KPMG or Deloitte? I have Manager offers from both. Former consultant going back after 4 years in industry. Salary is the same, both are Change Management roles (KPMG Transformation Delivery, Deloitte Human Capital). My best friend works at BCG and thinks I should go Deloitte for brand / future opportunities, but I find myself leaning KPMG as I think WLB might be better? Would love insights.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Curious (selfishly) at what the company range is foe both of these ? I’m also interviewing with both firms at the M/SM level

likefunny

Wow sorry, typos galore. Didn’t realize until now. But yes, comp at both companies :)

I just joined TD a few months ago as a manager (moved from another firm). I don’t mind it but I feel like consulting is consulting no matter where you go.

like

I’m ex D

If comp is the same - go to KPMG, I’m getting similar exit ops while working 75% of the hours.

Yes, Deloitte HC practice is best, but the hours come with the “prestige”, TD is a massive target growth practice for us, for strong performance, you’ll be set up for success, especially as a director

like

Am newly minted SM at deloitte hc. Had a similar choice at SC. WLB is good here!!

like

Whichever fit with the people is better. By far

like

Choose the people you feel most comfortable - per comments we didn’t lay off more people than anyone else during pandemic…and work life balance will be the same. Let’s be honest it’s still consulting. Deloitte is doing big push for better work life balance and I do feel it. Brand recognition is better with Deloitte agree with your friend…

like

I’m hearing horror stories of WLB at Deloitte but I’d love to hear your perspective and how they’re changing that

Been to both. KPMG

like

The D human capital rep is good but it’s mainly just consultants that know about that. Most industry hiring people won’t care that much about it, they just know the big 4. So go for less hours, same pay at K.

likehelpful

Deloitte will take you to other big fives in the future.

like

What were the offers if you don’t mind sharing? I’m also interviewing at both for manager.

like

If the goal is to eventually exit to industry than go with whichever firm is going to go be you the best quals / stories to tell when going back to industry. Personally I think Deloitte tends to get the “more impressive” engagements, but obviously I’m biased.

If you’re coming back to make Partner, then choose whichever one you think gives you the best combination of “get there quickly” and work life balance.

like

I came from kpmg and switched to a boutique firm

like

Federal or commercial practice?

Commercial

like

Didn't D layoff a ton of their human capital team during the pandemic? No knowledge of kpmg, but I think you'll be fine at either or since they're still big 4. Yes Deloitte might be slightly better brand recognition, but you'll still have to network for great exit ops in the future anyways.

At this point if you’re an M/SM you can do whatever you want bro. Just go wherever you’re getting the best vibe. Do a little research within your network and just try to ask around as much as possible.

Any reason in particular you assumed this person was a "bro". ?

like

Deloitte’s desperate right now for bodies. It’s good and bad but that’s where I would go. There will be more growth potentially and depending where you go you could have some good leadership.

Related Posts

Hi folks,

I have been offered a position on Senior Consultant/ Deputy Manager at Deloitte India for 4.5 years of exp.

Is this position/role normal for years of experience I hold?

like

Any advice/recommendations for the BCG Chatbot case round 1? Seems to be a blend of math and structure questions. Thanks!

like

How is IBM gurgaon for java developer(i have 4 year exp). is IBM gurgaon having good java development project?

like

Hi,
Can anyone help who has recently joined TCS.
By when we can get the onboarding link and other details.
I missed one of the documentation webex session.
Can someone share the experience of joining.
TIA

like

I have 3 YOE current CTC 6.75 LPA. I got selected in TCS for Java-AWS Developer. Is 8.5 LPA valid package? Thanks!

like

What is your view of Design consultancy in India?

like

Can anyone help with a rough comp guideline for BlackRock UK iSW relationship manager in London? Thank you

like

Any Deloitte strategy fish want to chat? Thinking about moving there and want to learn about day to day and responsibilities

like

What is typical salary for M1 - Accenture Strategy ?

like

Deloitte 🐠: any insights into reasonable signing bonus expectations? Starting the process with the Government and Public Services group...

like

Can anyone tell me the salary range for a consulting associate at Huron? Strategy and operations. Huron.

like

Thoughts on TC for Walmart. Currently interviewing for a Supply Chain Manager role, 4.5+ YOE, Masters Degree, High COL

like

Natwest group offering 18 lpa for 5 yrs with position software engineer B7.2. Is it good package at this designation?
Having offer from citi group of 17 lpa. Which one to consider?

funny
like

BCG folks - my interview process was interrupted by the pandemic in the spring. Would you recommend reaching out to the recruiter to see if it is possible to restart the process now? Or are things still pretty frozen for experienced hires at the PL level?

like

Is anyone here an analytics engineer? If so what do you do, and what are the main differences between your job and a data engineer?

like

Does anyone here work as a client development manager at RGP consulting? Phone screening with them tomorrow and I would love some insight on the compensation package they offer before I ask about budget etc.

like

I interviewed with PwC for sf dev two weeks back. Last week I called up the HR who got me interviewed for an update on it but she just said that give us some more time we will get back to you. Is it pretty usual in PwC to take this much time?

like

Any insight on Brewer (either office, generally curious about the firm). I assume comp after year 1 is discretionary, rather than lock-step, given the size of the firm. Would appreciate happiness, horror stories, of whatever “firm culture” falls between the two. DM me if you don’t want to share publicly.

like

I am product designer with a fair amount of experience (6yrs).

Recently was interviewed for a Sr. role in Booking but unfortunately the team finds me better suited as a core individual contributor.

I am also in the advanced stages of some lead designer positions in other companies.

However I am really interested in joining the team at Booking, especially because of the design culture.

What should be my reasons to accept or not accept the offer from booking?

like

More Posts

Folks what is the general OTE compensation for enterprise SaaS tech sales executives in India with an annual quota of $1.5million.

like

What would be the salary standard for blow skill set with 10+ years experience

1. Oracle DBA, Golden date , RAC, data gaurd
2. MySql, Mssql, Postgres Sql
3. Cloud DBA in AWS, GCP
4. DB migration from onpremise to Cloud

CCTC - 21 lpa

like

Hi Folks,

Any idea how much a Fresher would be paid in Finance dept in @TechMahindra Please share details

like

Is it worth considering a career in Restructuring Consulting in the long term given that their work can be quite cyclical and hinges on the spectrum of the economy.
Or have I misunderstood this? Are the teams always busy with projects?

like

Has anyone here ever felt like they always had to prove their worth at work while others were simply given a chance?

like

Average salary increase from Sr. Art Director to ACD in a medium size NYC agency under one of the big conglomerates...What's standard/been your experience?

BMW or Mercedes
Which is more impressive as a brand? Thinking of either the E class or 5 series.

Which is more important mental health or job?

like

I have to pick a direction to move ahead in, Brand & Marketing Design(with website) vs Product design (Games UXUI , Physical and digital)

I have a solid background in both, so keeping preference aside - which direction do you think makes more sense to gain more experience in? And will make more sense for the future.

McKinsey & Company what type of projects generally strategy consulting peeps do? what skillset is required flr strategy roles?EY Deloitte Accenture McKinsey & Company @bcg

Got two offers for MSBI stack, data analytics -SQL n SSIS

Bureau Veritas -24 lpa fixed is 21.5 n rest var
Hexaware - 30 lpa 27 is fixed

Which one should I opt? Hexaware has good stabiloty n work life balance n do they follow hire n fire rule ?

Please help as my joining us next week. Thanks

Is the EPGP programme from IIM Kozhikode worth it?

like

Sharks your thoughts on this plssss

Post Photo
like

Hey folks, can y’all share tips and tricks to get over interview anxiety? I’ve joined toastmasters to work on my public speaking and communication skills in general + I practice interview questions before interviews. The issue is, when I think about an interview I start to panic. Any advice would be much appreciated, thanks!

like

Hi all!

Apologies in advance if this is the incorrect space for this - but my agency - Spark Foundry - is hiring at multiple levels within the analytics team. If you’re interested, private message me. A lot of growth here!

like

Guys EY Mandatory learning course answer key anyone.!!??
If someone will provide genuine and positive answer, I can tell course name in comment.

like

Penchooooo... inhe believe hi nhi ho rha ki hum itne Churan kaise ho sakte hai 🤣🤣🤣EY

Post Photo
like

What is the salary of BPO1?? How many years it will take to move from BPO1 to BPo2 and BPO3.Is there a possibility to move to IT from BPS from BPO1 directly???

like

I was downsized by this company 6 years ago and had worked for them for 8 years prior. I am now in talks with them about another oppertunity but they do not want to let me start back with those 8 years. I looked up standard practice and according to the standards at the Society of Human Resources Management HR should give me my time back cause I was downsized (not fired for cause and I did not quit). What should I do?

like

1. Need some feedback how anyone proceed during HCL Technologies Discover portal login. It's showing me invalid login continuously and using forget password options, able to login one time by luck 2. BGV documents uploading links are routing to smart portal. Will it be the same credentials which is being used during discover portal login? Asked my recruiter HR, but no reply so far
3. Anywhere we need to accept the offer Letter?
HCL Technologies

like

Additional Posts in Org Development & Human Capital

Phr vs waiting for sphr?
Taking the credential and want to prep.

Any book recommendations on change management?

like

Anyone have any leads for OCM roles that are remote?

like

Has anyone found a way to automate salary certifications?

We get about 3-5 requests daily to fill out salary certifications for our employees in EMEA.

At the moment, we have to do all of them manually. We open a pdf, then open their employee file and plug away. It's tedious and time-consuming, but the banks I found won't accept an internal salary certification for some reason. They're adamant about using their form. Has anyone come across this?

like

Came across a role at Deloitte in Richmond, VA today called HRST Talent Culture & Change Management Specialist. Can anyone give me insight into the type of role this is, day to day, comp, etc?

like

Anyone ever move from an internal role to one with external clients? I manage a learning function for a line of business and pondering the next move: industry, startup, consulting...

Has anyone made the switch to OD/HC from recruiting? Have been considering making the switch, but would like to hear about other people’s experiences, pros/cons, etc.

likehelpful

I’m a recruiter who would like to eventually pivot to HR but I don’t have an HR degree. I’m considering pursing a Masters degree however am torn between HR or Org Psych/Org Development. Would love to hear folks’ perspective of either degree!

likehelpful

Does anyone know of any great org development projects or opportunities? Looking to gain more experience. Im open to new locations & have experience in large scale change management implementation.

like

So... I have questions for change/org effectiveness practitioners who have successfully leveraged their experiences to acquire high paying, high level roles in industry. How did you do it? What was your path? What would you recommend to others so they can make the most of their careers? I’ve included my reasoning for this Q, below!

like

HR M&A, does anybody know what type of work this role entails? Within it there's a Strategy, DD, and Integration team. Thanks!

like

Hey Fishies need a recommendation on an international coaching certification. I am a senior HR professional with SPHR and SHRM-SCP certification. I am interested in coaching for career advancement. Thank you for your recommendations

like

For those who have started (or tried) their own consulting business— what’s the experience like? How’s revenue?

I'm looking at a company that's beginning to build its HR function in the U.S. (they already have overseas teams). What are some questions I should be asking the CHRO or things I should be considering when I evaluate the HR roadmap? How do you evaluate an HR strategy at this stage? I've worked at startups, but this would be my first time helping build the HR function.

like

Is the SPHR or PHR license necessary to pivot into human capital? I have a MBA from a Top 15 school. Any thoughts?

What is the general consensus on online I/O psychology programs? I’m looking to pivot into HC consulting and am strongly considering USC’s online MAPP or Harvard Extension School’s I/O Psychology graduate program.

like

What is your take on the PROSCI certification (on the company's dime of course)?

like

Has anyone taken the SHRM-SCP? Any study suggestions and impressions of the test?

like

I'm considering switching from Accenture T&O to EY Change Mgmt practice for 150k. Is that a smart move? I'm in Chicago

like

How do the HC offerings at McKinsey and BCG compare to the depth/breadth found at Deloitte, PwC, Mercer, etc.? (Talent, HR Strategy, etc.)

likesmart

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal