Do you think diversity training actually works? I can't tell if it's just a way to tick a liability box or if it's actually effective.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've been working in D&I for 5 years and I still wonder that. I think this industry is so situational success wise. Really depends on where you work and what they stand for.

like

It works if you get every single one from leadership buy in. Not just diversity training but DEI efforts as a whole. Depending on the organization and where you are in your DEI journey, it may take a couple years to get everyone's buy in. I'm still working on that myself but it has to be everyone, not just people with DEI in their job title or responsibilities.

like

My company hired a DEI consultant to come in and tell everyone that yt people should feel guilty and bad by default, and default to hiring minorities over skills. Not exaggerating.

Conversely, I got a good buddy hired last year. She’s a black lesbian female. She called me crying last week after attending a work event (never seen her cry before) because she was the only black person there and the only one intentionally not invited to dinner or drinks or anything.

Everything I’ve seen points to it being just a box to check, to cover them.

like

I think I see this as a reaction to the company trying to react to social equity goals internally. they may not have the right execution plan and role out to establish better diversity. they may benefit from finding an ESG Specialist to consult with them. you have an opportunity to be part of the solution using the experience of your friend.... both of you can be momentum for improvement. help your company learn and hold them accountable. no one deserves to be marginalized, in sorry that happened. Wishing you and your company well.

No 🥺 People in power are ok with the status quo.

It can work but is often just a box tick or PR thing.

It does work. It works in my company and the mandatory training that is given to all leaders have been very effective.

No, people are people. It’s just due diligence.

I don’t know if it works for several reason. 1- people are selfish and seem to push their “minority” above others, 2 - people may not agree on certain topics under the diverse umbrella so they reject the whole system. 3 - people work to make a paycheck- not always to feel like a part of a work “family” or feel like they can be their real selves.

If your asking about DEI training for your workforce including leaders…I would say not really. The folks who already support DEI will use the training to help them be even more mindful or thoughtful or may try and implement something new. The folks who already don’t see the value…still won’t see the value. I think you have to define what the objective is…what are trying to get out of training? Awareness? Compliance/Regulatory obligation? Well I think training can support those needs. However if the objective is behavior change then it would be a hard no.

Related Posts

Don't miss out 2023 Global Diversity and Leadership Conference on November 1 - 3, 2023! Recommended by Aché Lytle at 2022 NPA Annual Conference via Whova event app

like

What do you wish you knew before starting your career in Diversity & Inclusion?

like

Any advice from fellow women in this industry? How did you overcome gender biases?

like

Would you categorize this industry as diverse? I was just reading an article on USA Today that centered around the lack of diversity in finance, especially in positions of power. I’d have to agree with them based on what I’ve noticed.

like

Any agencies putting their money where their mouth is with addressing the Gender and Minority pay gap or is it all just BS/ lip service?

like

Agency Idea: The Ginger Group. Redheads only. You should see our Diversity and Inclusion page!

likefunny

How is it at the BDO Boston office? Is there diversity in people and what is usually the number one complaint?

like

Drinks today near Chelsea/Midtown area? 32 - F
Pls share age/gender

like
like

How do you professionally address a noticeable lack of diversity on your team? More than 85% of my team is white or white passing, and of the remaining individuals none are Black, Indigenous, or AAPI.

like

General question: Is there any room in corporate America for real, actionable DE&I discussions and initiatives? I've observed so many corporate versions become an advertising strategy (SM posts, diversity reports) without doing the actual work (increasing representation in senior leadership, salary analyses, having an effective reporting system for bias). Is this just how it is?

like

Anyone from Nationwide? I’d like to hear feedback from current and old employees about the work environment, salary (G3), development, diversity etc. I completed an interview for Claims Manager position.

like
like

Any consulting firms that are particularly good for Jews or which honor Jewish holidays? My firm has a Jewish diversity team but I’d love to learn about others.

like

Everyone talks about diversity all the time, but I'll just say, I've never once seen a news anchor who wasn't abnormally pretty (girls OR guys). Just sayin' is all

like

Do any of you spend time on HNBA or other affinity organizations? If so, do you bill your time as non-billable, i.e. diversity? And how do you balance your time going to an events/getting involved?

like

I have an offer to move to Detroit to work. What’s advertising life like there? Is it a diversity community (ask since Detroit is like 85% black and I’m a black man)?

like

I have taught Pk-2 (full time aides) & SpEd inclusion K-8 with parapros. This will be my first time alone in a classroom of 27 3rd graders. What is your favorite project to do in 3rd??

More Posts

like

If I join pwc india in mid of August 2021. Will I be eligible for next year that is 2022 hike and performance bonus. Please enlighten me.

like

I don't understand the point of hiring candidates. Its been more than two months and i am sitting idle. There is no updates from management. I am getting info like i will get half salary this month because of the bench policy. I m confused what to do next

like

S&P Global Hi All, can anyone please help me with salaries of SDE 2 at 9 grade for 5.5 YOE.


I’m in negotiations this would really really help S&P Global

like
like

What's the average CTC of OSP State lead in Jio

like

I have three offers
1. Jio -9.5 lpa fixed + 1lpa vp + 1lpa jb
2. Evc Ventures - 11 fixed +3.5lpa vp
3. Unified Cloud -11.5fixed

No 2 and 3 is not MNC.
My LWD is Aug end.
May I know if I can negotiate with jio for counter offer ?

Thanks

Hi Fishes

I have an offer from Reliance Jio at node Js developer and experience is 7.5 years so should i join or not ??

like

I have an offer from JIO and BottomLine.
Which one is better and recommend to join.

Can anyone suggest on it?

like

What is the average hike provided in Reliance Jio for an employee who is already at market standard and at Manager position. Consider he rated top in a fiscal year with no promotion? Please consider 4 year average while answering if possible.

like

How do you cook chicken breast so it stays juicy? Also how do you warm up leftover chicken so it stays juicy so you can cook less frequently? When I make chicken it is so dry and tastes terrible warmed up.

like

Larsen & Toubro Infotech Is anyone aware of NatWest account? Are there onsite opportunities ? WLB ? Larsen & Toubro Infotech Wipro Tech Mahindra Tata Consultancy

like

Those who perpetuate the myth that the only valuable people are those who worked at specific agencies are the same people keeping this industry homogeneous. There is more than one path.

likeupliftingsmart

In offer letter, nothing is being mentioned about being on permanent role...how to make it sure

Recommendations on emotional intelligence/leadership books, trainings, classes, coaches?

like

Prior to applying, on average how many current students, alumni, or adcom members did you connect with from each program?

like

do schools even consider the IR and AWA sections if they dont factor into score?

like

If we take the GMAT online, does it actually take a full 7 days to get the results? Or do you have unofficial results immediately after?

like

How long should it take to hear back after a final round BCG experienced hire interview? Does it vary with campus recruiting going on now?

like

Additional Posts in Diversity & Inclusion

Does anyone have experience with starting a Business/Employee Resource Group? I would really like to start one for Middle Eastern and North Africans as my company does not have one. There are many discussions that could benefit others and opportunities for intersectionality here. TIA!

like
like

My company has ERGs and one of them is pretty large and includes a lot of demographics. Within it, people are starting to kind of form their own subgroups (like based on office location or country-specific ethnicity). Does anyone have any thoughts around what would be appropriate for DEI practitioners to be aware of when serving these populations?

like

Do you feel like your work is making a difference at your current company? Why or why not?

like

How do you professionally address a noticeable lack of diversity on your team? More than 85% of my team is white or white passing, and of the remaining individuals none are Black, Indigenous, or AAPI.

like

General question: Is there any room in corporate America for real, actionable DE&I discussions and initiatives? I've observed so many corporate versions become an advertising strategy (SM posts, diversity reports) without doing the actual work (increasing representation in senior leadership, salary analyses, having an effective reporting system for bias). Is this just how it is?

like

I’m interviewing for a newly created position, Assistant Director of Communications & Outreach in my organization’s DEI office. This is the first interview they have requested after reviewing my writing sample. They didn’t say who specifically I would be interviewing with, but said “members of the DEI staff”, and it will be virtual.

What types of questions outside of my marketing/communications background should I expect?

like

Hey everyone! Does anyone have a list of top companies in the US that are truly diverse and inclusive. I’m disabled poc and a recent grad as of December 2021 and I’m looking to start applying to other jobs as my current company has not been accommodating at all. TIA!

like
like

In honor of National Voter Registration Day, The New Yorker released the transcript of a previously unpublished interview with James Baldwin, who gave a first-hand account of "Freedom Day 1963," a Black voter-registration drive in Selma, Alabama. Baldwin's descriptions from that day are so vivid and detailed that you can feel the fear and anger of the event. If you have a couple of minutes, I highly recommend you read it.

like

Current DEI Professional, can everyone support me on the likes so that I can unlock being able to message someone. I will do the same in return. Thank you

like

I’m trying to cultivate discussion oriented DEI spaces, any topical themes that would make fun and engaging discussions?

like

Our team is about to recruit and we are trying to live our DEI values. Any tangible actions you can suggest to how we can widen our attractiveness to a more diverse candidates? Applies internally and externally. Thanks for any suggestions.

like

Hey I have an large project idea but I am looking for a business partner who is interested in helping fund the project. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to find a business partner like that?

like

I have often wondered if being honest when I fill out EEOC / diversity forms if that limits me from new work / promotions. I used to be able to hide my disability, but it is progressive so now it's not as easy to hide. Thoughts?

like

Hi all,

My boss makes jokes about me being from a different country whenever there is a work meeting or a gathering with coworkers, even though he knows where I am from. This usually occurs when I meet new work-related people or for example if I am in a situation that involves ethnic related subjects.

What is this? This is normal?

Stereotyping?
Racism?

The first time I ignored that, but now it has become a pattern and is bothering me now. I am south-American working in the UK.

like

Hi everyone! I’d love to hear your thoughts on EEO surveys during the job application process. Is it more beneficial to self-disclose or refrain from disclosing race, gender, disability, etc?

Which method is more likely to get your application noticed? Any guidance would be helpful on my job hunt. Thank you.

like

Hi, we just launched Diversity and inclusion committee at our work place and one of our many initiatives is to share some reminders /notifications about safety and inclusion in common employee platforms/portals e.g There’s no place or time when discrimination is acceptable. Please feel free to report to HR if you com across any discriminatory behavior. Anyone has any more similar ideas what other topics we can add?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal