Let’s discuss “acting managers” that never get promoted because they can’t pass their CPA. Do you think at a certain point they should be pushed out?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Firm should enforce a mandatory unpaid 3 month leave for those who don’t get pass cpa after year 5. Return to employment contingent on passing rest of exams.

likefunny

This is clearly a challenge in our industry that seems to have become worse in recent years.

While it may solve a short term need, in the long run it is a problem to have career seniors. There are numerous downsides and negative impacts, that in my opinion, outweigh any benefits (maybe at the temp level I feel differently).

To succeed, any business (any profession) needs people who are driven and motivated. I understand there are dozens of reasons (excuses) why people cant pass the exam during their first 5 years. But I suggest in most cases the reason rests with the candidates skills, drive, passion, motivation, desire, etc.

Another issue is the inconsistency among firms and how strict they are with the "need to be a CPA to be a manager" policy. A few firms require it to be a senior (or offices within a large firm get stricter like that) while other firms/offices allow people to be managers without it. Very frustrating, especially because this inconsistency even happens among the Big4.

We all need to find a way to better hold staff accountable for making the exam a priority (and staff need to look in the mirror and find a way to be self starters). If you're a staff or senior and have not yet passed (or even taken) the exam, let this be a catalyst and wake up call. Whether you plan to stay in PA or move on, getting your CPA is highly valuable and you just need to set your mind to it. It only gets harder as time passes.

Just do it! Good luck!

likehelpful

If they are really good at their job why would they? You get a good “manager” at the billable rate of a senior and you get to pay them less also. But if they are average or below then send them packing.

like

With the shortage of both managers and seniors in public, no

like

^Preach P1!! It is truly a test of commitment. My friend who took the bar and passed it the first time gave me the best advice - for the three months before the exam, don't plan anything on your schedule except studying. Put your friends and family on alert that except for holidays, you are going to be studying. I certainly over studied for the exam, but it was once and done and out of the way. It's a sacrifice, but if you put in the time, you'll do it.

like

My only issue with acting managers is that they are often scheduled as the senior on the job, based on their title. If they’re the senior on the job.... either a lot gets pushed onto the other staff/seniors that wouldn’t be if the acting manager were “acting” the level that they were scheduled as, or the acting manager ends up actually being the senior on the job and has had to be a senior for many more years than the senior role is supposed to last, which results in extreme burnout. Seems like a no-win situation to me. If they are scheduled as the manager on the job and the engagement is staffed appropriately for that, then great, but at that point I see a lot of resentment toward the firm start to build because they are the manager on the job but not being paid at that level or given the title.

like

OP that’s on them though. If they don’t buckle down and pass the exams like everyone else they’re going to have to deal with people getting promoted above them. Most firms will let you take sabbatical and all of the big four have good PTO policies. Let’s not forget the free Becker. There are too many tools at their disposal for them to not be able to obtain a license if they truly want to.

like

@ey1 yeah and their bills could be paid by the bill pay fairy! 🧚‍♀️

likefunny

Partner 1 always coming through with the insight!

like

I’ve tried and tried, failed multiple times. It’s hard. I understand what everyone is saying but I’m a hard worker and good at my job, just bad at test taking. I plan on getting back into it but honestly I just feel so disappointed in myself

like

D1, keep trying! And try harder. I believe in you!

like

Big 4 is way too lax on cpa licensing requirements. Law firms require you to pass the bar before starting work. Banks require you to pass series exams within months of starting. Several jobs require you to get licensed prior to working: nurses, physicians, dentists, pilots, real estate agents, esthetician, etc.

If you can’t pass the cpa exam in 5 years, you should consider moving to industry. Or you save all your pto days (25 at Deloitte), which is 5 weeks, take an additional 7 weeks of unpaid leave, which is three full months of studying. Plenty of college kids with no work ethic pass it in summer before they start. You are a hardened big 4 veteran, who has cranked out 80-90 hour weeks, passing all 4 in 3 months should be a breeze.

like

So I guess what I’m saying is yes they should be pushed out, I don’t think it’s really a good situation for anyone involved

likesmart

Presumably at that level your technical skills are solid. That said, why wouldn’t you strive to get your CPA? After ~5 years in PA, one would think you could knock out the exam. I also feel that if you don’t have your certification while others do at the same level, you’re surely looked down upon

like

Look. Selling work is not for everyone. Managing revenue is not for everyone. Climbing that ladder isn’t everyone’s dream. What is wrong with being happy with where you are at? I enjoy my job. I enjoy being able to avoid all the weird political shit that drains hours from the week and years from our lives. I enjoy having some autonomy over my day to day while not being responsible for signing shit. My refusal to become a manager opens up another spot for someone else, so what does it really matter?

like

I think that there would be a lot of resentment from them as people who worked below them get promoted above them.

like

D1: I’m in the same boat.

Unfortunately, I’m in the boat of everyone this post is about. I think what sets me apart of everyone else are my “excuses” as to why I haven’t finished. When I first started (5 years ago) I passed 2 (FAR bad AUD) and was working towards the 3rd then my mother passed away. I could hardly live life losing a mother when I was 24yo, let along live, plan my mother’s funeral, arrange my mother’s affairs, work at a Big 4 and study for CPA... so I unfortunately took a break from CPA. A long break that ruined my study habits when I was ready to hit the ground running. I took a Month break as an S1 from work to study but suckeddddd at it (I had been out of the routine for too long). Ever since S2 I have been the Lead Senior on a large integrated audit, which as P1 indicated has only made it harder. Additionally, all of my engagement reviews have been excellent in the past few years and I have maxed out encores every year - which further shows that I do not work 40 hour weeks and even during PTO I am most times not completely removed from work.

So OP to answer your question, I personally, from experience, believe that we 5th years should not be kicked out... not yet at least. I have every intention to pass because not getting promoting and recently finding out that someone in a class below mine (who has not had the same work challenges) was promoted in my spot are both simply because of an exam and are both horrible nightmares.

like

There is literally no excuse not to pass in 5 years. I completely agree that big 4 is too lax on CPA passing requirements. I took all 4 in two testing windows/four months in my last semester of college. Literally studied every waking hour, while I ate dinner, while shitting on the toilet, till 1-2am, and every weekend, etc. Still had to go to class, do homework and study for exams for the classes I was taking. There is a reason credits for exams you’ve passed expires in 18 months. It’s because you’re not supposed to take longer than that!

like

KPMG 2 totally agree, except then they make actual seniors life miserable.

Point would be to scare them straight to finish it before year 5. Financial consequences = results

Related Posts

Hi Guys, I have 15 years of experience in IT..the experience is in different domains including project management.Now i am getting offer for both project management and technical roles.I am confused, should I go for PM role or technical role as an cloud architect.

like

I really like finance, but I want to be a sole proprietor. Any ideas of what I can do besides making my own hedge book?

likeuplifting

Currently looking, and I’ve had a few recruiters/shops reach out to me, but they’re all looking to fill Sr.AD roles. Problem is, I’m trying to move up to ACD. Do I change my title to ACD on LinkedIn?

like

I can’t get out. I’m a barred attorney looking to move into a JD preferred role. I don’t like being at a firm. I’ve applied to hundreds (literally) of contract, compliance, regulatory, etc. sort of jobs. I’m not looking for a crazy salary either. I don’t know what I’m doing wrong. How do I make the switch? Any advice is appreciated. Thanks

like

Do you think consulting is not the right path for core technical people ?

like

Has anyone ever thought of switching out of accounting and pursuing another career? If so, which career? Did you pursue it or stay in accounting?

like

Can anyone working for DT’s ARA or PwC’s CMAAS tell me what does their job specifically include, hours and exit opportunities?

like
like

Like this if you hate tax and feel stuck right now with the pandemic so I know I'm not alone 😭😭😭 I wanna be a consultant so bad.. also if you have any recommendations or advice please go ahead

like

Can't really share this with anyone else, so thank you fellow fish for indulging. 3 years in, finally at a point where I can comfortably work 40 hours a week the last quarter+, and still be a trusted team member and major contributor. Normal tasks and collaborations now take me a fraction of the time compared to my first couple years / others on the team. 6 YOE and my TC has also gone up a lot from low 200s last year to high 200s this year. Hope to keep this optimal mix of WLB & progression 🙏

like

Hi
I have one year experience in AWS python
development.now i Switched to nokia here i am working in 5g technology automation testing.

I am under training now, will i have a good career in Nokia or should I switch to development? please help

Anyone know how Slalom's exit ops are for the D&A practice? Not super interested in leaving rn, but I'm curious how the firm is viewed by tech companies and the like

like

Hi, I’m a tax professional but want to transition into a coding role such as bot coder and artificial intelligence. I’m really advanced with Excel and Alteryx, I even can create macros for my team and considered the technology rockstar. Do you recommend any certifications such as UIpath for my future career change? I’d also be interested in how to work for Google someday coding artificial intelligence and machine learning.

like

I’m a wealth management associate and Considering a move from wire house-brokerage to RIA. Have you made the switch? Good/Bad experiences welcome.

like

My dream job just landed in my inbox. What did you want to be when you grew up?

Post Photo
likeuplifting

What’s the shortest amount of time it’s respectable to be in a job before leaving?

like

I’m an L6 SDM at Amazon but a Meta recruiter sent me an M2 sdm job description. I have all the XP I need from previous job experience but does Meta keep your same level as Amazon? Meaning if I am an L6 at Amazon am I automatically interviewing at M1 or can I jump to an M2?Amazon Facebook (Meta)

like

What are some feasible exits to the investment industry? PE seems to be too hard. Currently at Strategy& Deals Strategy and will leave at the 3YOE mark

like

Does anyone has completed Servicenow ITSM certification recently?

like

Trying to get into stand up comedy, any advice? Not sure where to start but am really serious about giving it a shot

like

More Posts

Those who moved from MBB to Strategy& , why did you do it? Pros and cons?

like

I have been given P30 but it was no where in my offer letter, I was under an assumption that I will be going as a Manager but this is not a Manager role, I am having 10+ years of experience

like

Got an offer from Bain for Project Leader. Will it be worth leaving Gartner and joining Bain

like

Anyone joining genpact in november last week or december first week.

like

Who all started hating Globant India…. Because of stupid..idiotic studio culture

For new joiners…. You have to slog in project….but in appraisal only a**licking of studio leadrs is considered…
Share your experiences.

P.S. left globant 3 months back only because of this reason
P.S.S. New joiners if you mind your own business… you are not good at chamchagiri… avoid globant please

Hi fishes, how is the increment percentage when compared to erstwhile Altran....? Is it better or worse

like

Hi fishes, With a close to 3 years experience in Tata Consultancy Services (tech stack : java j2ee). At max how much CTC can I expect (as fixed) after switching to a service based company ?

like

Needs some ideas for scenario planning optimizations! Currently have a model to predict conversions given media spend, I can adjust spend up and down to create different budget scenarios and send to model to get respective conversions. Thoughts?

like

Is anyone planning on trading water futures?

funnylike

MBA1s: Tell the recruiting market is bad without telling the recruiting market is bad.

Now go!

like

Dear Sharks,

I want to shift my career to UI/UX designer as an entry level designer. I have good hands-on experience. I work on Figma.

I have an experience of 2 years. Need help with referral for the same.

Thanks and Regards!

uplifting

I put a deposit down on a Rolex for my wife last November with my local dealer. Nice guy and no reason to doubt it as I underwent here were a lot of delays with Rolex. He initially said they’d expect it in 3-4 months and has since said they’re working to fulfill all orders by end of June. Is this ridiculous or sound about right?

like

For 12 Lpa in Barclays how much will be the in-hand. And why are Barclays taking so much of time to issue offer letter?Barclays

Anyone joining Citi on 5th dec at Pune location?

like

After 3 years in TCS, I'm looking for a job switch. It would be highly appreciated if anyone can provide me with a referral to HCL.

Profile: Data Scientist/ML(Computer Vision, NLP)

Relevant YOE: 2

Hello fishes 🐟 Capgemini is hiring for Below postion, If you need a referral

DM ME 💯✉️✅

Post Photo
like

Anybody joined wipro recently??
I have my onboarding this Monday on 1st August. How much time did it take for you to get the laptop??

And what type of joining kit you got ??

like

What is the best advice you would give to a junior account manager?

like

Hello, I am in USI GES tax at DUSI. I love my job but not my team and mgmt anymore. I'm a performer and I'm dumped with work of 2 ppl while others are searching for work. I am burned out.

I resigned and accepted a job with EY GDS with a huge pay bump that DUSI can't match but I also gave up my potential promotion for 2023.

I've been feeling bad about putting my papers down and letting go off my promotion but I am really tired. I took up this job as an escape.

Did i do the right thing?

like

🐠 Fam - What’s a good whiteboard solution for my home office? What do you use and from where do I get it? Thanks!

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

New auditor here, I see most auditors get booked for 10- 12 hours on engagements during busy season. But heard everyone’s working 65 hours to 100 hours a week during that time. Does that mean almost everyone is eating their hours in big four and midsize firms ? If you’re assigned for 12 hours daily, Monday to Friday, but actually working 15 hours and weekends, do you book 12 hours Monday to Friday ? Or the actual hours you worked including weekends ?

like

What is EY’s reputation like in Charlotte and the Carolinas region? I hear they had layoffs around a year ago. Is all of this sorted out?

like

Anyone else feel like their eyes are dry when they drink 5hour energy?

like

Hoping for help w/ studying. TRANSACTION CYCLES?? I see inconsistent lists online and in books: (Revenue, Purchasing, Inventory, Payroll) vs (Sales, Purchasing, Payroll, Financing) vs....

like

When finishing your work means absolutely nothing cause you gotta help out someone that has been slacking !!

like

So finally i found a sweet girl. She was my uber driver from airport. I felt a sudden "💙2💘" connection the first time we had an eye contact. Is it just me after busy season or what?#trollswelcome2💩

like

Don't be fooled. Recruiters never have your best interest in mind. Find your own dream job.

like

has anyone had any luck leveraging an offer from another Big 4 to have your current firm match/transfer the new offer? specifically switching service lines

like

If you asked to be considered for early promotion and didn’t get it (despite being highly rated, exceeding billable goal, etc) would you look elsewhere? Is it right to be angry about it? I don’t want to spin myself up unnecessarily if it’s unjustified

like

Prometric closed until 4/30

Post Photo
like

I wonder if we’ll still have minimum billable hours if WWIII breaks out

likefunny

What should I know/how to be prepared for FSO senior interview with EY?

like

is it hard switching from EY FSO Audit to Core?

like

Highest number of billable hours you have seen in a year?

like

Does anyone here work normal hours with rarely overtime and make 90k-100k range?

like

looking to apply for a Senior Consultant position at EY Canada Climate Change team and hoping to get a referral. Can someone from EY help with this? Much appreciated!!

like

I have FAR and REG left for CPA. Not sure I really want to stay in Big 4. Want to move to Corporate Finance, FPA, or IB. Thinking of just pausing CPA and studying for GMAT. Never given time to study f

like

What examples of passive aggressive behavior have you seen on this job?

like

Best accounting humor instagram accounts to follow?

likehelpful

I’m 4 rounds into the interview process for an Assistant Controller position in SoCal.

For the next round, I’ll be meeting with the Controller, Accounting Manager, and 5 other junior accounting staff.

I’ll have 30 minutes to explain a month-end close task (of my choice) to the accounting team.

Also, I’ll have to analyze a random reconciliation and explain improvements that can be made.

I’m just a 2nd year manager, so I’m getting so nervous, and any insight or tips would be appreciated!

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal