Put an offer on a house, we really liked a lot. Offer was accepted, however, the price per square footage is like 40-50% higher compared to the comps in the area, we felt like we were extremely over paying, given the house does need Windows, Roof eventually and other stuff. We backed out yesterday, however, now having second thoughts. Any input is helpful.

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If the house is smaller than comps, then price per sq ft may not be the right way to compare.

I assume that the state of repair of the windows, roof, and “other stuff” was discovered through the inspection. Is there a reason why you backed out instead of attempting to renegotiate around the items you found?

likesmart

Yeah, if the comps are twice as big, then price per square foot won’t be comparable. Buying the smallest house in a good neighborhood will have a skewed $/ sq ft than larger houses in the same neighborhood.

If the level of repair doesn’t justify the price, I get backing out, especially if the house is still sitting. But I wouldn’t use $ / sq ft as the primary gauge of “value” for an outlier home like that

like

Can you renegotiate? Seller may be willing to accept a lower price as long as it's higher than the second highest?

like

You should counter.

That’s very high. Unless it’s in an amazing location compared to the comparables and interior finish is different

like

Would you have loved the comps? What about this house did you love?

like

Decided not to move forward, as I saw another house around the corner go on the market for substantially less per square foot and was a nicer house.

like

If you're financing, the bank will require an appraisal. If it comes back lower than your offer price, thats your opportunity to renegotiate.

There are, infact, good Realtors out there. A good buyer's agent would have pulled comps and advised you on price before your offer.

You've probably lost a lot of faith and confidence with your seller's by pulling the offer after you had already agreed on price. It will be much tougher for you now.

If you don't have a decent buyer's agent, you should get one to help you navigate this situation if you really want to end up with the property.

like

If you really really like the house, talk to your realtor about your options. Or you can keep looking, I am sure there will be other great houses.

What state are you in and was there no penalty (ie loss of Due Diligence or Earnest Monies) for backing out?

What did your realtor say?

Price per square foot is just one indicator

We don’t have all the data so there might be something that indicates the extra cost.

Idk, stuff like south facing, larger yard, newer build…hundreds of things may contribute. Or not! Maybe it’s a rip off

The fact that you loved it might indicate why it was more expensive. Would you have loved the comps?

Would it be bad if we want to proceed with the offer we submitted even though we backed out yesterday? Say we had a change of heart, or no?

What does your realtor suggest?

If there’s no backup offers, it might be worth letting it sit for a week or so to help prove that the price is too high.

like

Possibly a forever home? If so, go for it!

What did the appraisal say?
If I was the seller I’d be very worried now since you flip flopped twice and would rather wait for someone serious.

Updates?

Sounds high but once you do your inspection you should renegotiate with all the structural issues save bring the price down. Usually they’ll accept if they don’t want you to pull the offer

Related Posts

I have 10k extra to invest. How should I grow it? Any growth stocks to recommend?

likehelpful

Is there a reason to get the luxury SPG amex if I got the new Chase Marriott card like a month ago?

like

Recommendations for best ways to save for retirement after contributing to 401k up to match and maxing out Roth IRA?

like

I have a client who needs a 401k, or a solo retirement account w loan options. When I was at UBS/Ameriprise, it was no issue but now it seems tougher to find a firm that does solo 401k as a RIA's.

likehelpful

Hello folks, any credit card suggestions with good benefits and cash-back? Please advise. TIA

like

Cons of moving 75% of my savings to an Intermediate US Treasury ETF (SCHR)? I wouldn’t mind losing 4-5% if the market rallies, but would rather put cash to work if the market keeps tanking

like
like

Personal finance book recommendations?

like

For any of you real estate investors, what tools or sources did you learn from when getting started. Can’t find a mentor currently so want to find some highly recommended books or videos. If focused on the tri-state area (NY, NJ, Long Island mainly) that would be even better. My hope is to buy and rent out a apartment while also owning a house and house hacking that by renting part of it out. Trying to understand all the steps, traps, and how to find if it’s a good investment.

like

Newbie to investing. What are good online courses / books to get smart on investing?

like

What is the name of the credit card that gives you United PQM for each dollar spent?

like

Canadian 🐠 Which ETFs are you buying right now?

like

Anybody here make significant weekly/monthly passive income off Covered Calls and/or selling puts? Looking for success/failure stories for those who have tried this!

like

Quick question - my package includes some fixed component for housing. Say if I spend less than that at actuals, I cannot claim the full amount?

Post Photo
like

When do you predict the dip? I've been waiting for so long, but don't want to buy now. VTI seems inflated.

likefunny

Incoming BA - any advice/links on the math for the best credit card for personal use?

like

What is personal independence??
Why Pwc asked me to fill all investment details for me and my dependant.
Can anyone please help me on this ??

@pwc

like

Has anyone invested in a company that you know was initially started as a RollOver as a Business Startup (ROBS) or a ROBS holding?
I am looking at this as an incubator model to avoid interest payments and other forms of initial capitalization.
I understand the level of risk and the objections some have for ROBS.

like

Nifty 50 index mutual fund vs Nifty ETF ? Which is better ?

More Posts

Hey there..
Please guide on salary bracket based on C-bands..

Hello, Is anyone able to refer at Fitch Ratings Inc. ? I am looking at a structured analyst position in CBMS department. Would love to set up a set up a phone call or zoom to share my background and learn more. Thanks!

like

Do we get mobile phone for Office purpose?

like

Can anyone share their experience for "Wealth Management Americas(WMA) Investment Products IT Change the Bank(CTB) team"? How are projects I mean newer or legacy technology, WLB, team's culture?

like

Bank of America I have come to know there are multiple openings in Product Control dept. I have total 9+ yrs of work experience, can anyone refer my CV?

like
like

What does the “Platforms and Ecosystems” product strategy team do and entail?

like

Generally how long are on sites? Are they all on one day’s block? The entire 4 hours?

helpful

Only sentence that matters... not a single Republican objecting to the election results is objecting to the victory they won on exactly the same day on exactly the same ballots.

likesmart

#SAP - Special Mega Drive on 10 December 2022 

#LTIMindtree is #Hiing.!! For multiple #SAP roles across India.

If anyone interested for below jobs opportunity, Please DM me or share your resume to
lti.referraldrive@gmail.com.. !!

Subject: <Name>_<Skill>_<Experience>_<Notice Period>

If experience is not in required range profile will be auto rejected. Please go through JD before applying.

Need immediate joiners preferred within 0-30 days...!!

Grab this opportunity..!!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Hey, has anyone done the GW Boot Camps, especially Data Analytics Program? Appreciate any good insight on their programs.

like

Jackie is developing her yoga practice

Post Photo
like

After submitting the info for my background verification, I came to know that my ex-employer switched his number. I mailed the verifying entity about it but haven't received any response yet from them. Can they reject my verification based on it solely?

like

Anyone in EY CCaSS? Wondering what the impact of the potential company split might be in terms of the focus and ability to help clients with broader strategy, transformation and technology aspects of their sustainability efforts?

like

Any recommendations for a strong performance media agency?

I’m planning to spend about $300-400K / month.

I’ve engaged a couple independent agencies already but got turned down because we’re “too small”

likeuplifting

Anyone who is joining TCS on 21 Nov got onboarding email?

like

How long does it take to hear back after your final interview for an in house counsel role? I did the final round of interviews for a Bay Area company last Monday and still haven't heard anything. No rejection yet, but the longer I hear nothing, the more I worry they're not confident I'm the right fit.

like

Bloomberg Law or Practical Law if you had a choice?

like

Anyone going to the security/privacy conference in DC this week?

Additional Posts in The Real Estate Bowl

Any investors in the woodlands Texas for single family homes, rent looks good as per Zillow , good school district and houses are still affordable compared to Dallas and Austin

like

Under contract to buy my first home - house hacking a triplex. Property has been leased by the same three tenants for the last 5+ yrs, rents haven’t been raised since they moved in. Market rents have risen 70-100% in the same timeframe. All seem like ideal tenants (retired and take great care of the units) but I’d like advice on how to approach the rent increase conversation. Rents don’t make/break my mortgage payment but I’m leaving a lot on the table if I don’t increase significantly.

like

Please help! Do these fees look within normal range or are they too high? I am especially concerned about the title company fees!

Post Photo
like

Fishes! what are the best grounds to dispute my property tax valuation? What support should I have?

like

Looked at a house (new build) and MIL said the vinyl windows imply the whole house is probably made with cheap, shoddy materials. She thinks everything has to be wood Marvin windows or bust. Is she right? From my research vinyl has its pros too... as long as we aren’t paying like they are wood marvins. Any reactions?

like

Closing on my first home. Advice for anyone with student loans in administrative forbearance per the Cares act: once your offer is accepted have you student loan servicer put your account back in repayment status.

Accounts in forbearance, even administrative forbearance, are calculated at a higher monthly payment by the underwriter.

My fictitious debt to income ratio was too high for them to approve me, and it took seven days for my loan to be officially back in repayment. So just a heads up.

like

Anyone have any luck selling a condo in chicago using Redfin? The 1% fee for listing is attractive compared to the standard 6% with an agent. Are there extra fees with RedFin that I should be aware of? Looking to sell as quickly as possible so weighing the options and just starting to interview agents and look around for the best way to get my place listed.

like

What are the mortgage rates you guys are getting? Best I’ve heard is 2.5% (30year fixed) curious if anyone has heard better?

like

Hi guys! Looking to learn about real estate investing! I am a senior in college graduating with a degree in finance so I understand certain aspects, but am looking to learn more on my own about real estate specifically!

What books would you recommend I read?

like

I have a rental property and my tenant is asking me to change the fridge light burb. I live out of state and don’t have property manager locally. Is it bad if I ask them to change the fridge light burb themselves?

I’m pretty responsive for things they need help with like laundry machine got broken or pantry doors fell off. So I had sent people to fix those maintenance and repair issues.

But light burbs? Srlsy? They are grown up people (fresh out of college girls)

likefunny

Do you recommend getting appliances home warranty (ie American Home Shield) for rentals or do you deal with maintenance issues as they arise (I’m thinking appliances, AC, garage, etc...)? For reference, American Home Shield warranty charges ~$50/month and ~$125/service order!

like

Planning to call the bank today, but wanted to ask this here to see if anyone has experience with something similar.

I found a 6 unit property ( 5 apt + 1 coach house) that I’d like to buy and convert to a 4 apt unit. Is there any way to qualify for an FHA 203k loan since it will be a 4 apt unit after renovations?

Thanks!

like

I am moving to Charlotte, NC for a new job. I currently live in Portland, OR and have a single family home here. With my income, and current mortgage, I can afford a 350k house I’m Charlotte with about 10% down. What are the pros and cons of buying a new place in Charlotte and then sell my house in Portland?

like

Does anyone have experience managing an out of state property yourself? Are there any tips/services you use?

like

UK - thinking of a buy to let in either Birmingham, Liverpool, Manchester - any recommendations on either /areas where you can get something under £140k.

like

In process of buying a house, both my surveyor and specialist damp contractor found damp under kitchen tiles (In the grout) & in skirting boards and up one wall. Sellers had work done initially in 2014 on the wall only(with garuntee) & their company has visited and assured there is no damp… what is next best course of action, get another damp specialist to examine independently of other reports? I don’t trust them….. (U.K. Victorian terrace, damp is in the kitchen extension built circa. 15 y/o)

like

For the folks that bought an a second property (rental) with less than 20% down, how did y’all pull it off ? 10 % down payment is all I can afford.

like

What are your opinions on financing furniture purchases? Most of the big stores are offering 0% for a few years and I’m wondering if there are reasons I shouldn’t do it

like

I am getting a 3% interest rate on a jumbo loan with 20% down on a $850,000 single family home. The ball park in July was 2.65 - 2.75
Checking if folks are noticing a spike in interest rates or if I need to look for another lender.

like

Got news that my house closing may have to be moved due to a delay in the sale of my home. My partner’s income was excluded in the DI ratio, but if it were included we’d be well under the % threshold and can be approved to close on time regardless of the sale of my house. However our mortgage company’s underwriting team has been painfully slow in confirming if her income qualifies. She’s been at her new job 1 month after a year off. Anyone with underwriting experience have insight?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal