I’m interviewing for an in-house PR role (mostly content/media relations) at a digital company. I’ve had 3 interviews so far and completed one extensive writing assessment (800-word article). I’m pretty sure I have the job, and had a great interview with VP of Corp. Comms. today. She mentioned she had no hesitations about my qualifications. But the HR mgr said they now want me to do a 2nd assessment “just to dot their i’s” and they want a 750-word release by Monday. Is this normal?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What’s the point in pushing back? Do you think they’re using your work for a client? That release will probably take you 1-2 hours, I’d just do it. 🤷🏼‍♀️

like

I’d still complete the assignment. Definitely don’t push back. But who the heck writes 750 word releases these days?! That’s way too long.

like

Thank you all for your feedback! I went forward with the assessment, and they loved all of my work/both assessments and offered me the job. The recruiter explained that they wanted to take extra steps to make sure I was the right fit as they’re a small team and 100% remote, and there wasn’t any in-person interaction or interviews.

like

Congrats!!!

They’re using this as either a final tiebreaker between you and another candidate, or they really like you but maybe saw something in your other samples that gave them pause, so they wanted one last pass before a decision.

likesmart

Also want to note I’ve shared more writing samples than asked for already. Should I push back at all on this? I feel they should have a good idea of my writing skills by now and this is a good bit of work to do before getting an offer.

like

I had to do multiple assessments for my in house job but there was only one writing assessment and it was at the beginning of the process. Agree it’s odd - they might be deciding between a few final candidates and this is one of the inputs they’re evaluating

like

First, this is stupid & arbitrary. I'll say what no one else will. The fact that multiple comms pros can't crack this case demonstrates that this firm doesn't communicate very openly.

Second, a writing sample proves almost nothing. As a fmr VP at a top 10 PR firm, I constantly pushed colleagues to move towards a case study interview format. Give em something we've worked on or are working on...give em a few days or a week to chew on it and see what the candidate comes up with. Have em present in front of a group as if they're presenting in front of a client. This way the firm gets to see an in depth view of the candidate's analytical abilities, oral and written presentation skills and ability to persuade. Much more than a funky 700 word writing sample.

likesmart

It’s a lot, but if you want the job, I’d do it. It’s just a release.

like

It sounds like someone is concerned about your writing capabilities and they’re wanting to make sure you’re the right fit or being brought on at a proper level. Would recommend you submit the request.

like

Seems excessive, I’ve been given “writing tests” with multiple components but it was all given at once...never had to do a 2nd round of writing.

like

Related Posts

What do you all think is the upper limit range for someone in an account manager role at a tech firm? What’s the career path? Was there anything you’ve done in terms of upskilling that resulted in increased pay? Or should I just pick something else if I want to be making more than what I make atm ~150k TC with 6 years exp.

like

For American expats, what % of your salary do you take home and what are the deductions involved? Contemplating an offer for a role in London but want to make sure I get a realistic sense of what my pay will be

like

Is any place hiring for a corporate strategy role in Atlanta or remote? 5yoe (3.5 at big four and 1.5 program manager in TMT)

like

Hey fishes, can anyone refer me to for integration role.. my skills - IIB, MQ, Azure, Java, Python ..

How much EY GDS pays for test lead position with automation experience?

like

How long did it take you guys to get used to your first role at a BB? How long did it take you to get little to no supervision on your work?

like
like

Has LinkedIn apply helped anyone to land an interview etc.? If not what according to you are some of the best ways to land a job in your company of choice or bette yet what has worked for you?

like

Anyone know of IT Security jobs specializing in NIST and/or FISMA that are hiring?

I am leaving retail pharmacy after 15 years. I am opening a 403b pharmacy for a FQHC. I don't believe that retail pharmacy will be able to sustain itself with patient costs skyrocketing. I think people will become enraged or indifferent enough to allow the federal government to take over healthcare. How many times do we see people getting free prescriptions via government coverage that drive better cars than we do?

like

Interviewing with DoorDash for an infrastructure Security position. Anyone interviewed for a security position with them recently?

like

Thoughts on taking a position in the same practice group and same class as your spouse?

like

Should I complain to a firm's HR if the interviewers laughed at my answer during an interview? Maybe it sounded scripted but it was still heartfelt and genuine: my immigration story and how that made me appreciate the rule of law. I said it soo many times during OCI's that maybe it eventually sounded robotic, but for the interviewers to laugh and one to say sarcastically "nice elevator pitch", I thought was rude. Thoughts?

like

Got an interview with Amazon within their Advertising department. I hear working for Amazon can be great if you get into the right department. Anyone have insights to their advertising department? Good or bad? Also, would love some interview tips if you have them! (It’s for an Executive Assistant position) thank you!

like

Hi! Anyone here open to giving a referral for American Express?

like

Looking for a sourcer/recruiter position, preferably at Apple or Google. Can anyone refer me?

like

I just started looking for a job and made some profiles on various job boards. I'm getting a lot of emails from recruiters that look like this. Whenever I talk to them on the phone it's very hard to hear them and the whole thing just seems a bit fishy. They ask for my DOB, and one asked if I would sign something so they could market my profile. Is this a scam?
I've censored names, addresses, and phone numbers.

Post Photo
like

What's the salary FIS can offer..I am currently at 55..This is for a PM role at FIS

like

I'm interviewing with RSM for a Manager Consulting role. Does any one have any idea what the salary range for manager level in RSM consulting?

like

What's the review process for firms. I have people getting rejected but I haven't heard anything. Is it interviews, offers, rejections? Or is it review/ interview and rejections then offers.

like

More Posts

Who has a TikTok for interior design! Looking to follow new interesting accounts

like

What's the biggest life lesson joining the military taught you?

like

New York Shitty

like

Any leads to get Mechanical Job in US from India??!! I'm with 5 years of experience in Automotive field

like

I’m too lazy to post Instagram stories.

likefunny

Hi all, still trying to get a sense of what a program manager salary range is for e-commerce company in Toronto, 15+ YOE. Anyone?

like

I feel like I've been lowballed, can someone explain the below breakdown please?

Base salary: 60k
Quarterly quota (per quarter): 107k
Quarterly bonus (per annum): 23k
130% Annual bonus = 11.5k
"23% commission on quota minus base": 37k (don't understand this)
"Proposed 23% commission on 150% quota minus base": 86.5k
Sales commission threshold per month: 22k
OTE: 122k
Cost/Sales: 28%

That base salary is lower than my previous base by a significant amount by 32.7%

like

The only qualifier to becoming an industry legend should be whether or not you’ve worked with Sam Elliot. Nay, his mustache. Prove me wrong.

likefunny

What does a VP1 make all-in in IBD?

like

Let’s talk finances. How are you all paying for this? Loans, I assume, but any strategies?
In early 2021, better to try to max out retirement accounts to maximize financial aid or to just start saving?
200k is so much.

like

how common is the 40x rule (landlords want you to make at least 40x the rent)?? i’m looking to move to nyc and want a studio, so narrowing down my search to find a studio <2k feels impossible, esp in a convenient location. any insight would be helpful!

like

BGC becoming strict in all companies these days

Post Photo
like

After document verification how many days it takes to release offer letter in TCS

like

Found a random engagement ring.

Hi all, so I found a platinum ring (which I assumed it's an engagement ring as it has dates and initials engraved on top.) And a Divvy tag (I have no idea what it was until I googled it. Apparently it's a bike sharing service in Chicago) in a briefcase I ordered online. I was thinking of returning the item back to the store but that wouldn't help the person who lost the ring. Attached is a picture of them.

What should I do now?

**I'm not in Chicago

Post Photo
like

Does anyone have membership information for Fields Ranch at the new PGA headquarters in Frisco?

like

Is it possible to transfer from CN India to Accenture Canada (if one gets a Canadian PR themselves)? How well is it taken by the leadership and is any kind of support provided?

likehelpful

Interviewing with DoorDash for an infrastructure Security position. Anyone interviewed for a security position with them recently?

like
like

What pays more at the partner level? MBB or LMM PE? I know it's a no contest in favor of PE for MF and UMM. Wondering how lucrative LMM is.

like
like

Additional Posts in PR and Communications

What PR agencies have creative departments? I know Weber and Edelman do - but any others?

like

Started recently in February and ended up on clients I don’t love/understand. I know for a fact I want to change at least one account. How do I go about asking HR this? When would be an optimal time?

like

How do junior level employees make it work in NYC? Want to work for a top tier firm which more seem to be located in NYC. But with starting salaries being low and cost of living being high is it worth it?

like

What’s the culture like at Ogilvy San Francisco?

I was passed up for a promotion after 1.5 years at the agency/in the role despite consistently great feedback and was told that I just needed more time in role. A guy with my experience level was....

like

What’s the best thing you learned this week? Good, bad and ugly. 😭

Drop your key learnings in the comments.👇🏾

like

Has anyone done a collab with influencer MIKIRAI? I know she’s a big deal but i’m trying to figure out if she’s worth the money, our agency just had a bad experience with an influencer and the client is not happy. We need to make a comeback! All insights are appreciated.

Getting ready to go freelance after a decade doing corp comms in agencies. Looking for guidance or good resources on how to determine my hourly rate. Any solo practitioners got advice? I am nervous about underselling myself.

like

Anyone work at an agency that doesn’t recognize titles? How does it work? How do you foster growth, recognition and satisfaction? Pros/cons associated with prioritizing function over seniority? Would love any thoughts!

like

Hi all- curious if anyone can speak to life at LifeSci Comms in NY? Appreciate any insight!

like

Any insight into Red Havas ? I’ve been interviewing with them and it seems too good to be true…

like

Looking for any communication roles. 10+ years of experience in public (local and federal government consulting) and private sector. Either remote/hybrid, or in the DC metro area. Thanks!

like

My team oversees internal comms and we’re in the process of signing on BananaTag.

Any fishies out there that can share what level of reporting + KPIs you’re providing leadership?

We plan to use it for exec comms and department-level leadership (HR, IT, etc.).

We’ve historically done mass communication through Outlook, so this will be our first time getting insight into staff e-mail + Teams performance.

like

What’s the culture like at H+K? I get the impression that it’s a lot more up tight than other big agencies. I get old school, suited up, lobbying type PR vibes but I could be wrong.

like

Candid thoughts on the Ogilvy LA office?

Does your brand use the Oxford comma?

like

Feeling burnt out and unmotivated with agency life. Throughout the past year I’ve been added to a variety of “problem accounts” with challenging, disorganized and rude client contacts. Since then, it feels my teams have dwindled and I’ve been left to pick up the pieces / manage it all. I’m struggling to feel inspired and am starting to dread my work. Any tips for how to initiate account changes without sounding whiny? Or - any tips in general?

like

Anyone have advice for advancing in your current role? My co-worker was hired in at manager level but somehow “proved” he was actually doing director level work and got a title promotion and salary increase in less than a year. I also went above and beyond my job as well (covering for him for a month while he was away on paternity leave) while taking on other projects outside of my job title and got zip—no raise or recognition. Any advice would be appreciated!

like

Has anyone’s agency developed a practice focused on social justice in the past couple months? Saw Praytell’s and was curious about if other agencies had too.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal