Am I the only one who feels like the STAR interview method is just an exercise in creative storytelling? I have to turn standard, boring bug fixes into dramatic stories about overcoming adversity. If I just say I looked at the logs, found the typo, and deployed a fix, I fail the rubrics for communication and problem-solving. So instead, I have to invent this massive team conflict and a ticking clock scenario just to satisfy the corporate narrative requirements.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Based on that , here’s how you can describe "I changed a light bulb"


Single-handedly managed the successful upgrade and deployment of new environmental illumination system with zero cost overruns and zero safety incidents.

likefunnysmart

Think of it as a soft skill you’re learning to apply towards other types of jobs or life challenges- How to convince others to feel a sense of urgency about something that would otherwise mean nothing to them.

like

“I agree the star rating is just okay—he handles the situation and story fine. I’d say HR is always coming up with new ways and redefining how interviews are conducted, and honestly, it’s all become robotic.”

like

Like it or not it's here to stay. Because everyone loves a hero story.

You'll find that a lot of people who get ahead in their careers are those who can sell themselves well. It doesn't have to be some pumped up BS. It's just making others aware of what you've done and how it was impactful.

STAR is simply a structured way to help you more clearly deliver your narrative, that's all.

like

Yeah like I understand its benefit but it’s really not natural. Once you get used to it though I think you can use it to talk about even simple situations without embellishing dramatically.

like

As a project manager I get asked “tell us about a time a project went off the rails”? Simple question. The problem is for over 16 years I never had a project “off the rails”. I had to tell stories about doing a project during Covid that had changing deliverables and no end date or picking up a project that was off the rails before I came on board and I got back on track.

like

Well it is story telling. It’s a structured way to communicate your experience to someone who has no clue about you or your skills. “

You are describing what you did. Everyone does that. Everyone looks at logs and deploy a fix. Why should they select you?

Was the bug urgent ? Was it breaking something critical ? What if it wasn’t fixed by you in time. People make a big deal out of the method while don’t realized it is a logical way to describe your experience to someone. If you have to invent stuff, then you don’t qualify for the job that you are interviewing for. You are basically saying whatever you do is useless and has no significance at all. “I look at a logs” - nobody cares about that.

It can an entertaining exercise, when it isn't exhausting. I just look at it as explaining your business value. You’ve got experiences and skills that you need to talk about. You need an organized way to recall them easily.

You need to tell a story that others can tell for you. A recruiter hit me over the head when he said “What should I tell them to sell you?” I should have been able to give him 2 or 3 solid stories right then.

STAR draws a straight line: A situation needed to be addressed, I did something that saved someone’s time or the company’s money, or made someone more productive or the company more profitable. That’s it.

Related Posts

Hi Everyone,

I'm actively looking for Frontend Development roles and my tech stack is Angular. My current CTC is 10 LPA, YOE : 2 and im expecting 40-50% hike. I am able to clear the interviews but companies are not coming forward due to budget issues. Am I expecting too much here ? Can you please list out some companies which can offer my expected CTC ?

like

Hii,
Fishes..

Today I give technical interview in Infosys
Its goes very well.
After few hours I got the mail to submit my document
What does it mean??Am I selected ?? And how much Salary can I expect from Infosys with

Tech -Java Stack
YOE -3
CTC -4
No Offer till yet

Please give your review...

like

Hi! I’m scheduling a screening phone interview for a senior marketing manager position and I’m wondering what my salary expectations should be? 6 years experience & nyc based. Any insight here would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you!

like

Interviewing with EY UK and was made aware of a case study round (second round). Any suggestions on what I should expect?

like

Hello, I have an interview scheduled for the position of Product Manager for Mumbai location. Could anyone please help me with details like culture/benefits and pay at ICICI?

Asking advice from a recruiter: I’ve been recently laid off :( This week I took some time to reflect, talk to friends and family. I want to be more thoughtful on my next move and although interviewing right away would be logical I feel I want to take a break and some time for myself. Take a month or two off working and use that time to plan thoughtfully on my next move. Would having that gap in my resume be an issue when I go back to the job market?

like

Faced this weird behaviour from Optum recently. Gave interview for Data Scientist position. HR said feedback is positive. Asked for documents. It's been month now since I have shared the documents. I have no update on the offer. Today I called HR, she called me back saying the position is on hold due to recalibration in team, She has shared interview feedbacks to other teams and will get back to me in couple of days. I am clueless now. My last working day is approaching (In a month). Any Help??

What happens if I fail to clear client interviews multiple times? Will they terminate me?
Its been a month i have joined and not able to clear the client interview 😞.

While giving the tech interview as well as while having the HR discussion, I mentioned my expected CTC as 9-10 LPA(CTC). I cleared the interview and uploaded all the documents in the portal yesterday. Today mrng all the document verification was completed. But when I got the call for offer discussion, she asked what u expect. I said 9-10 LPA. She questioned me that on what basis I am asking for this much hike. She offered me 6.3 LPA as CTC with 21% variable. 5.2 as basic. Rest part in comments..

like

So I just finished my initial phone screen with the recruiter and he is patching over my résumé to the hiring manager to get another interview. What is the timeframe to hear feedback?

like

I jad an interview on 2nd August, 2022 and on 17th August, 2022. I received an email stating that interviewer is moving up your profile and contact a person email id for further information.
Since that day I haven't heard anything from the HR. I had called HR several times but no response from calls as well as mails too.
Anyone also faced this situation?
Please suggest me what to do as I have my last day in existing company nearby in 20 days

Anyone have any scoop on Mono? I’m interviewing with them for a remote role and not currently based in MN.

like

Might be off topic, but guys please, take care of your health. I've been rejected by all companies in the last 2 months.
I had my Walmart interview today and it went really well. And guess what? I got a rejection email.
I felt dizziness while working and fell down today.
I had to go to the doctor due to the anxiety and stress I was carrying since the last 2 months. It has affected my health.

It's important to push yourself to achieve your goals, but don't forget to "Live" in the process.

likehelpfuluplifting

Currently applying to a government position for the army corps of engineering. Does anybody have experience working for the government?

like

Hello, I am currently in India with a valid Candian PR and looking for jobs in the talent management space - Learning & Development / Performance Management/ Recruitment. I have overall 6 years of experience working in a professional services global set up.

I have been reaching out to recruiters on LinkedIn and also applying on job portals but haven’t had any luck so far in the last 3 months.

Any referrals/help would be appreciated. Thanks a lot, god bless.

like

Is it a good idea to go into SaaS pm role just for the sake of breaking into product management? Seems like b2c/consumer product management is the more popular one and is harder to get into from SaaS than the other way around. Just got my first PM gig offer and I’m trying to decide if I should keep interviewing

like

How much experience is recommended before applying? I’m 2 years out of undergrad and have been working in consulting at Big 4 since graduation. Aiming for M7 and interested in Data & Analytics and Finance.

like

More Posts

I accept follow requests left & right without following back and without shame. What does this say about me besides that I and, let’s say Beyoncé, are generally very similar?

likeuplifting

How is KPMG india for Salesforce technology in case of learning, projects and team

like
like

@KPMG India have an interview this week in national risk management team for an entry level position, any tips would be appreciated.
YOE- close to 2 years
Position applied for- executive

Thanks a lot!

like

wlb for client jp Morgon anyone suggests

Peanuts. But that's ok because I'm compensated by 'Mother culture'

likefunny

Is Zs associates still providing WFH allowance for new joiners. Please guide as I am going to join and I am planning to buy a comfortable chair, so I will decide the budget depends on the allowance will be provided or not. Please suggest.

like

Best doctors in NYC to get injectables / facial contouring?

like

What’s a good budget for rent if I’m making 138k + 14k sign on in NYC? I’ve got like 10k in student loans and about 5k in credit cards. No other obligations.

like

Any good sari rental places? Will be a guest at an Indian wedding in 2 months

like

For anyone applying this year, selling my applications for CBS, Yale, and Tuck - DM for details

funnylike

Our company is going through a major transformation and there is quite a bit of resistance due to uncertainty and lots of broken promises. Are there any books you would recommend on how to change corporate culture and help employees adapt to change?

like

A great one by iopsychmemes!

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Hi All

I saw there multiple openings for testing profile in Harman.Can anyone refer me.

I am having 6+ yrs of experience in Testing Domain.

Referral or suggestions for any other company will also be helpful.

Thank you

like

How soon did you tell your office you are pregnant? When is the best time?

like

Hello! I currently work in Software Asset Management with almost one year of experience. Is there anyone who has recommendations on what companies to apply for? Companies hiring for this role?

Thanks,

Blair

like

Hello guys
One of my friend in deloitte is under IAP process and she want to keep resignation if she keep resignation will they give immediate relieving Or IAP will ends on dec 25th(they will wait till IAP ends) or according to deloitte norms do they tell us to do notice period for 2 months?? Any idea can any one pls give me the suggestions??

like

115000 Bonvoy Points vs $500 cash (corporate rate) for 3 night stay. Which is the best value here?

like

Additional Posts in Job Hunting in Tech

What is the best way to begin a transition from a help desk job to an actual career path in IT? I’m getting close to being at my current job for a year, however I have a lot of experience in the tech field, which is what landed me this job without any actual IT background. I definitely feel over qualified and under paid in the position I am in now, and looking for the next step towards an IT career. Any advice would not fall on deaf ears. TIA

like

So... Switching jobs but they have a 60-day waiting period for insurance at the new spot. Do I pay full premium on insurance for those months, or is it the same? I do not understand COBRA.

like

Anyone have any experience with DoorDash s&o final round cases? Have a “problem solving” interview, “operational excellence” interview and a “critical thinking” case. Any tips?

like

Hey got a question for anyone and everyone! My sister is looking for a job. She’s been out of the job market for a while (5 years) to be a stay at home mom and with the economy, is looking to get back in it. My job isn’t hiring. Qualifications in comments

like

What can I except a product manager role interview questions to be?

like

Getting ready to leave my role - looking for community ops, comm ops, member support, account management - anything in those customer facing roles that is paying minimum 75k. Remote preferred, based in Chicago. Background in freight/logistics and healthcare.

like

Hi everyone, a question to the tech industry at large.

Why are people so hesitant to hire disabled candidates?

I am a visually impaired practitioner in South Africa, with 7 years of experience, and as soon as recruiters or business owners hear/read that I'm disabled, the conversation gets awkward and I never hear from them again.

like

Hi all!
I’m currently on my last year of university, pursing a computer science degree. I have yet to get an internship, or any experience in tech. Any advice on where to start? I would be attending part time in the spring semester and taking night classes so I would like to have something set up for January, let me know what you think. Thank you in advance.

like

Those of you with a degree in computer science (or similar), what do you do for work and how did you end up doing that?

Hiring in Taipei Taiwan. DM if interested. Check HPE (server storage sector of HP) for the specific roles. Good luck!

like

Considering pivoting into tech. Currently considering Project Management or Presales tech. I understand the general roles of each. Presales seem to make more than PM, so I am leaning towards presales. Curious if any PMs considered presales and why you decided to do Project management instead

like

Hey, wondering if anyone is into cloud engineering or cloud security here?

like

Asking advice from a recruiter: I’ve been recently laid off :( This week I took some time to reflect, talk to friends and family. I want to be more thoughtful on my next move and although interviewing right away would be logical I feel I want to take a break and some time for myself. Take a month or two off working and use that time to plan thoughtfully on my next move. Would having that gap in my resume be an issue when I go back to the job market?

like

Since we returned to office in October, is it appropriate to give holiday gifts to team members?

likeuplifting

I have been a software developer (professionally) for about 7 years now, but I’ve decided to move out from that job and do something else (still in tech).
I don’t know yet what to do exactly, but I know I just don’t want to be only writing code every day.
Tbh, I am scared. But I have set myself one year to learn something new.
I also want to go for a job that pays more (55k€ currently). I live in Paris, France, and software developers are not well paid.
Any suggestion for a career transition?

likeuplifting

Conuslting ——— vs. ——— Data Science + Machine Learning ??? $$$$

like

Where do lessons in humility come from? Why is humility important for strategic success in tech leadership? Thank you for your response!

like

How does contract to hire work? If I’m offered $37/hr on w2 for 3 months and then possibly a permanent position, how much can I expect to get annually as a full time company employee as a BI data analyst II? I have a M.S. and certificates in DA but this will be my first job as DA.
I prefer working for what is offered on contract without negotiating, and then negotiate when I transition into the company itself so I have a better chance of getting the contract position and show my skills.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal