So I posted on LinkedIn that our firm was hiring, and a friend responded asking for a referral. They are a great person and friend, but an awful worker…what would you do here? I don’t want to be an a$$hole but I also don’t feel good about putting my reputation on the line by referring them.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Tell them sure, get their resume, don’t put in the application, tell them they will receive an email if they are selected. All done.

likehelpful

Its an awful idea proposed by Pwc1. Its raising false hopes and also acting as me know it all. The firms are made of thousands workers. So many people are junks. So many people make partners even though they have questionable skills, ethics and other character flaws. Let him go through the interview process. He needs to know what he is lacking so that he can improve on.

like

Bruh a random recruiter at your firm you’ve never talked to doesn’t care about and won’t affect your reputation

likefunny

You are just referring them , not giving them the jobs . You could be in his shoe one day . Karma is a bit**.

likesmart

In such cases I just refer them... and let the interviewer know they should be thorough with their interviews.

like

🙌

like

You sound like a pretty terrible friend; I'd just communicate your thinking to them so they can reevaluate the friendship now that you're being honest

like

😂😂😂 ok EY.

If you think an SC sending a referral link is risking rep, that's been throroughly covered above; last I checked OP wasn't a recruiter. They have no idea what fit looks like.

Be a friend an either A) send the link B) explain honestly why you won't C) have a different person send then a link.

Absolutely amazing how out of touch people are. If OP was nervous to set up coffee chats, that's one thing. This ain't that.

like

To recruiter: hey this person reached out to me and is keen to be considered. I don't know him/her but if you could have a chat with him/her, that'll be great!

like

^ 🥇🥇🥇

like

If the aforementioned person is your friend, express your concerns in a constructive manner and then refer them. You should be more concerned about your character than a referral that doesn’t work. Michael Monsoor jumped on a grenade to save his friends without hesitation - dwell on that while you’re figuring out your next action on whether or not to help out your friend.

like

I would probably tell them that their skills or whatever don't align with the job thay well and they dont have a high chance or something or straight up tell them that they're lazy and no

To provide more context around why I’m asking this; our practice is relatively small (~40 people), so if you refer someone you’re going to receive a message from a colleague (aka the hiring manager) asking your opinion of them and why you think they’d be good for the practice.
I’d hate to submit a referral knowing they’re not a good fit for the firm and then say “yea he doesn’t the have the experience/fit but he’s a good guy and friend so I referred him”

Tell the hiring manager your honest objective assessment. Don’t lie. You are not hiring them, your company is. Just don’t reject your friends before the process even begins. If your company didn’t need anyone, they wouldn’t have posted. Regardless, you should help your friend remediate any deficiencies, referral or not.

like

Never hurts to refer.
If asked by recruiter or your higher ups then you can ask them to assess the candidate as per their expectations. Gets it off of your shoulders at least.

Related Posts

So my SO got offered a role based in London, I’m new to the company and am wondering if anyone has negotiated a move across the pond within the firm

like

What is the salary range for Technical Lead role in Infosys ? I have a HR round coming up and don't want to get lowballed into that one.
Exp: 5+ yrs

like

Hi All,
I had my 1st round of interview with Executive Director and 2 leads for Technical role. I have 2 queries-
1. How many rounds should i expect in total considering I clear everything? (I think my first round itself has technical + manger/director)
2. How long (time) will it take to get an offer?
TIA :)

helpful

I know people say the Google hiring process is long, but I’ve been in the process for over 100 days now...when does it become too long by even Google standards?

like

About to get promoted at PwC from Associate to Senior Associate (mgmt consulting). I interviewed at Deloitte for a Consultant position, but they’re potentially giving me an offer for BA. I’d essentially be holding out on the promo until next promo cycle. Usually, I’d understand hiring at a level below for higher levels but I feel like doing a 3rd year as a junior might not be the best decision. Should I push HR for Consultant level? I haven’t gotten the official offer letter yet, just verbal.

like

Hi folks!

Currently interviewing with Mastercard data and services for the consultant role.
Wanted to enquire about the travel opportunities in this role, be it within India or outside. I personally enjoy travelling and have travelled quite a bit during my consultant stint previously. However, not sure of what the norm is within Mastercard.

Thanks!

like

Anyone know anything about Greycroft for an associate VC role?

likefunny

Hi there, my name is Tiana(she/her). I’m based in NY. I have 4 years of administrative experience & I am looking for a new role. If you have any referrals, can you send them to me? It would help greatly with my job search! Remote or Hybrid preferred.

like

I’m a 9th year in a mostly litigation-based practice group at a one-tier partnership firm. My group’s billable hours have been low the last few years, so making partner will be nearly impossible, and a counsel position is not viable long-term in my group. What’s the best option here if partnership is the ultimate goal? Try to get a NEP/counsel position at another firm, which is likely difficult in my market, or offer to take a class cut by a few years?

likehelpful
like
like

How bad is reneging a week before I start? Have an offer with FAANG but the role is sales. Got a dream job with Disney in Analytics & Strategy with comparable salary. Should I stick with FAANG?

Better manager & culture & benefits at FAANG, better role & opp at Disney

like

Can someone give some idea about hiring process of Oracle India? I had an interview 2 days back but haven't got any feedback from them.

like

What programs do my fellow HR managers recommend as far as personality assessments for hiring ?

like

Anyone willing to refer to a role at Flatiron Health?

like

Guy any openings for senior business analyst role for pune location i am serving notice period and LWD will be 19 july. Having good knowledge of capital markets investment banking and scrum master as well

like

Hey Fishes Looking out for a job change and came across vacancies at Deloitte India as per my profile and experience. Can someone kindly help me with the referral. That'll be great help. Have been trying from a long time to switch but nothing fruitful yet. Your referral might make the job hunt a bit easier so kindly help. Yoe: 3.3 Profile: SAP SD associate consultant Immediate joiner
Deloitte India
Thanks in advance for your help.

like

Just curious. Why are the ME offices always hiring? Is it because people are leaving all the time versus other regions? Or just that the business grows crazily all the time?

like

Looking to brainstorm ... What's the next wave to ride for the next 3-5 years and how to position yourself?

like

Folks who do hiring, what do you think of adopting the following question in future interviews?

“Evidence suggests that teams that include a variety of perspectives and backgrounds will often produce more creative solutions and catch mistakes earlier. What background or experiences do you bring that will help broaden the perspective of our team?”

like

More Posts

So stressed! Not getting any calls- any good referrals for resume services, probably need to refresh my resume- or any other tips is much appreciated! 11 yoe experience in data and Analytics and have stayed in same firm. First time going out and looking for job.

like

Hi Fishes,

I'm looking for Guidewire Testing QA Job and TOSCA Automation.

I worked as functional tester in Guidewire application. Also worked in TOSCA and developed UI, DB, PDF scripts validation. 

Serving in notice period. Any vacancy is there, Kindly provide a reference

YOE: 6 years

Tech stack: Manual testing Guidewire Application, Automation testing (TOSCA)

LWD: 29-Dec-2022

If any vacancy or referral, Kindly ping me

like

I need to perform well after months of bad performance for 6 months to not get fired I'm scared but want to do it impossible?

like

Have 3 years of tax processing then 2.5 years with tax prep; passed CPA exam. What is the comp i should take? Thanks

like

Not sure how I feel about this #DeleteCoinbase movement...perspectives?

like

How does approval process usually work with rolex ADs? I have a purchase history with a current AD and been on a waitlist for a while. Got a msg saying they have one in system and waiting to get approval to sell me one, but no promises. Does this mean I am likely to get one soon?

like

Will be doing consulting/part time work for a small finance/acct outsourcing firm for startups. What rate would be a reasonable ask? I assume it would be hourly but anyone ever experienced getting a flat monthly fee?

HCOL area
100% remote
Role is sr acct/manager. Will be working on startups so i can expect to roll up my sleeves too. Responsibilities include reviewing staff work, month end close, FS prep and analysis, typical industry stuff but smaller scale

like

What’s the pay rate for Full Time for Senior Integrated Producer - 10+ years of experience. Job is with agency and client is in tech.

like

Thoughts on the Tech investment banking scene in Charlotte, North Carolina?

like

Any Grainger Commercial Account Executives that can verify base salary range and OTE? Any heads up on benefits would be great as well.

like

If you left public accounting and are now in industry, are you still forbidden to do accounting services outside of your job?

likesmart

The learning and design content I write belongs to the company where I work. Am I able to add and/or share my work in my portfolio? Is it acceptable to create some generic content to demonstrate my skill set?

like

Deloitte Consulting's M&A team is hiring IT M&A professionals for their Dubai office (United Arab Emirates, Middle East)

If interested, please reach out for more color

like

Been a coach at the collegiate level for 6 years. Make a $65k salary. Want to leave coaching and break into sales/marketing/recruiting/consulting. I have ample leadership and recruiting experience with a strong work ethic.

I’m assuming I’m going to have to take a pay cut and start toward bottom of totem pole. Any recommendations/advice on roles to apply for since I’m new to the field? Would like to be in tech if possible in Charlotte, NC or remote.

like

Somebody pls refer me
Looking for manual/ automation tester
Experience 2.5 years
Desperately looking for a job

like
like

Got offered 115K with 25-30% bonus for a fund accountant role with 3 years of public experience. Is that normal? Seems like really high. I live in NY to clarify. Combination of Big 4 and midsize experience. What’s the normal salary range for ppl in that range?

like

How to move into executive leadership? I’m a mid-40s former MBBer with, I think, an impressive and diverse resume. I think I’m suitable for an executive leadership role, but unsure about how to pursue one. Any suggestions? Career coach? Headhunters? Cold “calls”? Thanks!

like

Hi,
I'm thinking of changing my career to data analytics. What course should I be doing?

like

Hi ppl,
I heard that for hike, promotion input about performance is taken from TL and teammates and Lumos plays only a very minute role in it. Is this true?

Additional Posts in Consulting

Anyone here take APICS CSCP? Is it worth it? What type of role are you in?

like

Hey all I am in the process of quitting Deloitte to move to salesforce in a month. Anything I must keep in mind while leaving ? Like using up subsidies and benefits before the year ends?

like

I have $20k in savings, I owe $6,000 to my 401k loan, that’s the only loan I got. I am debt free otherwise except for my house. Should I use my savings to pay off? Since people are talking about unemployment and being fired, I wanted to make sure I have enough, 👩🏾‍💻... What should I do? I initially took the loan to add to my home equity when I sell my house for a new house then covid hit.

like

Advice or Book recommendations on how not to get bothered by others/ friends/ peers? What they think or what they do!
Been struggling lately

like

When they say utilization doesn't count for the month of May/June what exactly does that entail? I'm assuming being on the bench for those months will still show on personal utilization reports...

like

Good nonfiction book recommendations? What are you all reading?

like

What are your expenses/time horror stories? Has anyone gotten fired in relation to expenses? Compensation withheld?

How do I check my actual utilization (not the effective one). Mybusiness only tells me the effective utilization

like

For those that have been laid off, how’s the job search going? Have you gotten offers fairly quickly (I.e. 2-4 weeks after getting the notice)?

like
like

I like consulting but the multiple project workload sucks. I have 5 active projects and I’m barely scraping by on each one. I’m just surviving week by week. I could do such an amazing job on these projects if I had 2-3 instead. Sucks

like

Will start my first project in a few weeks. What would be best for my learning experience between the options below:
1) on site project
2) remote but more exciting project (industry I love)

like

Anyone been to the Harvard Extension School - Consultant’s Toolkit program? Any insights to share?

like

Hi All,

Moving out of IT consulting to Product Management side in the next couple of weeks.
The new company I will join is an e-commerce division of a leading food retail group.

Any suggestions about books/ videos that I can access to learn the basics of the product side?

like

Any really impactful books that have helped you career-wise? Not necessarily consulting focused. In need of guidance and a new book so figured I'd kill two birds with one stone or whatever.

like

Which consulting firm has the best 401k match?

like

Looking for some material for a crash course in IT strategy consulting - books article etc. any recommendations would be appreciated

like

Given the Facebook (Meta) layoffs, how likely is it to have an offer rescinded? Starting in mid June which now seems far away but have an offer from another FAANG (higher TC too). Was going to decline but now I’m worried.

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal