Is it hard to switch from agency recruiting to HR. Curious to hear from anyone who has done this? Thank you!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Mentally. It is a complete different mindset.

like

I’d say the opposite. I came into agency and then went to HR/ coor recruiting. A million times easier :) ( just my own experience )

likesmart

Nope. Not at all.

If anything, you’re more invested in the business strategy.

Now, that said, recruiting is a sales function. It’s not an hr function. So your skills are highly transferable. You’re selling people to managers and businesses to people. I think this should be incentivized in some way. But that’s personal.

like

Do you mean agency to in house recruitment or straight hr?

like

Is it remote? I’m on the East Coast.

Yes. Its a completely different skillset. Having done it myself and having recruited other who have transitioned it's a STEEP learning curve. Typically agency recruiter have basic employment law knowledge with little experience of the complex stakeholder management. In an agency you are given the spec, you fill the role, with limited consideration of the wider implications. It's doable for sure but not easy in any way shape or form and is basically starting again from scratch in a new career

like

Hey, I made this exact transition over the course of the past 8-10 years, and it was DIFFICULT! Agency recruiter for engineering and manufacturing field for over 3 years, transitioned into corporate recruiting but that itself wasn't easy. Did it a couple years before it was cool for companies to accept agency recruiters. Worked a couple contracts not in the same industry before getting a break. After a perm recruiting job for a couple years in a similar technical industry, moved into an HRBP role in healthcare. Industry and team were not a good fit, but I did learn a lot about HR and realized the path I wanted to go really was what I wanted. Worked a couple short recruiting contracts for manufacturing companies while searching for a perm HR Generalist role, then landed my current job as a Generalist at a manufacturing company. I'm the sole HR rep at my site, and it has been a massive learning curve. But I have help and the backing of people who want me to succeed and grow. Btw, my recruiting experience was key to me getting my current job. Advice: join HR orgs if you haven't already, find a mentor, take courses, maybe get an HR cert (like I did, it can only help but it would be preferable for a company to pay for it), leverage your ability to transition your recruiting experience into HR, and network, network, network! Maybe you'll land the right job sooner than I did. Good luck!

like

Not at all! In fact, I think agency recruiters can bring something to HR that many who’ve never worked in an agency can’t. Agency recruitment is known as a “sales” role but I found when I went corporate, HR was so stiff around talent attraction and being creative, they were stiff around “selling” the company. I think internal HR/Recruiting still needs to hold an element of selling why someone wants to work there!

like

Agency > in house > apply for HR role.

It can be done relatively easily. But these will be lateral moves.
If you move up the ladder along the way, it’ll become more challenging.

like

Go in house. Many more doors to many more careers will open. Agency is cool, as is the money if you’re making a lot of placements, but in house is the way to go is my opinion.

like

I went from agency to in house recruiting, expressed interest in picking up more HR responsibilities, and slowly transitioned all the way over. Slow and steady :)

like

I did the same above and the base salary is typically an increase. Started as an HR Coordinator at 50K and moved up to 75K in 3 years. You will however miss the commission checks but not the stress and pressure those being.

I would say no, but it is different and the model will vary based on the size of the business.

like

Not at all! Best decision I’ve ever made going corporate

like

I switched from agency to in house recruitment and although some companies did look down on me/discredited my agency experience, plenty of companies were excited to talk & I had multiple offers. I put in the networking legwork & sent an insane amount of personalized messages, but it paid off. The right team is out there & they want you- I promise!

like

I think the biggest difference is the ways of working- you’ll be looking at a more partnership mindset vs this the role we’ll need to be filling.

Partnership then unlocks a lot more thinking like talent pipeline, org culture, data insights etc

If you are in tech recruitment not so difficult to shift. But challenges are totally different. Stakeholder and change management are two important skills good to have to succeed.

Related Posts

If you were in a private company assistant controller position being offered $10k more to switch over to public and much better PTO days and fully remote as opposed to an in office position that I’m currently at in a Real estate growing company. Would u do the switch back to public (left public just recently)?

like

Hi fishes, I am as SAP ABAP consultant having 5+ yrs of YOE . Please suggest me which technical skills I should have to excel in my career as a technical consultant. Please guide me how to have those.

like

CohnReznick hiring for cyber/tech risk ... seniors and managers. Lmk if anyone interested.

like

Interviewing for a Senior Analyst role in data science & analytics in Detroit. Any idea what salary I should be asking for? Don’t want to sell myself short, but having trouble finding market value. Thanks.

like

To all who have exited from life sciences consulting, what firm did you work at, what did you exit into, and how is it going?

likesmart

Nursing is the only job I've had where I've wanted to quit every week. I always come back to it.

like

How long after transitioning did you start to feel comfortable in your role? Feeling major imposter syndrome in my first 3 months

like
like

I’m stuck at a transitional point in my career where I can’t figure out a direction that I feel excited about. Does anyone have resources, books, career coaches, etc. that may help me find clarity?

like

Hi all, I have a friend who has a PhD in reproduction physiology (beef cattle) and is looking to transition to consulting. What firms have good animal science consulting arms? Is that a thing?

like

What is the promotion hierarchy at Apisero?

like

Pay, prestige, and career progression of Nous Group in Australia?

like

Hi,
I hope everyone is doing well!
I recently accepted an offer with B.O.A. How soon is standard for one to work a position before looking for upward mobility?

like

Hi, I want to apply for UX Designer role Accenture. YOE: 1
Help me understand the process.

like

My 2nd round of interview for AWM VP position got cancelled with #JPMC at the end minute. HR said the position is put on hold by Business.. any similar experiences? Anytime HR came back with interview schedule later in such cases?

hello! what will be my monthly take home as per this? does anyone know what special allowance means.

theyre offering me this for the position of an operations consultant 1 at EY India with 3 yoe

Post Photo
like

Hey Dolphins!
Need some inputs and if possible referrals.
I have a current offer from Accenture S&C CN Role L9 under CFO EV practice and have 30 more days left in notice period. Wanted to know where all I can apply and get competitive offers both in terms of comp and brand name?

Btech MBA
Yoe 6.7(3.5 yrs after MBA)
Work Areas FP&A (EPM)

like

I’m trying to secure a role in GCP Strategy and Operations team in USA. I have cloud experience through AWS, GCP seminars and engineering background + strategy and operations (not consulting) experience directly advising senior leadership. Do you guys have any advice or know someone I could contact to get an interview?

like

Hi all, debating whether to apply to MBA this year or next. I’m an Asian female, 330 GRE, 3.65 GPA in economics from a T10 undergrad. Spent 2.5 years at a T2 consulting firm (AT Kearney, OW, LEK etc) with one promotion and currently work as a product manager at a unicorn startup (currently 3 YOE). My main goals for an MBA would be to ideally transition to product marketing or working on my own startup idea, and hoping to meet more entrepreneurial folks. I want to apply this year, but worried

like

I joined a new consulting firm and have been here for 6 months. Recently, a SaaS client (1k employees) that hired my old consulting firm reached out to me about a job opening - Lead BA working primarily to implement their benefit admin system for insurance companies. My current TC is 95k. Is it worth making the jump if the offer is north of 110k? Anything I should look out for? The client and coworkers were all nice, but I remember being stressed on the project due to limited resources.

like

More Posts

Ya’ll take ya vitamins today?

likehelpful

Account executive here, who has about 5 years of agency experience. Who else is completely over working in advertising and what steps are you taking/planning to make a career move?

Not looking to make a move anytime soon due to covid but am curious to what everyone else is thinking.

like

How are things at Willis Towers Watson? Share your feedback

Not a very good cook but tried making red pesto pasta. Didn’t look great but tasted good.

Post Photo
like

I have zero clue where to ask this question so I am going to try here - WHAT is with the tree at Daley Center Plaza near the NW corner of Dearborn and Washington that is always just absolutely covered in birds. Like thousands of birds. Does anyone else know what I am talking about or am I losing it?

likefunny

Whats the most reliable among german cars? I am worried about paying a lot for maintenance and repairs but also dont want a japanese tin can

like

Best practices to avoid burning out in FDD?

like

Another looting happening now downtown Chicago. WTH is going on !!!

like

Looking for a short term rental. Anyone renting/subleasing/Airbnb their place? Ideally a 2Bed

like

Sometimes it is not...

Post Photo
likefunny

Welcome to Automation Testing group. Please feel free to share your testing related queries, comments, solutions, tips n tricks here

helpful

Hi anyone from infosys who has joined cognizant please ping need help urgent

like

Anyone have experience taking the GCP Machine Learning exam?

like

Anyone know who illustrated the Seamless subway ads?

like

Anyone in late 20s-early 30s in nyc looking for friends?

like

Joined at 502 in JPMC in mid July (in Operational Risk). 6 YOE (4 in audit, 2 in BPO). Haven't really started working in the true sense yet. Objective setting discussion just began for this year. Wondering what to expect from performance appraisal considering these facts in terms of hike and bonus. LOB - Corporate.

like

Any idea what areas/roles will experience the most growth in relation to hiring based on the recent announcement?

like

Looking for senior Salesforce developers/architects in the US! Joined my previous mentor in starting a new Salesforce practice. Company is based in SF but we’re ok with folks working remotely. Might require some travel once it’s safe again but not anytime soon. Good opportunity to be actively involved in building something from nothing

like

Hey i am appearing in SFCC architect exam can anyone help if there is any preparation material available other than sfcc documentation.

like

Hello All, In the next couple of months i am targeting companies like Apple , American express, Salesforce, Microsoft etc. Can anyone please share the required skill set and preparation strategy for these companies? YoE - 4 years Current skill set - Advanced SQL , Pyspark,Azure services, Hadoop ecosystem , shell scripting, Power BI

I am not very good at DSA.

Apple Microsoft Salesforce Amazon

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

Looking to finally go get my SPHR having the PHR for the past 6 years. Still value and pursuing and obtaining?

like

Hello Everyone,

I am looking to hire a couple of technical sources who have a keen interest in diversity. I am building out a diversity sourcing team to support AWS AI/ML practice. Great opportunity with lots of visibility. Let me know if you are interested in learning more.

like

I am looking to make a career change to HR. I currently make 75K as a sales and development coach. I had a recent offer for a state government position in a talent acquisition role but I’d be taking a $25K pay cut. I am extremely over qualified for the position but it could possibly be a stepping stone and gives me the time to acquire SHRM certifications and possibly start taking classes to get my MBA. My question is those currently in an HR role, would this move make sense to you?

like

Hi all!
Would love some insight on how you went from an HR assistant/coordinator to an HR Generalist. I’ve been in the HR world for 8 years, and only in the last 2-3 have I really done real HR work. The first company I was at didn’t have a solid HR team so I don’t really count that. I feel like I’m ready to take on more responsibility and learn more. And of course make more money.

I have looked into getting SHRM certification. But should I go back to school and get my masters in Hr?

like

Hi everyone! I ‘m trying to transition into learning development. Any advice? Which jobs should I apply to? If you’re already in L&D what is your day to day experience?

like

Bilingual Talent Sourcer in Canada (French and English) seeking remote work. Please message with available opportunities 😁😁

like

Random question for my HR Benefits professionals- if I need to take a leave from work for an arm surgery (torn muscle not pre existing condition) would it be better to enroll in short term disability or take another type of medical leave?
Thanks

like

Why is it so hard to find a remote HR position? I have my SHRM-SCP, my MBA and over 10 years of experience being an HR Manager.

likesmart

Am I being paid competitively? I have been the Onboarding Sup for my HR dept for over a year now and I’m being paid the state min for salary, which for CA is 62,400. I have not gotten a merit raise since the last 2 January’s, the state raises the threshold for salary folks. My company says that was my raise. Is this right? I bring a background from the clinical operations of my company, scheduling, field work, and what the average employee faces. I want to look else where but I’m not sure.

like

I am trying to land a role as a human resources business partner and I'm wondering which certification would be the best for me going forward. Phr? Shrm? Thoughts? Thanks!

like

Does anyone have a job application tracking software they love? I’m mainly looking for something that allows customizable application forms that allow me to ask questions outside the normal and something that I can automate rejection letters and keep a database of applicants.

like

Hi all, I’ve recently onboarded as an HR recruiter with a small NGO. It has been wonderful so far. I want to make the most of my new role. If you have any suggestions or advise, I’d greatly appreciate it.

like

Hello! Has anyone ever built a campus recruiting structure for a company? Meaning they started from scratch and built out campus recruitment? What was the pros and cons? Also, what was your salary, how long did you stay there and did you enjoy building this out?

like

Hi, I work for a non-profit and we hire nationwide for 2 positions as well as locally for numerous positions. I’m looking for recommendations, reviews and any advice for online job boards. We use Indeed, Glassdoor, Craigslist, just got back into Zip Recruiter and working on getting LinkedIn up and running. Any help is appreciated.

like

Hello, which is more beneficial Master’s in Human Resources or PHR Certification?

like

At a tech company with less than 50 people and $6 M Revenue. Our current maternity and paternity leave policy is not good for attracting talent. 12 weeks for mom only 4 weeks paid and no time off for dads. Curious to know what policy other companies have, and can you let me know size and approx rev of company?

like

Hello! I have a two part question: 1) is it worth it to obtain an SHRM specialty credential if I don’t have the broader SHRM certification? 2) has anyone gotten the People Analytics or Talent Acquistion credential? If so, how valuable was it from a learning perspective? Do you feel it significantly contributed to your knowledge in either area? Thank you!

like

Hi everyone! In this field, when choosing a masters degree program is it more beneficial to get a degree in Human Resources to further my knowledge in HR (my undergraduate degree is in Economics) , an MBA, or Data Science Degree due to the fact that HR is becoming more data driven as well as get a PHR / SHRM-CP certification?

like

My annual perf discussion is monday morning. I work on a tough team for a tough place. I think Im a pretty good/almost high performer but only around 3 years and my boss seems to still act like I’m brand new (lifer boomer). I try to tell myself he has 6 direct reports and has to do this with everyone, Im no more or no less special - but I hate these convos and negative feedback even when most of it is unsurprising/fair feedback. Any tips? Just need to get through it! HR people are not immune!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal