Can a future employer ask for your current pay stub? HR wants my current salary but it's low since I just moved from industry. Just want to get paid market rate!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Objection: “I really need a number to move the process forward.”

What you should think: “You’re lying to me to attempt to get me to compromise my negotiating position.”

What you should say: “I’m more concerned at the moment with talking to you about discovering whether we’re a mutual fit.  If we’re a great fit, then I can be flexible on the numbers with you and you can be flexible on the numbers with me.  If we’re not a great fit, then the numbers are ultimately irrelevant, because your company only hires A players and I only work at roles I would be an A player at.”

like

Illegal in Massachusetts. Interviewers can no longer ask for past salaries.

like

Tell them you want to see the anonymized pay subs of others in your proposed role.

like

I had it done when coming here. - ny - 2 years ago

like

Your salary history is none of their business. Just tell them your target range.

like

Whatever you do don't lie. Your future employer can easily find out what you were making with one phone call. A friend of mine had an offer rescinded from another big 4 because he lied about his base to get a higher offer. Firm made the offer, he accepted and left his old firm to travel. A week before his starting date he gets a call from HR asking him to explain the difference between what he put down as his salary and his actual salary that they had found out. Hiring Lerner ended up rescinding the offer.

like

Hide. They can ask, but you can keep avoiding and ask them to anchor the number.

like

Deloitte federal asked for my pay stub before...bc i didn't want them to contact my current employer

like

BAH1 - no, probably not, but it would be a good way to say no to their request. "I'm happy to share that information on a reciprocal basis. Would you be able to share...?" "No? In that case, I'm happy to share my desired salary and proposed role and would gladly respond to your perspective as well."

like

I've actually seen someone tell the potential employer that he cannot divulge his salary information / package because it is considered proprietary by the firm he was leaving. Didn't go over well initially but they liked him enough to make him an offer and then verify afterwards.

like

He just didn't want to give them anything until he had an offer in hand. Once he had it it didn't care, he was jumping ship.

like

They can ask and say its policy but you can decline. They can ask how much you make at your previous job (which is iffy in itself) and they can ask what you wanna make but asking for a pay stub that's junior league. I hope someone can help ya with that.

That's DC btw

@ow1 great retort but no hr rep would ever show that -- would they?

Hiring partner*

Del2 r u federal? Del federal tried make my offer based on my current salary

Haha man I would love to say that OW1, but recruiters are so sensitive and will think you're being combative

"...Or did you forget you were interviewing a benchmarking expert?"

I had to for Deloitte, but they still met my requested number.

Nope Acc2. Commercial. But my friend was recruiting for another big4 when this happened to him. He was commercial too

Related Posts

How much salary does jp pay to promoted associates in India? Which are not in tech

like

What's the salary range for AVP IN CITI with 12 YOE?

Any idea what directors earn in big 4?

like

Any info on Fractal Software salaries?? They are hiring for a Research Investment role, and I can’t seem to find anything on compensation.

like

Why is education deemed more valuable on a pay scale than experience? Employers will pay someone with a degree and no experience a greater salary, than someone who has exhibited the experience. Understanding that the degreed person committed to school and finished, yet that doesn't diminish what the not degreed has committed to and accomplished in their careers. This has to stop!

likefunny

Pay for teachers in Arizona is so awful 😭. I always wanted to teach in my local community but frankly I can't afford it. I want to move to another state where comp is better but I'm not positive where. What do you make & where are you located? For context I'm a 3rd year 2nd grade teacher.

like

Is it worth leaving Deloitte for LEK? I currently have 1 year exp mostly in strategy projects and honestly the experience hasn’t been too bad. Not sure if I want to start over from the bottom but they’re offering 15k more. End goal is M7 mba. Is it worth the extra year?

like

Should I leave my first permanent job as a team leader of 4 DPs in a FMCG business (only been there for 4 months) to join a huge Tech business for a 12months contract?

They offer me 60% more money than my permanent role. Circa 2000 dollars every month in my pocket

However, I am worried if I accept the tech role and I do not become permanent I will be looking again for a job in 12-24 months and my CV won't be showing a managerial position. Won't be showing any progress.

like

Any thoughts on salary/pacakage for a Solutions Architect position in London vs Amsterdam? As the cost of living in Amsterdam is around 10-12% cheaper, would it have an impact on salary?

like

Do partners know each other’s compensation? I see partners selling engagements for vastly different numbers b/w shorter ‘interesting’ strategy work and longer ‘boring’ transformations. Thoughts?

like

Thoughts on lifestyle / culture / exit ops at Bain Cap? Does anyone know the comp?

like

I got an offer from IBM earlier they didn't discuss the salary and directly sent the offer letter, now I have another offer which is 1.3 lacs more than the IBM's offer. Will IBM counter that offer and provide matching or slightly more than what I received from the other firm?

like

Hi folks,
I am working as a Business Analyst with 3.5 YOE and in total 4.9 YOE. I am getting 6.7CTC which felt totally low. If I switch then how much I can expect as a market standard currently. Thanks

like

I just got a call from a Partner in a competing a competing firm. They are interested in my skill set. I like my current firm, but am intrigued by the call from the competition. Do I have a conversation and try to get an offer or stay loyal and enjoy my current role and team? I would like more $$, but I know $$ isn’t everything!

How is trust & safety team at Swiggy? What is the average pay for Sr Manager position - 6 YOE with full time MBA.
Swiggy

like

What were your bonuses this year?

What is the salary slab for a CA as Senior Associate/ Manager in Forensic Investigation profile in KPMG/Deloitte/EY?

like

The new compensation is up on Workday. For AC Bangalore

like

Which big pharma or biotech companies offer high pay for bioinformatics scientist (masters level) with 3 YOE?

like

Can anyone refer me For UI React Developer Role?
Tech Stack - HTML CSS JavaScript React Redux Node Express MongoDB
Exp - 2.8
CTC - 11

like

More Posts

Would you marry someone that’s unemployed or doesn’t want to work? What’s the minimum salary you can accept from your SO ?

like
like

Best and worst cars you’ve ever owned?

What is the probation period in Deloitte USI for lateral hire?

like

Any advice on how to prep for Boston Consulting Group interviews for consultant roles? What questions do they ask? Any concepts they prefer discussing?

like

does bosch provide allowance for chair? table? Internet bill?

like

Any ideas on planning a quarterly retreat for a startup? Specifically for strategy day and culture. Never planned a quarterly retreat before and is not to sure what it entails. I’ve been told agendas for retreats are very subjective to company but would like some general ideas if anyone has any!

like

I am generally uncomfortable when I’m around my mother-in-law’s husband.

While he is overall a decent guy, his anger issues, yelling at his wife for the slightest issue, and insulting nature makes me uncomfortable and triggers my own anger due to his blatant disrespect for just about everyone around him.

My mother-in-law says he’s worked on things, but it’s been 10 years of this and I’m not sure I want such behavior around my wife and our kids since we’re trying to conceive soon (cont).

like

It's hip to be square

like

Is it just me or do 90% of the jobs being laid off by big tech sound made up? Many job descriptions with multiple bullet points that all kinda revolve around the same idea. One of my buddies works for a big IT company and literally just sits on meetings all day. No one really contributing to anything other than agreeing to whatever the speaker is saying. Are these kind of jobs finally being exposed? Six figure employees getting paid to sit and bounce ideas off each other?

like

Spending 48 hours in Belgium this summer. Do you recommend Brussels or Antwerp?

Is anybody here a notary? And how much are you making from that? Is it a potential side-hustle?

like

Hey everyone. I am in desperate need of reorg data access for a project deliverable.

Wondering if anybody has a company subscription and is willing to help a girl out. I am willing to pay $$ for a username&password so I can export 1 or 2 data sets.

Any good gyms in the West Village/Soho area (excluding Equinox)

like

Has anyone used any softwares that make it easier to walkthrough a Google slides template or PowerPoint in away that makes it easy to hit the commonly changed items? I have customers monthly that need the same intro presentation and have a templates deck but it’s annoyingly time consuming to go through every section each time to make sure I don’t miss anything

like

When people ask me what my weekend plans are...

(425): So what are you going to be for halloween?
(503): A woman sitting on her couch watching Hocus Pocus.

like

Is FAAS under assurance or advisory under EY. What the difference between FAAS and Start&Transactions. New at the firm so trying to learn the differences

like

One of my coworkers thinks she deserves more PTO than it is allowed in our agency because she's "struggling". We all struggle with our own battles but she's being very rude about it. How can we handle this?

like

Anybody know of any art director positions open?

Can anyone suggest good pgs near office areas? (Hyd)

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

One of my lead partners is super nice to in front of others but then really mean to me when we meet 1x1. How to deal with this?

like

Hello,

Currently, in accenture. I have had very bad billable hours and not much achievement this fiscal year. I am worried of getting fired, so i applied for another job. Got offered may be 5% above my current pay with 5k bonus, but in lower level at Deloitte. I think working lower level will give me more opportunities to learn as i think i have lot to learn. I made decision based on my gut and accepted the offer. I have not talked to anyone on accenture side yet. What you think?

likesmart

I've started my own creative business on the side. One of my services includes marketing/comms, which is technically what I do for work. Would advertising my business on LinkedIn, where I have lots of colleagues connected, cause any issues? I.e. can I get in trouble for having this side hustle business and offering one similar service?

like

How do I become less addicted to my phone while working?

like

Considering the FRM certification. Those who’ve taken it, how quant heavy is it? I have a compliance risk background and don’t have a deep math or statistics background. However, I want to expand my skillset. Any thoughts?

like

Just fired my therapist. Feels better than it should

like

Want to warn stakeholders that their hostile, posturing emails with our main client CC'd is only going to backfire (main client ❤️ us). emails will no joke prob get some of them fired. #restructuring

like

Who has to work today? Which company should we cancel?

likefunny

I do believe EY is d kindest when it comes to putting people first.Thank U Kelly.Resume travel based on CDC & facts, no layoffs in foreseeable future, extending trust when wfh& personal accountability

like
like

Just went under contract on a place and need renovations. What steps can I take to accelerate the renovation prior to closing?

likefunny

Got a random email from a supposed Amazon recruiter for a SDE position (which is not at all a fit). The email is amazon.com domain and there are no red flags in the body but it doesn't feel like an Amazon recruiter due to the tacky signature, etc. Has anyone seen this kind of cold-calling from FAANG recruiter?

like

Resume writing tip: how to make “conducted client workshops to communicate and gain agreement on recommendations” sound more impactful?

likesmart

Best & affordable places for a weekend trip? I am located in upstate NY for reference so recs that are drive-able or flights wouldn’t be insane

like

Male fishes - looking for skin care recommendation. What has worked for you?

like

Any idea why EY is not on the list of Vault 50 top consulting firms but it is on the prestigious list?

like

Has anyone moved states and changed their home office / region? (Personal choice not project driven)....If so, what's the process? What approvals are needed?

like

How long does it usually take for Deloitte to get back to you after the first round for consultant position?

like

Too harsh as my farewell message? 🥳

Post Photo
likefunny

Does anyone have the Bain cases pdf from HackingTheCaseInterview website? I have first rounds on Tuesday and I want more cases to practice. The preview of those ^ ones looks really good! TIA!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal