I had a strange call with a recruiter. It was a screening call about a role but also to keep me on file for similar roles. Was a generic chat about why I'm looking etc. He then asked about my current salary, I said my expectations would depend on the role/bonus/equity etc. But he wasn't having it, kept pushing, so I gave my desired salary range. But, he wanted to know my CURRENT salary & when I wouldn't disclose it, he said don't think we can work together if you're hiding info. Is this normal?

likesmarthelpfuluplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Probably not a recruiter trying to hire you, they are interested in how much people earn in different roles and companies, to build a database.

likesmarthelpfulfunny

Probably just a recon call. Shadier recruiters that don’t want to pay for actual data aggregated by companies will sometimes cold call to get a pulse on what competitors are paying their staff.

Either as a way to target snipe talent or just figure out what they need to budget for similar roles. Not the most ethical route but it does happen.

As a note: Don’t be stupid. Don’t reveal what you’re making now to any recruiter. It’s irrelevant and puts you on the back foot in negotiations. All that matters is the range you’re seeking and what their budget is.

likesmarthelpful

Would you guys recruiter cost WhatsApp because I've never seen anybody use WhatsApp

Recent IconRecent

I think that its not legal to ask you about your current salary, so its not normal, but is good to know that kind of company that it is.

I’ve noticed since the tech layoff in 2024 recruiters sometime have like productivity calls since no one is really hiring and they need to show that’s some type of work is being done so they call and tell you about all possibilities but no true vacancy or proposition in all actuality. I always start with: do you actually have a vacant position and a working relationship with the hiring manager within the past two weeks and I need a Yes for both answers before the conversation can continue.

You can always tell them your expected salary as your current salary .so-they know you will go no lower than that .

There are actually laws against this practice in many states. https://www.findlaw.com/legalblogs/law-and-life/can-employers-legally-ask-about-your-current-or-previous-salary-2/

In India it is mandatory.

It is illegal here.

Sounds like the recruiter is desperate to keep their job because they suck and don’t want to improve their performance.

I had a similar situation but instead of salary, they tried to sell how high their expectations were (to discourage my application imho) and when I told them that my minimum expectations at the current place was much higher and I was achieving my metrics, they told me they didn’t believe me and told to me reapply if I wanted another interview.

It was weird and I didn’t reapply. Got to watch yourself out here. Lot of scammers at legitimate companies.

Reframe it... it's anti-DEI because DEI stands for exclusion, not inclusion, if it was really about events, planning and growth then fine frame it that way instead but yes, DEI, would be a red flag no matter what people tell you

Sir,
Reframe it... it's anti-DEI because DEI stands for exclusion, not inclusion, if it was really about events, planning and growth then fine frame it that way instead but yes, DEI, would be a red flag no matter what people tell you

I be more restrictive those days. If they call from India with their strong Indian accent I thank them and tell them I don’t work with Recruiters from India. If a US Recruiter outsourced their jobs it is a red flag for me.

They 100% require one up front us they say so. And you can’t get one without a job that sponsors you for it. It’s a catch/22 and why once do many people get into that market, they stay in those jobs to not lose the clearance.

Related Posts

Does anyone know Barclays Ib summer bonus cycle month?? Thanks in advance

like

Any tech recruiters here ? I'm looking to join the field. What can a tech recruiter expect to earn in a corporate/in house role ?

like

Dear EY folks, what's the difference between EY GDS and EY India?

I have been selected for EY GDS as PM. What kind of projects I can expect?

Also, how is yearly appraisal and bonus in EY GDS?

like

Can anyone please tell me what’s the expected salary range for Risk Analyst Role. Thank you.

like

Have you had comp discussions as yet? What was your promo raise from S1 to S2, what practice and city?

I’m currently an SA2 but was offering a 6 month rotation working on product strategy for the firm with a promotion to Manager. Recruiter explained that It’d be at the same base pay with the potential of a raise in June, would you take just a title bump?

like

I have an offer of John Deere and Ezest of same package which one is better
I have 2.6YoE

like

Hi Guys,

I've received offer for the position of Data engineer from Fractal, Gartner and Dunnhumby.
Fractal - 13.5 LPA
Dunnhumby - 15 LPA
Gartner - 15 LPA
Any suggestions on which company should I join ? I've 2+ years of experience.

like

Hello Geeks

Please help me out to pick the best company.

WellsFargo :36 including 10%variable
Coupa: 34L including 10% variable and 3L JB,3.3L stocks (10Lakh total stocks for three years)
EY: 38.2 including 10% variable
CNH :40LPA with 11% variable
One Small product based company setting up their office in India offering 40 fix and 5L JB and equity in the company.


YOE 9.7 CCTC: 20LPA

like

Hello,

I have offer from

Optum, Harman Connected Services, CGI, WIPRO, Concentrix and LTImindtree

All of them are giving package of around 18 lpa. And location for optum and wipro is Hyderabad others are in Bangalore

My joining date is near can you please help me in choosing one of the best from these.

YOE : 3.9
Skills : Java, Springboot, Microservice, Azure Cloud with React Js

like

What should be the expected salary for a person with below background:
1. Tier 1 engineering
2. 4 yoe
3. Currently working as Associate Product Manager

Will be making a next shift soon, hence wanted to know for my reference.

Hi everyone, I am locking for a job change . I have 8+ years of experience in hr generalist for 6 years and 2 years in knowledge management. My current package is 8.2 lakhs and expected is 12 - 15 lakhs, request you to please help me in fi ding a job in your organization

To all the event profs out there, could anyone please advise on what is the base salary of a Senior Event Coordinator in Toronto? Thanks!

like

Does Big4 have AMS (Application Management Service) seevice lines. Does Partner comp / targets differ for AMS vs rest of the service lines?

like

What is the salary range for a desinger 2 position at Microsoft?

PwC question: Is there any small wiggle room (+/- 5 - 10k) in the cohort pay band you're assigned to or is it dead set on a number? Fully understand between cities and non/MBA the numbers are different

like

What is the pay for Business Analyst at Infosys .?

like

Salary for research coordinator at John’s Hopkins university? What is a good salary range for someone with a masters of science and 3+ yrs of experience. Thanks

like

Anyone from PA Consulting know the ranges for Consultant Analyst and what a typical offer package would look like?

like

What would be my in hand after tax deductions?

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Joined EXL last year in OCT at C2 -Project Manager
First appraisal will happen next year after 17 months of joining
Questions:
A. When does the process start ?
B. My performance has been good and client has given good feedback, How much hike should I expect ?
C. I will be eliGible for promotion in Apr , Next year. What will the promotion process?
D. How much Promotion hike can I expect when the band changes C2 to D1 ?

Can the learned member of this group share their opinion on above questions ?

like

Is it just me or is the YouGov Profiles tool completely unintuitive to use?

likefunny

I mean those $6 meals are nice but stay safe y’all 😷

Post Photo
likefunny

Thoughts on dipping into the condo market? Was thinking of waiting till March but don't think prices will drop that drastically and will be ok long term...

like

Not related to consulting but anyone has experience with ratehub / canwise financial as lender for the house mortgage? They seem to offer better discount on Prime rate compared to the big 5 banks.

helpful

I've been approached to advise a SAAS startup, series B roundwise, with a 4-5 hours per week expectation max. How would you figure out how much equity ask for (company is valued at 54m USD)?

like

Swissre Hyderabad has below BA Opening. Please DM me if anyone is interested

Post Photo
helpful

Shabbat Shalom! I’m 22F and wanting to find my NJB. If you’re in la let me know!

like

Does "Gold Standard" matters? I did not get any. What rating will I get.

like

Is the salary structure different for people working in "Infosys consulting" and regular Infosys.

What are the differences between these two entities.

like

I’m a first year associate. I don’t feel like I’ve been tasked with enough work whereas other associates who’ve been at the firm slightly longer are swamped with work. Any advice?

likehelpful

Any advice on how to be the best targeting analyst there is? I start in 2 weeks and am somewhat nervous but excited, but want to stand out amongst the rest of the analyst

likesmart
like

Anyone haves OB/GYN in the Chicagoland area you would suggest? Looking for west suburbs, Elmhurst, Lombard area. Thanks!

like
like

Can anyone offer advice around working with UAE government committees? How they make decisions, allocate budget and deliver? For example.. a multi-ministry committee set up to spearhead the digital agenda within government. Thanks in advance!

Anyone know any good divorce lawyers in NYC?
Thanks in advance 🙇🏾‍♀️

like

Hello all. Does anyone work at Affirm and willing to provide a referral?

like

Additional Posts in Tech

Equifax What is the salary bracket for 6 years experience candidate at Equifax in Atlanta and also St Louis?

likefunny
like

Any advice on moving from L4 to L5 in Amazon?

like

Definitely using both of these.

Post Photo
like
like

I can’t understand, why in the big tech: data scientist = software engineer?!!!!! It is not… and it is huge disappointment when you ask for data scientist who can improve your results that you are not satisfied with, but you design all your technical interview around SE

like

Been trying to find a new job because $112k just doesn't seem right for 3+ years as an Eng 3. On the east coast wanting to move out to California. Not getting many bites. Do employers ignore applications for people who would need to relocate?

likefunny

Hi all- I’m a first year staff who works in Forensic accounting & compliance. I am almost at 1 year in PA, & have come to terms that this career is not for me. I am a creative at heart & interested in working in the music business/ tech industry. My PA experience has provided me with hard skills, which is why I think it would be a great segway into the music biz & entertainment industry. Please react/comment if you are in the music biz/tech field. Would love some advise on how to pivot!

like

Can anyone tell me whats the median salary for Functional Safety Engineer? I had an offer for 140k (it was a 6 month contract position though). I will also be getting an offer internally at my current work place (which is full time) . Since full time offers more job security. I am not expecting them to match or put in an offer close to that amount, but just wanted to get an estimate.

like

How is mechanical engineering at places like Microsoft Google Facebook (Meta)? How's work life balance and salary, compared to the defense industry?

like

What would you consider the “it” company of today in tech from an employee perspective (in terms of culture, growth, pay, etc) and what companies should be avoided?

like

Anyone know which teams or job titles at Google would be related to international expansion (like new product launches)?

like

I have accepted an offer for the role of Director of Data Science & Analytics and I'll be working with old colleagues. I am very excited. I haven't given notice yet because I am waiting for the background check to complete, but my boss just asked me about traveling to a meeting in November. I start at the new job Oct 25. I'm really struggling for how to respond. If I were not leaving it is absolutely a meeting I should be at. I don't want to respond with a lie. Any dvice on how to respond?

likesmart

Hello is anyone willing to provide an Atlassian job Referral for US/Canada jobs?

like

Are people with criminal records allowed at any corporations? I don't have one, I'm just wondering what level of misconduct is allowed on a background check for a large company to still consider them?

like

If anyone knows of any good fully remote LMS prospects, please let me know since I'm looking now. Thanks in advance. I have 13 years experience.

like

Anyone ever worked two full time remote jobs? Curious, how do you handle the scheduling

like

Hey everyone, I have my first interview coming for Project Management role at Meta. Any tips or recommendations? Does anyone know the layout of the interview?

likehelpful

Folks who managed to switch jobs in this economy, how did you get the job? Did a recruiter reach out to you ? Or did you go on sending out applications?

likesmart

Hi,
I just want to understand how the recruitment works here in Canada. I applied for quite few openings but nothing is clicked so far, even Though my profile matches quite all criteria. How much a referral can work here, I tried to reach people in LinkedIn but most of the times I won’t get an answer for my ping. I literally feel annoyed and distressed. Can you please pour your ideas how we can actually search for a recruiter in LinkedIn and how to approach and how to atleast get single intervie

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal