👀 Can we talk smack about auditors? Trial balances based on filed financials are still trash once it comes time to do returns, so all I’m saying is materiality can kiss my a**

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You know the auditors did not prepare the financials/TBs right?


We must stand together op. I hear you loud and clear. EY2- I don’t think he is saying that. There comes many times where questions arise with discrepancies in accounts where the auditors don’t care because of materiality.


Exactly, thank you!


I felt exactly like this as a staff. Fast forward to now and I really appreciate the auditors. The difference between then and now is before I tried to figure it out myself and spent hours on something spinning my wheels. Now I go straight to the audit team and let them explain it to me. They usually know exactly what you need and can answer it in 15 minutes, or they have the data you need, it just wasn’t crucial for the audit. Go talk to the auditors.


I mean... Everyone tries to act like materiality doesn't exist for tax purposes buuut it does kind of. The times it gets tough for me is when you have small entities as a part of a larger audit and the entire small entity is viewed as immaterial so little work is done.


As an exec or even in upper mgmt your time should only be spent worrying about items that have an effect on the business. If I have $1 billion in revenue, it is not worth the time to chase about $100,000 variances for a week. You have more important decisions that have larger dollars at risk. Now if the issues are all over then yes hou need to look into it but that's usually not the case.


Former auditor now tax staff. I know OP knows this but the end goals of an audit vs return are completely different. Audit fees would be astronomical if they set materiality suitable to a return level.

Plus audit workpapers will usually get you 75%+ of the way to a correct answer for a return adjustment


But the audit partners. Typically condescending and act like nothing can be more important than their job. Meanwhile, coninuous news of restatement and other issues within the audit practice...🤔🤔


Yo auditors are nice! They’re always coming in clutch with tie outs and stuff like that. So much better to ask them then the client


ALSOOOO... how about when they have a zillion topsides booked at the top co when there’s a dozen different regarded entities underneath.






Related Posts

Hi ,

My last working day in
FIS Global was on 28th June and i got June month salary three days back and got payslip of June month.

But I didn't get my Service Letter till now .
Kindly tell how many days it will take to get the service letter and to whom I need to drop mail.

I have already dropped mails to teams but they are just mentioning other people in mail by saying please assist but noone providing my service letter.

Kindly tell to whom I need to drop mail.

A recently promoted manager, I constantly worry if I am performing like a manager. This anxiety doesn’t let me focus on work and I end up staying silent or lost. I was a stellar senior, but this...


What’s the best GMAT prep strategy? Past experience much appreciated. Aiming for M7


Any F 🐠 in their 30s in DC interested in connecting?


How to get into Human Resources with a Master Degree in Psychological Organization Leadership


Buehler....Buehler....Anyone even here? Lol

How do you explain those parts of your projects where you made decisions based on intuition and not necessarily some quotable textbook methodology?

I’m a rather ‘organic’ UXer who is often able to achieve impressive results just by following what makes sense to me instinctually.

Oftentimes I might unintentionally mimic the same steps as some methodology because it’s just what comes naturally to me.

How do you talk about this?!?


"Designer" stole projects from other Designers, for her own website. I know this happens sometimes, and it's certainly one of my biggest fears. I want to spread awareness within the creative community, in case anything else on her site may be one of your own projects. Julia is a design educator for Adobe and she found one of her own projects on Lucy's site—and have since identified 2 other projects that belong to 2 separate designers as well. Please be aware, and check her site out!!

Post Photo

Any female fish interested in connecting? Male here, 29, NJ.


Welcome to the bowl. This bowl is dedicated to discussing FAANG and alike tech exits. Topics may include: interview process, interview tips and tricks, mock-interview teaming, salary negotiations, team matching, etc.


I've been working with deloitte since 2 yrs with a wide range of experience in RPA,.NET Tech,SQL and worked at clients location for various projects,Looking for new roles, Would appreciate any leads.

Need advice - Neighbor always has an outdoor party at their house.They start as early as 5p during the week and earlier during the week end. They have very high volume up until 11p (and keep talking outside until 2a). How can I make it stop without confronting them? Im so so upset that someone ( + older people ) would be so inconsiderate on a weekly basis to their neighbors and dont understand how nobody ever reacts… (I just moved here few months ago)

How did you overcome workplace jealousy? For promotions, projects, and so on


Hi Fishes ,

Can anyone advise if they have interview with @s&P @ihs markit . I have an interview for SME profile (dev ops) .

Seeking advise on what grounds shall i prepare .


Any advice on making the switch to M&A/TAS?


Is there a good book to teach kids, teens and even college students about personal finance or should i write one?!


The way that some clients respond to an email make me think "Damn, I'd be fired if I talked to a coworker that way"


Anyone know where I can play indoor pickup basketball in midtown or downtown manhattan?


Babymoon ideas? Where would you suggest/what type of trip and what stage of the pregnancy? Wife is 11 weeks with twins for reference.


Additional Posts in Tax Bowl

Has anyone used a tablet with a pen or or other interface with their PC to take hand written notes and covert to a file that can be filed in One Note or in a document retention system?


What industry do you think pays better: pharmaceutical or financial firms (IB/hedge funds)?


As a manager how many hours is normal to bill per week?


Manager salary in NYC for general tax


Going to a competitor. I told my PML about 2 weeks ago and have been on a parental leave and will officially put in notice when i return from LOA. PML is saying i need to put in notice now since i accepted offer from competitor and they will shut me down ASAP and that i shouldn’t have taken my leave. Is this really an HR thing or my PML bullsh*tting me out of spite?


Have you switched to another b4 thinking it’ll be better but it turns out it’s worse? 😂 cause same


For those who work as tax consultants in public accounting just for the tax season, how much do you get paid per hour? Is overtime paid at 1.5?


Smallish firm that just merged with another smallish firm. We're switching tax software and about 3/4 of my team is anxious about any change after a couple of roller coaster years full of changes already (pre-merger and unrelated to it.)

Anything you recommend to ease the transition? If it makes a difference for your advice, staff is on the older side. They had buy in on the software and plenty of demos and time to check it out and test it etc. But implementing it is making them anxious


Any successful tax professional stories out there? Non-PA**
Curious of the career opportunities people have migrated to.

Whats the best test prep software for the CMA? I used GLIME for other exams but I feel they over prep. Questions are way hard and intense. Anything else more user friendly you’ll would recommend?


Saw an International Tax Shared Services position at KPMG. Is this different from international tax service? “Shared services” makes it sound like in-house back office role.


Have you heard about PwC switching to a system where they pay people based on where they live and not based on the assigned office? This is affecting people who work remotely for a large market office but live in a low cost area. I heard HR has started sending out emails and telling people to expect a pay adjustment. Seems like getting a pay cut will anger a lot of people...


Has anyone considered leaving tax to be a real estate agent? I have thought about doing this off an on for years but have never had the guts to do it.


Kpmg vs Deloitte vs Pwc. Which has a better FS team?


How to you avoid zoning out and staying productive ? Amazes me sometimes how much time has gone by while working


Do any B4 use OneDrive or Google Drive or is everyone still sending versions back and forth? I’m talking about for things like adding comments, suggesting changes, etc etc for NON-AUDIT work

I work for a top 10 firm in the northeast (Philadelphia area) and want to make a jump. I have 4.5 years in Private Clients - individuals, trust, partnership, gift tax but I also do international 5471/8865/8858/926/1116 and such. But I can’t seem to find any Private Client positions. Is it possible to try for International tax and step back to maybe a first year senior? I am still working on my CPA but I’m not happy where I am and need to jump


If the partner for my group isn’t in the office and doesn’t appear to be online should I give notice to my counselor or HR first?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or