Looking for input on an internal struggle I am going through. How do you rationalize settling in the US/Canada while your parents live alone in India? I am having a hard time deciding if I should move back to India so that we can be close to our parents. They don’t guilt us to to come back, but I know they feel anxious thinking about managing their life as they grow older. They did and still do everything they can for us. I feel I am being selfish if I settle in US. Contd....

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Same story for all immigrants. Some stayed some went back. Most still don’t know if it was the right decision. Some are happy with the choice they made, some are not. Boils down to the individual end of the day. You can always go and come back later. Be sure to have kids in the US though.

like

I grapple with that each day. I plan to just hoarde money for the next 10 years or so and then decide. Working and taking care of parents in India will not be possible with a job in consulting- so may take a break. Let us see. Thankfully don't have a SO or any kids to worry about. Hence for me - my parents are the only family I have and will have. I have already made peace with a lot of decisions in life - the next big one will come soon.

like

This decision will be the next big one - when and how to move back.

like

Same boat. I am planning to do what S1 suggested 👆

Work here for another 5-8 years and be in a position to FIRE. Then move to India and take what I see as an “optional 9-5” job to cover basic monthly expenses.

I see it as I am of no use to my parents if I cannot actually take care of them. I know that sounds harsh but obviously not totally true. But still. If I work in India I will grind and not be able to provide same level of support.
Right now they are healthy and active and have have full lives. So this is the best time for me to do the same.

like

I had the same thinking as this before I married my SO who was an American citizen, and my thinking was that I may never go back to India again.
But parents were very helpful and supportive as we decided to marry. Both my parents had just turned 60 and said something like 20 years of us should not cost you the opportunity of love and happiness that lasts 60 years. We have made it a point to visit once a year and have them over for a few months every year as they are now both retired. Their health concern is an issue especially with COVID, but this was the best we managed to get to.

likeuplifting

This is v tough.. I lost my parents and wish I’d move back. On the other hand, I am a minority and didn’t feel safe in india anymore otherwise I would probably have moved back, came very close a couple of times. If it is not a safety or sanity risk, move back but do something that gives you the option to come back.

like

CAA-NRC, lynchings, attacks on free speech, cases against Twitter, arrests of activists

like

They don’t like the option of moving to the US. And my concern is for both my and my wife’s sets of parents. Am I overthinking this?

like

You are not over thinking this at all. Every first immigrant have lots of choices and sacrifices to make.

like

at some point you have to decide what your priorities are, make a decision, and be at peace with it. maybe you can set a deadline for yourself, i.e. save up and make the most of next 4-5 years and then go back. alternatively, decide to stay and make efforts to visit parents often or have them visit once a year and then you go once.

like

I am able to provide for them because I live here. They visit all the time

like

I lost my dad in 2019, and was planning to move back since I would never want to be in such situation ever again, but then COVID started so I paused for a bit and eventually moved back end of 2020.

I am single so it was easy for me, would not be as easy for married or married with kids.

Had friends and was involved in social activities too to keep myself engaged, moved back since I was not happy and constantly thinking like OP is.

I earn less now but I am happy now and feel that I made the right decison.

like

I am in the same boat ... and many of my friends also in similar situation. I can feel your frustration and self guilt.

like

I am in the same boat. Infact planned to move back to India, for a year or more till this pandemic ends. You can always come back to US or earn more money later. Unless you have bought a house or significant investment, this country doesn’t give you a home like feeling.

like

Same boat OP, I tenon know it’s just setting the right priorities. Hoping to finalize mine in a month . I wish it was binary

like

Can we connect. Sent a DM

OP -- same .I wish to make enough , maybe for another 4-5yrs. Married or not, I wish to go back and take care of my parents. I am living with guilt basically not really enjoying full heartedly.

like

Longer you stay here, lower the probability of you going back. Once you have kids you will never go back. All these people saying I will wait for 5-10 years and go back, never go back. It’s called immigrant dilemma. Once you get green card, there in additional incentive to stay here.

This is true for a lot of people. I never started my GC for 4 years after I was eligible to start it in my company and now need to get it done within the next 2 years.

Thank you for sharing! It is not an easy decision and I agree that it is getting more complicated with every year that I have lived here. We had pretty much made up my mind to leave but the recent COVID crisis gave me and my wife a pause. It just exposed everything that can go wrong in a country like India. But we both feel at peace here close to family.

Not yet.

My son is in 2nd grade I am planning to complete his elementary here then plan yo go back. I agree with comment that more you stay hard to go back but need to take hard step at some point. Also I am planning to get my extension before leaving I have approved I-140 so extn mostly go for 3 years and if I think my move was not right decision I can try to cone back as I will have valid visa. Its lot of planning let's see what will happen after 3 years when I need to make decision.

We all are in the same boat. Every immigrant is. For us Indians the bond with our parents is stronger. My suggestion, either move back soon (next year or two) or don’t. The ten year horizon isn’t good for you since you won’t be able to life your life fully and not good for your parents.
Support you decide not to move, that is ok, don’t feel guilty. Provide the best care to your parents, visit them often, get them to US for short visits. But atleast then everyone knows what the future holds and can plan accordingly

My parents never stayed with their parents when they moved away for a job. Back then there was no air travel and they met their parents over holidays, etc.
same thing that I do now 😁

Related Posts

Love my boyfriend but embarrassed by him when he gets drunk... he always seems to be the drunkest person at happy hour when we go out w friends/starts slurring/eyes aren’t as focused. cant tell if I’m the one that’s being restrictive — does anyone else feel this way w their partner?

likehelpful

I’ve been in a relationship now for two years. We are living together. We talk about the future etc. I could easily see myself marrying her. However, I have an issue… cont

like

This is a question about friendships. Two friends got into a really bad fight this past weekend. They have each asked me to hang out this weekend. What do I do? I don’t want to have to choose sides. One is a friend I’ve known a little longer and has been a good friend and so she would feel betrayed and angry if she knew I were still friends with her now-enemy. The other I’ve known less longer, but we seem more compatible. Advice??

like

Hi fishes,
Want some feedback for Employees Assistant Program (EAP) by Capgemini which provides facilities to connect with Therapist.
Actually I am going through some tough times(going through a divorce), want to connect to EAP to discuss my mental health issues.
I had connected once and they say that the conversations are strictly confidential.
Just wanted to know do they really keeps stuff confidential or can they inform my Manager regarding the personal conversations.

like

Hi! Have any here gone the natural cycle IVF route? What was your experience like? Did you have success in growing your family this way? Would you recommend it to others?

like

For the last month I’ve been contemplating life. It hasn’t been so much if, but more so when. A director on my team in a different vertical has been pushing me to the brink with extreme emotional abuse and now sabotaging my livelihood; job security (health insurance, financial stability, place to live etc) following months of initiating a flirtatious relationship they finalized a divorce. Just months ago this was someone I saw spending my life with, growing old besides …

like

I feel like a lot of my fellow producer friends are getting absolutely destroyed with their workload this summer (myself included). How are you guys surviving?

Post Photo
likefunny

Do you consider your in-laws family? For example, if your spouse’s sibling has children, do you consider those kids as your family or your spouse’s family?

like

Does anyone feel bad seeing friends when you’re job hunting? Just feel like I don’t deserve a dinner out and will feel bad comparing myself since they are all doing fine.

like

My gf and me call each other everytime we have free time. However lately she seems disinterested in phone time. She never initiates calls anymore and she tells me she wants to hang up in the middle of the day and not right before bedtime. We live a 4 hour drive apart. And I told her this is like living together from a distance, because I put her on the house speakers. What can I do to keep her engaged?

like

I’m irritated ALL the time and it’s ruining my relationship. What’s wrong with me? lol should I just start smoking weed or get on an anti depressant?

like

What do you wish on your ex?

like

I lie to my girlfriend every time we make plans — I always tell her to be ready an hour before I want her to be and she’s still normally running 15-30 minutes late

likefunnysmart

Hi everyone I am relocating to Hyderabad next month. Even though I look forward to meeting new people I can’t seem to ignore the fact that I will move away from family. My family situation is already complicated, my mom and dad are not on good terms so we don’t live together and when I move it’ll get worse. I am financially independent but I feel guilty for not being there for them. Is there any possibility of getting transferred to Gurgaon office(a lot closer to my home)if I talk to my manager?

like

My brother-in-law (age 30) told us recently that he is transgender. How can we support him? (‘Him’ as we haven’t discussed pronouns yet). It was a surprise to us!

likeuplifting

I got that coveted big law job.

But I would much rather want a family of my own and someone to hug and kiss, something I feel really sad about around christmas.

Never had much contact with my dad, and two years ago, I broke off contact with my mother because I realized that she had been a manipulative narcissist my entire childhood.

Working 50-60h weeks on average doesn’t help your dating life though, and who would want to date someone with no family anyway

likeuplifting

This bowl has been quiet and I see partners commenting on odd posts around fishbowl so I figure you need more fodder: partners, did any of you have parents that travelled as much as you do?

like

Is it normal to feel depressed/lonely during wedding planning? I almost feel like I can’t talk about it since other people aren’t engaged and I feel like I’m rubbing it in their faces talking about it. So I have to keep everything to myself and it’s kind of stressful

like

I and my boyfriend have been dating over a year now. Our relationship in general is pretty smooth and sweet. The only problem is he has not come out to his parents yet. It was not an issue before the pandemic thing since we were just living in the city, being in our own bubble. But Covid happened and he moved back to stay with his dad. Since he is not out, he can’t pick up the phone call whenever I call him, he can’t tell his parents he is dating someone in the city. Cont.

like

I am generally uncomfortable when I’m around my mother-in-law’s husband.

While he is overall a decent guy, his anger issues, yelling at his wife for the slightest issue, and insulting nature makes me uncomfortable and triggers my own anger due to his blatant disrespect for just about everyone around him.

My mother-in-law says he’s worked on things, but it’s been 10 years of this and I’m not sure I want such behavior around my wife and our kids since we’re trying to conceive soon (cont).

like

More Posts

like

what does the bonus range look like for a new band 4 at bank of america?

like

Looking for a lighter/puffer winter jacket and figured at this point I’ll wait until they go on sale. Does that ever happen with Barbour, Patagonia, Northface etc?

Any other guys ever consider getting into high fashion/“street wear” but then just get intimidated and turn away bc the sheer amount of clothes we’d need to buy to have a somewhat versatile wardrobe?

like

EY application has turned to “We'd like to progress you to the next step in our recruiting process”. How soon does communication begin and typically how long is the process?

like

Will it be a negative if we don’t use the full 10 minutes for the Accenture technology showcase? I’m clocking in close to 7 minutes.

likehelpful

Do I need any words

Post Photo
like

Has anyone ever worked with Mark Pollard or Julian Cole? Are they as great as they seem?

likefunny
likesmart

So I feel a combination of relief and guilt as a bankruptcy/restructuring attorney. I think I’ll be ok since it’s going to be a very busy time soon. But at the same time nobody else is going to be ok

like

Why are we so hesitant to identify ourselves?

like

Anyone in dental sales?

like

How much do you make and how many years experience? I’m a senior para at a mid sized firm in Central FL. 10 years experience. I’m making $64k—fair salary?

like

2 part question:

- Does anyone know who Accenture uses for their 3rd party background checks?
- If i allow them to contact my current employer, do they still ask for W2’s and Paystubs?

like

How does a role in clinical affairs differ from clinical research? Any clinical affairs manager out there to shed some light? Wondering if clinical affairs will have more sciencey roles.

like

Does anyone know about the onsite policy of UST ? If an employee goes onsite does UST pay both indian and onsite salary ? Any other benefits that UST might provide like rental home etc ??

UST Global

like
like

We're always looking for new ways to make things easier for our customers and clients, but sometimes I just want to take a step back and breathe.

like

I know I’ve seen a few similar posts before in the past, but do you guys have preferred/recommended apps to keep you organized and productive with work? I have my work calendar and synced through outlook on my phone, but just looking for suggestions to keep everything as organized as possible.

like

Additional Posts in Desi Consultants

36 yrs old. Still have hair on my head, I’m glad. But belly starting to come out and slim fits are not working anymore. I need to do something...

Hi all, has anyone temporarily transferred to the Canadian office of their firm and done the Canadian PR application while they were there on work visa?

like

Any book recommendations to gift my cousin sister? She studied (masters) psychology and is a trained classical dancer.

like

Going to India from DCA (flights were cheaper) but I live in Houston. Flight from DCA is at 10 pm. Should I book my flight from Houston to DC the same day or one day earlier? Given the flight cancela.

like

How open are mental health discussions in your families? Whether it be talking about your struggles or suggesting therapy to family members? Anyone done it successfully and mind sharing ideas here?

helpful

Which trading platforms do you use in India??
As a NRI, how do you guys plan your investments?

Just started to work in the US on h1b.should I invest in 401k? What if I am not sure about staying in the US for the long term..Is there a penalty for early withdrawal - does it make financial sense?

like

Anyone from Huron on the group? I see booming Oracle Cloud things on there, want to know more - Risk and Controls guy from PwC.

RFE REASON: GGlaw not sharing RFE Reason on my H1 change of employer RFE, shouldnt a beneficiary get to know the denial/RFE reason. Anyone in same boat?

like

Planning on telling my parents about my white boyfriend this weekend…. Any tips or words or motivational words please

like

Looking to buy an 💍. Might make a trip to India in 6 months. Any advice on helping me make the decision to buy in US vs India?

like

Married fish, how do you ho about decision making for buying property and how do you decide who to register it on?

like

Passport renewal- how much does it take for Indian sf consulate to issue a new passport once they receive all the documents?

like

I’m F traveling to Delhi for the first time with another F friend. I would like to tour Delhi and Agra over 3 days. Looking for personalized services as I’m interested in visiting specific spots in Delhi. Appreciate any tour services recommendations. (Safety is our biggest concern.)

like

Is it legal for green card holders to work on a second /side gig on Corp 2 Corp ?

like

Can I file AR-11 myself or this has to be done by lawyer?

like

Anyone did transit though Hong Kong? Seems we need to register and get approval? Can you pls share your experience if any?

Any lgbtq desi consultants want to connect offline ? I am struggling to make friends in the desi circle with similar mindsets / challenges. Single indian gay male here:)

likeuplifting

What is the best and cheapest courier service to send an parcel from us to India. I want to send some medicines and pain killer creams to my mom who lives in country side of up,India. Does custom blocks pain killer creams ?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal