Hey everyone! Which is more beneficial in the new normal - a Master’s in HR/ Industrial Organizational Psychology, or a SHRM certification? Context: I’ve been in the corporate TA space for 10 years and now looking to level up my career in HR - focus would be on TA and Talent Management . Any advice?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Given your interests, industrial/org psychology doesn't make sense. A masters in HR, is pretty niche and honestly overpriced for the things you can do wih it so would never recommend that. Getting some SHRM certs would have the best ROI and supports your interests. Don't get a degree just to say you have one and drown in debt, you've waited this long so get things that will support your interests for the lowest investment.

likesmart

I would agree with this as well. I would opt for which ever you would enjoy more and which makes the most sense given your career path. To me it seems like the obvious choice would be go for a certification! I think that will benefit you the most.

I’d recommend working backwards from your long term career goal to determine what your toolkit needs to look like to set you up for success. A certification in HR is a way to flex and prove your specific job skills. A Master’s degree isn’t about job specific skills, it’s foundational learning of the science behind the practitioner work and the application of frameworks across the entire talent dimension.

I have both. The SHRM certification was helpful at opening doors in the first 7 years of my career and also provided me with street cred in orgs that valued experience and specific skills. The Masters has been a differentiator for the full 23 years of my career. I no longer work for organizations that are focused on specialty skills, I’ve opted into organizations that value intellectual aptitude, learning agility and strategic thinking. My MA has served me well and has enabled me to be a successful business leader who happens to have 20+ years of experience in HR.

Best of luck to you as you forge ahead with your career goals.

likesmart

I would also agree on Masters. In my experience SHRM certifications are not as valuable.

My current manager moved from a sr benefits analyst to a benefits manager with only a bachelors with no Certs. And makes 145k base.

likehelpful

I have a friend who has a bachelor and shrm-cp and 9 yoe, just landed a role as a sr talent advisor with a base of 93k.

Master’s in I/O Psychology! I have both a masters in I/O and a SHRM-CP and I will say what I learned in grad school has been invaluable and a great way to market myself during my job search. Message me if you want to chat more about this, and I can also recommend a good program that is not too expensive. You won’t regret it.

like

Hi! Sure thing! I earned my master’s at George Mason University. They have two I/O programs - MA and MPS. I recommend the MPS one because it’s fully online (I needed the flexibility since I work full time) and the program is more geared toward working professionals who are looking to apply what they’ve learned in grad school directly in the workplace. Some students go into the PhD track afterward but most of my cohort just wanted to apply it in business. It’s called MPS in Applied Industrial and Organizational Psychology.

The program is heavily based in science, research and data analysis applied to topics like employee performance, talent acquisition selection, leadership and team effectiveness, organizational development, change management, training, well being, motivation, etc. The program can be completed in 21 months. You take 2 classes per semester but the good thing about it is that you take only one class every 8 weeks. Fast paced program but I loved being able to focus on just one class at a time, before moving on to the next one.

There are no exams, it’s not about memorizing concepts but rather applying them (hence the name of the program) so you get to work on individual and 2-3 major team projects each class. There’s 1 practicum where you work with another student to create a research study and write a white paper on your topic of choice. No lectures, but professors host weekly virtual office hours so students can ask questions.

Faculty is GREAT, they put a lot of effort so students can succeed, they value feedback and the program director is one of the most caring mentors I’ve ever met!

I started the program summer 2020 and the overall cost was around $25K. My company helped fund part of tuition so definitely recommend looking into your employer and seeing if they can cover a portion of it.

I highly recommend I/O psychology to get a well rounded education if you want to continue pursuing HR as a career especially due to its focus on science and research which is the future of work.

Let me know if you have any other questions!

like

Why not an MBA instead of masters for hr? Then you can have multiple paths with mba but also it's more relevant towards a business overall and can leverage that worldwide should your situation change

like

I am graduating next month with my MBA with a concentration in HR Management. Highly recommend this route. Will look into certifications later down the road.

Given your interest to pivot to TM or Talent Development, a Masters in I/O is good. If you’re seeking to move up in TA purely, no. However, if you can financially afford it w/o debt or if your company can pay for tuition, that would be the route. I think Talent Mgmt/development route can be hard to break in and I/O degree can support that career path. I also think this could be done w/o a Master degree if you have a path to cross-over. A SHRM cert. is definitely doable for foundational knowledge and little to know experience - but it’s more generalist HR not super deep in I/O.

like

Following this! I’m planning to pursue my masters in I/O in the near future.

like

Posting to follow and see answers - I’m curious too!

likehelpful

Depends on geographic location and company. Some larger companies valué masters while smaller companies in Chicago for example seem content with certifications. Masters pays more and I find those companies that don’t value Masters and are ok with cert only tend to pay less

like

HR can be a challenging, eventually people do burn out. A degree is sufficient for many careers getting an MA doesn’t guarantee higher pay or role it all depends of companies and industries . Also you need to consider the financial implications, ideally you would have tuition support from an employer….they are expensive and you want an ROI that makes sense for you

like

Masters will put you in debt but it depends on your finances. I have an MBA in Technology Management and SHRM-SCP. I don’t know if hiring managers look at either honestly. With your years of experience you have to decide how you want to pivot as you move from early, mid, to experiment years.

like

If you can support yourself with the cost of attaining a masters degree then go for it. But if money is a little bit of a concern, I suggest you go for the SHRM Certification in the meantime.

like

I think a masters will do you well! I have my bachelors and got my masters in year right after and I was able to dip into the HR space and grow just fine without having an HR background! I was HR for a big company and shifted to TA for another well known company! Good luck! I think a masters sits well and will suite well for what you’re trying to do but I also heard the cert is pretty good. On my end I’ve seen people get the cert to help them grow in their role but for the most part I have VPs in HR I spoke with that just have their experience and didn’t do the cert or had a masters specific in HR/IO so it kind of depends id say on the company you join and how well you can grow within them!

I would say masters. I have both and the SHRM-CP doesn’t include much about recruiting. If you really want to learn then get your masters and be sure to take the recruiting classes. Itll also teach you leadership and HR management.

Related Posts

Hello, can anyone advise which Becker CPA program is better? Advantage (flash cards) or Unlimited (final review)?

like

Starting a new job as a Merchandising Coordinator for a large food/sales company soon… no experience in merchandising, just customer service. Any advice???

like

I'll switch to a startup as the only data engineer and will closely work with all the Head ofs + the CTO.

Any advice/books/... on stakeholder management at that level? Especially when things fail/discussing budgets/new hires etc.

like

Has anyone left healthcare and is now really happy? I’m an MSN, RN with 12 years hospital experience. I’m burned out and tired of making crap pay. I have an opportunity outside of healthcare that would pay more and challenge me in new ways that I haven’t experienced before. It’s a total shift that would really heal my work-life balance, job satisfaction and budget. My only fear is that I would not be using the license and degree that I worked so hard for. I would appreciate any input!!!!

likehelpfulsmartupliftingfunny

Best way to study for AWS cloud practitioner certification? (Not very technical but hoping to learn)

like

Any designers or ADs here make the jump from advertising/marketing to product? (and adjacently - from agency to in-house tech) Would love to hear about how you pivoted and any challenges/insights.

like

How many years after college did it take you to become an art director?

Any advice for becoming a public defender in Southern California

Which online resource is best for learning about SAP modules say ABAP and other hot SAP skills?
Any blogs that you'd suggest?
SAP

like

Tata Consultancy I am a manager in Capgemini... have an offer frm TCS. the designation being offered is Assistant Consultant.. 9.8 years experience( 5 yrs with Cap) Even though I am getting a package of 25Lakhs.. it seems like a demotion in designation.. Cg has offered to match upto 23.5 lakhs.. Is it worth moving to TCS on this grade? My primary reason for moving out of Cg is i m bored of beauocracy and WLB at current project. Is it a good idea to still switch with the counter offer from Cg Capgemini Tata Consu

like

Is it a good Idea to switch after 6 months if project is not suitable or should stay for longer?

like

Anybody know anything about Ubiquiti Inc.? How is it to work there? What does career progression look like? Thank you

like

I’m a CPA and am weighing going back for my Masters, maybe an MBA?

Will I get any benefit from going back to get my masters?

like

I am an experienced CNA/MA (17yrs) trying to break into ER tech role. Previous company wouldn’t pay for phlebotomy class, and when I took a position with a company that would train me, there was so much drama and b.s.
I was out of there so fast because of the toxic environment. Should I just forget it and do my best to finish my RN?

like
like

Anyone transition from healthcare to legal sector? I reached out to a recruiter because I’m looking to make that transition from healthcare administrative to a legal project coordinator. What are some transferable skills and goals I can best illustrate to recruiters and hiring managers?

like

I have offer from KPMG India and PWC AC Banglore. Package is almost the same. PWC AC has Canada shift with permanent wfh and KPMG India has hybrid work model in pune location. Please suggest which one is better in terms of growth , wlb , culture etc

like

Any good business/consulting books on amazon kindle that y’all have read that has helped you in your job?

like

On the verge of leaving law but getting cold feet. Could someone talk with me? I feel like it’s just a matter of not getting good mentorship but I’m concerned my feelings might not change elsewhere. I just don’t know. I wish I could just have a mentor and guidance

like

More Posts

Any recommendations on places to stay, visit in Dubai? Holiday family of 4 if that helps. Thank you!

like

Any insight on NYC firms with great work life balance? Doesn’t have to be cravath scale but something relative to the market.

like

I’m moving to a new firm in a few short weeks. I’ll obviously be missing out on bonuses in December at my old employer. What are your thoughts on asking for a prorated bonus from my old firm? My instinct is to leave it, but does anyone have any experience or guidance on this matter?

like

I am moving to Hyderabad on 4th Nov. Can anyone tell me if they have a vacant room in an already occupied flat near office. I am preferably looking for something within walking distance. Please help 🙏

like

All else equal, is it easier to become direct admit PP rather than promoted to that role from SM or MD? Seems less obstacles. Thoughts?

like

Are there any certifications or comprehensive courses for attorneys looking to break into blockchain?

like

Why is Deloitte’s 401k match do anemic?

like

I’m a 9th year in a mostly litigation-based practice group at a one-tier partnership firm. My group’s billable hours have been low the last few years, so making partner will be nearly impossible, and a counsel position is not viable long-term in my group. What’s the best option here if partnership is the ultimate goal? Try to get a NEP/counsel position at another firm, which is likely difficult in my market, or offer to take a class cut by a few years?

likehelpful

What is scaring you this spooky season?

Post Photo
likefunny

Is it bad luck to pawn a promise ring?

funnylike

I feel some OPs are using people as free therapy in this bowl. Just saying, although I'm happy to be a free therapist.

funnylike

Hello,

LTI or Mindtree ?
Offering same package.

I heard about the merger, will there be any impact ?

YOE:7
Tech : Data Analytics

like

Hi Fishes, I have an interview with PwC AC in the coming week. My tech stack is Power BI, SQL, SSRS,SSIS and Tableau. YEO -4 Current CTC is 9 LPA. During the initial call with the recruiter he asked for ny expected CTC and I asked for 17 LPA. Can anyone from PwC comment on this? Is this too much to ask or is this what someone at my current level would get paid at PwC. Please let me know!!!! PwC PwC India Pwc AC Deloitte Deloitte USI

like

Any layoffs in Luxoft , will there be any difficulty for bench employees

like

Sign-on Bonuses, is it typical for a company to ask for a re-payment agreement? i.e. 100% if leave/fired within 12 months, 50% if leave/fired within 24 months?

like

I’ve always been comfortable concepting and writing. But when it comes to nitty gritty logistical stuff, I struggle. Like the discussions about aspect ratios, social post timelines, and the nuances of Facebook collection ads.

Can any other writers relate?

like

Hi Fishes,
I've got offer from EPAM System and Fiserv. Which one to join in terms of management, appraisal/hikes, benefits and growth? Both are offering similar compensation.

like

Can anyone refer me for Accenture strategy management consultant role ?

like

Anyone willing to give a referral at Amazon / AWS? Happy to pass on CV and any other relevant info.

Currently applying for contract manager/paralegal role.

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

I've been working at this company for about 3.5 weeks now. Its been great so far.

We have an org chart in our dashboard ATS/HRIS and so I clicked on my first day buddies name just for fun.

I was able to see her entire employee file..even her address. I was really freaked out and I went to another profile and the same thing happened, I was able to see this person's emergency contact. Is this fucking normal? Should I say something and will I get in trouble for looking at a colleagues file?

like

For those of you who are SHRM CP certified. Can you please advise if the SHRM learning system is worth it? Are there other effective learning tools that are less expensive ?

like

We have a lot of inexperienced managers and leaders throughout the company. I wanted to propose bringing on a L&D leader who has experience creating long-term curriculums for managers and executives. For those that have a management training philosophy, who runs it and how often,m?

likesmart

So, a recruiter gave me feedback that my lack SPHR or SHRM-SCP is causing my resume to be knock out by AI and human recruiters despite my position and work history in Multinationals and being in Technology. They suggested that we put SPHR ( Lapsed). I let it lapse in 2017. What is your opinion? Plus if I were to take another certification - should I take SPHR or SHRM-SCP?

like

Any advice for someone looking to transition into a full HR Generalist role from Recruiting. I’m currently a Campus Recruiter with about 5 years of HR experience (Coordinator- Higher Ed). I received my PHR certification in September 2020 and sitting for my SHRM-CP in two weeks. I’m having a hard time transitioning into a full Generalist position.

like

Hi, I came across an HR role for a company that offers consulting services for other employers. Has anyone work for one? My understanding is that it’s project base. Can anyone here share their experience in a similar role? What do you think?

like

I am the first HR professional at a small company. I am looking for an easy to use platform for performance management. I have used Bamboo and Paylocity in the past. Eventually we will want something that has a payroll component as well. What systems have you used and liked?

like

Why is it so hard to find a remote HR position? I have my SHRM-SCP, my MBA and over 10 years of experience being an HR Manager.

likesmart

I have 2 years of sales experience but am looking to make a career change into HR? Any tips of how to standout on my resume or any general advice? Thanks!

like

What are your best tips when letting an expecting parent know we will not be revising the parental leave policy for them (but we understand they think it’s not good enough)

like

Would you say your job got easier or harder since Covid started?

I’m currently working with a senior level HR candidate. This individual has a doctorate in business with a focus in HR, her SPHR, Federal, and private sector experience at the singer level, and has a fabulous personality. I’m curious is anyone else having difficulties play some candidates like this? At this point I’m starting to think it’s racial or her sex based of the lack of interest in this candidate. Any thoughts?

like

Advice on taking and passing the SPHR exam?

likehelpful

Hi HR Professionals! I am revising our current employment application form. Per SHRM, I was just curious if any HR Professionals completely removed the following fields: social security number, recommend salary, graduation dates, military discharge info, race, maiden name like (Ms. Mrs. Ms), & criminal history questions. I was just curious what other Employers/HR Professional have done. Any information is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

like

Can provide more details if needed, but if an employee is constantly coughing at work (small retail establishment), is it okay to ask them for a doctor's note stating they aren't contagious? They're claiming it's due to allergies, but I've gotten several confidential concerns from employees and customers alike due to the current enviornment.

Hi, we are currently updating our Apprenticeship Policy and I wanted to understand what other organisations offer in regards to:
1. Rewards for exam passes
2. Holiday allowance during study

Any detail would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

like

Hi All

Looking for recommendations for the SHRM-SCP exam; going the self study route…thanks

like

I am in the process of finishing up my MBA but considering also getting my SPHR or PHR cert. Is it even worth it or a waste of time and money?

like

Hello everyone! This is my first time posting since joining this platform. I’m interested in connecting with someone who is open to HR mentoring. I’ve been in HR now for about six years and have never had a mentor. I’ve been relying mostly on SHRM and other people in the company for feedback. Even if it’s for feedback, I would really appreciate it. Thank you!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal