Approaching 30 now and living with roommates in NYC, but considering moving to my own place. Has anyone found that living with roommates is better than living alone? Conventional wisdom says no.

I’m a pretty outgoing person and i like to have people around. I also like my roommates cause we chill. So I’m really scared of moving in alone and being lonely. Increase in rent will be marginal and totally affordable.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I moved into my own place this past year and won’t go back. I can do whatever I want, never have to fight over tv, kitchen, bathroom. Can poo with the door wide open. That being said, it’s considerably more expensive.

like

This, I’m about to move to a new city and thought about getting a roommate reading this thread. Your post reminded me of the time one of my roommates stole my money in the dumbest way possible.

there are pros and cons to both. you pointed them out in general, but to dig a bit deeper...

with roommates, you get more socialization, never feel lonely, have people to do things with, can share a larger space, have people to split the cost of things with, etc. but also, you have less freedom because you have an obligation to be a good roommate. you can’t walk around naked, leave your shit wherever you want, cook anything any time you want, watch or listen to anything any time, make noise at all hours, have as much stuff, have people over whenever you want, etc.

you might find that you don’t care about some of those things or that they don’t apply to your situation. that’s fine.

living alone does come with other benefits that aren’t easy to immediately value. when you’re alone, you’re bored more easily. and you learn about the type of person you are. what you spend time doing, how deliberate you are about keeping in touch with others and making plans, whether you have your own friends, whether they’re good friends, etc. it’s somewhat stressful, even though having your own place to come home to and nobody to please can be liberating.

girls will probably like it more, but on the other hand, you won’t have friends always at the ready to go out and meet any with you. the first time i ever went out by myself with no plans, looking to get laid or otherwise meet people, was when i lived alone. and when going out alone, you rarely want to travel far. so you go to the bar across the street, etc. if i had roommates who were staying in, i probably would have stayed in. but i didn’t want to be alone at the apartment on a particular night.

some of the experiences you have while living alone are disappointing, and may be improved if you had roommates with you. but it gives you a glimpse at what real life is like - often disappointing or mundane. to that extent, it can be motivational, or it can teach you to really appreciate the times when you are together with your friends, instead of taking it for granted. or it can be depressing. it’s all of those things. but if you’ve never lived alone before, you’ll definitely grow from the experience.

likehelpful

i wouldn’t rock the boat if you’re in a situation you like. but if the band breaks up, maybe you should consider it. only reason i say that is because once you live alone, it’ll be hard to go back to having roommates.

like
Recent IconRecent

If you like roommates stick with them.

like

Living by myself for the first time after having roommates was awesome. Live with SO now and at times I wish I could live by myself again. Living on your own can be lonely at times and it can take more effort to get plans together to socialize, but overall I prefer it over having roommates.

like

I’ve lived alone multiple times in my life, and while it’s nice to have my own place, I found that I had way too much time alone with my thoughts.

like

I live alone and I would never go back. I’m still very social and live pretty close to a lot of my friends.

like

That was me too! Even though I’m very social and I love seeing people, I loved the freedom of living alone. No one messed anything up or moved anything or ate something that was mine, I could walk around wearing whatever I wanted, no one made any noise that would wake me up.... if I got lonely, that is what connecting with friends is for!

So I really like living alone and would find it hard to go back.

That said, you do develop some weird habits that your roommates might do a good job calling you or on. Like is it weird that I snack on marshmallows?

like

Why is that weird?

like

I have a buddy who is also 30 with 2 roommates. For him, it’s not about saving money. He could certainly live alone and pay his own rent. He doesn’t like living alone - thrives from being around people (and I guess his roommates are the same way). They’re living life, no relationships, so it works out for them. Me on the other hand needs my own space and quiet time. I love being around others but not when it comes to living. I’d say, do what you feel comfortable with and if you’re not finding having roommates prevents you from living your life the way you want to live it, then it’s fine

like

I always loved having roommates and always did until I got a job in a new city when I was 26 and didn’t know anyone so I was forced to live alone. It was reallyyyy lonely at first, because I didn’t have friends or an SO, and I always felt like a loser if I didn’t go out on the weekends because I wouldn’t have human interaction. Versus watching movies with a roommate felt like still being social before. So it was a hard adjustment at first. But I think that it made me grow a lot and learn to be even more independent than I was before. I’ve had to learn how to handle a lot of challenges all on my own and learned to focus on my future plans and ambitions. Other upsides are: you have the kitchen to yourself, you can have sex in any room whenever you want, no fighting over the tv, you can stay up late watching tv on the couch without being rude, when you are tired and don’t want to clean you don’t have to feel guilty. I don’t think I can go back to having roommates after living alone now. And I need human contact a lot more than most people. Downside has been corona loneliness though lol.

like

I moved from LA to a smaller city (like 1 mill) and so I think that my social life suffered much more from leaving LA than it did from living alone. But it did push me to try to make new friends! My apartment building was all guys except for me at first and they were all rude or creepy, but few months in another lady moved in and I saw her at the mail box and we have been close friends ever since! I don’t know if I would have put myself out there like that if I had had the safety net of roommates. I’ve also made friends by just doing stuff by myself around town. It’s harder for sure, but some times you settle into complacent friendships with roommates who you may not really have chosen as friends otherwise. This forces you to find your people.

uplifting

Following. I’m scared to move out alone because I’ll be lonely. I also don’t have a huge group of friends in my city and no prospect of a bf.

Maybe if you have a large friend group or SO you might be okay!

like

Aka single af!! Hard to date in my city and made impossible by corona. If I was dating someone already I’d be less hesitant to get my own place because I wouldn’t be as lonely.

like

Hello millionaire in the making. Save $$ as much as possible now. That's all I can say now :)

like

I hope :)

Living alone does provide an oasis from everything else in life, big plus is that things are left as they were. Looking for places within neighborhoods with friends helps with any feelings of isolation too.

likehelpful

I was in NYC in my early 20s. Amazing location near Flat Iron. My two roommates where early/mid 30s and both easily making upwards of $150k a year. They enjoyed the company and location. Both found their significant others while living at our place and now live with partners in Queens and BK. If you like the situation, who cares.

like

I love having roommates - more social, have friends around, people to watch your stuff, have your back if you get locked out, etc.

Personally, between having friends and a gf/wife, I’ll never live alone, and wouldn’t really care to.

like

That’s what I was thinking too! But sadly I don’t have an SO and never say never, but I don’t really think I’ll get one for a couple of years. Certainly not move in with one.

If you really love your current set up then why shake it up, bro?

like

A little bit of the “fuck I’m 30 and I’ll be living with roommates”. A little bit because my roommates also are thinking about moving out to get their own places but haven’t decided yet. A little bit of “I want a space that I can decorate and manage the way I want to etc.” but it’s entirely possible for me to continue for another year or two.

Oh man. I can’t imagine being 30 and still having roommates. I’ve been on my own since I graduated college. Couldn’t imagine anything else.

like

33, currently living with a flatmate. This particular arrangement works out for us because we largely do our own things but living together lets us still get the serendipitous hangout that happens less and less the older you get. Many of my friends have expressed the idea that it would be great to live together in a small community in a way that has more overlap than merely living “nearby”, e.g. with private areas but some shared spaces across multiple families.

Also, it goes without saying that this is pretty contingent on having a flatmate that meshes well with your work-life style.

like

If you want to save money, stay with roommates as long as you can. Once you move in by yourself, you will not be able to go back.

I’ve lived by myself since I was 23, so it’s been 5 years. Saving money is the only reason why I wish I had lived with roommates longer, but otherwise I’m so glad I live on my own. But I’m also a very solitary person and don’t need more than texting to get a social fix (aka I love the quarantine).

like

The money saved is great; otherwise, not having roommates is the way to go.

If you have solid roommates then what’s the rush ? I never lived alone til I moved in with SO. I get bored and it’s nice having someone around to bullshit with. Having your own room and bathroom generally helps. The money saved is nice and if you’re single it’s definitely worth it.

Related Posts

If you loved your small independent broker dealer but they had just been acquired by a much larger corporation which does have benefits in terms, mostly, in technology, but you lose your “family” in the home office, what would you do and who would you look at if you were considering a change of your own?

like

Has the overturning of Roe v. Wade significantly impacted anyone's relationships? I lost two friends who were pro-life and on the verge of losing another. Wondering if I'm being too rigid in my perspective or if this is normal in Texas

like

My relationship just ended yesterday because he wanted to “focus on myself and figure things out.” My relationship before that ended (~2 years ago) because he wanted to focus on himself. I can’t help but feel like it’s because something is wrong with me. What am I doing wrong?

like

Hi i lost majority of my money in the stock market. I married and promised my family that I will not make the mistake I made 7 years ago. Gambling. Is this an addiction I have. I keep selling stocks and taking loses buying other stock hoping it will recover but never did and sell again taking loses and buy again. It now sink in to me. I borrow personal loan hoping that the market will do k and I pay it back but I even lost that. I can't stop crying that I hurt the one I love the most my family.

like

I know this bowl isn’t the most active, but my grandmother is in the hospital for Covid (severely high risk), grandfather has it, as does my mom and 8 year old brother. My mom is also experiencing PTSD or some form of mental issue where she has certain triggering events. Everyone is concerned about her and my grandmother. Please keep my family in your prayers

like

Would you break up with your girlfriend if she doesn’t want kids and you do.... this has been weighing on my mind a lot recently...

like

I give massive kudos to all the parents out there juggling work and home life. But it’s starting to feel like I pulled the short stick by not having a kid. Really struggling to pick up all of the slack from all of the colleagues that do have kids and feel like the expectation is that parents should turn off while the rest are working from 7am - 2am everyday to make up for it.

like

34 and noticing that all my friends are friends of convenience - ppl from work, friends of friends, or ppl I’ve met randomly. How do I cultivate more deliberate friendships based on shared interests?

likesmart

Need genuine advice
I’m 29 , Bisexual man more inclined towards men

Will it be okay if I marry a woman , asking in terms of my mental health ? I’m succumbing to the family and societal pressure .
I’ll always be loyal to my partner, but is there anyway I could curb my gay side completely? A conversion therapy or something?

like

I think I might get a divorce

likeupliftingsmart

I am getting ready to send my 2 year old toddler to a toddler program next week for the first time. Have to fill out a form “bathroom waiver”, which is basically allowing teachers at the school to clean my child after a potty, including genital area. I feel uneasy about this but I know I have to let them… I assume all parents have signed such waiver?

Family luddites ask about my work and immediately behave annoyed when I start to answer.

like

How have you dealt with anti-vaxxer friends? I have one and I’m not mad or angry at them. I’m just disappointed that I’ve associated myself with someone like them. 😔

like

Is bfs account Contract get extended or they simply release and we get bach to parent (cts), for another project is complete bgv happening or they just handle from their side?

like

I just broke off my first real relationship after almost 5 years. Even though I made the final call, the pain is still horrible and I have depression/anxiety separate from this. Any advice beyond the

Our 5 month old started daycare about 5 weeks ago. We’ve already had to keep her home for 2.5 of those 5 weeks due to catching various illnesses (croup, rsv, brinchiolitis, etc). Both my wife and I have been sick most of that time as well (gotten it from the baby). Wife is thinking we get a full time nanny for the next 4 months to help the baby build antibodies. Cost aside, is this feasible / worthwhile to go thru the effort / finding the right fit, only for 4 months?

like

About to be a new dad. Starting to look into childcare but feeling a little overwhelmed. Would love to hear thoughts/opinions on what to look for besides convenience.

Girlfriend has very obvious high functioning anxiety and body image issues that she admits but thinks she doesn’t need therapy or medication and that reading self-help books will help her. It’s not changing in the last several years and it’s impacting our relationship. Anyone have experience with their SO dealing with untreated anxiety? I know I can’t control her but would like to express my feelings without sending her into a spiral. For context, I’ve been in therapy for 12 months and medicated

like

I’m happy with my relationship but the thing is I never really have a spark with the girl. Can someone relate or explain? I’m not sure if I should keep doing this. Maybe I’m just in an comfort zone now?

like

Realizing that I am way too old for nights

like

More Posts

EY 🐠, promoted from Sr3 to Mgr with a 5 rating in FSO Advisory, based in NYC. Anybody know the pay band or percentage increase to expect?

like

Compensation ranges for restructuring partner or equivalent at FTI, A&M, Alix, NY based.

like
like

I’m dealing with a difficult management situation and don’t know what to do, how would you report someone when nobody really cares what’s going on or is automatically going to side with the other person?

like

29/M , I love to listen , cook and travel internationally.
I am looking for a Female who is funny, stylish and willing to try new things.

like

Can someone share how old caterpillar India engineering pvt ltd is, not able to get much information online

like

what would be Product Manger salary range in Lowe's ?

like

34 and noticing that all my friends are friends of convenience - ppl from work, friends of friends, or ppl I’ve met randomly. How do I cultivate more deliberate friendships based on shared interests?

likesmart

I give massive kudos to all the parents out there juggling work and home life. But it’s starting to feel like I pulled the short stick by not having a kid. Really struggling to pick up all of the slack from all of the colleagues that do have kids and feel like the expectation is that parents should turn off while the rest are working from 7am - 2am everyday to make up for it.

like

I am getting ready to send my 2 year old toddler to a toddler program next week for the first time. Have to fill out a form “bathroom waiver”, which is basically allowing teachers at the school to clean my child after a potty, including genital area. I feel uneasy about this but I know I have to let them… I assume all parents have signed such waiver?

Need genuine advice
I’m 29 , Bisexual man more inclined towards men

Will it be okay if I marry a woman , asking in terms of my mental health ? I’m succumbing to the family and societal pressure .
I’ll always be loyal to my partner, but is there anyway I could curb my gay side completely? A conversion therapy or something?

like

Family luddites ask about my work and immediately behave annoyed when I start to answer.

like

I think I might get a divorce

likeupliftingsmart

Can Virtusa revise the offer letter after accepting as well?

like

Hey Fishes,

I’m looking for a referral at Infosys Consulting.
Any leads would be helpful.

Thank you.

like
like

Partners,

My firm is immature in guiding development planning. I have energy to accelerate to the next level of responsibility.

What evidence distinguishes an analyst as ready for the next level?

like
like

Additional Posts in The Worklife Bowl

Can I just say that this bowl really makes me feel thankful. Coming from the consulting bowl, I feel like this is slightly better. I’m not saying all opinions are to my liking, but it’s diverse.

likeuplifting

Unexpected quarantine perk: not having to sneak off to an empty conference room to cry

likefunny

Not sure why the execs keep their jobs and layoff production. Do we need all top-level operation staff when there isn’t much left to operate? I have ahead time seeing C-suite doin any production work

like

Why aren't stocks going down anymore?

likehelpful

Happy Saturday 🐠 Fam!

Post Photo
like

Question that could belong here or in the Relationships bowl:

How do women prefer to be turned down if the guy they’re pursuing is not interested. I know men have the capacity to deal with rejection poorly, and I’m not suggesting otherwise. But in my anecdotal experience , women take the gentle “no thanks, not interested” poorly.

likesmartfunny

Best books on entrepreneurship? Trying to find a good birthday gift for a friend thinking of starting his own company and exploring business ideas

like

Is there a problem to stay contract with your recruiting agency instead of converting to full time with the company? Should you push to get converted sooner rather than later?

like

I want a puppy, but I am not sure I am ready for the dog. Does that make sense?

like

A little late here, but any suggestions/recommendations or watch outs for an automatic standing desk preferably with charging attachments? Looking to invest in a decent one around $2-300 !

like

How do you address someone who seems condescending? We’ve never met in person, and they’re slightly more senior, on a parallel team. (Not at TBWA)

like

Lol y'all calling yourself a homebody goin' take a whole other level of meaning after this

funnylike

I have recovered from Corona Virus. Its 6 weeks now and I can tell you that the after effects are real. I have anxiety that I will never get over the fatigue, brain fog, inability to form sentences and words and headaches which make my work days very difficult to get thru.

like

Please help suggest good standing desk brand!!

like

Is it normal to not be motivated at all and feel “brain dead” all the time? Just started with new company a month ago and I don’t have a spark. I didn’t on day 1 and 4 weeks later I am still bleh. Is that a sign?

like

I miss driving.

like

Is a 49% debt to income ratio doable for someone who lives very frugally?

like

Has anyone started on anti-anxiety or anti-depression meds due to covid? Has it helped in any significant way? My mental health is really suffering and I’m considering medicating but so worried about all the possible side effects 😞

like

Corporate environment makes you forget your true self. Think back to who you were before you started. Throwing success out of the equation, would your old self like what they see?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal