Traditional 401k vs. Roth 401k?

Context: 25F. New associate at $63k. Also have a Roth IRA, HSA, and HYSA.

Leaning toward Roth 401k due to the expectation I’ll be in a higher tax bracket later, but would love to hear advice from this bowl!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Here‘s the question you have to ask yourself: Is tax likely to go up or down in the future?

When I look at the current spending, debt levels, and fed policies, we have no choice but to raise the government’s income, which translates to higher taxes. The question is who will pay for it: the poor, the rich, or companies. I bet that it’s going to be the poor.

like

I think it’s mostly going to be companies, and the middle class (further bifurcating your “poor” population into a poor and middle classes). And I think most (at least in this bowl) plan on being middle class at retirement.

I don’t understand why so many people convince themselves they’ll want to retire on a lower income than they had early in their careers. You are probably going to have some level of success in your career. Lifestyle inflation is a thing. And many people eventually want kids.

When those things set in, you’ll realize even if you still want to FIRE, your number is going to be based on what it takes to support the lifestyle you want, and that lifestyle will probably be a lot more expensive than your first years out of school.

So if you’re under 30, unless you plan to have a career where you never get raises beyond inflation, you should probably be in Roth.

like

And I stand by the points that a) kids are expensive and b) lifestyle inflation is a thing. You may be happy making 65k, bringing home 40k after tax and spending <30k today to save >25%, but that doesn’t mean you’ll be able to do that at 40, or want to retire like that. My brother easily spends 25-30k each year just on summer vacations for his family of 4. I spend a bit less but only because I don’t have kids. If/when I retire, it better include a nice ski condo and those don’t come cheap.

Recent IconRecent

Roth 100%. The tax-free growth over 30-40 years is why

likehelpful

You're right!! Stand corrected

like

Why do you think that you will be in a higher bracket when you are retired? You might be but most are not

like

I have a feeling that the rates for higher incomes will be higher. No idea if anyone will actually raise rates in lower bracket. You need to consider your facts and do what you think is best for you. For many just splitting will be best. I just think that when people say Roth is a no brainer, they often don’t really know and are often wrong

IMO there is no way tax rates are lower than your current rate in the future so I would do Roth

likehelpful

65 when I qualify for Medicare 😃

like

Roth all the way

like

Saying one or the other with no knowledge of the individuals facts is not really useful. Roth is the right answer for many but wrong for many

helpful

Pre tax 401k and mega back door Roth combo for the win 😭

like

😭

Related Posts

Considering buying a home but was told to account for unexpected maintenance bills that come with owning a home. What’s the biggest bills you guys have received (e.g. broken air conditioning)?

like

Hello and happy Thanksgiving! What are the pros and cons of living in San Diego vs San Francisco? I’m from NY and looking to move to one of those locations. I’m hoping to get more info on rent, dating, entertainment, taxes, and job stability.

like

This is a little embarrassing… I don’t know anything about investing. I come from a low income / immigrant background and never received financial education. Just recently learned the difference between an TR and Roth IRA 😓 I have started to contribute $$ in my 401K. I am 27 and only have like $15K in my Vanguard account feel like I am so behind. Can someone recommend good resource/advise to learn the basics?

like

What are the parental leave benefits at Siegfried? I can't find any information on their benefits package or online, neither can I find it on the internet, I'm new and don't want to ask about it since I recently started,not planning for a baby right just want to know for the future.

like

Compared to facilities which company (Samsung and Intel) provides best facilities? I know Intel has lot of benifits like free cab, child day care reimbursement, telephone bill reimbursement, 15% discount on shares purchase, very good leave structure, Free UDEMY for developing skills, Intel wiki for lot of knowledge gathering etc... Any idea about samsung? Intel Corporation Samsung

likehelpful

Anyone in Vancouver want a Programmer Analyst role doing data conversion from Oracle into WD? UBC is a great employer that pays well for Vancouver / Canada and the work is remote, though you have to be in Canada. 4 weeks vacation and benefits start on day 1

like

Need help on how to invest. We are positioned to pay off our house later this year. Expect to work for another ~20 years. 401k fully funded and have some company stock investments maturing over the next few years, but no investments outside of that. Kids have a prepaid college plan for certain schools. Emergency fund is solid. Where should I look to start investing? I have fidelity for my 401k, would they be good to open a taxable investment account with, or are there better options?

likehelpful

Does LTI provide reimbursement for WFH setup ?

like

Just got a financial planner/advisor. Tips on prepping for the first/intro meeting?

like

Ex healthcare workers in Tech/Sales Engineering/ Healthcare consulting;
I have my masters in nursing/FNP (1 yr) making <K70 (Indiana) due to low patient census in my role. No desire for a different FNP job nor to return to bedside nursing (RN 5 yrs). I have heard of some individuals with remote positions making >K100 with little to no experience in tech or consulting after doing a boot camp or cert?
If you pivoted; What’s your current role/ Income & what did you do to complete the transition?

like

Use savings to (partially) pay for business school or invest and fully cover via loans?

like

What are your favorite personal finance books? I just read Rich Habits and really liked it. I am also reading the Psychology of Money. Looking to read some more!

like

If you leave J2 and get another (new) J2, does the first J2 show up on new J2 background check? Assuming these are w2 roles. If so, how do you explain that? 🧐

like

What is the name of the credit card that gives you United PQM for each dollar spent?

like

We are trying to change plan. What you’ll think about Aetna EPO, heard it pays 100% for IVF? Currently on BCBS not much benefits if we would want to skip IUI and jump to IVF. Any suggestions here would be helpful. Thank you.

like

Can we show rent paying to parents if we are living with them.. Do company mandates that parents should be living in different city to qualify for such HRA exemption.

likehelpful

Pwc salary structure? Benefits

Urgent

like

How to choose which financial advisor to work with.
I have no financial experience and an advisor reached out from equitable.

What's a good percentage (they're offering 2% as a fee)

like

I am interviewing for an AVP business data analyst in London, 2 YOE.

What benefits does citi offer and what salary can I expect / negotiate?

More Posts

HCL -
Fix -   1,156,500
Variable - 107,200
Total CTC - 1,340,006

EXL -
Fix - 1,100,000
Var - 1,650,000
CTC - 1,345,000 + 50 K Joining bonus.

Which offer is good and which company should i join.

like

How strict is Jio background verification?? My wife has not shown her previous company in CV and now HR has asked to share last 3 months salary slip to release offer letter. Is it fine if she skip this company??

Does London banks do drug testing for new hires? Not a new hire but looking to switch offices within the company, thanks!

Not a drug hardo at all but sometimes enjoys the occasional 420 on weekends

Any recommendations for best balance transfer card? Like zero APR for 15-18 months and no fee? Also nice to have points or cash bonus

like

I'm a recent MBA graduate from Vancouver, Canada. I want to make career in Digital Marketing. I'm facing hard time to find a job in the same. Indeed and LinkedIn are names. The way they send the job recommendations is pure gimmick.

What are ways to land a full-time permanent job? Any referrals here

like

Saw someone on my team floss their teeth with their own hair in the bathroom like it was normal & i was stunned. Is this seriously a thing? please tell me it’s not…

likefunny

I think he wants something….

Post Photo
like

Happy Monday All!


St. louis or Kansas City attorneys looking for help resolving your clients property claim.

Shoot me a message!

Let’s talk!

Mission Consulting & Estimating LLC

Post Photo
like

When submitting your taxes, do you share how much you pay for HOA? Is there a form to fill out or do we get any type of reimbursement for paying HOA?

likefunny

Would anyone in a product analyst role at Visa or senior product role be open to chatting? Looking to pivot into payments industry from financial services and would love to get a better sense of product

like

I have to pack to leave tomorrow morning but I really don't want to..

like

Anyone experience not working well with managers and up (due to micro-management, talk to you like a child, etc), but find them cool outside of work? Finding it hard to hang with them during HH now.

like

How is Quinn Emmanuel’s culture? I’m interested in their virtual office.

like

Anyone has any idea what would level 6 may look like in Amazon India for Analytics. Is it equivalent to Sr manager in big 4 or VP in bank

like

If you’re apply from a big 4 to another for the same job you do, how do you explain to recruiters why you want to be there? It’s basically the same place…

like

I recently cleared all rounds of interview for Mindtree and waiting for the offer letter. However, since Mindtree has been recently acquired by LTI, is there any layoff expected to happen in Mindtree?
Kindly pls give me an idea about how the situation is now in both companies.

like

Range of EY salary for Senior consultant in HCOL/Tier 1 city? Around 3-5 years of consulting experience.

like

Hi Fishes,

Could anyone please tell the avg year on year hike in Societe Generale GSC? Thank you.

like

Anyone work at Guidehouse and know next year’s benefits? Have job offer but they won’t tell me if benefits will be the same for 2023.

like

Looking for advice! I was approved to work remotely but my salary will decrease 10%. I received two raises so the decrease brings me down to my previous salary. I was told that it’s due to the cost of labor in the area.

I’ve been with my company for 8+ yrs, I love my manager and the work I do (engagement, recognition, & wellness programs) but I feel like I’m limiting myself since I have the experience, an HRM degree, and SHRM-CP credentials.

Should I apply for roles outside the company?

like

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

I’m thinking of opening a TD Ameritrade account for investing - does anyone use this/have any feedback? For reference, I recently graduated and have no prior investing experience, so any feedback on investing is appreciated :)

like

Hello all!
I'm 26, I studied economics but I don't know why I'm not much into investing/trading. Someone else like this?
I recognize this is not a very good approach for someone with money "knowledge" and I would like to change this mindset. My main weakness is that I easily get bored of following the market and that I do not see big opportunities. Any advice?
Where to start learning, general advice for LT and ST investments, things you learnt, books that changed your pov on the topic etc.

Thx!

like

Who’s buying the dip today?!

like

Looking to invest money with a Schwab brokerage to save for a down payment on a home. What ETFs should I invest in?

like

Question on after-tax contributions. I’ve recently upped my contributions to after tax through payroll (already maxing our 401k+contributing to traditional Ira to be converted to a Roth shortly contd

Why is Oracle buying tiktok? seems utterly far stretched away from oracle’s current business model

Post Photo
likesmart

Is it too late in our lives to jump into a mortgage?

So my fiancée and I are relatively late in terms of finally landing well paying jobs and being able to save money instead of living paycheck to paycheck. We’re both 36 and currently rent a 2 bedroom in NY and have a combined savings of $35,000 which she wants to use as a down payment on a condo. I kinda just wanna continue saving while renting. I also literally just started contributing to my 401K so I’m also late in the game for that too.

helpful

I paid for my kid’s college fee this year and last year thinking I will use 529 in future for second kid but now I am having second thoughts as I need little more money to buy an investment prop cntd

like

Best HYSA with a good account opening bonus?

Mutual funds you have your eye on right now?

like

Anyone part of F45 or close side red franchise opportunity with them ?

like

This is a little embarrassing… I don’t know anything about investing. I come from a low income / immigrant background and never received financial education. Just recently learned the difference between an TR and Roth IRA 😓 I have started to contribute $$ in my 401K. I am 27 and only have like $15K in my Vanguard account feel like I am so behind. Can someone recommend good resource/advise to learn the basics?

like

Need help on how to invest. We are positioned to pay off our house later this year. Expect to work for another ~20 years. 401k fully funded and have some company stock investments maturing over the next few years, but no investments outside of that. Kids have a prepaid college plan for certain schools. Emergency fund is solid. Where should I look to start investing? I have fidelity for my 401k, would they be good to open a taxable investment account with, or are there better options?

likehelpful

Just got a financial planner/advisor. Tips on prepping for the first/intro meeting?

like

What are your favorite personal finance books? I just read Rich Habits and really liked it. I am also reading the Psychology of Money. Looking to read some more!

like

Looking at purchasing a townhouse/condo on the beach but the HOA fees are ~25% of the PITI. I’m wary of HOAs to begin with - any insight?

like

How do people increase their credit score? Mine’s only around 790/770 for transunion/equifax respectively and its been like that for a while now. I have 100% payment rate, only 3% credit utilization, and 0 hard inquiries for the past 6 months or so. So far I only have credit cards, no loans yet. Thanks in advanced!

likehelpful

Anyone have experience with or recs for a good moving / shipping company? Trying to gauge typical cost, have about 5 furniture items to ship between states (7h driving distance) and would like them to load / unload. Thanks!

like

Investing noob. Just started putting money in back door Roth IRA. Have been losing money each month. I thought the market was doing well… what gives?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal