Does it look bad to “decline to self-identify” race, gender etc on job applications? I usually do it whenever possible because I don’t want that to be a factor in my hiring

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I don’t think anyone but HR sees those things, but also, who cares… I’m middle eastern and unless they have that as an option, I’ll decline to self-identify. The history of these demographics submissions is dark and unless it’s accurate to who you actually are, it’s more harmful than helpful.

like

Right? It’s trying to be progressive but only sees black Hispanic and Asian.

like

It’s definitely something some employers take into consideration… my friend is a recruiter at Meta/Facebook and there are usually dozens of people who fit the criteria for any given role, so hiring managers and recruiting managers often ask my friend “did you get any qualified applicants who would add to the diversity of our team?” or a kind of roundabout question like that. My friend will then pull out the POC, people with disabilities, etc etc to bring into the first round of interviews, based on the answers to those demographic questions. If an applicant didn’t fill out the demographic questions, my friend might make assumptions based on name, LinkedIn photo, etc., but obviously some things don’t come across in a name or a photo. So even though it’s illegal to discriminate based on those factors, if a lot of candidates are similarly well-qualified, companies that are trying to boost DEI will definitely prioritize diverse candidates. Therefore, if you CAN check any of the diversity boxes, you should. But if you can’t…not filling out that part of the application won’t do anything to hurt/help you. At least from what I’ve seen/heard.

likesmart

Agree. And it’s a good way to tell if hiring decisions have been slanted towards 1 group of people while others from underrepresented groups are being passed over.

like

The way this industry usually works, for better or for worse, is that while someone is stressing over what precise language and qualifications and aspects to include or not include in faceless online application portal, truly thinking they have a chance at it, the job has already been promised via the must-hire system/buddy of a buddy doing the hiring.

like

Unfortunately I’ve noticed. As I’m trying to get to NYC and my lack of connections is killing me

like

Wondering this too. Would love to hear from HR/recruiters.

like

I doubt it plays that big a factor in the hiring process, especially the initial rounds as so much of that stuff is done via programs that scan resumes for keywords.

like

I would recommend using a standard resume template for exactly the reason you described. You can showcase your creativity through a portfolio but for the recruiter, easy, quick, and simple is the way to go!

like

An alternate view to consider: recruitment is under pressure to present more diversity to hiring managers. I as a manager am looking to really build a diverse team. It’s so hard to get there without some way to measure and have kpis. But I say that totally understanding the reluctance. As a woman I’ve always wanted to be viewed through my capability vs my gender. I think there is no easy answer. Do what you are comfortable with.

likehelpful

And while we’re here, why is identifying as Hispanic/Latino typically asked as a separate question? If they know we can be mixed, why not make the whole question multiple-choice?

like

People have biases. Got overlooked because I didn’t fit the cultural fit. Names, gender, outside activities, and social economical class all play a part.

like

Should not affect the hiring decision at all. It’s meant to be aggregated in overall stats. I dont believe anyone outside of HR can view your individual response.

No, I don't think it looks bad, even to HR. Those questions are only there to collect data on the demographic of employees applying and getting hired. If you feel uncomfortable or would rather select decline it shouldn't affect the hiring decision at all unless the hiring process was already racially motivated.

Nah. It really doesn't matter. I don't think anyone pays attention to it so much to be honest.

They want to know for a reason. Hate this question.

I hate that question. Never had to self identify until I came to the U.S.

Related Posts

How high does L6 range typically go for Sr Program Manager roles? I am currently at ~250k TC and the position they were interviewing me for hand a max range of 200k TC. Is >300k TC possible?

like

Can anyone talk about the fixed income research role (Hours, daily tasks/projects, exits opps/career progression)? Is a Masters needed or can you start as analyst as opposed to associate? Any insight is greatly appreciated!

like

Hi everyone, I am appearing for data scientist position in Accenture Dublin at level 9. What salary should I quote ?

like
like

I have my salary discussion today. Can you please advise the avg package for the associate manager in SCB. How is this role placed in the hierarchy? My total experience is 5.7 years

like

Hi I have 5+ yrs of bedside clinical research nurse experience and have been trying to pivot to the CRO world. I have applied to over 40+ positions and keep getting rejected. I have reformatted my resume to ATS but that doesn’t seem to be working either. Why is it so hard to get into the CRO industry and why is my hospital experience not translating? Thanks

Please reach out if you need a referral at IBM

like

Has anyone had an interview with Aston Carter before? If so, what would be some advice you would give?

like

Hey Guys,


I got a call from
Infosys HR on 16-September-2022 that I have been successfully selected for the job position of Test Analyst at Infosys, as per our conversation I have to receive an offer letter within 15 days, but I haven’t received it till now.

Now They have sent a mail that your Candidature is on hold. Is this happened with anyone else also.

Please do suggest on this guys.


Infosys

like

#LTI - Larsen & Toubro Infotech is hiring for multiple #Data job profiles.

Interested for below jobs opportunity can DM me with Jobcode
4+ Yrs exp

Python developer -JR Code 957669
Azure Consultant -JR Code 446367
Data Science Consultant -JR Code 446347
GCP Consultant -JR Code 446327
Abinitio Developer -JR Code 446287
QlikView/Qliksense Consultant -JR Code 446267
Bigdata - Pyspark/Java+Saprk/Spark+Scala -JR Code 446247
Snowflake Consultant -JR Code 446227
Informatica Consultant (MDM/IDQ/PC) -

like

Folks if ur looking for referral in EY across the globe then DM me with requisition job ID.

Must not applied or attended interview in past at EY

Only above fullfilling folks DM me

like

Hi, I got two offer from Capgemini (24 fixed+ 2.5 Variable CTC) at C2 band & Harman international (25L Fixed+ 1.5L Variable +1L JB)
at senior solution Architect role. Please suggest your opinion which one should I choose.

YOE-7
Skill- SAP Functional Capgemini @harman international

Is it a norm to send a thank you note through your recruiter? I had an iffy interview, and wondering if I bother sending a thank you note. It was very clear that they were trying to do a stress interview so I feel weird saying the usual nice things.

like

Deciding between Structured Finance at EY and Valuation associate at Alvarez Marsal. I value work life balance but also want to get the most out of the job with great exit opportunities. Any input would be appreciated.

like

Did anyone who recently attended UST interview for Java tech stack can share interview experience??

like

Is internal audit a good career path? I was presented with a position at a fortune 500 company, and I’m ready leave my PA firm, but not sure if leaving PA is right. I’m senior level

like

If you work at FAANG level company do you get recruiter calls almost daily?
Cause I work in a lower level firm and I don't get calls

Was told I’d only have one round (4 interviews), each split 50/50 on case/behavioral. This is for an Associate position and will be interviewing with AP/P/SP level. Is this typical? Since I see most people have multiple rounds.

like

DA AC profile interview, what all is usually asked?
Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

like

Could a position as an Office Coordinator be the same as Administrative assistant or could be considered as a higher role?

like

More Posts

I'm shameless! Who wants to hire me? Full cycle corporate and commercial real estate sales rep who wants to get into BDR/SDR roles. #ninja

like

Just curious about salaries in Morgan Stanley Investment Management India, particularly Marketing department. What's the pay like for Associate, Senior Associate and VP? Do share your Yoe as well! Thanks.

like
like

Anyone have a standing desk recommendation between the Fully Jarvis vs Uplift V2 vs Autonomous Smartdesk 2? Leaning towards the Jarvis but the Autonomous one seems 50% cheaper, but can’t really tell what the drawbacks are according to their website/reviews

like

Do people think working remotely will remove some gender bias in the work place? Or impact people’s perceptions of women colleagues?

like

Been with my boyfriend for 4 years. His family is much more wealthier than mine (6 cars, owns 4 houses, part of 3 businesses). My family is middle class and I feel inadequate around his family because they’re so wealthy. I feel depressed because I can’t live his lifestyle and sad for our future. His family just bought a house for us and my family can’t even buy a second car. Idk how to go about this situation.

likefunnyhelpful

How TF does someone become a product manager at a MAANG company at 23 when every PM job posting out there requires 5+ years of experience???? Genuine question

like

What kind of comp could I expect for corporate strategy at a MF?

like

Is a 900k net worth for a single person at almost 40 good or terrible? I see posts from our US counterparts on net worth and salary and feel so behind yet we have such a high COL in Toronto.

like

Is fishbowl only available on the US App Store?

like

Was told that an LCA will need to be filed since I am now working from home - anyone else in the same boat and any ideas about timelines?

like

I am a Sales Support Engineer (Applications Engineer) with 2 YOE. I am thinking about making a change because my job is no longer challenging, and there isn’t much growth opportunity in my company. I love my team, but I feel like I may need to move on. I am at 70k a year and have been told time and time again that I have learned faster than anyone they have seen and am a top performer. I don’t feel like I am being compensated for that either. Any suggestions on companies and target salaries?

like

Currently I work for a small company that does the construction of small cell utility poles and roof top sites for the major cell carriers like VZW, T-mobile, AT&T and so on. I am a project coordinator but I do everything under the sun. Created project tracker. Submitti bids, sourcing material, negotiating price on materials, handling post construction inspections, scheduling sub contractors, notifying stakeholders, coordinating with construction managers - property owners - building management.

What would you choose & why?

Post Photo
like

Total 7 years experience 3 years in automation with selenium and rest in manual testing. Looking for switch. Could someone please refer to their companies.

Wells Fargo referral: Can someone working at WF please refer my profile? I can share the job ID. Please help!

Post Photo
like

What all companies have openings for Informatica Developer for 7.5 YOE...
if anyone has any referrals pls post
Currently serving notice period....

Hi ,

Looking for a job change and interested to join and explore your career in Qualcomm with below jobs, please DM me.

Post Photo

Additional Posts in Advertising

Just had someone in NYC I want to work for ask me my salary. It's illegal now but I didn't know how to tell them. I told them my range. What would you have said?

like

Why do people in this industry say "like" so much? It makes it annoying to, like, walk around the building and listen

like

Why do I literally chew my nails off throughout the day. Need to know so I can stop

like

How did your agency handle layoffs? All-agency meeting before they started? After they ended? Both?

Kinda sorta trying to predict if I’m losing my job tomorrow.

like

Has anyone ever worked with Kate Spade’s husband? I hear he works in Advertising. Sad day for fashion today

likeupliftinghelpful

Without asking or confirming, account lead booked an in-person client meeting that requires travel. Who books ~any~ major client meeting without first checking with the team ?

like

Will the lawsuit against DMA force the victims to come forward? It’s the only way DMA will not end up in serious trouble. I’ll bet that Ted Royer and the rest of the DMA targets will follow.

like

Been asked to present my current client’s plan and PCA in second interview for a role. Am I being over cautious by not feeling comfortable with this?

like

Mccann creatives - what are the good groups?

like

A post-mort meeting scheduled with:
6 account
2 strategists
1 creative

Sounds like an ambush!

likefunny

For all the Q3 and Q4 misses, looks like most of our agencies are projecting big rev increases for Q1. Trump effect 📈 ?

like

Given the outbreak, are places actually going to be hiring right now? Recently laid off from 9-5 and my freelance is starting to fizzle.

like

Best time sheet system you’ve ever tried in a job?

like

Is anyone hiring free lance/ contract AEs or PMs? Any state.

like

After an awful solid four weeks, I left work today at 6:30 and am fucking getting my nails did.

likeuplifting

I promise you, whatever you have to tell me as I sit down with my lunch is not as important as eating my lunch.

likesmart

Has anyone been able to negotiate anything extra or terms when being laid off?

like

Account: *Sets review for Monday
Account: Why aren’t you guys leaving?! It’s summer Friday!

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

Thank you all for existing on Fishbowl and for being such a supportive community. It’s been a difficult year, but at the end of the day, I’m glad to have people to commiserate/celebrate with ❤️🙂❤️

like

I’m bored in an airport. Vowed not to bring my laptop and my flight is delayed 2 hours. Can we spark a controversial thread? Post your unpopular opinions below!

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal