next

like

Hello how does Kearney and OW compare in the MEA? And who would you pick out of the two? Oliver Wyman Kearney

like

Saving for a home. Should I save my money in a CD or savings account?

like

Dear all,

Please help me to fill the my accomplishments tab in ionboard hcl portal, its not enabled. Please suggest me.HCL Technologies

Post Photo
like

Anyone have an issue with Global Entry due to govt shut down?

like

Good places to scuba with lower currency value (cheaper hotels, food, etc.)?

*URGENT* Any freelance mid-senior art director available starting next week to work on an integrated campaign for one of the coolest agencies in Europe? Drop me a message. Thanks!

like

YOE - 6 years in functional testing
How much CTC should i expect from CG
For
Grade - Senior Consultant C1

like

Hi fishes,

What are the interview questions to expect for the role of AWS database engineer?

like

do schools even consider the IR and AWA sections if they dont factor into score?

like
like

Additional Posts in Veteran Bowl

I went to Strayer

like

Anyone use a lawyer to get increased disability? If so, any recommendations?

To all the post-9/11 veterans, it’s a somber day that unites us all in the reason we fought. It’s easy to forget - especially with the younger generation having 9/11 be a history lesson rather than something they lived through. The waters became muddy with two wars and politicians, but you all stepped up and did your duty. Thank you all for your service, it’s an honor whether we crossed paths or not.

like

Question for the group. What keeps you from freelancing/ working as a professional services contractor? Are there particular aspects that prevent you from diving in such as concern of gaps between projects, difficulty getting paid from clients, or do you enjoy the w2 position you’re in currently? Would love to hear your thoughts!

like

Hey Ladies & Gents,

I'm trying to find anyone I can talk to about getting into DISA or CISA. Anyone have any experience with USAJobs and navigating the federal application and interview process?

like

My SSBI experience expires next year May, and my investigation is is in adjudication process. What happened my result don’t come back before my investigation expires?

like

Perspective. I’m retiring from the service and I’ve positioned myself decently to be competitive. I have a graduate degree pursuing a doctorate, LSSBB, ScrumMaster, SPHR, and PMI-ACP. I’ve been offered two positions that are great and on the human capital team. For someone in this situation where should I be looking as commensurate with my certifications and experience?

like

Almost 2 years out of AD, and now thinking about going back to the Reserves to get my TSCI and just cause I miss it. Does anyone have insights on fed consultants’ salary with a TSCI?

like

In my prime workout days I could down 3 cheesy Gordita crunches, 1 chicken quesadilla, and a chicken soft taco from Taco Bell ....just tried it 10 years later...would not recommend.

funnylike

Just want to rant. Failed an interview because I brought up ranger school being the reason I left the military. Cont. Below.

likesmart

What are the best consulting firms for someone with a TS/SCI with FSP? Non staffing roles. I’d rather do strategy, transformation, tech integration, etc...

likehelpful

Any Vets here consulting in the DC area? Thinking about making a move.

I want to buy a new home and then sell my current home after we are moved out. Current home is a VA loan, is there any way to buy the second house on a VA loan?

like

Any veterans here still serving in the Reserve? Drill Hall is a new bowl here.

like

What is the present value of a government pension? How does one calculate it? Trying to get a sense of weather it's worth moving over to Federal.

like

I work at a medical device manufacturing plant as a training coordinator, I have a military background and a degree and am trying to advance but am feeling stuck. I am a literal jack of all trades, and am trying to get out of the hourly life, I’m working an average of 100 hour weeks and have been for at least the last 6 months.

like

Thoughts about if/how to include military reserve service on resume? Don't want to be deceiving but also don't want to get passed over for interviews.

Context: prior AD, 5+ years post MBA, newish to reserves. Prior consultant, current entrepreneur but thinking about getting a corp job instead.

like

Anyone here downshift in life post service?

Feel like I've been going full bore for the past decade and literally have no problem continuing the trend. Like I could just keep marking milestones and grinding or whatever until I die.

Wondering when if anyone else felt similar and decided to pull back and do something more relaxing. What was the catalyst, what are you doing, and are you enjoying it?

I'd considered taking up a 9-5 somewhere but not sure if thatd wear off fast.

like

Have service related PTSD or anxiety effected your clearance level at all?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal