I have 2 offers on the table. Sales role at an investment bank. Offer A: 250k all in, strong and established brand, good work life balance with hybrid setup, 40 hour week, existing client portfolio. Offer B: $320k all in with higher tier/ceiling for comp with performance, top brand, 100% in office expectation, 50-60 hours, lots of prospecting to create book of business. What would you pick?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Option A: $120.19/hour with the ability to do something other than work
Option B: $102.56/hr but the pleasure of working more hours all in office

likesmartfunny

Ding ding ding!

likefunny

A would be my option. You can always make more money. You can’t make more time.

likesmarthelpful

A for sure. At that tax bracket, your incremental take home $ is not worth the potential 50% more work. Also if option A has a strong brand, this has value to opening doors in the future for exit when you decide to do something else or jump ship

like

A for sure

like

Obviously, Offer A

like

Option A unless you don’t like having a life, option b is great if you were going to commit for a few years and then move, but 50-60 hours a week doesn’t seem as do able and your likely to experience burn out. So I’d really ask about pace and put money aside if you really in to just working and your doing 50-60 hours now I’d take the option b but everyone works differently.

like

The reality is at that comp level I really doubt option A is really 40 hrs/week. Especially in investment banking. The folks I work with routinely get stuff dropped on them at 5pm on a Friday. It’s their job to turn things around for the client and they get paid handsomely to do so.

like

and having a hybrid work schedule may help offset those extra hours.

like

Serious questions: HCOL or MCOL area? Do you have kid(s)?

likehelpful

I would ask a man or a woman that question. It’ll matter even if they’re taken care of. It’s about the time that they’ll be committing to things other than their family. It’s a valid question.

likehelpful

A. No doubt

like

A- for sure

likesmart

You have to pick what you can live on and thrive in. if you can do both with the first one, go with it. The second one sounds like the challenge for you then do it. Sometimes extra pay isn't worth the downside. what will make you happiest and give you the best life. personally the second seems exhausting. 60 hours in an office with no hybrid plus commute. sounds like no time to enjoy that extra money and burn out quickly. but, for some, that's where they thrive and feel their best. really look at who you are and where you thrive because that is more important over time.

like

B.
You will end working 50-60hrs anyways.
Only if can guarantee that you and the company will respect the 40hrs/week.
I do believe that as anyone, you will start strong and it will commit more hours and it may be your new normal.
You can advance to hybrid once you show how good you are, whatever the place is.

like

A - 70k shouldn’t make a huge difference.

like

Depends how much you think good quality of living is worth.

like

40 hours a week? Lol I have a bridge to sell you. I even question your experience in this business if you’re commanding $300k in comp and you believe or even think 40 hours a week is reality. You’ll be working at least 50/60hrs at least. Not including client time. Regardless, still not the whole story you’re giving us here. Too many other factors to consider as to whether or not either of these options are better. Details aside, based on what you’ve provided, the answer will ultimately lie in time vs. money. Do you commute? How long is it? Family? Do you have outside interest and activities that you would prefer not to sacrifice? If so, then option A is clearly your choice. Otherwise, take the money every time, bank all you can and get out of this game ASAP

like

Option A sounds good and may probably be my choice but I’m more than midway through my career. Option B may be suitable for someone at early to midway through career…an opportunity to learn, earn and to save for the future before moving on to option A when when you are settled and have a family

like

I would consider B based on my mortgage balance, but still prefer A.

like

Option A, 90k isn’t worth it to me but others may think it is.

like

B. Doubt option A is actually 40 hours a week. People seem to say $70 is nothing but it's on an annual basis so the gap is bigger and will likely get bigger every year. How much do you value hybrid vs. in-office? I prefer being in-office so I can actually get work done

like

A - stable work balance

like

B of course. It is a career move

like

Related Posts

Leaving my current job for a career pivot. Current job has been challenging to say the least and senior management never hears what others have to say. Employment is an at will state.
Senior leadership is so unforgiving that I fear by giving notice, I’ll be asked to leave and lose out on two weeks pay.
Thoughts and feedback on not giving notice or reducing the typical two weeks?
Thank you!

like

Hi All,

Current salary - 21.4L(base - 21L, variable- 40k)
New offer- 30L(base- 27.7L, variable- 2.25L)

Note: Due for promotion in Dec, will probably get 10% hike.

Is it good to switch from CGI(chennai) to coforge(bangalore)?

YOE- 15 years
Tech - AEM

like

I’m seeing most of the commission only jobs are mainly cold call sales. Is that the industry norm? I’ve only done inside sales salary + commission.

like

150K in Singapore, and $150K in Chicago. Which one would you accept?

like

I am having HCL offer of 19 LPA but I have got counter offer from other company of 21 LPA, if i again go to HCL and ask for better compensation means will HR agree and process for more than counter offer ?

like
like

How much is the shift allowance for US or UK shift????

I am done trying to pretend everything is fine at work. The higher ups on the team kept asking if I’m doing anything fun for the weekend during video calls. I felt the pressure to make something up but I just can’t. I’ve been struggling with depression, loneliness, anxiety with immigration and the fact that I might be out of work soon cuz my visa is expiring. I’m thousands of miles away from my family and I just want everything to stop. But when my manager kept asking in front of everyone am I

like

Dealing with asshole client who tried to bully me into changing our recommendations, and spineless partner who is back pedaling now given client reaction, despite pre-aligning on our view. People suck

Hi Fishes,
I got offer from persistent with 31lpa.
But most of the compensation they added into skill bonus-1400000. Due to that my basic salary is low- 50k as compared to my cctc basic salary, which is 63k with 19.5lpa.
Is it normally happening with everyone joining to persistent?
Can Persistent increase basic salary component and reduce the skill bouns?
I asked hr to increase my basic, but she mentioned that it’s system generated and standard format, vary cmpny to cmpny.
Plz help me out guys.

like

BofA Vs Hsbc

Which one to choose if BofA is paying 2 lac more than hsbc ? Is Hsbc worth to consider at a lesser pay?

like

How much do GS associates make? Is there any room for negotiation with HR?

like

Hi fishes,

I wish to know .. for a ux designer .. having 3 years exp. And post graduation degree ..how much CTC can be expected to be negotiated with hr.

Current CTC 11.5

like

Being forced onto banking project with no finance background or cultural leanings—tips? 🥴

like

Hello amazing people. I currently work in CA as a HH RN and planning on relocating to MI in couple months.
I’m not sure about the most efficient way to proceed. Is it best to start as a travel HH RN? Do I apply directly with an agency that offers relocation benefits?….I have over 15 YOE, what’s the pay like in MI?
Thank you all for your help!

like

How much offer can i expect from IQVIA india for senior business analyst role? 8 YOe, skill business analyst, BE and MBa qualification, current ctc 12.36. Hr discussion pending.

Earlier during expected CTC i said 20lacs, however i feel i quoted less.

Has anyone ever seen Accenture counter an offer for a Consultant? I’ve got an offer elsewhere for 40% more base but wanted to see if there was any chance ACN could counter with a off cycle raise or one off bonus?

like

Obligatory financial info post. 1) size of firm, 2) billable requirements, 3) salary, 4) bonus, 5) quality of life, 6) debt, and and 7) family/married/single. Go!

like

Is it the smart move to take a pay cut and clerk for a judge?

Little context: I was an ED student, full time paralegal/clerk throughout my law school experience, and a single mother. I did not take advantage of the law school extracurriculars and missed out on clerk application deadlines my final year (2020). Would it benefit me to take a pay cut as a transactional clerk by about $20k to work as a clerk for a year then re-enter firm life? I’m transactional and enjoy that line of work.

like

More Posts

Anyone works/heard of DMV Group? Mind if i shoot some questions about them?

Moving to the Bay Area this summer from chicago. Any recommendations for good luxury apartments in Palo Alto, Redwood City or Mountain View? Also how critical is it to have your own car? I live in downtown chicago currently where everything is walking distance

like

Q for JPM crowd: Is manager notified when employee sends a request for 360insight feedback to a colleague? (Want to make sure manager has no way of influencing the feedback provider). Thanks

like

What will be in hand for the below after-tax deduction?

Post Photo
like

I came across a copywriter position that I’m interested in, but one of the requirements is 8 years of experience. I’m currently just over 5 years. Would it be ok to still apply?

like

KPMG Cloud hiring

Post Photo
like

McKinsey & Company Whats the difference between brainstorming and framework? I feel it’s largely the same. Am I missing something? McKinsey & Company

like

Hi All,

I have offer from Accenture with 15.5 LPA with 21percent VPA including 3.25 L variable pay. The pay is for Level 10 and domain is SAP, YOE is 4.6. So what is the pay range for Level 10 and I do have counter offer so can I negotiate further with Accenture.

like

All cool 😋✌️

Post Photo
like

How do you go about driving up business as a freelancer? I used to search for email contacts but I’ve started to connect more on linkedin and IG

like

Who is your favorite director you have ever worked with and why?

like

It's funny how Democrats are getting absolutely rocked in this election but still want to make jokes. Must be in that numb phase

likefunny

I live in South Loop and want to take 290 to go west out to the suburbs tomorrow. Am I going to have any issues with marathon closures?

like

I'm having offer with Cognizant, Wipro, and HSBC bank as Java Backend Developer with approximately 7 YOE please help me what I need to discuss in HR. And hows the work culture of HSBC and offer should ask.

like
like
like

Simon-Kucher & Partners Ballpark salary/bonus at Senior Consultant / Manager levels at Simon-Kucher & Partners ? 5 YOE

like

Hey fishes,
Are certifications important for hikes while switching companies?

like

What is everyone’s thoughts about Hilton? Just got asked to interview

like

Anybody knows how much earns an average line cook in Orlando, Florida? And how many hours have to work to get a decent wage

like

Additional Posts in Finance

Has anyone seen Doctor Strange yet? Thinking about going to the cinema for the first time in years :)

like

Any one familiar with comp for a Portfolio Associate roll at PIMCO on their mortgage backed securities team? I’m looking at an offer and want make sure I’m in line with the average comp for the company and industry. Only 4 months of experience and offer is 98k w/ 10-20% bonus plus 15k relo/ sign on. Looking at Glassdoor, bonuses seem higher than quoted by the hiring manager. (No written offer yet they say they’re still working on it)

like

I currently work in commercial banking and have been contemplating the switch to private credit / direct lending. Right now I’m struggling with where we are in the economic cycle as I feel private credit is less secure in downturns but would give me more career upside. Wondering if anyone else has dealt with a similar situation/has any advice?

like

Who here actually owns a car and what kind of car is it?

like

What should I drink with my senior colleagues at the bar so I don't look like a total scrub?

like

I need a new hobby or something to channel my energy and emotions into. Something that won't require much of a time commitment. Ideas?

like

How many of you already have life insurance and long term disability with a trusted provider? Is it worth getting?

like

I have a 12 hour layover in Houston next weekend – any tips on what to do to kill the time?

like

Are cover letters important if they don’t ask for one? There are so many job postings and applicants I can’t tell if they would be beneficial to show effort or just a waste of time to write with how little time I assume people are looking at applications with the mass hiring going on. If I should be writing one, any advice how to format?

like

Hello!
I'm italian, 26 yo and currently working in France as financial analyst.
Work environment is great, friendly and multicultural but I don't like the job at all.
Personal life is not so nice since I manage to see my family and gf every 30/45 days only. Colleagues have their own lives and at the end we don't hang out much.
My dilemma is:
A) going back to Italy at a lower salary with less growth opps but better personal life or
B) Switching my job here and hold on

What would you do?

Thx! :)

like

What's your favorite industry to work a deal and why?

like

What's your morning commute reading material?

like

People interested in B-school: what are your top schools and why?

like

How many days a week do you manage to go out? Dinner, drinks or movie with friends etc.

like

Ladies - few girls in finance date guys in finance, even though each one of you are dating material. Top 2 things wrong with guys in finance? Be nice...

like

Just found my first grey hair. World’s smallest violin, I know...but still!!!

like

How do you lead a morally fulfilling life while being in this industry? I’ve been battling with this question as of late.

like

Realization: I'm good at my job because I'm single

like

Best and worst recruiting firms for Private Equity

like

Things you wish you would've known before working for your firm:

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal