Approaching 30 now and living with roommates in NYC, but considering moving to my own place. Has anyone found that living with roommates is better than living alone? Conventional wisdom says no.

I’m a pretty outgoing person and i like to have people around. I also like my roommates cause we chill. So I’m really scared of moving in alone and being lonely. Increase in rent will be marginal and totally affordable.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I moved into my own place this past year and won’t go back. I can do whatever I want, never have to fight over tv, kitchen, bathroom. Can poo with the door wide open. That being said, it’s considerably more expensive.

like

This, I’m about to move to a new city and thought about getting a roommate reading this thread. Your post reminded me of the time one of my roommates stole my money in the dumbest way possible.

there are pros and cons to both. you pointed them out in general, but to dig a bit deeper...

with roommates, you get more socialization, never feel lonely, have people to do things with, can share a larger space, have people to split the cost of things with, etc. but also, you have less freedom because you have an obligation to be a good roommate. you can’t walk around naked, leave your shit wherever you want, cook anything any time you want, watch or listen to anything any time, make noise at all hours, have as much stuff, have people over whenever you want, etc.

you might find that you don’t care about some of those things or that they don’t apply to your situation. that’s fine.

living alone does come with other benefits that aren’t easy to immediately value. when you’re alone, you’re bored more easily. and you learn about the type of person you are. what you spend time doing, how deliberate you are about keeping in touch with others and making plans, whether you have your own friends, whether they’re good friends, etc. it’s somewhat stressful, even though having your own place to come home to and nobody to please can be liberating.

girls will probably like it more, but on the other hand, you won’t have friends always at the ready to go out and meet any with you. the first time i ever went out by myself with no plans, looking to get laid or otherwise meet people, was when i lived alone. and when going out alone, you rarely want to travel far. so you go to the bar across the street, etc. if i had roommates who were staying in, i probably would have stayed in. but i didn’t want to be alone at the apartment on a particular night.

some of the experiences you have while living alone are disappointing, and may be improved if you had roommates with you. but it gives you a glimpse at what real life is like - often disappointing or mundane. to that extent, it can be motivational, or it can teach you to really appreciate the times when you are together with your friends, instead of taking it for granted. or it can be depressing. it’s all of those things. but if you’ve never lived alone before, you’ll definitely grow from the experience.

likehelpful

i wouldn’t rock the boat if you’re in a situation you like. but if the band breaks up, maybe you should consider it. only reason i say that is because once you live alone, it’ll be hard to go back to having roommates.

like
Recent IconRecent

If you like roommates stick with them.

like

Living by myself for the first time after having roommates was awesome. Live with SO now and at times I wish I could live by myself again. Living on your own can be lonely at times and it can take more effort to get plans together to socialize, but overall I prefer it over having roommates.

like

I’ve lived alone multiple times in my life, and while it’s nice to have my own place, I found that I had way too much time alone with my thoughts.

like

I live alone and I would never go back. I’m still very social and live pretty close to a lot of my friends.

like

That was me too! Even though I’m very social and I love seeing people, I loved the freedom of living alone. No one messed anything up or moved anything or ate something that was mine, I could walk around wearing whatever I wanted, no one made any noise that would wake me up.... if I got lonely, that is what connecting with friends is for!

So I really like living alone and would find it hard to go back.

That said, you do develop some weird habits that your roommates might do a good job calling you or on. Like is it weird that I snack on marshmallows?

like

Why is that weird?

like

I have a buddy who is also 30 with 2 roommates. For him, it’s not about saving money. He could certainly live alone and pay his own rent. He doesn’t like living alone - thrives from being around people (and I guess his roommates are the same way). They’re living life, no relationships, so it works out for them. Me on the other hand needs my own space and quiet time. I love being around others but not when it comes to living. I’d say, do what you feel comfortable with and if you’re not finding having roommates prevents you from living your life the way you want to live it, then it’s fine

like

I always loved having roommates and always did until I got a job in a new city when I was 26 and didn’t know anyone so I was forced to live alone. It was reallyyyy lonely at first, because I didn’t have friends or an SO, and I always felt like a loser if I didn’t go out on the weekends because I wouldn’t have human interaction. Versus watching movies with a roommate felt like still being social before. So it was a hard adjustment at first. But I think that it made me grow a lot and learn to be even more independent than I was before. I’ve had to learn how to handle a lot of challenges all on my own and learned to focus on my future plans and ambitions. Other upsides are: you have the kitchen to yourself, you can have sex in any room whenever you want, no fighting over the tv, you can stay up late watching tv on the couch without being rude, when you are tired and don’t want to clean you don’t have to feel guilty. I don’t think I can go back to having roommates after living alone now. And I need human contact a lot more than most people. Downside has been corona loneliness though lol.

like

I moved from LA to a smaller city (like 1 mill) and so I think that my social life suffered much more from leaving LA than it did from living alone. But it did push me to try to make new friends! My apartment building was all guys except for me at first and they were all rude or creepy, but few months in another lady moved in and I saw her at the mail box and we have been close friends ever since! I don’t know if I would have put myself out there like that if I had had the safety net of roommates. I’ve also made friends by just doing stuff by myself around town. It’s harder for sure, but some times you settle into complacent friendships with roommates who you may not really have chosen as friends otherwise. This forces you to find your people.

uplifting

Following. I’m scared to move out alone because I’ll be lonely. I also don’t have a huge group of friends in my city and no prospect of a bf.

Maybe if you have a large friend group or SO you might be okay!

like

Aka single af!! Hard to date in my city and made impossible by corona. If I was dating someone already I’d be less hesitant to get my own place because I wouldn’t be as lonely.

like

Hello millionaire in the making. Save $$ as much as possible now. That's all I can say now :)

like

I hope :)

Living alone does provide an oasis from everything else in life, big plus is that things are left as they were. Looking for places within neighborhoods with friends helps with any feelings of isolation too.

likehelpful

I was in NYC in my early 20s. Amazing location near Flat Iron. My two roommates where early/mid 30s and both easily making upwards of $150k a year. They enjoyed the company and location. Both found their significant others while living at our place and now live with partners in Queens and BK. If you like the situation, who cares.

like

I love having roommates - more social, have friends around, people to watch your stuff, have your back if you get locked out, etc.

Personally, between having friends and a gf/wife, I’ll never live alone, and wouldn’t really care to.

like

That’s what I was thinking too! But sadly I don’t have an SO and never say never, but I don’t really think I’ll get one for a couple of years. Certainly not move in with one.

If you really love your current set up then why shake it up, bro?

like

A little bit of the “fuck I’m 30 and I’ll be living with roommates”. A little bit because my roommates also are thinking about moving out to get their own places but haven’t decided yet. A little bit of “I want a space that I can decorate and manage the way I want to etc.” but it’s entirely possible for me to continue for another year or two.

Oh man. I can’t imagine being 30 and still having roommates. I’ve been on my own since I graduated college. Couldn’t imagine anything else.

like

33, currently living with a flatmate. This particular arrangement works out for us because we largely do our own things but living together lets us still get the serendipitous hangout that happens less and less the older you get. Many of my friends have expressed the idea that it would be great to live together in a small community in a way that has more overlap than merely living “nearby”, e.g. with private areas but some shared spaces across multiple families.

Also, it goes without saying that this is pretty contingent on having a flatmate that meshes well with your work-life style.

like

If you want to save money, stay with roommates as long as you can. Once you move in by yourself, you will not be able to go back.

I’ve lived by myself since I was 23, so it’s been 5 years. Saving money is the only reason why I wish I had lived with roommates longer, but otherwise I’m so glad I live on my own. But I’m also a very solitary person and don’t need more than texting to get a social fix (aka I love the quarantine).

like

The money saved is great; otherwise, not having roommates is the way to go.

If you have solid roommates then what’s the rush ? I never lived alone til I moved in with SO. I get bored and it’s nice having someone around to bullshit with. Having your own room and bathroom generally helps. The money saved is nice and if you’re single it’s definitely worth it.

Related Posts

I’m posting this here instead of my usual Big Law bowl because I’m guessing there are people here who will understand. I just need to vent. I am married to a wonderful man who has a young son. My husband is the kindest, most patient and supportive man I’ve ever met other than my dear late grandfather. He is saintly. But the chaos that surrounds him hurts me. I am the primary breadwinner and far out earn my husband and my stepson’s bio mom. I have always put pressure on myself to succeed (Cont.)

like

It’s during this time of year that I’m reminded of how the word ‘no’ does not work with my beloved little kin who insist on climbing and trying to eat random inedible objects.

like

Do you think it is easier to overcome cheating in a relationship that has or does not have children involved? Listening to an interesting podcast and would love to know peoples take on the topic

like

How do I get better with frustration with family (even though warranted)? Therapy?

like

Do you factor in career trajectory and earning potential when finding a SO? Is it so superficial that I care about these things?

like

Um, I feel like my BF of almost 4yrs (1 living together) and I are on the brink of separating. I think COVID is putting it into perspective. We’ve gotten through the worst of the quarantine while supporting each other as best we could (very thankful for him). But his coping skills with stress (during covid) are lacking and as things progressed he’s just been taking it out on me more and more in the moment, then he feels awful for not treating me as well as I deserve (he treated me well before..)

like

Why do we always tell people “Be the best version of yourself before starting a relationship?”
I feel this is wrong…first, if you’re someone who constantly wants to be better, this doesn’t work. Also, what happens when you’re going through things and you’re not the best version? What happens is…the going gets tough and then one person leaves the other.

like

Why can’t my exes leave me alone

like

Hi! Have any here gone the natural cycle IVF route? What was your experience like? Did you have success in growing your family this way? Would you recommend it to others?

like

Boyfriend and I have been dating for ~1.5 years and we still only spend weekends together. I want to move in together at the 2 year mark but bf thinks it’s too soon... just feels our relationship is stagnant and not going anywhere. Any thoughts from ppl who’ve gone through similar situations?

like

My whole sleep schedule is fucked up thanks to my husband the teacher, who can sleep in and “give out assignments” for like an hour

likefunny

Friends are ignoring me after they got promoted and I didn't. Really didn't think I would see this day :( How should I handle this?

like

I know this isn’t a marriage therapy bowl, but my husband has a really terrible tendency of saying things like “you’re being really mean” and completely shutting down during a disagreement when i objectively am not being mean, just truthful or vocal about how i feel about something. It’s a really convenient argument for him because it enables him to either be the victim and me the villian, or forces me to concede my stance and not reach a true resolution. Any tips on dealing with the irrational?

like

How to FIRE with kids? No kids for us yet but wife and I do FIRE and we’re wondering if it’s even possible with kids. Just takes longer maybe?

#NTA #Sugesstion

Should you get married to a girl who ask you to relocate after marriage and tells you to divide all household work like a roommate. Also reluctant to cooking.

It’s a arrange marriage, girl wants to do job at Gurugram only and want to relocate to it. I am currently living in Delhi with my family and my job location is Noida.

like

I have a non-existent relationship with my dad & mom. It’s so hard trying to maneuver life without support 😢

like

F*****-up story…please be constructive (but also open & direct)
With my wife for 14 years, 2 kids under 8y - both under a lot of pressure bc Covid/work/private life/… and have been (unconsciously) running away from our couple not working “since a long time” (dixit my wife). We want to try and fix it, but I also met someone new (not sure if she would even want me) and wondering if it’s worth fixing it (since we are trying/running/avoiding it for years) - just worried about the kids…any advice

like

Celebrating the end of the week and passing my AWS cert exam with something really special: Octomore 06.1. It’s like Lagavulin 16 and Oban 14 got together and had a lovechild that’s rambunctious and gregarious. I love it, too bad the bottle is almost empty.

Post Photo
like

One of my friends has been given a choice, to work with an extremely outrageous target or to leave the firm. If he chooses to stay, he will be bound to serve a total time of 6 months. And if he refuses, tomorrow will be his last day, what can I suggest to him?

It's a critical decision and he is overwhelmed by this sudden obstacle. Any leads would be helpful.

like

A relative is raising a teenage son with her ex-husband. They have joint physical custody. The ex-husband has re-married. When the son is in his care, he often leaves the son at home in California with his (new) wife when he travels for work (which is often). The relative wants her ex-husband to leave their son in her care when he travels out of town but the ex-husband disagrees. The relative wants to know her chances of prevailing if she were to appear in court on this issue. Thoughts? Thanks!

like

More Posts

Was scrolling through linkedin posts and saw EYGDS opened one more ofc in Kolkata and the interior and location is too good.
Why Deloitte acquired a 2 decade old Technopolis building in Kolkata!?!? 😐😏

likefunny

How much bonus does an L6 in tech consulting get ?

like

What is manage payment elections in pwc workday? I'm unable to add anything to it. Does it open after our DOJ?

like

Can someone explain to me why people end their IG handles with .jpg or .PDF?

like

I have a non-existent relationship with my dad & mom. It’s so hard trying to maneuver life without support 😢

like

When I look for jobs as Java developer, why many of them asking me about the devops? Docker, kubernetes etc...why it's necessary for a developer ? Project may have a seperate operations team to manage it right ? Or anyway I need to learn it to survive ?

like

Hi Fishes
Is being a Salesforce developer a desired skill in the IT market ? (Present and 10years from now)

Please tell me as i am deciding to learn b/w Salesforce development and Full Stack Development.

Yoe : 1.3
Current tech stack : SQL, INFORMATICA, Service Now

like

Any job openings for indirect purchase and maintenance

"She's like 30, but doesn't look super old"

likefunny

Any good moving companies to move from socal to NorCal?

like

I am new in oracle . Just wanted to know is there any yearly hikes in oracle idc and are hikes project dependent and manager dependent here?

like

Are all the Oracle certifications free irrespective of our team after we join Oracle? Or WT can do certification only of our manners assigns any to us?

like

Hey Guys,

need some help.

my DOJ & Notice period is conflicting by 5 days. None of the party agreeing to adjust.

New Employer (Oracle) mentioned that his budget will expire by May 31 so cloudn't shift the DOJ.

What should I do now ?

like

What could be the expected CTC for 16+ experienced Linux Sysadmin in Oracle, waiting for the HR round current CTC is 15 LPA

like
funnylike

Hi! What are some of your best strategies for coming up with a name for a side project? I’m about to start a food related site + dinner club but am having a really hard time coming up with a good name

Is there some type of document I can sign to protect myself and my assets when buying a new property?

like

Hi fishes
I got an offer from Accenture today night
Fixed 6.5 for management level 11
Can someone please help me is it a fair offer?
And there is no any discussion happened with me regarding salary
Please help me

like

I recently got my advertising degree and created an art direction portfolio. Would any creative be interested in looking at my work and give me feedback?

like

Additional Posts in The Worklife Bowl

I feel you..

Post Photo
likefunnyupliftingsmart

Did you buy anything that you need to return but can’t because everything is shut down now?

like

People who work in NYC: how do you feel about taking trains or the subway to work if shelter in place ends by end of May?

like

So... are agencies hiring, or no? I feel like one minute I’m witnessing layoffs, and the next I’m seeing job postings on LinkedIn.

like

Um, I feel like my BF of almost 4yrs (1 living together) and I are on the brink of separating. I think COVID is putting it into perspective. We’ve gotten through the worst of the quarantine while supporting each other as best we could (very thankful for him). But his coping skills with stress (during covid) are lacking and as things progressed he’s just been taking it out on me more and more in the moment, then he feels awful for not treating me as well as I deserve (he treated me well before..)

like

Anyone else realize they haven’t used an alarm clock during the quarantine after using one every day previously?

like

If you were still in undergrad would you prefer 1. Go back to campus and have an in person/hybrid learning experience with restrictions on social life
2. Have your school go fully remote for the entire fall semester
3. Defer for a year and resume your education fall 2021 when things will hopefully be “normal”
I think I’d choose 3 but idk. Tough call, and I feel bad for current college students

like

My whole sleep schedule is fucked up thanks to my husband the teacher, who can sleep in and “give out assignments” for like an hour

likefunny

Can you spot the demon sperm that gives you genital warts at night? Sleep tight fellow 🐠!

Post Photo
like

Approaching the 1 year mark of my career and taking some time to reflect. What advice would you have for your 23 year old self?

like

Thoughts about associates and in-house counsel (i.e., attys with no control) unionizing? I have friends who are required to go into their offices despite 'Rona! Collective bargaining helpful here?

like

What levels are there in Industry Tax?

like

Me, on holiday on the Mediterranean with my American accent... ☀️🏖🍹
Locals: 😳😷😬

likefunny

We didn’t listen!!!

like

Wanting a new computer for games and stuff. Mostly so I can play the new flight simulator when it comes out. Don’t want to spend a fortune- any good value recommendations? :)

like

Tomorrow is the 1 year anniversary of the passing of my roommates mom. She’s devastated and I know tomorrow will be hard. Any ideas on what I can do to help her through appreciated.

likeuplifting

What’s cooking? I’ve got Brazilian Caldo Verde simmering on the stove. Post tonight’s dinner.

Post Photo
likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal