I was in a meeting, and there was a new attendee, a fellow Asian guy.

Senior member: “Hi [new attendee’s name], where are you from?”

New attendee: “from [city and state]”

Senior member: “No, where are you reeeeaaaallllyyy from?”

**awkward silence**

New attendee: “from God”

Well… 🫣

If you are an immigrant and people ask you where you are from, how do you usually respond?

likefunnyhelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Is there a polite way to ask someone what their ethnicity is? Obviously the “where are you reeeally from” is rude but I also don’t think that people who ask that question mean it in a malicious way typically. Is the topic of culture/ethnicity just off limits at work? I ask all this as a white guy who grew up around a lot of Asian and Indian people and was fortunate to be exposed to a lot of different cultures.

likesmart

A] India is in Asia. Indians are Asians too
B] No. Do white people get asked that?

like

“What is your ethnicity?” is how I like to be asked.


-second gen Asian American.

likehelpful

I get tired of saying I'm from Oregon, Boston, and Maryland... I now say, "born & raised in Seoul, Korea." I also never refer myself as a Korean-American anymore, too long, once over 40 years old I just don't give a shit anymore.

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

I once asked where someone of a different ethnicity was from because of their accent.

Not because they sounded foreign, but because they sounded like they were from the same area I grew up. (They were!)

But I realized how it must have first came off!

likesmart

As an Asian immigrant that gets asked this, I try to see the good intent behind these questions and say, I was born in (country) and my parents decided to move and I grew up (here, here, and here).

I married into a family of European immigrants and they often share, with pride and without any question, their heritage.

So, I try to remember this is just a point for us all to connect and to be proud of our own history.

like

I appreciate it when people ask me where I’m from. Anyone I meet probably knows my ethnicity but doesn't want to assume where I was born. That’s a good thing!

I used to get offended by the “where are you realllllly from” questions. So now I make it easy for everyone and respond with, “I currently live in (insert city), but I’m originally from India.” It puts everyone at ease!

The question I hate more than anything is, “oh, how come your English is so good?!” I rarely have a good reaction to that one!

like

I think I would still follow the same principal! I would just say originally from whichever American city , or " (city) born and raised
" or something like that.

This thread makes me wanna ask a bunch of white people where they're REALLY from just for fun 😂😂

likefunny

I don’t think too much about it as an immigrant. Grew up somewhere else, I say it when asked. I don’t know why assuming I’m from elsewhere is offensive if I have a physical characteristic that suggests I might be. Whatever.

like

It's not that asking the question or being curious about it is wrong, I think it's that they weren't happy/interested with the first answer and would rather keep digging for an answer that makes sense to them. It shows an ignorance of diverse/multicultural backgrounds and the senior doesn't try to ask more respectfully or show genuine interest the second time around. It seems like this person assumed the Asian person was from "somewhere else" when they asked and when the answer didn't seem to fit that assumption, they keep looking for an answer that fits their preconceived ideas rather than actually respecting this person's identity and origin. The intent seems pretty clear in the way in which the question was asked twice.

like

I usually respond “[city]” and if they ask “where are you really from”, I respond with a nice email to their superior and HR

likefunny

I prefer to go with now "what's your background?" It doesn't sound as rough as "ethnicity" and it allows people to give a general story of themselves

like

Yikes 😳

likesmart

Planet earth 🌏 you?

like

Not cool

like

I say “If I tell you, you might not really know where”. 😆 phrasing depends on how annoyed I am.

like

I’m a new immigrant (moved as an adult). This was one of the things I heard about and was like oooo I AM READY FOR THIS since I’m actually a foreigner! What I was NOT ready for was the following:

Them: “Where are you from?”
Me: “Non-US Country X”
Them: “But like… where did you grow up … in America??”
Me: “I’m… I’m not American??”

This happens weirdly frequently and baffles me. I’ve even had people suggest areas in the US that I grew up in where I guess there’s a heavy concentration of people with my ethnicity??

likefunny

I have people tell me ' oh but you speak such good English' inside I am like duh thanks to the Britah colonizing the world I can't speak my own language properly

like

Perhaps they are trying to be nice. But Asians are conditioned to ask questions from their young age. For instance Asian moms ask tons of questions to their kids returning from school and to their friends visiting home etc etc

funnylike

It could be, the way she mad it sound, yeah some sounded like they where being friendly, though others sounded a bit sketchy and gave her a feeling they where trying to take advantage of her based on where she was from.

like

This is a teachable moment that you can leverage to reduce the amount of ignorance in that question.

1. I grew up in Dallas and identify as a Texan.

Where are you really from?

2. I was born in New York before I moved to Texas

No, where you are reallllly from?

3. Oh, if you're asking where my family originates from, my parents grew up in Hong Kong and immigrated to the states back in the early 70's. So, senior manager, where are you reallly from? :)

I give people the benefit of the doubt, as they typically don't realize their ignorance shines through their mode of questioning. Replying with snarky remarks does not build any good will and can further alienate you.

like

Good thing you are so patient.

like

Just because you're "curious" or you "find it interesting" does not mean it is relevant to or appropriate for the workplace. It reads as thinly veiled racism, regardless of intent. Let someone offer personal details about themselves as they are comfortable, and in the meantime accept the reality that's it's really none of your business.

likefunny

Just say “what’s your ethnic background? I’m curious” - also maybe consider having this as a 1:1 convo instead of putting the person on the spot in a meeting.

like

Sure, for ME it’s ok. I’m a POC. If I’m having a 1:1 conversation like a coffee chat or something, I really think “what’s your ethnic background if you don’t mind me asking?” Is ok. I would also say no if I didn’t want to answer. It’s way better than “where are you from?” Or “where are you REALLLLLY from?” I wasn’t born here. So that’s still my actual lived heritage I’d be telling them about. I can imagine someone whose family’s been here for generations may feel different. BIPOC are not a monolith when it comes to our comfort.

like

I’m an immigrant born in another country and raised in an American city. I usually just say “I was born in X but I grew up in Y.”

If I want to know (I usually do bc I like to connect w fellow immigrants), I ask AFTER I divulge my background so the other party knows they’re talking to a friendly party, and then my question is “what is your heritage?”

That way the other person can divulge as much as they feel comfortable, and it sounds more interested (I want to know more about your culture / background) than interrogative (“well you don’t LOOK like you’re from Iowa…”)

like

Also I would add that I only go down that path if it’s reasonable to think their family came to America relatively recently so we can connect on the immigrant experience. I don’t usually ask white Americans or black Americans

like

I was just in a D&I workshop where we discussed saying 'what's your ethnicity?' or 'where did your grandparents grow up?' instead.
I'm an expat working with expats, and I still don't think that's ok. What do you'll think?

like

I’m adopted, so it doesn’t matter how far up the family tree the question goes. My answer is somewhere along the East coast of the US.

like

It’s a judgment call- some people are just trying to break the ice or be nice, and others are just being rude.

like

Always good to call it out.
"I am not going to answer that now. Lets talk later and we can both share our personal backgrounds and experiences"

like

I can facepalm only so many times here, folks.

like

Related Posts

I saw some job postings on LinkedIn for Vedder Price. Does anyone have insight regarding the firm and culture

like

Hello fishes, got an offer from KPMG Global Services, Mumbai as Consultant - SPI (within Deal Advisory).
Can anyone help me know the quality of work, work culture and wlb ?

Other offers I have -
ZS Associates - Business Operation Associate Consultant, Mumbai.
Quantiphi - Senior Business Analyst, Mumbai.

Hi Fishes,

How is Birlasoft company overall ? please do comment as per your exp. It is urgent.

#wlb #projects #work-culture #growth

Looking for some direction here from Melbourne community. My fiancé is moving to NZ for school. To be closer to her, I am exploring opportunities in Melbourne. I am a CPA in Canada with 7 years of experience in corporate finance and FP&A under my belt. Would anyone here to open to sharing some tips that may help me transition easily into Australian culture? Specifically - what’s the best avenue to search for jobs as a foreigner? How do you budget for CoL? Are there green spaces in the city?

like

Hi fishes,
Just wanted to know work life culture in publicis. Got selected and I’m in a confusion on seeing glassdoor reviews.

like

Considering a job at Boston Consulting Group project leader in Org Design. What’s the culture like? Any sense of pay bands?

like

How is Capgemini in terms of job security and work culture?
How much CTC to expect from Capgemini with 10 years of experience in QA domain?
Capgemini

like

My fiancé just made Aliyah for med school. Long distance is hard but I love my job/firm culture. I wish I could stay, but I’ll need to switch to a firm that allows working abroad in a year at the latest. In a year, we get married and I make Aliyah too. I’m afraid to tell anyone at my firm. I’m also looking for American companies that pay well and allow employees to live in Israel. Thoughts? Advice?

Can anyone share work culture and flexibility in olam Chennai. Also what is salary range and incentives for associate director in olam.

like

Hey Fishes

I got an offer from gaming company @pragmatic play Hyderabad for SDE 1.
Not sure how the company work culture and work life balance and all.

If anyone has idea. Please do help.

Thanks in advance.

like

Fenwick & West LLP Can anyone advise on choosing between Cooley LLP / Fenwick & West LLP / Gunderson Dettmer / Orrick for EC VC work as a mid-level? All NY office. Ultimately would want to work in-house post-big law.

like

Any thoughts on AlixPartners London culture? This would be for a Director role in their Enterprise / Performance Improvement team.

like

How is the work culture of BNP Paribas Bangalore Bagmane ? Do they offering work from home , what's the dressing style ,is it formal which needs to follow ?

like

Hey Guys, I have an offer from Barclays for Analyst- Financial control. Would like to get your views about the work culture & benefits which the org. offers. How's the bonus and year end increments like?

like

So am I naive for wanting to develop friendships with my coworkers? It seems like everyone has a life outside of work and as much as we talk about being collaborative and teamwork, no one on my team actually wants to develop friendships. Is it pointless? Like I don't want to waste my time but I do think the work culture would be more enjoyable?

likefunny

We’re hiring for a ton of digital marketing positions across the US, and have a great culture - consistently voted among best places to work. Reach out to me if you’re interested.

like

Hello,
I would like to know about
Siemens Balewadi, Pune (Smart Buildings / Infra account)
How is the work culture, wlb, what are some Pros and Cons?

like

My work from home customer support people, do you miss the in person company culture or you’re good? Cause same

like

Looking for info on the Meta Reality Labs Global Marketing team, specifically Meta Quest. Have an offer and would like to get the real scoop on WLB/team culture. Does anyone work there, have a friend there, or have the deets? Happy to DM, too. ☕️🫖

like

More Posts

Is anyone else unfollowing all “influencers” on Instagram? I’m finding their posts to be so out of touch with what’s happening across the global to people’s lives (both health-wise and economy-wise.) They’re still trying to push a more is better mindset. I get that’s part of their business model, but I just can’t take it anymore.

likeupliftingsmart

Did 4 rounds of interviews. Last 2 with 2 partners at EY. Haven’t heard back even after 1 month. One partner even commented “you will be a good addition to the team”. Hiring manager gave EY email after her interview call with me.
Fast forward two weeks, no communication. Recruiting was surprised that I was still chasing for this position, month later. Got to know last week that hiring team was continuing to interview candidates. Should I drop the idea to get hired? EY hasn’t rejected me yet.

like

We bought a condo in February 2022 then as you know prices are going down while rates are flying up 😭 We're quite worried about the value of our home and can't really enjoy it. What's your thoughts about this? PS. First time home buyers 🤫

like

HCM / PAS / T&O/HP practitioners - are any of you members of professional organizations (ACMP, etc.)? Any recommendations?

like

Hi Everyone. I am applying for a few design positions and I just got a response from a company that wants me to do a short video as part of a campaign. The problem is that I have 24 hours their instruction is: "An awareness video (please avoid stock video, we want to see your proficiency on Adobe After effects). Please focus on this, as this is the most important item of this assessment". So my question is. Are they being unrealistic? Also. Where can I find good stock videos? Lol

funnylike

What is the TC range for managers in Accenture's Salesforce practice? Coming in with 4 YOE, 7x SF certs and am currently manager in the Technical Architect team at a boutique SI partner(1000-3000) employees. Thanks for the help! Accenture

likefunny

Anyone familiar with CVS Health’s L&D strategic plan or willing to share info about the L&D department? Prepping for an upcoming interview.

like

Hi all, can someone refer me for this role?

https://gartner.wd5.myworkdayjobs.com/EXT/job/Gurgaon/Data-Analyst---Business-Analytics_72978?source=JB-10120&source=JB-10120

ID 72978

I am currently in PwC, 14 months work ex in SAP, wanting to switch domain to analytics, versed in machine learning, deep learning using python.

Thanks in advance

Hijabi challenges/experiences in workplace?

like

Looking to move to Boston (ideally southie or back bay). Anyone know anyone looking for a roommate for a 2BR/2BA in a nicer high rise or have suggestions for other things to consider?

Feel like this has probably been asked in here 1,000x but...

I have an idea for a web+mobile based platform

I’ve done market sizing, know exactly what it is and how it’ll work, and even have verbal seed funding offers.

But I can’t code.

What do I do next and how do I protect my idea from being stolen?

like

Planning to resign, will I get my retirals and leave encashment?

like

Is ValueLab good company to join ?? I have offer in pipeline. How's the WLB and Job Security??
I heard they have hire fire policy ???

I know it comes with the job but the non-stop LinkedIn Messages are starting to get old. The legit requests are one thing but I get dozens of solicitations which week...

like

What kind of copyright work can you practice for clients outside your jurisdiction without violating ethical rules besides copyright registrations.

10x Crypto Elena Cardone .

Post Photo
like

McK 🐠 : CBS MBA here and I got invited to interview for the SA role in Atlanta. Any case/experience tips to maximize my chances of getting an offer?

like

What’s the difference between a porcupine and a BMW?

Looking for a referral for product manager roles. Currently in GM. Working as a PM. I have 6 YOE in Java DEV backend , Analytics and recent 7months in PM. SAFe Agile certified. Located in MI.
Looking for remote roles that will do an H1B transfer and would apply for GC eventually.
If anyone can refer me please let me know.

like

Additional Posts in #OverheardAtWork

“Chatroulette, but for apartment peepholes."

likefunny

“Isn’t meth, like, so early 2000’s? Does anyone do that anymore?”

likefunny

"Can you make it feel more like blueberries taste?" ACCOUNT TO CREATIVE

likefunnyhelpful

Recent client discussion (on a million + dollar dispute over secured FF&E).

Client: we need to do some thug shit to them.

Me: I don't typically recommend thug shit as a litigation strategy. Here's my thoughts...

Client: well I guess we can do this legit. Interesting...

funnylike

Today someone quit and just straight up walked out of the office. Like something you'd see in a movie. My jaw is still open. You ever seen this happen?

likefunnyupliftingsmart

Thoughts on “special” salary grades. I just found out the VP I was offered is not a grade 12 like most comparable roles (verified). Also not an 11, but an 11A. Slightly higher than an 11, a good bit lower than a 12. All due to the fact that it’s a leap from my current position. Why should that matter…..shouldn’t it pay what it should pay if I am selected, rather that curving down towards my current rate?

like

I'll stick around for the bonus but want to make my side hustle my main career next year.
The side hustle is Scentsy...

funnylike

“Do you think art directors look at images online for inspiration?”

funnylike

"Do you really think we can spend all that money?"

These were influencer managers not media

likefunny

“This report is like a bikini. What it is showing is interesting; what is beneathbthe cover is crucial.”

likefunnysmart

“Those glasses don’t make you look younger, they make you look older—but slightly more cool.”

🥺

likefunnyhelpful

“business advice: open the attachment” -RHONY playing in background

likefunny

From a UX Director... “Design is everything. You’re nothing without design.” Excuse me?

funny

"I don’t like morning people. Or morning. Or people”

Words of Wisdom

likefunny

I don’t have a horse in this fight

funnylike

What's more important for business longevity?
Value your customer's needs or your employees sanity/ mental wellness?

The company I work for clearly value the customer more and I feel that it's not aligned to my personal values :(
It makes me wonder if I'm the "crazy" one to believe the company should value their people first?

like

What type of background check do HF/PE/VC forms so these days? Employment, education and felonies are a given (I think) but is fingerprinting and drug testing still in the mix? How about credit score?

like

“Bad news, we’ve had to eliminate the position that we were supposed to finalize your promotion to. Good news, your current position is still available and the prestige of your current role is now increased”
Not the money, not the title, bonus or anything, but oh the prestige.

likefunnyhelpful

“Just came back from Hawaii, it was beautiful. Lots of good wine”-MD.
Tired analysts: 😒😒

likefunny

You know who gets that raise or bonus or even a promotion? It's not the hard worker. Not even the smart worker. It's the worker who advertises every task they did (small or big) in front of the whole team...

likefunnysmart

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal