Please help me rationalize through something:
2 kidneys but can only give 1 (potentially):

1) Cousin: 36, mom of 2, lives a fairly healthy lifestyle
2) Dad: 60-65 YO; kidney failure runs in the family, lives an unhealthy lifestyle but this is dad…

What should I be considering in thinking through how to decide? What factors would you think about?

P.S. will go through screening process for both but just want to start thinking about things now

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Sorry. That’s a tough one.

Considering the fact that kidney failure runs in the family isn’t it just better to keep it for yourself? 🤔
What if it fails after the transplant for either of them? How difficult would it be for them to find another kidney?

like

If kidney failure runs in your family, are you sure you want to give anyone one of your kidneys? What if something happens to yours?

like

🤗

like

Don’t worry about it until you know if you’re a match to one, both or neither. The problem may solve itself that way.

like

Agree, but I’m a planner and like to think ahead and weigh in on it to ease my nerves.

like

I would have to pick my dad. He’s sacrificed so much for me to be able to get to where i’m at, and to give me and my siblings the best life possible, so I’d happily give him a kidney to save his life (assuming i’m a match of course).

like

I’m sorry you are going through this situation, but truly admire that you are even considering doing something so selfless. I would recommend that your potential decision should be made depending on who you are closer to and who you would like to see live longer.

P.S. I would have given a kidney to my dad if it could have kept him alive longer.

like

The utilitarian way to think about this:

Which will provide more utility? If you give cousin the Kidney, you provide 30+ years of life, with kids. If you give dad, you get 10-15 years prob. You being close with your dad doesn’t come into the ethical considerations: the mother has kids too.

There’s also the matter of the transplant list— is the cousin given priority generally, being younger / a mom? If so, providing it to the dad may make sense because she will likely get a kidney anyway.


I’m not a utilitarian, though. I personally would consult a priest (insert person who has a doctorate in the ethical system you ascribe to), and work on it.

But cross that bridge if you get to it.

like

This is an easy one. Out of the two, Pops. He made you and has sacrificed a lot for you whether you've seen it or not. The least you could do is give him a kidney
*This is assuming he has been a good father to you*

like

Sounds like your dad won’t be cleared regardless of what you do. An organ transplant requires strict discipline and adherence to doctor instructions. A healthy lifestyle will definitely be part of their recommendations, so if he can’t change his habits he won’t be considered a good candidate for the procedure.

helpful

I say cousin 🤷🏾‍♀️.

Related Posts

I am preparing for my first trial! Very nervous but excited. All tips and suggestions welcomed please!

like

How do you deal with ADD and being able to clearly explain your ideas? Are meds the answer? Really don’t want to do that. Already in therapy. Plz help.

I was recently diagnosed with high functioning bipolar II disorder and was prescribed a mood stabilizer. I’m worried it may impact my creativity. Would anyone be open to sharing their experiences?

like

Can someone explain why alcohol is so debilitating on your health? I had a single drink and the next day at the gym I could feel that drink just wreaking havoc on my workout routine. Anyone have any tips on getting a balance?

likefunny

Spent the pandemic working on myself, got sober, focused on working out, left the music industry and started a career where I can make money and have a steady work schedule. Maybe this isn’t everyone’s version of “growing up” but that’s what this was for me. Now that I’m vaxed and seeing my friends, it’s clear we have little left in common, and honestly a lot of the things they do straight up embarrasses me. I don’t want to lose these long term friends. Has anyone else been in this situation?

likehelpful

Any update on work from office in TCS? Are they still calling ? As no. of cases are increasing

like

Does anyone else feel like their social skills went down during the pandemic? My new anxiety makes retail so hard.

like

Hi everyone, I’m seeking some advice - my dog (8yrs old) was attacked several months ago by another dog and after she became depressed and anxious. We got her anti depression meds and those seemed to help but how a lot now a lot of signs are pointing to a potential brain tumor. To get an MRI is +1k. My mom doesn’t want to spend money but it just hurts me so much to see the behavior - she walks around in constant circles, looks sad, seizures, hides under the bed. Any advice would be appreciated.

like

I need to take the booster but what would be an ideal.time? How did you guys schedule booster around treatments/twe/trying all that

like

In December, my goal is to
- lose 5 lbs.
- lose 1 inch from my waistline.

This is part of a broader goal to lose 45 lbs overall.

I will have a weekly update on my progress.

like

Nearly killed me this morning leaving my fiancé at home after he was up all night with a stomach bug. Thankfully I’m local, but annoyed this proposal is keeping me away from helping him through this

like

Anyone on a statin (eg Crestor)? I’m 40/m and had elevated cholesterol last checkup. Rx Crestor and second opinion concurred. I’m still hesitant to start. I exercise, eat pretty well, don’t smoke, use alcohol. Asking for experiences not medical advice. Thanks!

like

Does anyone in this bowl travel? Where do you eat? I find it exhausting to research nutrition facts all the time, and end up eating at the same 2-3 places every week. :(

like

I am having an issue with my thighs rubbing together and now I have bumps dark spots etc.

Any recommendations on clearing the skin up?

Virus is running amok in political circles.

Amit Shah tested positive for covid.
UP BJP President Swatantra Dev Singh tests positive for covid too.
UP Cabinet Minister Kamla Rani died because of Covid.

like

If I’m just looking to slim down is the best thing to do at the gym run?

like

I’ve made it 5+ years in a NY M&A practice and have consistent exceeding expectations reviews. I’ve had a few mental breakdowns because of work during this time, but thankfully made it through. I’ve been in a near constant depressive/anxious state for family reasons for the last year and half, and am soon having my first kid. I’m scared shitless that I’ll spiral out of control both at work and at home if something doesn’t change soon. Any suggestions on how to keep this job and keep it together?

like

Seems that the vaccine that usually takes more than 10 years to develop, test for side effects and go through the regulation process is being very fast tracked to roll out - which is a super great thing to potentially eradicate the virus. on the other side of the spectrum, people with life sciences n healthcare insights, how reliable and safe would you say vaccine (being fast tracked) is...?

smartfunny

I’ve been getting really depressed out of nowhere. It’s not really related to anything that’s going on in my life. Is there something wrong with the chemicals in my brain or something? I’m taking vitamin B12 and D3 but they’re not really helping

like

Stress is causing a massive flare-up of racing thoughts recently. I feel like it's been at least a week or two since I last was able to completely clear my mind. And if it's not random stream-of-consciousness mess, it's music. Ever had a song stuck in your head? Because I've had one for four days now. Driving me nuts. Anyone else struggle with this/have a solution?

likeuplifting

More Posts

I have zero clue where to ask this question so I am going to try here - WHAT is with the tree at Daley Center Plaza near the NW corner of Dearborn and Washington that is always just absolutely covered in birds. Like thousands of birds. Does anyone else know what I am talking about or am I losing it?

likefunny

So, who wants to vouch for me to Soho House?

like

Anyone from Accenture CN here? Need urgent help

like

Ever downloaded PNG from Google images? 🥲

Post Photo
funnylike

Has anyone successfully sold your gently used clothing for cash on the spot anywhere in Chicagoland? If yes, where? Have a lot of nice stuff that I’m bored of but Poshmark takes too much effort for me and I find consignment stores usually take months until anything sells and then getting your money is a pain. So looking for instant cash. TIA

like

Hi

Can anyone refer me for snowflake developer position.
Total 2.4 years of experience and 1 year on snowflake.

Thanks.

like

Have opportunity to work in my firm’s London satellite office for about a year and a half, and then come back to NY headquarters. In good standing with firm and have M&A and capital markets experience. Did not start traveling abroad until my bar trip (did not grow up with the money for trips like that) and think it would be a good personal and professional experience. Any thoughts / advice?

like

Any star alliance status match delta platinum?

like

I applied for a post of Test Automation Engineer in UBS, Pune. What salary can I expect?
Also would like to know about UBS culture and work/life balance?
YOE: 2 years

like

How do you all ask parents for supplies without bagging them constantly?

like

Most South Asian names seem to be anglicized in the US. Since it seems inevitable, any new parents have experience with getting ahead of the curve & going with an anglicized version in birth cert?

like

Crowe is hiring for quite a few positions across the US (Internal Audit, IT controls and cyber/digital security, Compliance,etc)… I’m a manager and would think some of these niche areas have great opportunity for new folks to excel rather quickly. Great flexibility and mobility policies. I’d be happy to chat if interested and get you directly in touch with the right people internally.

likefunny

Curious if all forms have been using “virtual” EAs and if so, how long before the “old” EA model is obsolete?

likesmart

When's the last time you've left the office at a reasonable time -- say by 6 PM ?

like

Is Gary Vee still saying that all of their layoffs were not covid related? Vayner folks, is that true?

like

Has anyone actually found love at work? My best friend started at a new company 6 months ago and she just took an offer somewhere else because she and her senior manager fell for each other. After 6 months she knew it was worth leaving her job for! I've been working at the same place for three years and I went on one date with a guy who didn't even work with me he just worked in the building. What am I doing wrong.

like

Does anyone have a MS lesson on kindness and acceptance of students with special needs?

like

I had one of those VERY nonproductive days today. I think I accomplished maybe an hour of billable work, even though I had a bunch of stuff to do. I just came off a 300 hour month, and unexpectedly got a continuance on a deadline on Wednesday, and it’s like all of my motivation leeched out of me at once.

like

Got to know that the current hybrid work policy (3 day wfo and 2 day wfh) is valid till december only, post which everyone is suppose to work from office.. is it true?

Hello... does anyone have any info on being an EA at BDO??? About to interview and I'm curious. Thanks

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Confession

Does anyone remember limewire and Morpheus days. My computer had so many stds from downloading all those music files

likefunny

Beer is now cheaper than gas. Drink more, drive less 🤧

likefunnysmarthelpful

Is it a red flag if someone says they don’t believe in self help books like Atomic Habits, Attached, etc?

funnylike

Week be looking good 🥹

Post Photo
funnylike

Anyone else expect there to be loads of attractive people when they started work and end up thoroughly disappointed?

likefunnysmart

Sometimes when I make a mistake at work I feel like I am not good enough for the job while other times I take it as “let’s do better next time.” Would love to find a balance between the two feelings.

like

Feeling grateful today. 🥺

likeuplifting

Can’t wait until Rachel Zane breaks up with the Prince and gets back with Mike Ross. It’s about time for Suits to reboot.

likefunny

I don’t like Chicago. It seems that I will have to move to Chicago in the fall. How do I survive this

like

I am a conservative who believes in being tough on crime but this is absolutely ridiculous and wrong.

As a lawyer, it troubles me that a public figure would come out and say something like this

Post Photo
like

Big birthday coming up in a few months and wanting to do things I have never done before (tattoos, surgery, etc.) What have you done as a result of a mid life crisis?

like

I’m so grumpy about new campus hires. Sometimes I’m judgmental (your hobby is “working on your golf swing,” really?). Sometimes I’m just exhausted by the worried earnestness. Sometimes I’m amazed that they seem to have zero useful skills, yet they’ll be making 150k easily in the not too distant future.

funnylike

I recommended a candidate for hire to a manager that reports directly to me. This person is a perfect match, but wanted the manager to obviously recommend. It has to be a fit. The manager just told me my recommendation is not her top pick. I feel frustrated because as much as we talk about the position, I wonder if we are mot aligned on criteria. What do I do? Do I push more for the person I want or will I cause an issue with the hiring manager? How do I get her to see this person’s value?

like

Don’t mind me here as an international student just sitting here with my bucket of popcorn watching you all bicker about student loan forgiveness

Post Photo
funnylike

I get significantly more likes on bumble BFF than I do on bumble dating

likefunnyhelpful

I judge the company I work every time they misspell my name even though I’ve corrected it over and over again. It tells me they don’t care and don’t want to make the effort. It’s in my email, my email signature, on my profile, etc. How hard is it to look it up and spell it correctly?!

like

Every night for like the past month I’ve been getting incredibly emotional about adulthood. I miss the lack of responsibility, the simplicity of life, friends were always around, and less pressure to be successful.

I’m 3 years out of college now so it’s not like I just started doing this stuff, but I am feeling the exact same feeling as I did when I first started work and just wanted to be back in college. I know I just need to grow up and accept that’s how life is but it’s incredibly upsetting

like

I would like to take this time to sincerely apologize for calling people in there 30s old, I finally turned 30 and we are young af, unlike the old geezers in their 40s

funnylike

We’re only getting older baby 🎶

like

Can you share your monster in law stories? Misery loves company

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal