{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "2 offers in hand.\nDeloitte - 23 lacs plus 0-15% variable (Advisory Manager)\nBNY Mellon - 29 lacs plus 0-30% variable (still negotiating level)\nThere is an obvious choice comp wise but looking to evaluate other factors like potential of growth, future switches, org structure, work culture, leadership etc etc. \nAny advice from the folks who have some insight would be appreciated.", "post_id": "60f5f0489cbb8a0020dc046f", "reply_count": 4, "vote_count": 3, "bowl_id": "5f0372b0eecc0b001af4c310", "bowl_name": "Consulting India" }

2 offers in hand. Deloitte - 23 lacs plus 0-15% variable (Advisory Manager) BNY Mellon - 29 lacs plus 0-30% variable (still negotiating level) There is an obvious choice comp wise but looking to evaluate other factors like potential of growth, future switches, org structure, work culture, leadership etc etc. Any advice from the folks who have some insight would be appreciated.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

YOE and skillset?

9 plus yrs. Business Analysis in structured finance, Lease accounting, Product management, Vendor Management

Deloitte is good company but looking at the package that BNY is offering go for BNY

How did you get to know bonus part of BNY? I also have an offer from BNY but bonus is not mentioned and hr told me it's about 10 percent on an average. Do you mind connecting on DM?

Related Posts

I’m interviewing a senior tax associate position at BDO, 2 years prior big 4 experience. What salary should I be expecting? LCOL like 80~85 index.

like

PwC Deals SM compensation. How much is it and what’s the lifestyle? Do they travel. It would be the NYC office focused on CDD and growth strategy

like

Hi 👋🏻 I’m new here! For people working in big 4 risk assurance, how many clients do you generally juggle at a time and how many hours do you typically work in a week? I just started a few months ago in an IA role for a company after working in external audit. I like the work, but it’s just not a great culture fit and I’m thinking of boomeranging back to public but for IA to get more of that experience.

like

Does your company offer a referral bonus? If so, how much is it?

like
like

Folks any insights on Engagement Manager vs Cloud PM roles in the PSO org? Pros and cons. And what’s the comp range that one can expect at L6 or L5 level.

like

Has anyone else in NY had an offer delayed? I was told by my EY recruiter that it would take some time to receive the verbal and written offer due to a new background check for NYC residents; I was told unofficially that the team liked me and wanted to move forward and we discussed comp and start date. I’m a little concerned something else is going on and my offer will go to someone else. Am I worrying too much? Thanks! EY

like

Really bummed lately searching for an exit opportunity. 80% of recruiters reaching out to me are from other consulting firms, the other 20% end up falling short on comp expectations. I’m reading a lot of success stories here and it’s encouraging, but I couldn’t help feeling like a loser, not even seeing any of those offers in my current world. I feel like I’ll be stuck in consulting unless I take a 30-50k payout :(

like

Fresh hire - still in probation - but have just been headhunted for a role at a large video games company. Pay matching. Role looks way more interesting and culture is much more chilled but isn’t Amazon. Take it or stay? How much does Amazon really accelerate your career?

like

I’m seeing so many nice affordable rents in Midtown, what’s the catch? Everyone tells me midtown is boring/no culture. Is this true?

like

Anyone working in Intuit? How's the work culture there?

likehelpful

Any Accenture execs out there? I'm wondering about your views on the culture at ACN at the exec level. Got a query from a recruiter recently and I am curious.

like

End goal in PE career? Let’s say you make it to MD at UMM shop. How is comp compared to let’s say F500 C-suite? I’d imagine both to be 10 - 30M, but a cushier rise in F500. Am I wrong? Just trying to figure out this giant rush by so many colleagues to the buy-side

like

Hi does anyone know average dubai salary (in AED) for 14yrs experience solution architect??

like

Considering an influencer diversity role at Marina Maher. It would be a higher role than I have now, but wondering about culture?

like

Looking for insights into / feedback on datadog. Just got pinged by a recruiter and looks like they are a pretty solid firm. Any thoughts on prospects / company culture etc. this opportunity is with their marketing team. Thanks!!

like

acn folks, so I heard that if you have certain hot skills or certificatation you get a special bonus...how do we know what these skills are in our dte? I'm in digital btw..

like

What’s it like at McCann NY? The culture, the work, the work/life balance (if there is one)?

like

DigitasLBi, what’s good? I still get my heart curious since 2016 to you. Benefit wise, culture wise, career development wise? The Asia’s office especially, Any insights?

like

When it comes to compensation, do you care more about immediate rewards (e.g., next year's bonus) or your future earning potential?

like

Additional Posts

Any M 🐠 in their early 30s in San Diego area want to chat and maybe meet up? F/30 here

like

I’m interviewing a senior tax associate position at BDO, 2 years prior big 4 experience. What salary should I be expecting? LCOL like 80~85 index.

like

Hey PwC time to step up your parental leave...

like

Working as a manager in a big 4 in SF isn't enough. Having to pick up driving for Lyft on the weekends, against firm policy of having outside employment.

like

PwC Deals SM compensation. How much is it and what’s the lifestyle? Do they travel. It would be the NYC office focused on CDD and growth strategy

like

What web meeting platform are you using for client meetings? I’m currently using GoTo, but considering switching over to Zoom. (Got rid of Fuze years ago, it was crap)

like

Anyone know if it’s possible to get into McKinsey as an experienced hire without a big referral? I’ve applied to several jobs and not sure if it’s even worth it. Always been a dream to work there...

like

I want to start seeing a therapist but don’t know how best to find the right one. Not into the idea of “dating” around until I find someone. Any recommendations or sites I can reference? Asking in NYC

like
like

Any D Corp strategy folks open to taking about their experience with the firm/team? Consultant in EY’s Strategy practice here and have an upcoming interview

like

Anyone from MBB who is within insurance practice (P&C), would be willing to refer me?

like

Hi 👋🏻 I’m new here! For people working in big 4 risk assurance, how many clients do you generally juggle at a time and how many hours do you typically work in a week? I just started a few months ago in an IA role for a company after working in external audit. I like the work, but it’s just not a great culture fit and I’m thinking of boomeranging back to public but for IA to get more of that experience.

like

Did he ask Mother before doing this?

likefunny

Does your company offer a referral bonus? If so, how much is it?

like

What kept you going when you were trying to break into consulting? I’ve networked a ton and gotten referrals. However it hasn’t translated to interview or recruiters ghost me after the initial screening call saying “they will follow up”. It’s honestly been a very painful process and idk what I’m doing wrong.

like

Anyone own a franchise? What’s your experience, how did you get started and how much did you invest and any lessons learned?

like

It’s pretty wild how much Big 4 demonizes people who leave. Even worse if you’re looking to jump to a competitor. It’s never that serious

like

Any Indoor exercise bike recommendations. Have to burn calories and bring down sugar levels due to bad travel food habbits and lack of exercise

likehelpful
like

Hi fishes. Wanting to teach myself some coding languages and would like advice on the benefits of starting with R vs Python? For context, I just find that I enjoy the quantitative work the most, and am pretty proficient today in SQL, Alteryx, tools at that level, so trying to expand a bit. Would love insights on what lends itself better to working in more data oriented roles in tech. Thanks!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal