I had an interview yesterday with a hiring manager and I have always answered the question of, “How much are you looking for in your salary?” as it is negotiable. This is the first time the interviewer scoffed and said that it was an inappropriate answer and that they needed a number. Was my answer inappropriate??? I already was told the range too.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

They sound unnecessarily dramatic but imo you’re doing yourself a disservice by answering that way. “It’s negotiable” would put you at the whims of whatever number they come back with. “I’m targeting a total compensation of $XXX” let’s you set the anchoring point and sets a better tone (you come across as a leader who’s direct and knows their value)

like

Unless you’re unemployed & desperate you should be willing to walk away if they can’t meet your expectations

You should definitely do your research beforehand and give a range.

like

Yeah, I have always looked at average salary range, but never implemented it as effectively...

I used to tell people to say that it’s negotiable and have a defined range. Now I’ve since changed it and it’s actually easier to anchor to hard-ish numbers in the same manner that the company operates. For example, if it’s a base + bonus + RSU structure, make sure you have numbers for all three and confirm with the right person that it is the structure. Ultimately, you have a TC number in mind but not every company pays out bonuses etc so make sure you are comfortable with the guaranteed portion of the TC.

like

I usually use Google. Otherwise crowdsourcing using the usual suspects like Reddit Glassdoor Levels Blind or fishbowl.

You gave a complete non-answer, most people would be put off by this. If you would be willing to accept whatever number they offer then say that, though more likely if you have a minimum almost in mind add 10-20% and anchor there.

like

Yeah... I can see that too. I will be sure to add it going forward.

Just ask them what the range for the role is first. Most companies have a pre-budgeted range. And be aware that your experience may not qualify you for the top end but it’s a fair place to start.

I would answer the compensation question with that it’s made up of many components, base + bonus + benefits + perks + travel benefits + firms market reputation etc. Given those haven’t been discussed it’s hard to provide a firm number. However, my expectations are around the 70 percentile mark of the total comp range advertised for this role.

Related Posts

Hi Guys,

Let me know if anyone is looking for a referral in Accenture. Multiple job postings are available.

like

I’m currently working in a DEI role but have some interest in switching to Employee Relations. Anyone in ER that can share pros/cons of the field?

like

I feel like all of my friends who work in tech are very open about their starting salaries and the increases each year. I am going to work in public accounting and I feel like when I look up how much I will make after being promoted or early promoted it’s very cryptic. Can anyone tell me the standard salary % increase in PA after your first, second, third promotion?

like
like
like

What’s something people assume about your role in this industry but isn’t true?

Joined IBM 3 months ago as data Scientist & In entire 3 months i am on bench. They said no projects in pipeline and no interview scheduled for next 2 weeks. Apart from data science i am getting every type of work 😂. Is getting data science project difficult in IBM now a days.

like

How is IBM GBS Nordcloud division.
How is IBM these days in terms of job security.
Is offered ctc is too high as per current market ?

Role: Infrastructure specialist Azure
YOE: 7 years 9 month
Offered CTC: 17 LPA.
Skill: Azure ,devops,linux ,kubernetes.

like

Currently an assurance senior 3 at EY (promoting to manager in Oct). Want to get insight or anyone who made transfer from one big 4 to another. Was it worth it? What’s the bump in salary? How hard was the transition for you (new terminology, tech, firm culture, etc)? Don’t want to think the grass is always greener on the other side, but I’ve seen so many people made the move to EY from other big 4 and they make much more than I do because of the switch (same city same service line same level).

like

Has it become common practice for leaders of a team to make less salary than their direct reports?

like

Just received my first offer today for an SDR role and I’m trying to grind to the top of these tech sales positions. I’m in Atlanta and my OTE is 60,000. Where should I be looking to get near the 6 figure range starting out? I graduated from the University of Michigan Business school and I have two years 2 tech experience, if that helps. Thank you!

helpful

Is anyone else having the worst time switching jobs? I’ve been applying for a year and haven’t gotten any job offers even though I get interviews. If anyone knows of a headhunter I could reach out to though I’d be so appreciative! I’m so frustrated….

like

What is the average salary for Clinical Research Associate I?

like

Brillio is hiring. Please check the below openings. Interested people can DM me.

Post Photo
like

I completed all rounds of interviews with capgemini. HR took all the documents about 10 days ago. However, offer letter is not yet released. HR stating that she is waiting for client project confirmation. Anyone faced such delays ? Ans what was the final outcome?

How does your firm measure utilization? I work for a small boutique that defines it as utilization = number of billable hours/2,080 and full bonus payout occurs at 80% plus.

like

Hello Fishes,
What salary should I expect from Deloitte India for SAP MDG tech. I am having total 2 year of experience. They are offering me consultant role.
Please provide answers in figure if possible.
Looking forward for your responses.
Thanks in advance!

like
like

Good day,

Is anyone able to provide a referral for Regeneron or another Pharma or Biotech Company? I am interested in PM/ Ops and Strategy Roles at the SM level and above. I have 13 years of experience, a MBA, PMP (since 2015), and I am a Lean Six Sigma Black Belt

like

How to prepare for a real estate investiny case study / memo interview? Apparently the case is light on financial modeling. Thanks!!

like

More Posts

Openings at Accenture. DM for referral.

Post Photo

What is Pinnacle award ? And How will that benefit me ??

like

Looking for consulting roles, 2 YOE in a more internal strategy role. Would love to see what’s out there. Thanks everyone!

like

Hi,
I have 4 years of experience in Sales and Uses tax from big4. I wanna switch to new company. How much CTC I can expect?

like

Going in-house full-time ✌🏻

likeupliftinghelpful

Wishing everybody luck on their upcoming exams and finals! 🤞 Remember to take care of yourself during this time!

likeupliftingfunny

“Isn’t meth, like, so early 2000’s? Does anyone do that anymore?”

likefunny

What do you like about your job?

like

Can anyone provide an in depth explanation of how the new tax bill will (in your opinion) effect M&A

like

DC - AFS, Senior Analyst making 88K salary with a 2K sign on bonus I had to negotiate is this a good deal?

like

Whenever i have a big deadline, my body goes into a panic mode where my energy immediately goes to figuring out how I’ll get something done well and on time. Outwardly, I don’t seem stressed so no one notices but actually I usually feel like I have a cold: fatigue, headache, sore throat, sinus infection. When a task is done, i stop feeling like crap. It’s been like this since law school. Any tips on managing stress or moving towards doing good work without my body shutting down lol?

like

Hi fishes,

One of my friends is working in a start up as an accountant he has 2.5 years of experience is there any possibilities for him to get placed in MNC's ?

like

Flight attendant woke me up while I was sleeping to give me ice cream, then I couldn’t go back to sleep.
How many points?

likefunnyuplifting

Hi Fishes, I need your genuine suggestions in finalising which company to join.
I have 2 offers :
ZS Associates - 15l fixed
Thoughtworks - 18l fixed
Role - Senior Consultant in Test
Experience: 5 yoe
Please consider job security and learning opportunities as parameters while suggesting. Thanks in advance!!

like

Trying to find an investment property to rent out for about $300k - what are your recs for location ?

like

Looking to relocate to Boston (fiance grew up there and wants to settle down around family). Sadly I dont have much of a network up there. Does anyone know of current searches?

Anyone who has worked for Trafigura client at Wissen Technology, how has been experience? Wissen Wissen Technology Trafigura Morgan Stanley

like

How does project allocation happens for lateral joiners? Is it forced upon or do we get a choice to choose or apply for a project? Accenture

like

Are there any disadvantages of joining a C2H role purely on the basis of high CTC even though it is for a big client of the contractor company?

like

Can anyone send me invites/codes to the EY and KPMG bowls?

like

Additional Posts in Compensation in Consulting

I think it’d be helpful if those of us who have exited into Bay Area tech start a comp thread so others can benchmark.

2 yrs post-MBA
BizOps manager
175 base + 225 RSUs (publicly traded, 4 yr vest)

likehelpful

Does anyone know the salary for Managing Consultant at Capgemini? The consulting practice not Tech

like

Fti 🐠, what is the salary band for a senior director in forensic and litigation consulting?

like

What’s the minimum percent salary increase you’d leave your current job for?

like

MBA? / yoe consulting / title / company / age / salary

like

Thoughts on Google L5 non-tech offer? Sales S&O GCP. ~8 YOE in both Fortune 100 and SaaS companies. No MBA.

Base: 165K
Bonus: 15%
Equity: 155K (on new front loaded vesting schedule)
Sign on: 20K

like

Need advice from the forum as I am confused between the two offers. Thank you in advance.

Currently working as Business Consultant + Project Manager w midsize tech consulting firm : 12 YOE + current TC 125k

Offers :
1. Local Bank >> Business Change management role (COO org) >> 152k Base + 30k bonus(to be paid in March 2023) + challenging work culture + 3 months NP

2. Global Bank >> BA + PM role (CTO org) >> 160k Base + 20k bonus( to be paid in Mar 2023) + Regular work culture + 2 months NP

like

For >20 YOE, multiple companies founded, highly technical, patents, academic papers, former F10 Director… even in a T3 city, $240k TC in consulting seems low, right? Not complaining at all just not sure what direction to go for higher comp.

like

“Experienced Hire” with 7 years of advisory technology consulting. Possibly looking to switch firms. Have no idea if I’m in the range, over or under market level on comp. What’s a good going rate for base plus bonus range? Currently 150k base with about 25 in bonus, but the bonus has accelerators which puts me closer to 180/190 in total comp.

like

Work in consulting division of acct firm making $88K base as senior associate 1. Interviewing with boutique consulting firm who has “competitive comp” and “typically more than Big4”. Is $105k high?

like

Product Manager offer is 120k salary, sign on bonus of 15k. 4 YOE total. Undergrad degree in computer science. Am I underpaid? This is a legit question lol. I’ve only done federal contracting/consulting work.

like
like

What's a median salary (considering all US employees) for big 4, Accenture, MBB and FAANG? Is 200k for big 4/ACN, 300K for MBB, 400k for FAANG a good ball park estimate?

funnylikesmart

Realized my tax withholding has been from NY (company based in nyc) instead of NJ (where I live)… I’m assuming this has to be changed asap with HR? And prob leaving money on the table…

like

Anyone start there career at GE as an FMP? Deciding if I should go get my MBA or if the program holds weight. Feeling like I got conned while in college

like
like

What is the biggest % increase in offer you received from negotiating a new job offer? (i.e. % over original offer)
Any negotiating tips/advice?

like

Base/Equity expectations for Series A Fintech (non engineering leadership role) in the Bay Area? 10 YoE. Thinking about a move but trying to understand the risk/reward.

like

Does anybody know if it is true that Kearney’s compensation is structured as “only” base salary with no bonus at entry level?

like

When talking about salary, do you usually say your base or TC?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal