What are your thoughts about only being asked STAR method questions during an interview and no questions about your background or skillset?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It bothers me a little bit but that’s the direction today’s interviews are heading. The key here is as you answer these hypothetical questions you need to find a way to showcase your experience and skills. This is why you need to prepare examples directly related to your experience.

like

I wouldn’t read too much into it. Sounds like they had a prompt and didn’t deviate from it, maybe because of inexperience or lack of independent hiring authority, but hard to guess.

I do think STAR type questions get at a lot of background & skillset because you end up talking about experiences and the skills you have used or developed in a way that shows instead of tells. I’m personally also interested in motivation and what a person wants (why they’re moving, why they want this job, what they want out of it), and I also like to see how the person communicates and summarizes information in response to different kinds of prompts too. But I wouldn’t judge someone too harshly for using different practices.

like

It could be that they are assuming you are technically proficient and want to assess your soft skills. I lean more into STAR for experienced candidates where I assume based on work experience they have technical depth or I’ve already had a chance to assess technical depth

like

I hate STAR. If asked answered right then they will get information about your background and skillset though.

like

I hate it, too. I've never been asked those types or questions, and the ones asked did not provide any information on my background, and I bombed it miserably. Had we talked about my background, it would've gone a lot better. I hate thinking you can miss an opportunity because of it.

like

I think only a sociopath could nail a STAR questions only interview.

like

Good to know I'm sane 🤣

like

What are STAR questions?

like

Questions like "Tell me about a time you had a conflict with a co-worker and how you handled it" or "Tell me about a time you made a mistake" questions like that.

Related Posts

Is it common to negotiate software engineer salary at smaller companies? I know it’s common at FAANG, but what about for companies with around 200 engineers? I have a counter offer from my current company and on-site interviews scheduled for end of July with google and Amazon, but I’d prefer to go with the smaller local company if I can negotiate the salary (from offer letter) up another 5% or so.

like

Any fish here worked in intelligence? Interviewing for a technical analyst role. What should I consider?

like

So, 100% of the times I’ve got further in the interview process and I’ve got an interview with the ECDs or CCOs, I got the job. Always.

Except for the 2 last ones. And the only difference was...cont

Hi All

From last 40-50 day's; I get call from HR ...
.they asked whether they can schedule interview on Wednesday....i said Yes.

But somehow I get schedule cancellation e-mail on or before Tuesday & the process continues from last 1.5 months

Will i get interviewed @accenture or not....

like

I’ve been interviewing at Slalom Consulting (S2 group) for a Consultant role. Waiting to hear back after my 4th interview now. What should comp range be for a mid to high cost of living area? Thanks!

like

What would be a typical salary for a junior in house counsel role (3 yoe) at a publicly traded company in a secondary market (think Austin, Tampa, Charlotte)? I’m having a really hard time finding what a reasonable range would be. Most positions I’m applying to require desired salary in the application, and the truth is I’d accept anything north of 125k but don’t want to undersell myself and take a bigger cut than necessary coming from biglaw.

like

I have one query, i received survey mail from ey gds regarding joining date and location preference, so it mean iam selected or any other round happens? Because i give self recorded video interview on 7th feb and i recive survey mail on 7th March which i filled on same day and in joining date there are two options 25 March and 25 April ,wheres i select 25 april but there is no communication after survey mail so what should i do?

like

ASAP:
I have an interview round scheduled for tomorrow.
Can anyone please tell what is C4E round in Apisero?

like

Hi Sharks,

Wanted to know your experience of applying for jobs abroad. For those who converted and joined abroad, did you apply for jobs on LinkedIn? Which platform would be the best for a senior data scientist in India. Also I get 30 lpa now, is it worth going abroad? Can we save more?

Thanks I advance!

like

I have an interview coming up for BCG but due to some personal reasons might need to push it a few weeks. What’s the likelihood the firm will be OK with pushing / is it even worth asking?

like

How long did you have to wait from last round interview until offer? (Public sector)

like

Any Simon Kucher fishes available to chat about casing and interview advice? TIA

like

I have an interview for a role in Quality, specifically ER. I have no ER experience but have med surg, oncology, home care, and OR so I was just planning on talking about how all my previous RN roles have involved process improvements. Any other helpful suggestions?

like

canada vs. US salaries at Amazon? I’m interviewing for a role at amazon. Any insights on if the salaries advertised for US roles are comparable for Canadian roles? I don’t want to give my range - in fear that I’ll undersell myself. Any insights? (It’s for a senior proposal manager role -10+ years experience)

like

Hello there. I have been interviewing with Okta and got through all 5 rounds of interviews. They say they want to offer me the job but there is a global freeze for all marketing roles at the company. They want to offer me a contractor role instead. Does anyone here know if that is the case? I haven't heard anything as they seem be on wellness week. Thanks for any guidance :)

like

Anyone here interviewed at or work for Nice? Would like to hear your thoughts/experience. Thanks in advance!

like

Feeling very anxious these days. I still have my current job, a potential promotion this year, and a safe-choice job offer but not something that I wanted.
Really want to jump ship but feel pretty burned out from the job application process after 40+ app and a few final round interviews.
I plan to apply to McKinsey but my referrer left the firm 🙁, now I need to start over and to find someone else. Please send encouragement my way to have the energy for this process.

like

Last week I had an interview with Infosys, it didn't go well as per my expectations but i was able to answer most of the questions asked by the panel and they said I will get the feedback from HR team but it's been more than one week and I didn't get any update on this. Yesterday I also wrote an email to the HR who scheduled the interview but still no update.

Should I consider that I am not being selected?

like

Currently interviewing with EY NZ as a risk management consultant. 1.5 yoe and expat from US. I have a rough idea for cost of living, so what should my minimum salary expectation be in Auckland? The position would allow me to work from anywhere in NZ but I'd prefer to be close to the office for at least the first year. Thank you!

like

YOE : 1 year 9 months

What can be expected for
Morgan Stanley Java Developer Associate Interview? Any favorite questions ?

TIA

Morgan Stanley @

like

More Posts

Hi Fishesh,

How much in-hand I will expect from below salary structure.

YOE 8.5

Should I negotiate more or its as per max bracket for C11 band ?

Thanks in advance

Post Photo
like

1st time going to Spain in May. Thoughts on the itinerary? Barcelona 4 days -> Seville 3 days -> Cordoba 1 days -> Grenada 2 days -> Madrid 3 days

like

Is there any profile which is based on purely SQL and nothing else, no excel/tableau/powerbi task.

like

My Accenture candidature has been put on hold after I cleared initial rounds and submitted my documents without HR Discussion... What does this mean?
Can I still expect the offer?

like

What's it like working with BCG in Dubai? Which service lines have the best people and which should be avoided?

like

Hi Folks,

What is the difference between EY India and EY GDS?

What are the pros and cons?

Thanks in advance :)

like

Hi guys, it's been 4 weeks since i joined GDS , I was assigned a POC task, in which I worked for a few days but now its on hold.

Could someone help me know what's avg bench time or how to get projects here, who should I contact(other then counsellor) or if there's any internal portal to apply for open positions in a project?

Thanks

like

Hey Guys,

Just got off a call with Counselor. Got Differentiating with Progression to Senior 2
Is there any hike for Progression and how much will be the VPB

SL: Tech Consulting

TIA

like

Interested in getting opinions on Wipflis benefits

like

What’s it like at Verizon?

likefunny

How much weight do you put into your gut feeling of "I do not like my interviewer who would manager me" if you think it could just be you have unrealistic expectations

like

What’s the difference between strategy & ops vs product management?

Hey fish, I started recently (within the last year) at post PhD level. I’m thinking about moving into pharma or biotech since I don’t think the ladder in consulting is right for me long term. How long do you need to stay in consulting for before making say 150-200k base in pharma/biotech?

like

Is SAP Fieldglass a good module to switch from sap hcm? Any idea about Fieldglass oppurtunities?? EY PwC SAP KPMG Deloitte

likesmart

I deeply miss my ex. The breakup was initiated by me 5 years ago because I was scared to commit. Since then, I’ve gotten married and have a daughter. I’m so embarrassed to admit it but I think about my ex everyday. I am so sad that I walked away from him. Life is ok now - I’m thankful for my family but my heart hurts. How do I move on?

Moving into a new apartment with no living room / kitchen furniture and appliances (e.g., vacuum, lamps, chairs). If anyone is moving out and wants to offer a friendly fire sale, please let me know!

Closer to midtown is preferable.

like

Bench ka Kya system hain bhailog capgemini mein?

like

Is't possible to move to projects with day shift? If selected for 2-11pm shift..or is thr any policy to spend this much time on the current project in JPMC

For all you in IT audit what has your salary progression been YOY?

like

Additional Posts in Law

What’s your take on Lydecker? What is the culture? Market salary? Expectation on billable hours? Mentorship? Etc.?

like

How do you properly vet a law firm? I feel the associates I speak with talk up the firm and aren’t always candid.

like

How often do temporary "might-become-permanent" type jobs (at small/mid size firms) actually become permanent?

like

Anyone else here kinda like doing doc review? (In moderation of course)

likehelpful

Does anybody work in a rule for a litigation finance or legal funding company who doesn't hail from a big law firm in background? Basically I have a lot of interest in the area have read a book about it in my free time and was wondering what sort of entry level opportunities I should be seeking.

like

As lawyers are there ways to get paid for connecting clients?

like

A friend was rewatching old episodes of Suits, which admittedly I’ve never seen. The main character starts at this law firm where associates are given cubicles not offices. There’s no way that’s accurate, right??? I have a cube but I’m just a lowly gov atty frm a state school LOL not a Harvard law alum at a reputable NYC firm

like

Hi new here. Idk what my value is and if I’m getting paid an amount that reflects my hard work. I am a paralegal for a small law firm (family and immigration) w only 1 attorney. I have about 20 files or more in my rotation at a time. I work on various types of cases at once. Some are simple, others are extensive. I feel like it’s very unstructured and one of the managers micromanages. It’s like every man for himself. Take home pay is $50k. I am working on my bachelors deg. Do I get paid enough?

like

I’ve practiced litigation in DC for about 5+ years at a larger plaintiffs’ firm, and am considering a switch to a defense firm. Is there any insight to how many billable hours this would require, and how much time that would actually be? For reference, the firm has a 1900 billable hour requirement and the partner said I would have “no problem” fulfilling that based on the work they have.

like

How do you wind down after a rough day?

like

For those of you required to be in office- do people use the phone and email to contact you or do they still come by in person? People in my office seem not to understand how the phone works...

like

California 🐟 does your vacation payout when you leave your job get taxed at regular wage, or bonus, levels? Does your employer have discretion to choose?

like

Transactional associate. Lateraled 6 months ago and one of the biggest pain points has been my new firm’s inclination to “hop on a call”, which of course requires every single stakeholder to join. The end result being every call has 25 people on it and nothing actually gets done because no one wants to ask a question that could come off as silly. It’s destroying my ability to get anything done during the day. It’s a complete performance and it drives me nuts.

like

I have an interview at a firm that focuses on criminal defense. I currently work in ID and have years of previous PD experience. I’ve never worked in private criminal defense. What questions should I ask in the interview? What should be looking at to evaluate whether it is a good practice?

Anyone at Pryor Cashman have intel on firm culture, work/life balance, and comp?

like

Can you share first year salary for midsize firms? I'm in NJ, but curious to hear other markets. Also billable targets? Thanks!

like

What is everyone’s: (1) billable hours this year; (2) practice group; (3) year; and (4) size of law firm?

like

How do you recommend dealing with a partner senior to you trying to do anything possible to push you out, force you to quit, or get you fired for years? Owner knows my abilities and likes me (contd)

like

Layoffs. Most big firms say they're sitting on a conservative pile of cash - which I believe is true - but work will obviously not return to pre-COVID levels in the short term, probably not even in the medium term. Are Biglaw layoffs coming?

likefunny

I'm a long time prosecutor getting into the ID game and billable hours. Are there any resources out there that can help me get more effective/efficient without spending months/years learning the hard way? Some days I'm at the office 10 hours, took virtually no breaks and yet only bill 7. 🤬

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal