For veteran parents - are you at all hesitant about encouraging your children to join the military if they express interest?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

If they express interest, I'll answer questions and be a resource in helping them make their own best decision.

With prior active duty time (that includes combat deployments), and still being in as a reservist, it's almost guaranteed that questions will come up.

I see my role as helping provide insights where they have curiosity, not pushing them in a direction I want them to go.

like

My kid was born after I was out, so she doesn’t know of my military experience outside of what I tell her. Part of me thinks “I joined so you wouldn’t have to.” My working class single parent house didn’t have the financial support for college, and I’ll be able to use leftover state level veterans benefits for her college tuition. That said, if my kid really wanted to join I’d steer to coast guard or Air Force. I’d be a bit upset if one of the others were chosen despite many in the family serving in them. Me and my kid aren’t the same person and I’d rather my kid forge a unique path.

Recent IconRecent

I would neither encourage nor discourage it. I plan just to be open and honest about the experience if my kid asks.

likesmart

Thank you!!

Same answer as others and hope they listen when I say:

Space force
Air Force
Navy
Army
Marines

likesmart

Up to them, but prefer Marine Corps like me.

I'm neither going to encourage or discourage it. I would prefer they didn't but telling a young adult they can't do something is the best way to make sure they will do it.

That's how the Marine Corps recruiter got an 18 year old me to sign lol

If they do join I hope they join the Air Force.

likesmartfunny

All the way! :D

I learned a lot and wouldn't be where I am today without the army.

I would want to understand why they wanted to join and just try to ensure that they understand it is a high risk (potentially) high reward move.

like

NOPE! Mine is going next week to swear-in! I’m so proud of him!

likeuplifting

Congrats! Which branch?

I’d say support your kid so you can guide them.

Benefits paid for my bachelors, financed my house, and pay for my MBA classes.

Air National Guard is best of all worlds. If they love it, going full time is easy. Leaving full time if you hate it is very hard.

As someone from a broke family, it was the springboard I needed. YMMV if you have money already.

I’d also encourage them not to drink the kool aid. Independent thought and not being offended if you’re not thanked for your service is good.

like

Agree 100% thank you!

I do not emphasize that part of my “story” with my kids. I’ve also since moved to Manhattan and almost no one in my kids’ friends groups is American much less an American veteran.

I suspect this environment/approach will successfully turn my past into an interesting dinner-table anecdote as opposed to me needing to dissuade my kids from joining (or worse, outright barring it, which might lead to military service being perceived as an interesting/compelling taboo).

like

Associate 1, that sounds as if your kids are missing out on some very important knowledge about their dad , I’m assuming. I think you can tell your family about your service as long as you don’t romanticize it with your kids and just be real. Your kids saw you going away during your deployment or whatever time it was that you had away maybe? if you withhold that part of your life from them, they’re missing out on some big lessons there, some real things to be proud of about their dad.

My father served a long time, and I just thought that the way we lived was just normal, I thought everybody’s family did that. I’m very proud of my father’s Service, and I’m very proud to be an army daughter. Living a military life gave me some absolute gifts that my civilian friends do not have. I hope you rethink your stance just a little for the benefit of your family.

like

I’d love to have my daughter serve anywhere but the Corps. One Jarhead in the family is enough

funnylike

Never encouraged mine and they both wound up serving. Funny how that works. It's a family business for sure (for all of us). If you're a veteran, your twice as likely as your non veteran counterpart, to have a son or daughter who serves.

All in all, this isn't a good thing as the civilian military divide becomes larger and larger. Not advocating for a draft, but we need ways for the larger population to comprehend what it means to be in the military. Especially for the politicians who send our sons and daughters to fight.

likesmart

I let him know my feelings around it and told him what I knew to be better options, especially with his education. I made sure he had access to better opportunities than I did so he wouldn’t need the Military for money for his education or a reason to travel. I also have always let him know it’s not my decision, it’s his.

like

Very measured and great advice, thank you everyone! I think my only hesitancy would be (having joined the Navy at 21 years old) the toll it took on my joints and liver, but I also gained so much from my experience that I wouldn't change it if I could!

like

I suffered and conquered to break the cycle.

like

Personally I like to let my kids form their own opinions. If they show interest organically somewhere, then I'll offer to help where I can.

like

Hesitant yes. I joined to pay for school. Almost the entire IET company and then my reserve unit was low income. We was mercs basically. But we had no idea we joined the Dept of Offense formerly Dept of War. Downing St Memo sums that up pretty good.

Now that tuition won’t be an issue for my next gen, there is no reason to go that route no more. Although college being a waste of money is its own topic, as is raising kids to have direction and grit. Would be interested in yalls thoughts on those in other threads.

like

I encourage my kids to go college and I let them know that it’s their choice after that. Personally, I’d prefer they didn’t join but I wouldn’t get in their way if that’s what they wanted.

like

Literally my perspective! So many things to consider and rally just want to support them along their path.

I’m gonna let mine watch top gun and a few good men. See which they choose lol

like

YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE TRUTH!!!!

I’m not hesitant at all but if my children decide to go in they will have a plan for what they want out of it, how to maximize their time and resources inside the institution, and an exit strategy. As long as those are laid out and understood then they have my blessing to do as they please.

If they’re interested in service we’re subtly talking up the Coast Guard. Otherwise, the Air National Guard or Air Force.

Hell naw

Related Posts

So my fiancé and I are having a microwedding in Rocky Mountain National Park next year, and we’re working with an elopement planner.
She sent over a sample ceremony (intro, sweet poems + passages to be read, and example vows), and we read through it last night. I was reading it out loud while my fiancé made dinner, and it just hit me that this is really happening. I’m just really happy that I found someone who is willing to take a vow to spend his life with me and I’m so excited for that day :)

like

Got laid off on Friday. Not sure how to handle the feelings and emotions. It will feel weird not going to work on Monday. Didn’t even get to say bye to my co workers

like

I’m thinking about having a baby on my own this year. Every marriage (2) man changed his mind after vows. I’m over waiting on them! I’m 38 and work at a private law firm. Anyone here been here and done that? Joys, pains, regrets, triumphs?!

like

I cheated... we aren’t supposed to do real art in the morning. We watch an art video and discuss in the morning, then in the afternoon we post an instructional video and the kids do a small project at home... I cheated yesterday. I handed out air dry clay and went to town with my 3rd grades.... the kids said it was the most fun art class ever. I will get in trouble for passing stuff out, but I needed it. So did the kids. Best art day all year!

like

At what age as an EA did you marry, if at all? I find myself devoted to my career which leaves little time for a romantic relationship, especially during Covid. Hoping there is some balance to be found in this role!

like

My fiancé will NOT stop talking about her ex. After I found out they were texting arguing she justified it by saying it was about the dogs and not them. Even though Her social media is full of his pics. She still sends him $50 a month for dog food, still goes to work right by his place and suspiciously needs keys. I try to bring it up and I get dismantled for being too mean and making “false accusations.” How much more obvious can it be?

like

Mid 40sF, recently separated, seeking intelligent convo. For the love of god, do not be dishonest. I don’t even care if you’re married and lonely. I get that. Looking for same age range.

like

Anyone have any similar experience or insight? My boyfriend asked for space/not really together anymore and he says he started to become nervous about being in a long term committed relationship. Even tho he said he saw me as long term & I’m his best friend and he loves me but why then? Does space help you guys figure it out? (Help / advice please😞)

like

People who have cheated in their previous relationships, how did you come to realize the reason behind your behavior? A close friend confided in me that she has cheated in all her previous relationships and struggles to understand the reasoning behind it. She feels a lot of shame and is trying to understand why she does what she does.I have suggested therapy but she is not ready yet. How did you folks arrive at the root cause behind your behavior? Advice? Book suggestions that I can pass along?

like

When your also consulting boyfriend has to leave on Mondays.....

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

So uhhh anyone need a house sitter the week before memorials day weekend? Wanted to visit the city and go to the office a few days but my friend who I usually crash with is out of town

like

When did you know you were falling out of love with your partner? Did you fix it, or break things off and why?

In search of stories to hopefully understand a phase in my own long term relationship.

like

Joining ACN and thinking about moving to DC. Thing is I don’t know a soul there. I’ll be traveling so worried about making friends. For people that made the same move, how’s your exp been? cont’d..

likesmart

I am going through a divorce right now. I currently have a (my) family member stay with me to help take care of my children (until the divorce is finalized). My ex is oppose to my family member staying in the same house and decided to serve a notice to vacancy. However, I live in CA (community property state), and both of our names are on the title. Does my ex have any legal grounds to take such action to evict my visiting family member?

AITA? If my SO of 1 year wants to get a dog, do I get an opinion? We don’t live together

I think living a frugal life and aiming to retire early makes a lot of sense.

Recently, some of my family members are diagnosed with a rare diseases. When you look at the statistics, these are so many of these ‘rare’ conditions and cumulatively they are not rare.

These family members conditions made me reevaluate how I want to spend my life. I am 35 this year and I can’t decide if I should take great vacations with my kids or keep living a frugal life. Do you have the same dilemma?

likehelpfulsmart

I’ve been married in a Catholic Church before and now divorced but my now boyfriend says he wants to marry me in a Catholic Church someday. How do I even start a petition for that? Also is that possible to re-marry in a Catholic Church?

like

It really bothers me when I hear kids being referred to as under privileged. We say that to them enough then they start to believe they are less than others 😡

like

My girlfriend and I have been in a long distance relationship for 8 months now. We talk every single day online and recently I went to visit her for around a month. It was great and it seemed like the relationship was stronger than ever. But one week back after visiting her, I felt a strange detachment from her and our conversation topic got repetitive and stale quick. Any advice?

like

So I have been seeing a guy for 4 months. We have a pay disparity.. he earns less than I do (by quite a bit). He has mentioned a few times that he’s worried I’ll get bored of him when I know he can’t afford the same things I can. I think we are beginning to move past this, but now he’s starting to mention things like ‘I am really broke this month’, and last weekend he told me his mum has lost her job and he’ll have to probably pay her rent. I have a lot of sympathy for his situation … tbc

like

More Posts

Guys please give likes to enable chat for me.

like

26th Sept - Advisory Odyssey
Question to Leadership of PwC India - Do you think people would visit a hotel(4-6 PM) just for high tea?
No Lunch, No Gifts?
Why have you even wasted money in booking the hotel, just for high tea? Do you think, people would care about the townhall & go?, if you just give high tea?
Seriously man! I don't even know, why PwC is even coming under Big4! Shame!!

upliftinglikefunny

Hi - I have an interview with Johnson & Johnson for a Leader role. There seems to be multiple interviews with multiple people in the organization. Hoping to get some insight on this process from those who have been through it as it sounds like a great opportunity. What do they look for? How can I ace the interview?

like

Anyone know anything about Facebook Chicago? Good place to be?

Hi all, I’m currently a solution architect with 1yoe and two bachelors degrees. I also hold two cloud certifications and make 60k a year. This seems very low considering what I’ve seen for average SA salaries for those who hold the AWS SAA certification. Was hoping for some insight on this and if I should seek more compensation. Thanks!

like

Hi, I have got an offer with Wells Fargo, India. I have 8+ years experience in .net full stack. I am offered 23lpa fixed + 3 variable. Am i offered low for a 8+ yrs in Wells Fargo? Is so, what's the salary i should request to hr?

like

Has anyone dealt with financing a non-warrantable condo? About to drop out of the deal because I can’t find a lender. My finances are fully in order, issue is the building.

like

How is work life balance in citi for java developer in consumer banking department

like

What’s more important: creative freedom or financial freedom? Trying to decide…

like

This Accenture dress your day thing is awesome. Rocked the jeans, sperrys and a polo into the office with no problem #nomoresuits

like

Why does my left arm keep getting numb when I sleep on my back? Anyone experience this?

like

I don’t understand how people keep posting about the bench and being unassigned. I’m in advisory(not audit) and my entire LoS is trending 90%+ utilization

like

I’ve been in the industry for 23+ years, 16+ of those spent as a Producing Branch Manager. I hold S7, S63, S66, S24 and I’ve completed the education for the CFP (need to pass the exam). I excel in relationship building and providing exceptional service. I’ve only been on the full-service side for the past 2 years and my book of managed money is about $10M, with another $10M+ being self-directed by clients. I’d love to find an RIA job, what type of role would be suggested?

likesmart

Hi guys, what is this Reimbursable Flexible Benefits ( RFB) component in PWC india? PWC HR told me my fixed is 14 lakhs, but I don’t understand this RFB component. Is it some kind of Variable?

Post Photo
like

Hot take. Is FAANG even a thing? Or was Cramer just worried about the acronym if he took out Netflix?

likefunnysmart

Do you think house prices in NJ will go down/up? Thinking of buying a house in 9-12 months and saving. What % is a good down payment? (First time home buyer here)

like

Hi fishes,

Capgemini looking for below manager & senior manager positions.
If interested please let me know.

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes,

If anyone is interested in Capgemini Referral for below opportunities, let me know

Post Photo
like

About how long does it take for McKinsey to produce a written offer after the verbal offer? And then how long does the HR check take / is it just a criminal + employment history check?

like

What is Bain SAC comp these days?

like

Additional Posts in Veteran Bowl

In my prime workout days I could down 3 cheesy Gordita crunches, 1 chicken quesadilla, and a chicken soft taco from Taco Bell ....just tried it 10 years later...would not recommend.

funnylike

Thoughts on Veteran status and the ongoing corporate layoffs?

like

Anyone use a lawyer to get increased disability? If so, any recommendations?

Accenture is in the full gear military recruitment season. I was hired on through the process a few years ago and it’s been great ever since. They have paths for officer and enlisted. DM if interested

likehelpful

Hey Ladies & Gents,

I'm trying to find anyone I can talk to about getting into DISA or CISA. Anyone have any experience with USAJobs and navigating the federal application and interview process?

like

Are there any other Coasties here?

like

Is there anyone in HR that can clarify this for me a little- Hawaii is a state that prohibits future employers from asking your salary. How does this apply to remote positions? Is it only based on the home state of the company? Or would it apply because I am applying from Hawaii?

like

What is the present value of a government pension? How does one calculate it? Trying to get a sense of weather it's worth moving over to Federal.

like

Received bad news from Accenture today. Unsure of what they were looking for. I was referred for on a JMO application.

Post Photo
like

Just want to rant. Failed an interview because I brought up ranger school being the reason I left the military. Cont. Below.

likesmart

Any tips for how to maximize property damage insurance claim?

I'm 1st time landlord and my single tenant in Seattle unfortunately overdosed on cocaine+pills 5 days before found in kitchen. :( Extensive damage.

Seeking tips - ex. contractor validating damage was on highest cost cabinets & flooring, replace all tile/grout, contractors upbid damage value (within reason).

Too many are advising being bold w insurance companies we all pay for most our lives, but open to all advice.

like

I'm prior active duty, now a reservist, and am interviewing with Deloitte (anticipating an offer). What do I need to know about Deloitte's benefits and policies, especially as it relates to drill, annual training, and deployments?

like

Fam, planning to sign up for AASLT as my AT this summer. Ngl, not in best shape currently. How hard is it? How much prep would you recommend?

like

Has anyone in the guard ever picked up long term (12+ months) orders at NGB in Arlington? As an m day guy that title ten would be golden.

likefunny

I went to Strayer

like

Anyone has done state OCS, which is 18 months long and has any insights to share?

like

How’s everyone doing?

like

Anyone here use or know anyone who has used Vet Comp and Pen to get/increase VA disability benefits? Wondering if they’re reputable.

like

My SSBI experience expires next year May, and my investigation is is in adjudication process. What happened my result don’t come back before my investigation expires?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal