I manage someone who is terrible at their job. This has been going on for a year and they are not improving despite coaching, warning etc. my manager doesn’t want to put them on a pip because it is too involved, but in the meantime this is making my life impossible. What would you do?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Maybe this is obvious, but I'd say just dig in and find out why they're having so many problems. It's possible they can get some training that will bring them up to speed. But if it's just impossible to coach them or teach them, I guess the obvious question is why retain them? If they can't do the job, they can't do the job. Simple as that.

likehelpful

This also sounds like the manager needs to step up to the plate and do their part as well. To say that there is too much involved with doing a pip tells me that they are not holding up their obligations as a manager. And after repeated coaching and training that has been unsuccessful I not only would terminate the employee but I would also look into the usefulness of the manager as well. Turning a blind eye to the situation shows me that they lack the proper skills to be in the management position.

likehelpful

What is it exactly that makes them "terrible"? Are they self-absorbed, deflective, and low-quality? Ya, that's annoying. Or are they overworked and have too many patients to see, so they are setting boundaries with you. Two very different situations.

like

Oh-deflective is such a good word.

Do the PIP and show how you will manage the PIP. In the long run you will be better off by doing the hard work up front.

likehelpful

Honestly, it's worth determining if it's a skill or will issue before you spin your wheels on this one. Some people actually want to get fired and just waiting for you to do it. If they truly don't know what they're doing and need help, it would be in your best interest to get them uptraining and have them demonstrate understanding and proficiency along the way. In my dept, there are coworkers that seem to miss the same thing over and over but the manager doesn't take the time to get to the root cause. She just threatens write ups. Obviously, that's not working and they can't all just be dumb. Management, in many departments, needs to accept some of the responsibility for continuous low performance.

like

Or trading to get you fired

like

When I was lead, I had a clerk who was so slow and just could not catch on, I sat with her and asked what the hold up was, why she was struggling. Turns out, she was just trying to do too much all at the same time. I made a couple of suggestions for creating a routine and within a week, she was caught up and had a system down. I put myself in her position and asked myself how I would do it...

like

Are you hiring? I want a boss like you.

like

Look into your review process. Are they still on probationary status? You may be able to let them go without cause if they are. How often are reviews? At those reviews are you articulating very specific and progressively complicated goals? This leaves a paper trail of success or failure for you to use in case you need to place them on "final notice" or termination. Lastly, look to their personnel file and find out who interviewed and hired them. Maybe you need to be more involved in the hiring process to avoid this happening again. Good luck.

like

Pray for the person she may be mentally ill and try to help her

like

If you are managing them why is it YOUR managers choice whether or not to out them on a PIP? It sounds like they’ve been on one without the paperwork.
I’d either put them on one or get rid of them asap. I’d start documenting every single time they make a mistake that you correct them on and make sure to document the coaching and expectations moving forward. You can still get rid of someone without a PIP.

like

Oh, and the manager is lazy. Doesn’t want to do the work to get rid of them so it is left on you. Sounds like a cya with that manager!

I am also struggling to find a job. Every employer wants someone with experience. I obtained my license in March. During my externship, all the patients appreciated my work, including the doctor.

Is manager and director right for the job if they can't resolve the employment under them?

If that’s the case make sure you keep a lot of of notes a documentation on the employee and the boss,make sure you have dates and responses because in management with them being able to to claim that you are not doing your job and saying your not managing him can get you fired for the work that the employee is putting out. if this happens you will need to prove that you have discussed the issues with the employee and the boss and there responses believe me it happened to me but what ended up happening I started getting written up once a week for the work employees were putting out and because i hadn’t gotten written up on a job in ten years I got frustrated and I quit . I reported it to cooperate and the boss was made to resign months later but I had already left and taken a lower paying job

Let your manager know. Your mental health is more important!

From an employee perspective we see this too.

PIP them. Writing them up is not “too involved” as compared to managing an underperforming employee. If your manager doesn’t want to proceed, you can show him/her examples of how this person is terrible at their job and some data on how their underperformance is creating a negative impact on KPI’s.

Have convo with employee and ask her if there is anything going on that she is now struggling.

List things she does correctly with examples. Then go through accounts where she did incorrectly. Could find out so much.

Hire me, I'll help them!! I would love to work for such a lenient manager. I have never had that.

Related Posts

Do you have one-on-ones with your direct manager? What do you talk about? I’m early in my career, but always struggling with having productive meetings and feeling like my manager and I have somewhat of a relationship.

like

Have a client w over a million in IRAs and NQ account. Invested in a combo of ETFs and dividend paying stocks. Now bitching abt performance. Should I stick to my strategy or offer alt to placate him?

like

Just spent some time in Chicago for work and I love it. What is the main type of PR done there (media or other)? How is work culture, meeting people, dating scene? I’m in NY now

I have a virtual interview with Tesla tomorrow for an internship position. What should I wear? This would be first internship, so I’ve never interviewed for a position like this and am not sure how to dress (especially given it’s virtual). Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!

like

Just found out I’m staffed in Miami the rest of the year, coming from a much colder climate.

Any favorite tips/tricks for looking professional in heat & humidity?

I’m starting to work in the IB division in NYC soon. Was wondering what’s the dress code in the office. Would Business casual be fine?

I think there should be more males caretakers in this world. Some of my clients just feel more comfortable with a guy and it's kind of sad how often they say I'm the only male they could find.

like

What is the advice on what feedback to leave for a peer who really sucks at everything y'all have worked together on? It's about the time where everyone on my team requests feedback from each other and I'm nervous for it coming up. My manager knows that everything I've worked w her on I end up doing 90% of the work when it's meant to be split so it is a known issue. We're both at level 3 so are genuinely peers. She seems like a nice person but i have 0 positive work feedback tbh

I have a crush on my counsellor at work. She's much older but still really gracious and beautiful. Should I go for it or is this a bad idea?

like

I loathe Monday morning meetings. We have a monthly team meeting at 8:00am PT and it makes me so mad! 😂 It’s always on a Monday, and I have the hardest time getting motivated for them. Normally I wake up at 6:30am, check the news, stocks, shower, eat breakfast, get dressed and start answering emails at 8am.. no speaking meetings until 10am. However, on the team meeting Monday’s, I’m scrambling to do my morning routine and get setup to present/share my screen.. I hate them. We all hate them lol!

like

What do you do when a store manager let's a cashier.walk all over the assistant manager? Dm isn't any help. I'm at my wits end! Store manager sticks up for cashier every single time. I've offered to give that cashier my keys . I'm so done with trying to do right, only to have manager make up excuses.

like

What do you wear when your firm sends you to do law school recruitment? (I’m a woman fwiw)

like

When you email the partner with a question on one of your cases and he responds “okay thanks” lol

likefunny

do you cover your tattoos for client meetings? i already had tattoos but were easy to hide on camera, i now have a pretty full sleeve (all visible on camera) and not sure if i should cover them (wearing long sleeve top or cardigan) or just live my best life?

like

I'm a fresh grad and I thought this would be my dream job... I became the 3rd team member in this location and the regional team leader helped me understand and learned a lot... Until about 4 months down the line, he announced to quit. It's about half of year now since I started to feel ever so alone, hopeless and helpless in the team. The actual work is within my capability, but takes me ages to learn coz the overall team is not so collaborative and lacks communication... Maybe I need anew job

like

Gave notice to a partner this past Friday. The partner proceeded to curse me out and scream at the top of their lungs. What should I do other than obviously just walk away?

like

Feeling like it's only a matter of time before I have to tell the new marketing dept head that the snazzy jargon just makes him sound like a tryhard and alienates our customer base

like

Team is already talking about eating hours. My utilization is down cause I was in unassigned for a month in Dec/Jan. What's worse pissing off the partner or having a low utilization? -staff 1

like

SECRET WEAPON: A creative, thoughtful holiday gift is a freelancer’s secret weapon. To say “thanks for all the work”, be grateful and stay top of mind. What are some of best gifts you’ve heard of?

like

The counsellor who I was assigned is my SM. But now SM is asking to change counsellor to my manager suddenly before appraisal. They are saying HR mistakenly assigned SM as counsellor while joining.This is common? I just want to resign frm gds

like

More Posts

How is work life balabce at CookChildren’s?
Do you have remote days?

like

Hi Fishes, need your Insights on laptop purchase.
Can I buy and reimburse IMac? Or should I buy only laptop?

What salary can I expect from IBM for 7YOE into frontend??

like

Going back to work tomorrow after a 2 week long vacation. Scared to check my emails 😭😭😭

like

What are my chances in IT if I join HPE now? I heard they use mostly legacy tools and tools limited to HPE only. Does it affect my job search in future?

@cisco @vmware @HPE

like

Are the reports of the US running out of diesel in the next few weeks accurate? And if so, how will we transport food or anything else from one state to another???

like

Anyone willing to offer referral for lateral hire consulting opportunities at MBB. Is it possible to share the profile internally with someone at Partner level for consideration.
12+ yrs experience in strategy, transformation, change, process improvement, cost optimization & analytics. Helped F500 clients on Future of Work & workforce transformation cases in pandemic.

like

What do consultants do? I see Consultant titles pop up on here all the time and wonder what do y’all do? What are you consulting on? Seems interesting but i I googled and am still confused.

likefunny

Using the handicap stall as an able-bodied person in a public restroom: fine, only if otherwise full, or special place in hell?

like

I got an email from a Cybersecurity Advisory Partner with the subject "Catch-up". Last week we all rolled-off from project abruptly b/c the client terminated the contract. Am I getting laid off?

like

Relatively new in Big4 M&A advisory doing mostly integration work with some pre deal DD mixed in. I recently heard L.E.K. Consulting places well in MM PE but don't know much about them otherwise. Was interested if anyone had insight into whether a jump to their M&A or PE groups would be possible. In terms of background, I have an undergrad business degree from a T20 school and graduated a T14 law school as well.

like

Can anyone refer me for java developer role 3.11 yrs exp

like
like
like

Does Big4 have AMS (Application Management Service) seevice lines. Does Partner comp / targets differ for AMS vs rest of the service lines?

like

Associates at Morgan Stanley or any other investment firm, how much do you currently make? Morgan Stanley

like

We're recruiters in the lab science space working with mostly mid-size, stable, and innovative instrumentation companies. Now hiring for field service, technical sales, and director/product manager level positions all over the US. Check out tesatalent.com to see our open roles or consult with one of our recruiters about your career goals! and exciting employers in niche science industries innovative and exciting employers in niche science industries 

Post Photo
like

Any good books or recommendations on sales? Sales tactics trips and tricks?

like

Best consulting firms for the retail and CPG industries?

like

Is Canarsie in Brooklyn a safe area to live in?

like

Additional Posts in Healthcare

like

Any Mental Health Techs or Clinicians at “Community” in Indy. Looking for salaries and experience . I hired on with 6-7 years at $20 even

like

Hi. So I'm about to begin employment with United HealthGroup. It will be for Medicare recipients. I have some years experience with Medicaid. Any advice? I know, at first, it'll be working on the phones. Any thoughts also on how to get off the phones or how to move into other positions? Thank you.

like

Hourly pay rate

like

What's next after healthcare for you all?

like

Does anyone know what a chief sonographer should make? Managing 15 employees and 4 locations?

like

I currently work as a optician, referral coordinator and optometry technician. Busting my butt off wearing all 3 hats and I get paid $20 an hour… I don’t think this is a fare wage considering I’m doing the job of 3 people. I want to negotiate a higher wage any tips of what I should ask for?

like

Dialysis nurse (chronic) here for 12 years. Trying to apply to a different company to get a raise. Living in Sarasota, fl. What should be a reasonable pay?

like

Hi Fellow Fishies,

I am reaching out because I was recently contacted to interview for Cigna Provider Engagement Development Program. I wanted to see if I could connect with anyone on here that I can help give a breakdown of what this program entails, day-to-day, and WLB. Any tips on the interview and interview process for anyone working in this position? I would be truly grateful for any help or information that can be provided!

Cigna

like

I’m leaving my job soon but I’m wondering if I should be truthful when I hand in my letter of resignation. There’s a ton of reasons but it boils down to: I’m worth more than they can pay me and I need to pay off these student loans. What should I say?

like

Anyone here familiar with the medical records field reviewer positions at Change Healthcare? Looking to get a little more info on schedule, workload, and pay specifically. TIA!

like

So I had been working as medical interpreter up to the early part of this year. Today, during an interview, the Director with whom I was interviewing genuinely urged me to consider pursuing a career as a PA or even attempt to go to medical school. I had considered it in passing before but today was about the third or fourth time that someone had earnestly nudged me in that direction. Has anyone here made such a career pivot before? I love working in healthcare, there’s nothing like it.

like

Currently working as radiology access specialist that is a regular 10 to 6 Monday through Friday. I want to branch out to remote position in healthcare I have about 3 years of working administrative part of healthcare. This will be a second job in a sense. Does anyone have any ideas ?

like

Has anyone out there worked for a cruise line before? what was it like?

like

Hey! Considering negotiating my pay after 1 year of CT experience. In Florida my base is $29/hr. How much of a raise should I ask for (if they don’t automatically give one)? And should I wait to be a travel tech with another year of experience?

like

I’m a newer registered nurse (2 years) and want to get into remote work. I keep getting denied due to lack of experience but to even get the job I have now (case manager) the company knew one of my family members and they gave me a chance to interview because of that. For these remote companies where I don’t have connections how can I transition over?

likehelpful

Let's say you work remotely full time in private/group practice. Mental health or Wellness.
What's your maximum client load for a week? 20? 30? ... 10?

like

I am a RN in New York State for 14 + years. I am looking for remote jobs, all the jobs I come across you need a compact nursing license. The problem is NY is not a compact state. Does anyone have any suggestions? Thanks so much!

likehelpful

Currently a supervisor of a staff run group home for at risk youth. Anyone hiring for a supervisor with 1- years experience in mental health?

like

Question for nurses: What do you do and what's your salary range? Still deciding on which area should I pursue. Thanks!

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal