I’m seriously considering getting my PhD in Economics rather than the standard MBA track, does anyone have experience with this?

I have a good chunk of research experience (that i actually really enjoyed) and top notch letters of rec available, but it’s extremely hard not to think about the opportunity cost of 3 more years of school (and the real possibility I make more post-MBA).

Not exclusively looking to make as much money as possible, but growing up poor makes it hard not to think about.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Nice I’m considering the same…life seems to be a constant struggle of comp vs. fulfillment, but this path seems like a decent compromise

like

What do you want to do long term? Do you want to do research for a living? Teach at the undergrad or graduate level? Continue in consulting? Assuming you’re not set on a long term path in academia, two post-phd paths you can look at are economic consulting (Cornerstone, Analysis Group, CRA, Brattle, Compass) and tech

like

Apologies for the miscommunication—long term goal of PhD would be to work in academia as a tenured professor. Going into the private sector with a PhD is mostly for people who decide at the end academia is not for them; it’s a fine way to live, but if that was my goal I would certainly just get an MBA as you guys pointed out. Does that make any sense? Long form discussions are difficult on the FB app lol

A phd takes at least 4 yrs typically to complete. Some programs you may get an MSc in the process as well. There is an ROI working at a top business school or even going back to work in industry. If you enjoy research and can see yourself dedicating that time then it will be well worth it. What kind of financial position are you in now? Maybe 4 yrs of PhD won’t be so bad if you are really passionate about it. I haven’t done a PhD but it’s in the back of my mind - some questions PhD candidates ask me is if you really will enjoy what you are researching, or if there are opportunities to pursue research without being in a PhD program (if that’s what you want to do). That way you wouldn’t have to leave the workforce for many years

like

Kinda curious to hear other people’s takes that might have done this. I was Econ undergrad and MBA and my wife has a hard science PhD and I’m always around PhDs…… my strong assumption is that nobody cares about an Econ PhD and it’s only something you would do to be a career academic. Econ is not the same as business. It’s largely hypothetical and based in advanced math that is well beyond the scope of business leaders.

I might consider you similarly qualified if you were applying to a post MBA job, but then why not just get an MBA? I would think about the cost of an MBA compared to the graduate school stipend you would receive, but for more than twice as long.

like

I would probably work in more of a research-oriented role or econ consulting post-PhD. If I was looking at the same roles though you would be 100% correct that MBA is probably the better play, especially if I can get sponsorship.

Do you have a strong math background? That’s maybe the most important req for the top programs, from my understanding

Yeah I don’t think my math background would be a limiting factor. I was a math major also and most of the classes I took were with an Econ PhD in mind.

Related Posts

Does anyone know if it's possible to move from tech sales to strategy planning? I am a young professional and mostly have background in sales and account management but I do have an econmics and finance degree which could be helpful to move into more technical roles like strategy and operations.

like

I am a Fraud Investigator making $61,000 per year at Optum. I feel like I am very underpaid and that my counterparts are making more than I do. What is the normal pay for a Fraud Investigator?

like

Looking to get back into SaaS sales after a few year hiatus. Any tips or recommendations to ramp myself back into SaaS sales? Any podcast or books, etc?

like

How are the hikes at @UBS

funnylike

Any UK fish that took or was made redundant receive a bonus. If so please share details.

What is the average hike provided in Reliance Jio for an employee who is already at market standard and at Manager position. Consider he rated top in a fiscal year with no promotion? Please consider 4 year average while answering if possible.

like
like

Hello Fishes ...
Please help me

I'm looking for a entry-level role in finance domain and I would appreciate your support.

Recent MBA-FINANCE graduate with a focus in Investment banking, Financial markets, Financial analysis and reporting

If anyone knows of a job opening where I would be a good fit, I'd appreciate if you could send them my way! Of course, if you have any suggestions for where to start my career, or anyone you'd recommend I speak to, I would be very grateful.

like

I’m honestly tired of being at an agency and not feeling as fulfilled as I used with strategy as a career. Have anyone here make a career change? if so, what other jobs out there - outside of agencies and client side - can you apply what you know as a strategist? Curious if anyone has done it and has some advice.

like

I’m a woman in my mid 20s and constantly face situations where people outside of cyber (still within the company) that I’m dealing with (older men in particular) who always push back against my cyber/technical recommendations even with managers cc’d. I studied, earned certs, and worked hard to get to where I am. Is it bc of my gender and age? In all honesty, I’ve written recommendations that male counterparts voiced in the past that had ZERO pushbacks.

like

Has anyone moved from HR consulting to Core HR Roles?, I wanted to take some career guidance from him/her

like

Things are apparently going to get better after a client will be leaving, I’ll get to work on different brands but I am feeling pretty burnt out from the agency I’m at. Will new clients help? Or should I look elsewhere. Been at the agency almost 3 years, I feel like I need to switch things up for my sanity.

like

Hello Fishes,

Need your input please

If i get lowballed package with good learning curve. Is it better idea to stick to it for next eight month and make another switch to recover the loss? Or should I search better job ? I have only 20 days left in notice

like

Fellow desi folks - how do you keep your h4 spouse occupied? We are going to be marrired in january and want to provide her as much support as possible. .

She said she wants to pursue MBA but supporting her tutuion fees is currently out of limits for me given im purchasing a family home in mumbai which is going to cost me 4.5cr.

How do i bring up this topic without sounding too negative that i cant support her tution fees but can cover all other expenses (living,transport,food,travel,education

like

What steps should I take to become a marketing manager in 4 years? I'm currently a coordinator but I'm very goal-oriented. Determined to achieve this!

like

What are the different software programs I will need to know if I want to work in advertising/graphic design? Also, is there a way to learn them for free or cheap?

like

Any suggestions about how to become a project manager or product owner from being software engineer, please?

like

Got industry offer at bank, cyber. Would be going from 110 to 130. Perks are comparable. I feel like it is on lower end of comp based on Glassdoor and elsewhere. Considering countering at 135-140.

like

Hi,can someone help me in this . What is going to be the in hand monthly salary after all deductions?Tia!!

Post Photo
like

What will be an approximate I hand for 12.93L Package. Where 1.1L is bonus

More Posts

At what investment size should you typically start using fee only financial advisors?

like

Tata Consultancy not giving anniversary hike new joners?

like

can someone refer me in accenture for role of manual/ automation tester.

YOE: 2.8 years
NP: 3months

thanks

like

I’m pretty torn on whether I want to take an offer for an internal role or not…
The job itself sounds pretty interesting. Lots of opportunity for growth (eventually will build out a team).

My only concern is the hiring manager. I talked to someone in my network who has worked with him in the past and she told me that she would 100% work with him again bc she learned a lot, but that he has a very dominant personality and that some ppl can butt heads with him.

like

Anyone from EXL.need some interview tips.Thanks in advance.

like

Best & affordable places for a weekend trip? I am located in upstate NY for reference so recs that are drive-able or flights wouldn’t be insane

like

Hi All,
Can anyone tell me what are the grades present in
Optum. And what grade should I be getting for 8.2 yrs experience and what is the standard salary range for that role.
Tech stack - React (4yrs relevant)

like

FDD or Restructuring and why? Have an offer for both and very very conflicted (MM FDD vs. mid tier RX)

like

Anyone here in EY USA and can point me to the maternity policy? I can only find Canadian or UK versions ok the policy site!

I recently passed the CFE and was looking into the CAMS next. Any suggestions on how to best prepare for the CAMS? I’ve been mostly reviewing the index cards that come with the prep material.

like

Any book recommendations for soft skills at an agency/studio? For stuff like giving feedback, meetings, presentations, client interaction, etc.

like

I am going through 4 interviews so far for a job. There will be more because I haven’t had one with a CD/ECD yet. I have been sending thank you note to interviewer as well as recruiter for ...

like

How has your comp changed with TS/SCI clearance? After jumping ship? Looking to see if the long term salary increase is worth the clearance.

like

Do Citius HR dont respond/ignore if not selected ?
Or does that mean i am on Hold?

like

I have heard lay off happens in CitiusTech, is anyone aware about this

like

Swedish Meatballs & Gravy with Pickled Cucumber Salad and Lingonberries

Post Photo
like

Hi Any positions for research, account management or power bi ?

like

Awkward question incoming! - What is the average salary for a mid-weight art director at an agency in the north of the UK? (Specifically keen to hear from anyone Leeds based!)

How is ey gds for Data visualization branch? Bangalore location?

like

If you’re hoping to find a housing deal, you’re out of luck in the short term.
Maybe if you can deal with the higher payments for the next 3 years and sell/refinance above today’s prices you’ll be ok, but this isn’t going to be pretty.

Post Photo
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Has anyone heard of IVY: The Social University? What is this?

Has anyone used gliders that stick on tyres of office chair, for better movement over the carpet?

like

How many of you have no plans and cringe whenever someone tells you happy holidays 😞?

likefunny

Bain & Company Which are the best consulting firms and practices for Climate Change & Sustainability, especially in the Canadian geography? Also, please suggest the best Canadian city for consulting jobs.

McKinsey & Company | Boston Consulting Group | Bain & Company | Kearney | LEK | EY | Oliver Wyman | PwC | Deloitte

#ClimateChange #Sustainability #Water #ESG

like
like

I have 26k Hertz points... Are these any good for anything? I'm never going to use the rentals....

I'm sort of over Pokemon Go, novelty has worn off. What am I missing that has everyone else hooked?

like

Heard frm a friend at pwc that in consulting they have per diems. Is it for all practitioners and practice? Seems tight on budget.

like

Best / Biggest Happy Hour City in the US?

like

Does EY really fine their employees for missing training deadlines?

like

Which firm (out of MBB and Big4) has the most difficult interview process? Curious really!

like

Anyone here taken a career break (6 months or more? How hard was it to get a job again? Did you have to explain why you took a break? Any other cons I should be aware of?

likehelpful

Can't stand people shaking their legs under the table. Geezzz.

like

Best & affordable places for a weekend trip? I am located in upstate NY for reference so recs that are drive-able or flights wouldn’t be insane

like

Day 1 here.. What topics are off limits? Client lists, billing rates... What else?

Any good books or recommendations on sales? Sales tactics trips and tricks?

like

How long does it usually take for Deloitte to get back to you after the first round for consultant position?

like

Best consulting firms without the massive ego?

like

Can anyone provide a referral to Accenture?

like

Anyone here ਪੰਜਾਬੀ?!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal