Choosing between Bain vs BCG offers. Very torn here. Could you share what are the differences between the two (esp. in terms of culture, and ease of possible relocation)?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Make your decision easier by getting McK offer.

likefunny

Agree, go with mck

likehelpfulfunny

Bain has the cooler logo.

likehelpful

Personal taste, I see the appeal of both. BCG has kind of "The Great Wave" vibes.

Was in this position before and from talking to people from both sides the differences are:
1) Culture: BCG typically has a diamond structure where they hire more post-MBA people vs. entry-level consultants whereas Bain has a pyramid culture that is more bottom-heavy (more young ACs), leading to different vibes. BCG also feels more intellectual to me whereas Bain feels more collegial.
2) I am in Asia so it might be different elsewhere, but from the people I’ve interacted with, it seems like Bain has approved more personal transfer requests than BCG, which is a plus for me.
At the end of the day, both are great choices and you can’t go wrong! I’d say go with your gut and ask yourself whether you feel more comfortable talking with people from Bain/BCG :) Good luck and feel free to DM me if you have more questions!

likehelpful

Depends, OP. Anything other than core consulting business is very different in terms of culture and internal treatment by leadership. I recommend BCG for core consulting only.

likehelpful

Ans yes, I’m going into core consulting. I somehow thought that should already be a given since we’re in the consulting bowl

Bain got baddies

likefunny

You can have great experiences at both. Some things to consider as you make your decision.
- how have you felt in terms of fit with both firms during the interview process?
- is there a difference in which location / offices you have offers for?
- same for practices?
- look at size and strength of alumni network
- look at potential mentorship from people you’ve already networked with
....ultimately go with where you feel you will be comfortable and thrive.

like

OP, what is going to be your work profile at those two places? Could prob give some perspective based on that

I’d go with BCG. Stronger brand (if you leave) and faster promotions (if you stay).

OP, culture is super subjective. I loved BCG and felt Bain was too fratty *for me*. Both are great firms and on average you tend to make better friends at Bain. But it’s unclear whether it’s because more outgoing people tend to choose Bain, or Bain makes people bond more.

Relocation is easy with either firm. But if you already have a city in mind and that city has a BCG office but not Bain (or vice versa), the answer should be easy, shouldn’t it?

like

BCG if you’re interested in the grind I think has a higher upside, if you’re more interested in being friends with who you work with though/having a slightly more relaxed culture Bain is the wave. Lmk if you need more info - but this is the high level culture I’ve heard of at least

Going to also vary office to office a lot though

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

Have interview with UBS in Tech Software Engineer in Test role what can we expect my stack is CoreJava,Selenium,API testing.

Exp-8 years.

Thanks in Advance !

what's the average compensation package for L4 MLE in Kitchener Waterloo?

like

1. What are the hierarchy leveles in ZS Associates (software development). ZS folks , kindly help me on the same. I am having 4 years of experience, what hierarchy band can i expect?

2. How much percentage is variable component in ZS? I come from ACN which has 21% vp component.
Is vp paid fully?

3. Also, how is wlb in zs, Haven't heard quite good abt zs wlb..

ZS Associates

like

I have my unstructured case study round in ZS for a data science consultant role. Could anyone give few insights what to expect in the interview?

like
like

Hi Fishes. I am currently holding offer from BP and Citi , both offering the same package for penetration tester. Any idea which is an overall better option to choose?

like

How is Novo Nordisk in Bangalore? Quality of work, culture, work life balance, flexibility, other benefits apart from salary. Their leave policy is very good on paper. Practically, how easy is it to avail leaves in Novo? Are there onsite opportunities? What do you suggest about taking up a scrum master role with them after working in service companies throughout the career?

like

What is Netflix Program Management Lead responsibilities and total comp range?

At my org,full of politics and Partiality,still these kind species are there in org,when all the team members are working from home, specially they call one to work when all your colleagues are in wfh.,Dont want to have job gaps so bearing all these shits..Job pressures#work culture is an shit@Fincare small Finance Bank

like
like

Hello Fishes..need your advice. EY Technology Consulting or Infosys BPM Consilting. Infosys is paying 2 lacs higher. Need ypur advice keeping long term prospects

like

NielsenIQ Is it write time to join nielsenIQ in software developer field? Actually seeing a lot of negetive vibes against nielsenIQ. That's why asking. Please help me on this🙏NielsenIQ Nielsen

like

What is the Apta test in hsbc ? How difficult it is?

Could you please anyone let me know which interview questions asked in Infosys interview for Oracle SQl & Power BI technology ?

like

What are the perks and benefits working in GE Healthcare? Bangalore office..how are they in terms of pay scale?

like

I recently got an offer to join Deloitte Consulting LLP as an Analyst in Government and Public Services in the Business Technology Solutions profile, based in their Harrisburg office.

(I also want to mention that I have offers from Accenture & PwC right now, with a good chance of IBM being another one)

The offer was 88k + 12.5k signing bonus.

A friend of mine got the same offer but his offer was 91k + 12.5k signing bonus. Difference is, he’s based in Chicago.

I’m fine with my offer now b

Larsen & Toubro Infotech How much LTI pay for P2 band java developer in India ? Larsen & Toubro Infotech

Hi everyone, how is OW in the middle east?

In terms of culture, career progression and projects?

Are their projects more into strategy or how exactly?

like

Had an interview today for etl expert role in Capgemini.Have Cleared 1st round and the next round is techno-managerial round. Anyone can share experience of that round?

I am working as data engineer at Accenture with 2 YOE with ctc of 11LPA. After clearing all the technical rounds at Impetus technologies, tomorrow I have my HR discussion. She told she can't give more than 16 LPA. What should i do? How much should i ask? I am expecting somewhere around 19-20 LPA. Can anyone pls help. Accenture Impetus technologies inc

like

More Posts

like

Hi Sharks,
Looking for opportunities/referrals in MBB in consulting/project management role.Requesting support .

5th September is my last working day at Infosys. Yoe=4+ yrs
Tech= aws devops
I hold an offer of 18LPA from KPMG with joining date of 7th September. (Wfh)
I applied at Workday on 15th May and went through 7 technical rounds of interview and received a verbal offer letter of 21LPA (hybrid)
Now apparently their technical panel "forgot" about the interview and wants to have a discussion again as 8th technical interview. HR says their joining date will be 19th September.

Should i join KPMG?

like

NFW- I just had a good laugh. Earlier today I was on a video conference call reviewing a Private Label Agreement template with a larger company who wishes to brand label products we develop and manufacture. We came to a very one-sided provision and my sales VP stated “for this one, how can we just say ‘hell no’ ...nicely?” The other person on the call said we can replace the wording with just NFW (no f@$* way) and I said “I will have to add that to the defined terms section so it’s clear”

likefunny
like

Any input or advice on taking the SQE exam in the UK to become a UK qualified solicitor? How much to study or any recommended prep courses? How similar is it to the NY bar? Considering taking the July exam so any and all advice is very welcome!

like

Headed to a holiday party. quick: give me three interesting non controversial topics to talk about

like
like

Base salary for M at Accenture, EY, or PWC with 8.5 YOE at D Human Capital (tier 3 city; M.S. degree)? Should I consider any others? Thank you in advance!

like

Will IBM revise offer after accepting it ?

like

Hi Folks, I have an offer from IBM. They told me that variable component is not written in CTC breakup but you will get some amount each year

Is it so ?

like

Anyone know salary range for Product Manager - Associate role in NYC? YOE: 5.5

like

Hi Fishes, Can anyone throw a light about Genpact Pharma/lifesciences analytics practice in India-Bangalore. Considering for a potential opportunity, I have 9 years exp.
- How is the culture, wlb, and growth curve?
- About year on year hikes
- leadership team focus on mid tier's growth.
Genpact Genpact Headstrong

Accenture Deloitte Axtria IQVIA ZS Associates

I interviewed with the TBWA NY strategy team and they were the saddest people in the world.

likefunny

Can anyone please let me know what will be the take home/in hand salary for 20L Fixed per annum.

Thank you.

like

I have a promising interview at a relatively large law firm in my area (+100 attorneys) next week. The position is for a transactional role in their real estate practice group, and they are seeking someone with at least 2 YOE. I have a bit over 7 YOE with a strong real estate/commercial lit. background. Over the past two years in my current position, I've been doing a lot more transactional work. The split is around 50% transactional and 50% lit.

(Continued below)

like

I’m joining the Malad office next week and I’m looking for a space to rent. Could you please suggest me some places near the office? Also, I heard that the office is going to shift? Is it true? If yes, where is it getting shifted to?

like

Would anyone be willing to refer for PwC Canada? Hoping to apply for a role in Tech Strategy and Transformation. Thanks!

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best consulting firms to work for in Hartford CT area?

like

Best day spa getaways in NYC/NJ?

like

BCG folks, I hear rumors of layoffs happening given the slow pipeline. Is it true?

like

STARTUP FOUNDERS and FAANG: would you rather hire MBB with 3-4 years of exp or Tier 2 with 5-6 years? If you could isolate those variables and everything else held constant.

like

What are your expenses/time horror stories? Has anyone gotten fired in relation to expenses? Compensation withheld?

I wish I had a doggo with me to be my quarantine buddy...

like

Question from a newbie consultant - What are some good online courses/ books to improve consulting skills?

like

Please ping me when this live convo of robinhood and stonks are done. TIA

likehelpful

MBA grads who financed most of the experience through loans, any financial advice? Did you choose private loans over direct PLUS? How much did you take on to cover living expenses? How long will it take you to pay it all off?

Just enrolled in a full time program for next year and though I think my school is worth it, getting a lil nervous about the financial burden. To give some context, I got a small scholarship (25% ish of tuition), have about $60k in savings, and will be living in Evanston

like

Any good books or recommendations on sales? Sales tactics trips and tricks?

like

Not sure if I am getting laid off. What are some key signs. Thanks in advance for your help?

like

For people complaining about going back to the office, maybe think about it from new hirers’ perspective? How would you feel to not actually meet anyone at a new firm and make meaningful connections?

likesmartfunnyuplifting

Any suggestions for self help books on anxiety? Been dealing with anxiety for quite some time now and have been seeing a therapist but also just want to see what other resources are out there.

like

Has anyone booked a trip requiring air travel and hotels/vacation rentals for 2020? Am I a giant dumbass if I do? I will go insane if I don’t leave my city this year and I’d love to get to the beach for at least a few days

likefunny

This is a long shot but please anyone have a coupon for Babbel? Or is there another language site you’d recommend? TIA!

like

Hello! I’m going to BSchool in August. Any recommendations on books / websites / videos to be more prepared for management consulting interviews?

Lots of us are skilled at delivery but most sales books seem to focus on the pitch and closing... What are your best resources for learning to develop and nurture strong, lasting client relationships?

like

Would anyone be willing to review/critique my resume?

like

Inspired by one of my kids' favorite books, I penned this masterpiece of an Ode to Consulting:

One senior partner all alone
Calls two managing directors on the phone
Three associate partners at the door
Bring along another four
Five senior managers come overdressed
Six managers show up with a guest
Seven senior consultants arrive in a sack
Eight associates sneak in the back
Nine analysts come to work
ALL THE CONSULTANTS GO BERSERK!!!

Ok, I'll show myself out now... 😂

likefunnyuplifting

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal