When settling with a title company plaintiff on a subrogation claim, have any foreclosure defense counsel received settlements over and above policy limits? What is your typical settlement range? How has settling on your subrogation claim negatively affected your counterclaims against the mortgage lender if at all?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Real estate transactional lawyer here, so I’ll be of no help.

But I’m intellectually curious and want to understand the scenario.

Tell me where I botch this:

You are representing a client in a foreclosure matter (I’m assuming that based on you requesting opinions of foreclosure defense attorneys).

In connection with that foreclosure defense, a title company that is suing your client based on some claim it’s insured claims to have under a purchase agreement, a note and mortgage, or other security interest (based on title company being the plaintiff in the matter and the idea that the title company’s claim is a derivative of its insured’s claim, and thus that insured is a 3rd party in a contractual relationship with your client (this the subrogation rights reference), although I suppose there could be rights under an easement or some other instrument of record.

My disconnect is why your client who is facing foreclosure being sued by the title company would be settling the claim in a manner that would entitle your client to payment. I know I’m missing a key part here - but I’m not sure what that part is.

Finally, I’m not sure why a title company would be motivated to settle in an amount in excess of the policy amount. I suppose if they had exposure under both loan and owners policies, they may be willing to pay out up to their cumulative exposure, which would likely exceed the owner’s policy limit.

More facts might help others, but I’d like them just to understand the issue b

Thank you for your reply! Yes, it’s a bit interesting...I represent a surviving spouse...deceased spouse took out a mortgage on the primary residence without the knowledge of the surviving spouse. It appears that the funds from that mortgage may have been used to payoff a second loan that was on the home prior to. The title company attorney contacted me about settling prior to joining the action as a plaintiff and amending the complaint to add an additional claim for equitable subrogation, as I’m presuming the mortgagee made a claim under the lenders policy for the amount of the loans paid off using their funds.

Related Posts

Max out 401k before contributing to taxable brokerage? Roth IRA is already maxed out.

like

Hey folks I applied for a credit card they were asking for official mailid is it legal to provide bank mailid for credit card processing?

like

Hello fishes, please suggest me some tax saving methods as iam getting around 10k got deducted in tax.thanks in advance.

I thought the answer is yes but now double checking. Can we write off the interest we pay on our primary residence mortgage?

like

Solana 😭😭😭

I don't own any and it hurts.

Curious in seeing what people's avg cost basis is in this, when you purchased, and why?

like

How did you get started with your personal investing in stocks? I am 26, F, have some money in savings, 401k, stocks and just started my own business albeit small. I’m extremely interested in real estate investing have been reading and listening to podcasts. Any advice?

like

Anyone from Montreal QC area? Looking to connect with a new real estate banner

Experienced folks pls share your views. I am planning to buy a 3bhk. All tower corners (4 sides) have 3bhk options available and I might get to choose inventory in any tower and on any floor. Point to note: North has City view, South has Hill view, W has Forest view & E has city view. If you were gonna buy a flat in this site what all things you would think and then make a decision. First time buying flat.

Post Photo
like

Does anyone else think we should start investing in more light rail systems to cover some of the distribution problems we're having? I think it might be a good idea. Anyone have any thoughts about this?

like

New investor here. Don’t have too much money to invest because I have my first child on the way. I only have a 401(k) as of now. What would everyone suggest?

like
like

Im so happy! I just paid off all my debts!

like

Welcome to The Financial Life! I am excited to meet a variety of individuals, families and businesses to talk MOnEY! As you know, growing money is one thing but keeping it is a whole different game!

likeuplifting

Does anyone use quickbooks to calculate their annual P&Ls and other tax stuff? Do you find it’s better than just an excel template?Any other programs people like?

like

What would you say is the minimum amount of money that your household would have to make before considering to have two babies?

like

How do filmmakers find investors?

like

What is everyone’s top 1 or 2 favorite books on personal finance? I’m always looking for a new one to bring into the fold of what I’m doing

like

Anyone working towards early retirement? Whats your target $, age and location?

likehelpful

Is anyone an AIF? Is it a pain? Is it worth it?

like

So interest rates are really going down?

like

More Posts

What are Key questions asked for Program manager role at Amazon by HR?

like

Anyone got approval for first time H1 application?

Im so happy! I just paid off all my debts!

like

What would be my in hand after tax deductions?

Post Photo
like
like

Do you see substantial gaps between internal auditing outcomes on one side, and expectations of stakeholders on another side?

like

Thoughts on homage watches?

like

Does anyone in the UK use Haye Grades and know the salary range for a grade 20?

like

What’s the salary range for Manager role with 14 YOE .NET in PwC AC Bangalore?

like

I am a lawyer (based in the UK) and have been practising for 15+ years (financial services/banking). I love being a lawyer but I would also love to do something more creative or more independent. Has anyone moved from law into another role or has anyone done something more creative alongside their full time legal career? I’m feeling a bit stuck!

like

Crowe is looking for SALT professionals at all levels. If you are looking to make a move in your career, feel free to send me a DM and we can discuss details.

like

Does anyone else have “email social anxiety”? Not with writing emails that have to do with content/work I did, but when I’m “just checking in” and doing vaguely unsaid social things I’ve never understood well.
I feel super awkward and read too into things, it takes me 30+ min for a simple friendly email to a manager or above and I get worked up about it.

like

Does Zoom have an employee referral program? If yes, can someone refer me to an open position? Please reach out if so. Zoom

like

Republican or Democrat... I think we can all agree with this 👇

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Am I the only one left at the end of the month trying to bill 10hour days to meet hours because I slacked off at the beginning of the month? It’s a vicious cycle. Then the end of the month hits and I’m so exhausted that I need to take it was the next week... and the cycle continues

like

will cognizant blacklist me if i didn't join. my joining date in cognizant is 24th april and thinking of emailing my decision today.

like

How much medical insurance is provided by Tech Mahindra?

Hi fishes,
Can anyone let me know how is work life balance in NATWEST company.what all other perks include in this company

like

How long can you go without having anything to do before you get laid off?

like
like

Additional Posts in Real Estate - Law

Are paralegals supposed to be the ones handling title/survey/zoning?

like

Looking for a bit of insight on how commission or bonus is structured on flat rate residential real estate at Canadian law firms. I was offered a good base salary and I was asked what type of structure I was looking for. I am uncertain as to what is considered standard or what to look for in terms of bonus/commission structure. Any insight is appreciated!

like

Any defenses to put in an answer regarding violation of the IL Residential Real Property Disclosure Act.? Buyer is suing client pro se after discovering mold in the property from a tenant after taking possession. Seller didn’t know but there was a leak issue in the past. Other advice is appreciated.

like

How many different matters do you think you can competently work on before getting overwhelmed?

like

Are any firms hiring remote real estate associates right now? Mid level if that matters.

likehelpful

Anyone work at Apple in LA in the real estate department that would be willing to connect with me?

like

In CA, if a tenant dies, who paid 1 year of rent upfront BUT there was no rental agreement, does the landlord still have the right to keep the rent or can the executor of the estate claim it back? Thanks!

like

Conflicts checks question: thinking about making a move from small(ish) firm to a larger one. How detailed will a conflicts list need to be? Haven’t switched jobs since law school, so at a little bit of a loss about the whole process!

like

Title company just gave me a commitment with 72 B2 exceptions and the first one (after standard) is an unrecorded lease from 1862. Send help.

likefunny

Pro forma or proforma?

like

Any advice on shifting from association law to commercial real estate in FL?

I've been applying to jobs for months but every position wants at least 2yrs of experience in real estate transactions, usually way more. I'm at 1yr+ doing HOA/condo work but have had no opportunity to do real estate transactions like I expected. Seems like the only way to get the experience is to have nailed a big law gig right out of school and get put into that practice.

Do you review the other side’s escrow instructions and provide comments? 4 years in and I’ve never done this. Working for a new partner and she insists on doing so “in case there are competing instructions” but isn’t that the entire point of funding through an escrow agent/title company?

like

Feeling better about myself after reading a 20 year old correction deed to insert "grants to" that had been left out of a quitclaim deed. And I thought *I* was moving too fast and missing stuff 😂

likefunny

Any good books to help get you up to speed on real estate finance matters?

like

If a lien was placed in one persons name on a property held in joint tenancy with survivorship and the party who’s name was on the lien (one of the joint tenants) dies what is the status of the lien?

Question for anyone who may be able to answer.

We are looking to file something like an injunction injunction to stop a property sale. The property is owned by a sister and brother. Brother is deceased so it passed down to his children. The heirs bad no idea the aunt is trying to sell. Can we file some type of injunction?

like

Pro se plaintiff, an attorney, filed a complaint alleging mold defects after closing on a property. Client, layperson, may have agreed orally to a settlement amount without proof of damages prior to filing appearance and obtaining an attorney. Client filed appearance pro se, then plaintiff sent over a draft settlement agreement few weeks later which client didn’t sign. Client then got an attorney, filed answer, etc. Can this oral agreement be voided for coercion, indefinite mat’l term, etc?

like

Has anyone ever heard of this type of real estate private equity fund structure:

-One LLC, so only one PPM
-Multiple investors that can be onboarded anytime
-Multiple investments that investors can determine whether or not they want to invest in
-One K-1 per investor based on their investments and income
-Ability for the Sponsor/Fund to invest directly, indirectly and in equity, debt, Pref, etc.
To me this seems extremely cumbersome and would require multiple classes of (cont’d)

To add tables of contents to long agreements or not?

like

Any real estate attorneys interested in exploring new opportunities?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal