A quick question on interfaith marriages and proposing. My partner is orthodox Jewish and we’ve been together for a couple of years. I follow most customs and intend to convert to Judaism to continue the practices and be able to raise children when we have them eventually. The community and all of our friends are Jewish, except me. However, when it comes to him proposing, could he do that before I convert or only after I convert ? We’ve been talking about marriage for over a year. Continued………..

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

For most relationships like this, the proposal usually happens after conversion. My brother was in a similar situation and that’s what he did.

I’m based in NYC and know a handful of people that converted for marriage. Feel free to DM me if you have any questions or are looking for NYC based resources on conversion!

like

U can start the process anywhere. Look into gps beit din beit din of America and RCA.

A lot of the learning and early conversations are worth starting vs waiting ...so at least they know who u are in advance of having to do a full kick off of the process

The conversion process could take a while, so it might be worth starting it now or having those conversations with the rabbi

like

However, we want to ensure we do it right and after I move home to NYC permanently.
Any advice or experience in similar situations.

You can get engaged before or after since an engagement doesn't have religious significance.
Practically it may impact how the beit din treats you pre bs post conversion. And if ppl question how sincere you are.... honestly not sure what's better but def worth thinking how it will affect ur conversion process.

Good luck and mazal tov :)

Related Posts

Yesterday my younger brother called me looking for good hidden swimming spots in the mountains. He was up there with a bunch of friends and their original plans had fallen apart hard. And I go much more often than he does.

I told him I had map pins that are EXACTLY what you need for these hard to find places. I can send them in 10 mins when I get home.

Reply? Forget it, I'm all set.

Yep, 10 mins is too long. Here I was expecting "Wow! That's fantastic!" How silly of me.

like

My office knows that I recently came out of the closet to my family- which is fine, but making me feel young. Feeling the need to overcompensate as a result.

What’s your *wish-fulfillment fantasy* life like? Hot model wife, kids, a house in the suburbs and success in your career?

like

First-year teacher looking for some back to school advice/tips. Meet the teacher night is tomorrow. What are some things you do the first week for your littles?

Anyone else stuck here without family? I'm in SF and my roommates are going home to their families tonight and i'm going to be alone, it's going to be a long 3 weeks..... 😭😭😭

like

I’m in SF but nervous to officially come out to my friends even though I’m sure they all know/assume anyway. :(

like

Anyone know how much a full time nanny in the Austin area would cost?

like

Real talk ... if someone is over 35 and hasn’t been married before, do you automatically assume there is something wrong with them?

like

Has anyone quit their job because of a relationship? I started my job 3 months ago and now my employer wants me to move to NY. The thing is, I fell in love during the pandemic with a friend that I have known for 3 years. It's frustrating since I know I could continue my job from home. I would honestly quit my job and wouldn't mind the job search again.

like

A friend of mine was arrested last night over a DUI charge and his family is worried sick. How can I help comfort them...

like

Anyone with anxious attachment tendencies? Going through a breakup and I keep thinking about how I pushed him away and then am down on myself, replaying memories in my mind. At the end of the day, I think we were a bad match from the beginning and misaligned, but so hard not to beat myself over my anxious attachment during my relationship

like

Getting married in September, have a vax only policy for guests. My fiancé’s sister is bringing her unvaccinated spouse to the hotel where all the wedding festivities are being held b/c she is too scared to fly on an airplane without him. I find this incredibly uncomfortable and selfish given it will put me and my fiancé in an uncomfortable position (and it will also put my elderly parents and other vulnerable fam members at risk). Any ideas as to what (if anything) to do?

like

Has anyone taken leave after a very painful break up?

I work in a self contained classroom. A parent of one of my kids wants to come and volunteer after learning all my staff quit. Can I allow her to do this? Admin has no idea and I'm not sure with FERPA laws.. advice, suggestions? What can I have her do if she can come?

like

First-gen grad students, does your family put pressure on you to succeed? It feels like our relationship is them just bugging me about my work. I’d love some advice, I miss my fam.

like

Seriously don't know how to get a boyfriend as an IB analyst, most people who are in a relationship started dating since college. Really don't want to be single when I'm 30•••

like

My brother-in-law (age 30) told us recently that he is transgender. How can we support him? (‘Him’ as we haven’t discussed pronouns yet). It was a surprise to us!

likeuplifting

Lawyer Couples:
I’m currently an associate (no kids) in a very busy corp group (think 50-60 billable weekly). My wife works significantly less (currently part time, 10-15, but hopefully will be full time soon). I find myself getting upset when asked to help with basic household things (trash, cooking etc.) when she’s been lounging around watching Netflix all day. Am I being reasonable or am I a misogynist? How do you deal with one person having significantly more free time than the other?

likehelpful

What’s the best cadence for sending nurture emails? I’m looking to re-engage partners who haven’t worked with us in X amount of days. The series will be 7 emails and just wondering if anyone has seen more success with emails once a week vs every other week. I typically send nurture emails once a week but curious what success others have found breaking it up. TYIA!

like

Any 40+ women here interested to make new friends? 40+ man here.

like

More Posts

Hey fish: what are some of your favorite business/self-help books?

like

What’s your thought on Ripple?

I'm learning to make virtual escape rooms! It's so much easier than I expected. (Thank you Google and YouTube!)

like

Does anyone here teach HS Video Production at their school? I’m starting up this program for our school, teaching 2 classes this upcoming school year. I have a few questions for anyone who can help...

So who's curious enough to see the movie "The Accountant"?

like

Prometric closed until 4/30

Post Photo
like

Hi, I just joined and am hoping to find guidance and advice. I have a bachelor's degree in Rehabilitation and have tried a little bit of everything. From teaching to medical sales and now social work. Is there anyone out there with a career you love that's a great fit for an introvert?

I’ve very fortunate to have a new job. I wanted WFH, but I guess it wasn’t in the cards. Do you think people who work from home are that much happier?

likesmarthelpfulupliftingfunny

What y'all dressing up as for Halloween?

like

Hi Fishes
What does designation lead rep quant analysis means.

like

Anyone joining Deloitte India Kolkata location on 10th October?

like

Amazon Bangalore Hiring for EM

Post Photo

Can we say that we already have an offer in the other company interviews?

like

When your flight is overbooked, but you absolutely have to fly home...

Post Photo
likefunny

While the law requires it, it seems that there’s no mandatory lunch for being a nurse or other healthcare provider. What's your experience?

like

Need sincere advise on this
I recently resigned from Infosys (still on probation) - while discussing with my manager and lead both of them told me that - they cannot give me hike as the current in hand offer - however chances of on-site is possible… but I need to complete at least 1 year in Infosys.. Current offer in hand is from a Captive & they have fixed ctc - what to do?

like

Looking to exit from 195k base to a sales role base 140 + 40 in guaranteed bonus year 1 to make up for the lengthy sales cycle. I know in the long run total comp through equity and sales commission bonus can be much higher but having a hard time making the jump… mostly my ego to drop drastically in TCO the first year after spending all these years trying to increase base. Still interviewing - unicorn saas account exec. What would you do?

like
like

Been away from SF for 8 months. How is SF now?

like

Additional Posts in Jewish Consultants

Anyone taking off for Passover?

like

Any consulting firms that are particularly good for Jews or which honor Jewish holidays? My firm has a Jewish diversity team but I’d love to learn about others.

like

Shabbat Shalom! I’m 22F and wanting to find my NJB. If you’re in la let me know!

like

Hope the matzah is keeping everyone sustained at client site!

like

Yidden, I've been slowly drifting away from religion. It's odd because I used to be so connected, and I still retain the same values! Technology, however, has made religious ritual feel so lifeless, and I can barely muster the energies to maintain even a bare Jewish lifestyle. I become so sad when I see my friends becoming more connected, while I find myself gradually falling away 😞... HELP!

likehelpful

Anyone here work in Israel ? Planning to make Aliyah in the upcoming year

like

Is there any activity on this bowl?

like

How is everyone handling the stop and go of the holidays? Been feeling very anxious taking off two days this and next week.

like

Hey guys, I just found this group and I’m hoping for some guidance/advice! I’m hoping to get into one of the Big 4s or MBB and finally got a few referrals once joining FB. I am 29, have an MA in IOP, and 10 YEO. I have never worked for a non-Jewish company (despite trying pretty damn hard to get out) and I’m freaking out. I have no concept of normal professionalism, strategy for navigating the workplace and the real world in corporate USA,(cont. in comment)

like

יש אלו שמעדיפים לדבר בעברית?

like

Pesach Sheni Sameach!

like

Anyone at Deloitte in nyc?

like

Shana tova and chag sameach everyone. May this year be better than the last one. It’s a low bar to clear but 🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼

like

Does your consulting firm offer a Jewish community group or professional network? Please indicate your company name if possible - doing research on DEI initiatives for the Jewish community. Thank you in advance! 🙏🏻

like

My fiancé just made Aliyah for med school. Long distance is hard but I love my job/firm culture. I wish I could stay, but I’ll need to switch to a firm that allows working abroad in a year at the latest. In a year, we get married and I make Aliyah too. I’m afraid to tell anyone at my firm. I’m also looking for American companies that pay well and allow employees to live in Israel. Thoughts? Advice?

Is it fair game to report someone’s particularly polarizing IG posts to HR? Was friendly with this person but now I wouldn’t ever want to work with them after some of the things they’ve posted.

Anyone here know what the deal is at ICF?

I heard most of us are off for some holiday next week, so enjoy the day off to prepare for the holiday!

like

The festival of Karonakah...

Post Photo
like

Obligatory Rosh Hashannah post:
Shannah Tovah to my fellow Jewish consultants!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal