A friend of mine works at Accenture and has been contributing to his Roth 401k. He recently read through all the retirement paperwork and found that they don't offer a company match until 1 year after being with the company. He wants to know of he should roll current contributions into a Roth IRA and stop contributing until he's eligible for the match, then go back to contributing with the match once he becomes eligible.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Why would he want to do that? The benefits of a 401k stand, regardless of a match. If he has enough to do so, he should max the Roth IRA, max an HSA if he has one, and keep on contributing any extra to the 401k

like

Not sure what I was trying to say but that is a typo of some sort. Maybe had one more glass of bourbon than I should have. All I was saying is that I would put money in 401k before I put money in a taxable brokerage account

You probably can’t roll from your 401k to an iRA. What would they do instead of contribute to the 401k?

You can’t do in service with drawls except for the after tax 401k. Moot question. If he has enough extra to contribute, Roth 401k is a higher limit and better fees for similar index funds to Roth options. What funds is he invested in is the real question.

Unless the IRA is at fidelity or somewhere with zero index funds. Of course you are getting into minutia at some point. The difference between .01% and zero is $100 per million invested. I am certainly not losing a lot of sleep over that. Plus they may track a little differently and the lower expense ratio benefit is wiped out

Related Posts

Hi all. I am licensed in life, accident and health and am looking for new opportunities. I’ve been working in employee benefits in a small brokerage firm on a book of business of over 400 clients, I’m the only account manager. We’ve had 100% employer retention since I’ve been here. I am a high performer, but not sure I’m valued much at all . I want to reach the top and become partner in my career ; this is why I went to work for a small firm. My boss favors others when I do the most work!!

like

What is an appropriate salary range for a Senior Proposal Writer at a government contracting agency implementing technical solutions? What other kinds of benefits/compensation are possible? Location is in the metro DC area.

like

My dad is forcing me to take a govt job and taunts me pvt jobs are pathetic they won't give pension atleast I'm getting pension

I have a different opinion today govt jobs are less so much competition is there too and i knw i cant crack any govt jobs, Infact i like coding it pays well too. I have many college frnds who still try for govt job but no luck yet. When i look at all these things i think my decision of pvt job is fine he doesn't understand any of these and thinks I'm arguing (cont.)

likefunnyhelpfulsmart

Can someone help me understand how backdoor Roth works in my situation?

I contribute the $19.5K max to a 401K each year. Would backdoor Roth be (A) the ability to roll $6K of that $19.5K into a Roth? or (B) an incremental $6K that I could contribute to a separate IRA then backdoor into a Roth?

Asked another way, does backdoor Roth allow me to actually contribute $25.5K each year, or does it just allow $6K of my $19.5K contribution to build in a Roth?

Thanks!

like
like

Is saving over rated? Starting to think my general strategy/approach to savings. I recently posed a question about why people don’t retire earlier after seeing maxing out your tax accounts (~30K with match) gives you ~70k in today’s dollars (not 70k in 2060 dollars). I was a bit hyper obsessed about saving that extra 2-3k a year and saying no to that extra beach trip or mountain weekend or even a round of golf. Now I think I should be saying yes, what do you guys think? Just curious for thisconv

likefunny

MPH with 8 YOE post undergrad in healthcare/clinical research compliance, QI, program management, academia, VA. Looking to make a move into healthcare consulting. Suggestions on positions or firms hiring? Thanks!!

like

Aside from all the usual benefits like paid vacation time, health insurance, 401k matching program, have you ever seen a truly unique business perk?

like

I’m a PM at a healthcare tech company. Been in mostly client facing roles for years. I’ve found these clients can be verbally abusive, flat out lie, exaggerate issues or have exceptionally high demands beyond what my company promised. My leadership agrees with us but struggles to support and doesn’t know what to do w/o risking the relationship with clients. It’s been extremely demoralizing for my project teams. Other client facing PM’s here, what are your tips on dealing with bully clients?

like

Looking to transition out of Healthcare sales into SaaS and would like to get a position with Salesforce, Gartner or even move into the public sector. Just looking for some guidance and advice on anyone who has done this successfully and if you have any contacts that be helpful to learn from.

More of a benefits negotiation -How do I request for a company vehicle? I drive around 450 miles on a weekly basis for work site and my employer covers all vehicle expenses (gas, insurance, maintenance) but I drive personal car while my other PM colleagues have company vehicles.

likehelpful

Help!!!
The girl I am about to marry in Ind says she spends 100% of her salary every month and has credit of ~80k. Her likes include Partying, Shopping etc. Should I be worried or is it ok lately?

funnylike

Larsen & Toubro Infotech Hello Fisher,
I have some questions on LTI , please response 🙏 1. How is the work life balance? Is there any screen tracker ?
2. Is it ok for long term?
3. How much health insurance coverage they provide for family including parents? Is there any top up option? (My mom is suffering from some major diseases) Larsen & Toubro Infotech

like

How are Amazon benefits? Any really good perks you like?

like

6 months pregnant and just laid off. And 40% of my severance was just taken in taxes .. I just spoke with paid family leave and I no longer qualify even though I had been paying into the program (thanks NY).. I already applied for unemployment but doctors are telling me I’ve got 10-14 weeks left in this pregnancy.. so stressed having twins and being unemployed, no maternity leave, no paychecks coming in, and I’ve been applying but not a single interview.. just ugh. 😭

like

Anyone has any idea about CVS healthcare project in cognizant, how is the wlb n environment ?

Does Amex welcome bonus jail apply to all cards like platinum? Also any way to get out of it(or at least know you are denied bonus before you get a 5/24 chase hit on you)

like

Our 401k’s will go to hell! Vote red!!!

likefunny

529 plans question - what are the general thoughts on the age-based funds that do investment allocations for you vs. other options? They seem to be similar to target date funds in a 401k but not sure if there are any drawbacks I should be thinking about

More Posts

What's you travel Status?

like

How much studying is necessary for the FL bar if you are only taking the FL portion? Feeling overwhelmed doing this while working full time.

like

So there’s a major airline here in the South whose ENTIRE marketing/social team is white women. Should I even try to apply? That’s so…offputting.

like

Could someone please explain what cognitive computing really is? Is it just code that is written in a way that learns over time

Anyone buying VMware after the CEO news?

like

How much do you gift for a friend's wedding if you have to travel to a different city to attend?

like

Anyone have any thoughts on support groups? Considering it but I also feel like I should beware

like

NSR registration is mandatory for experience person to join TCS?

like

Congrats everyone! This week was terrible with omicron, schools closed, backlogged work from the holidays, general malaise from two years of a pandemic, etc. It might have been the most difficult week of my career so far. But, we made it. Kudos to everyone. Here’s hoping that next week is better.

like

i really dislike my significant other’s family. i feel terrible because he loves mine and constantly says so.

i can’t tell him that, so just venting here. any tips with dealing with that?

like

How much do you make as a DON and how many years experience do you have? What state do you work in?

The Investment Advisor, a registered investment adviser is looking for experienced Investment Advisors in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Must have Series 65 and book of business. Call 570-815-0770

like

C with 5 years of experience. Both IQVIA and Lilly offering similar pay (28-30 CTC). Which should I prefer in terms of salary growth and wlb.

like

Starting my own firm and was wondering what bank is the best for iolta? Also any affordable software, resources, etc that you recommend or don’t recommend for the beginning? Thank you!

like

I have applied to Actis and expecting to receive the online assessment, any insights?

like
like

My wife is using my credit card too much.
Monthly around 13K.

Everytime I confronted her the ending is always the same, I loose the argument and end up paying everything.

like

I don’t know what to make of this. I’ve been out of work and interviewing for 3.5 weeks now. I feel like they go really well, then I get, we will call you and let you know we have a couple other candidates. Then poof nothing. SMH…I am very skilled and would be a great benefit for someone. Has anyone else run into this problem? Please any advice would help. Thanks so much.

likehelpfuluplifting

What is going salary for a senior associate in FDD right now?

like

That feeling when you have cleared all the technical interview rounds and waiting for HR round to happen and initiate your resignation at current organization !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I check my email and mobile 1000 times to check any revert from HR team :D

likefunny

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

529 plans question - what are the general thoughts on the age-based funds that do investment allocations for you vs. other options? They seem to be similar to target date funds in a 401k but not sure if there are any drawbacks I should be thinking about

I anticipate getting a low interest 24 month loan (hoping 0%) next year of about 15k.

I am currently living "paycheck to paycheck" (after maxing retirement accounts). But I have cash savings from inheritance in a HYSA: 15k emergency fund + 20k excess cash.

I can afford to pay the loan in full immediately, but assuming low rate, I don't plan to. What's the best strategy here? I can't just invest my 20k excess cash because I live paycheck to paycheck and can't afford the minimum payments (cont)

likehelpful

What do ya'll think of this? Should i cut down and focus on a few? Been passively putting a little since march but upped it a little after august since i started work

Post Photo
like

Hypothetically, if you expected a civil war, how would you prepare from a financial standpoint?

likefunny

If you were an investor, what sectors to invest in this type of market

Higher inflation

like

My wife IT analyst and she wants to quit what job is a good alternative

likefunny

Can anyone send me a Betterment referral?

like

I was originally going to purchase a house but I decided to put that off for a year. I have about $170,000 in my ” high-yield savings account” but it’s only at .035%. What could I do with this money in the short term? I won’t need it for at least a year and a half. 

I have another 100k exposed to the market via wealthfront in an investment account and about 30k in crypto. I have 12 monthly of emergency fund in my bank.

any advice would be appreciated?

like

What’s the difference between putting my savings into a high yield savings account vs into a bond ETF? Which is better? Thanks!

For those who have analyzed COIN—thoughts on buying right now?

like

Is FAANG now MAANG?

like

People who have a million or so in your investment accounts - have you tried taking a loan against it to invest in S&P500? I could do this if I bought a home, but because of personal situation, can’t buy a home now. Still want to make the most of low interest rates now. Thanks in advance folks!

like

Robinhood users - is there no way to see the total YTD realized gains??

like

Does anyone use Merrill Edge? Opened an account because I'm a longtime BOA customer and the platinum honors rewards were attractive. Now the preferred deposit rates sunk from 2% to. 06%.. HYSA gone

like

Hello everyone, I'm trying to get into real estate investing. Some of the books I've read have talked about buying a multi unit property and utilizing investors to get the necessary capital. Does anyone have experience in getting investors? How do you identify investors who may be interested? Are there any sites where you can invest in or post investment opportunities?
Thank you in advance.

like

So I’m currently trying to figure out what to do next in terms of finances. I’m 25 in Tier 1 city. Salary is $115k

-$40K in Roth
-$17K in my emergency fund
-$10k in equity gains on my house

- $15K left in student loans but going to hold off to see if we get some sort of forgiveness
- my bills are about 50% of my salary

If you were in my shoes, where would you invest next?

like

How do you balance retirement savings with shorter term goals? I max Roth IRA and put in 10% to 401k on top of 7.5% employer contribution. But I also want to save for events in 3-10 years like bschool living expenses (tuition will be covered by sponsorship), wedding, down payment, and parents’ retirement. I’m also paying 1k monthly to student loans to get rid of them by EOY 2021. I understand I’ll lose out on tax/compounding benefits, but I’m assuming my future earnings...

like

What have people’s experience been with Ellevest? Is it worth it?

like

Reaching out to this savvy group.. any tips for leasing a car? Interested in a Volvo and the monthly price quoted at dealership was nearly 2x what was listed on their website. (Cont)

like

Thoughts on target date funds vs. index funds? 30yo with long time horizon, and concerned about drag of bonds on my target date fund.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal