Curiosity: why does a women’s income is only her income & a men’s income is whole family’s? Is this definition of an independent women ? Many marriages being compromised due to this mindset among working women. POVs are welcome

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I haven't seen this thought process recently. I belong to a middle class family and every man and woman are working in my household. And I have seen my parents and my in-laws, regardless of gender, they contribute to the family equally. We are also following the legacy.

Surely, this topic is a point of discussion but think like this, there is a couple, both of them are earning. In-laws don't like their Bahu and tolerating her because of their son. Now, the son thinks her mom and dad loves her, which is not a true thing. Now, the Son has nominated her mother as nominee with 100% share in all his capitals and insurances. The couple has a kid as well which the wife takes care with her money and sometimes his money, of there is a shortage. For some reason, the Husband is no more or get separated and In laws asked the Bahu to go away and no support is going to be provided to her, which they made clear. In this scenario, if the lady has not saved any of her money or worst, she is not working, she will become a burden to her family as well. Hence, her money should be her money, to protect her dignity and self respect in the worst case scenarios.

Though, for privileged Feminists, I have no idea what they are talking about.

This is my view point.

like

Nice view point. Hadn't thought of it this way. So this makes it clear that a husband and wife should have only each other as their nominees. Not their kids, not their parents. It's the husband and wife that stay together for life. All others leave at some point.

Well nothing like that. I am a girl and I myself suggested to my husband that we contribute equally to a common fund for all expenses. However, he suggested that at whichever point in life whosoever’s salary stands higher that person would take care of monthly household expenses (rent,electricity,grocery,househelp,xyz)and other person would save up for annual trips and weekend outings including movies,outside meals etc). And whatever would be the balance for both we save up for common goals and also for individual expenses. I kinda agreed with his idea and as of now we are just following it , Ofcourse with few adjustments sometimes for gifting expenses or sudden medicinal expenses we then do review it periodically . Also we are planning for a baby soon and we are both open to reallocation of the budgeted expenses in future.

like

Good understanding…! 👏

Recent IconRecent

It’s not like that I am a women and I do contribute in everything, I pay home loan emi which is 60% of my salary and rest of the money is also used for household expenses

like

But that should be fine, why they had to cancel ? Everyone may have their own liabilities.

like

It's vice versa before responsibilities phase and after responsibilities phase.

Before working stage:
Females (not talking about belonging to rich family) they are not given a freedom to spend the money as they want (some do get but some don't). There is a sense of dependency while making decisions related to anything be it spending money unlike most of the guys(few guys are exceptions) who don't have much dependency while making these decisions or it's easy to make it.
Initially it used to be consider it's the man role to provide food and shelter to family and wife role is to take care of family. Managing expenses, running the house, taking care of everyone's health etc.

Guys are risk taker, can take risk, can do heavy works because that's how their body is built. Females are good at multitasking and can manage things pretty well. So because of this, notion was like that.
Now women started earning so some of them consider it as an extra income(or side income) so they take it as an extra money and since they earned it they are free to use in the way they wish to. This thinking which was not there in the before working stage gets developed.
But not all women are like this.
There are some women(empathetic ones) who understands that pressure can be real for their husband as they must have feel it while working so they are also supporting them by contributing, not considering the money they have earn as an extra income but income to contribute in running the house(paying rent, bills, kid's fees etc).

So problem with those women is developing those kinda notion and thinking.

like

True that … They have the luxury to take their salary for themselves . when we ask anything about it they will say are you even a man asking for your women’s salary like this ? Meanwhile they always have the right to ask our salary for themselves and the family which is right … Men will always be loved with a condition that he will provide for the family whereas women and dogs will always be loved unconditionally …. Sad truth 😄

like

This is how feminist see women empowerment.
90% of the cases, men only have to take care of the expenses and women just enjoy their salary.

like

Lucky me. Me and my wife both believe what we earn is for "us". And that's the critical mindset which helps us decide together on the savings and purchases we make. And ofcourse our marriage stays strong without issues.

likeuplifting

And additionally in whatever investments we make, it should either be a joint ownership or the other person should be the nominee. So both will know that there won't be any issue financially at any point. No question of getting cheated etc.

like

So sad that you had come across women who set such standards for you. Character and integrity has nothing to do with gender. And spending/investing/paying bills through your income reflects your character.

like

Due to the same reason why women has the responsibility of the whole house and the family along with family's mental & physical health, their daily maintenance etc.. and men's responsibility is only regarding the financial aspect.

like

Not true, I'm not married but as a grown woman I too have responsibilities. My parents donot have enough money for the education of my brother who will be going to college soon so I don't contribute in running the household but they do know that I'm saving up for his education. Thinking everyone belong to the same boat or accusing women of spending on their will is not right, some might be saving for greater causes or some might just be living their life to fullest, this differs from person to person and I think has nothing to do with gender.

like

I was raised by a woman who worked in a bank and she contributed well to overall expenses. My mother's job ensured that our family got multiple benefits which come with the PSU bank job such as low interest loans, LTCs etc.
And while doing her 10-8/9 pm job, we never ordered food during weekdays and had piping hot food everyday.

Thankful and Lucky

like

Wow so glad to see humble MBB people around. Hope you too are surrounded by an understanding working woman. 😊

like

Kyuki main apni favourite hu🤡

like

Definitely, no choices left. So appreciate urself , think about yourself and mein apni favorite hu

like

Gone r those days when husband's takes care of wife needs n requirements. Now a days husband's says u r earning na , y cannot u buy what u want. I can only do this much , Anything more may be beautiful curtains of ur choice u buy n feel happy. Am ok with old curtains.
So stop pointing about women. Situations forces them to become selfish. They r paraya dhan for parents n paraya ghar se for in laws.

like

But is it right to be selfish once you are married ? You’ll never be happy & just self-centered, money is root of many problems.

like

This post is from 2004

like

I read somewhere one that if both partners in a marriage are earning then the husband's income can be used for household expenses and survival and the woman's income should be fully saved to make a big investment later like putting the money in property or opening up a business etc. this leads to a secire future for you and your family. Vice versa can also be done but 100% of the income of partner earning less should be saved.

like

Feels like feminists get offended badly seeing this post 🙂

funny

Good question.

OP was talking about not being cooperative and putting financial burden on one party.
It should be planned together nah.

I have several cases where females are like my money is my money. Spending lavishly and taunting husband not able to take financial responsibilities.

And have scene where the females are supporting their husband and trying to reduce the burden.

like

Ye sab kehne ki baatein hain

Jaisi jiski soch.

like

I have also seen cases where boys demanded that girl need to give her salary to boy family.
Or they will take hisaab for her own salary
Paying expenses equally is fine but nobody should control other’s salary.

Its upto the mentality that anyone can have , but what I can say is community has made those rules . Not the people so its upto the people what needs to agree and what not.

Related Posts

What would you do if you didn’t need money? I have a fair amount coming one day and don’t actually need to work to live a good life (middle / upper-middle class). I work because of this vague notion of “ambition” and because everyone I grew up around is highly competitive and hard driving. I just feel unhappy so often and am wondering what this is all leading to. Scared I’m wasting my life being unhappy / in turmoil cause it’s what my culture wants me to do.

like

Does EY have anything to help you get connected with an au pair company?

I have pretty strong social phobia and am worried about making friends. I'm going to be working for an engineering company so I imagine I don't have to be really up on the latest trends or anything but how can I talk to people without making it sound unnatural?

like

How have you combated your fear of rejection? I fixate on such small things as when my friends, for example, reject plans I have made. This definitely makes me more averse to putting myself out there and makes me ruminate on past perceived failures, which are clearly not good for personal growth

like

Is my relationship worth it? Met my SO of 3 years senior year of college. Hoped we would graduate and start our full time jobs together, but my SO is unfortunately still in school (switched majors, transferred schools, etc). Our relationship has taken a big hit, as I am moving forward with my life but he is still in school and can’t find a job. I am also starting to resent him and he is turning more insecure. I am only 23, is this worth it?

like

Happy wife happy life is a really toxic saying. I’m just shocked how this has become the standard saying for men in relationships. I have friends of mine saying this all the time, and I have just thought it’s so cringe and always want to say my thoughts on it but always decide to hold back. However, imagine the saying reversed - happy husband happy life - that would lead to all kinds of uproar. To me happy wife happy life means I need to sacrifice my wants and needs to make my wife happy.

likefunnysmarthelpful

I hate that I still want to hear from him. I just have no idea what I want him to say or what I want to say. I feel like if I get anywhere near him he’ll be able to sense my pain. Are we sure the no contact rule is only 21 days? I feel like I need 21 months.

like

Any single parents in here? If so, and you want support and understanding from other single parents please join the new “single-parents” bowl. Especially as busy season is here.

like

When your also consulting boyfriend has to leave on Mondays.....

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Would you break up with your girlfriend if she doesn’t want kids and you do.... this has been weighing on my mind a lot recently...

like

My wife reads nearly an entire book per day just in her spare time after work, no exaggeration. I’m amazed by her and wondering what ideas are out there to monetize her skill? Book editing maybe?

likefunnysmart

Early mornings became my best friend once I had kids. Managing to put 2 to 3 hrs of work Sat and Sun before they are awake means that I get to spend more time with them during the day.

likesmart

Anybody willing to help a broke kid out with some mock interview prep?

like

Best self-care tips for dealing with loneliness/sadness this time of year? This is my first Christmas without my mom and it just feels like nothing will ever be the same again 😭. If you’ve lost a parent can you give me advice on getting through the holidays? Being a parentalish figure to my students is both healing and heartbreaking.

like

How do you and your partner (married or not married) split financials?

like

Starting at PwC next year... newly married (Husband) with a kid on the way. How's life going to be with a newborn as a new associate? I'm older (30) and went back to school for my CPA if that matters.

like

How many couples here where the husband/male SO is younger than the wife/female SO? And what if the age difference.
To start..I'm 34 and wife is 36.

like

Anyone in the suburbs find it harder to make friends compared to the city? I don’t want to move back but I don’t know what else to do..

like

Partners, how have you managed to balance the work, obviously substantial, and your family? I see many with stay-home SO, but wondering if it is possible to prioritize family if your SO has a demanding career

like

How do you know if you have outgrown someone? Known my boyfriend for 2 years but have dated seriously only for 6 months. Confused as why i’m feeling this way.

like

More Posts

Which PE firms in Boston have the best reputations?

like

What is the salary range for an associate at JPM?

like

Anyone know of any Cannabis clubs/groups in Houston? DM me please

Is it so ?? Still companies will call employees ?

Post Photo
like

Microsoft Azure
Aws
Developer, administrator, architects

Remote support from india, for USA customer contact on 8851891563

like

Hi, I was promoted to Associate in March. Am I eligible for October annual hike?

like

Hi, any tips on leading/having a post mortem with a new client? Articles or first hand experience appreciated! Thank you!

A toxic co-worker tried to throw me under the bus to cover their mistake in a call with leadership 😢😢. I showed the proof of conversation the next moment without hesitation to everyone. Suddenly their tone changes and tries to divert the topic 😒😒. I am distraught 🙁🙁

likeupliftingfunny

What are the best ways of tax exemption

like

What brands do Pride right? Any favorite campaigns come to mind? Or on the flip side, any campaigns you dislike for being tone-deaf or performative?

like

I live in metro Atlanta. I’m looking to move to a space that has a more suburban feel, but is still close enough to the city to not hamper my social life. I like going to the party - not constantly living in it. Any suggestions? Currently renting, but open to buying in the next three years.

like

Lets be real

Post Photo
like

Is making 10 times your initial salary in 25 years at the same company good progression? Started at 20k and making 210k.

like

Where is Kyndryl in Mumbai? What kind of job roles are in Kyndryl Mumbai? Is it good to join?

like

What's the ACD salary range in Chicago? Same for in-house?

like

Today’s my first day changing my pronouns at work, I am excited and terrified!! If you did the same and feel like sharing, I would love to hear your experience 💫 I am so anxious!

likeuplifting

Hi! How is everyone holding up?

Which city is the best to live in for a couple in their mid twenties?

1. Hamburg
2. Munich
3. Berlin

Thanks in advance!

Looking for advice! My poor pups get eaten alive by fleas even with the regular flea medication. I'm thinking about trying a flea collar. Has anyone had luck going that route?

Davy Crockett here would love to know your thoughts 🐶

Post Photo
like

I see only people with huge lpa of 15lpa+with yoe 2 to 3 here. Anyone with yoe between 3 to 5 but is having an median salary of 5 to 9 lpa here? Just wondering!!!!!

like

Additional Posts in Corporate Humour & Stories

An out of office email i read somewhere.

Hi,

Thanks for your email. I am currently OoO.
For emergencies conatct below
USI -112
US - 911

All other things can be taken care when i am back.

funnylike
like

bawaaa 20k+ members in this bowl.
😁

thank you all for being part of this.... ❤️

likefunnyuplifting

So I used to work for this shady Series A funded startup in Mumbai. Our CEO was a drug addict who funnelled money back to a lobbyist on the VC side. They paid INR 1.2 Crores for their logo to a "creative agency", just one of the many dodgy expenses they made including multiple so-called official trips to exotic locations like Hawaii. Till date their SAAS product has not found a single buyer. The CEO's girlfriend was the Sales Director whose job was to wear skimpy dresses for business meetings.

like
like

Please bada do yaar😂

Post Photo
likefunny

Happy diwali 😂

Post Photo
funnylike

Hi
Staying at current company tech Mahindra with 23lpa (100% hike) or going to societe generale with 20.86 lpa(81% hike),which one is better?
Will societe generale brand name give me anything extra in long run?

like

Trend after FY is over😅

Post Photo
likefunny

You got it, Boss!

Post Photo
funnylike

Especially on weekends 😅

Post Photo
funnylike

Totally agree 😁

Post Photo
funnylike

I am pleased to announce that i have successfully eaten lunch today without any hindrance from external factors like urgent calls, deadlines, quick calls, random meetings, small doubts questions from newbies. What are your thoughts?? Comment below

Post Photo
likefunny

How to handle the when company doesn’t have Work life balance They literally Have in times and No out times 9 To 9 or sometimes till 10 11

like

Hi Fishes,

I work as a application support Analyst with 11 years of experience. What should be me my current compensation according to present market. Thanks in advance.

like

How much salary to ask for if I hold 3 years work experience in financial services domain? ( not a CA, CS, CFA) I hold PGPM degree. ( previous in hand monthly was 42K)

like

Now. That's quite prevalent

Post Photo
like

As the Friday progresses to its end my dopamine level starts increasing.....😂😀😀

likefunny

I can preorder for whole week! 😬

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting
likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal