In CA: PC bought condo while with gf, then quitclaimed it to her via quitclaim deed and sold it to her for $100k, which they put in writing. Fast forward they broke up and PC tried to get his $100k from her and filed suit but her attorney is saying that since he quitclaimed the property to her he has no rights including no rights to the breach of contract claim. This doesn’t seem right but I’m having a hard time finding caselaw that directly says this. Any help will be appreciated!

smart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

The part that is intriguing me is the order in which you say this. Did he quitclaim it to her and then sell it? That seems backwards which makes it seem like his gf’s attorney’s argument might hold some merit. If he quitclaimed it before the contract then it wasn’t his to sell because he didn’t own it.

like

They drafted up an agreement, that they both signed. He then deeded it to her a couple months later. She never paid. He didn’t bother asking for the money bc they were still together and it kept getting delayed. After they broke up he asked for the money.

I’m confused as to how this unfolded. He executed a quit claim deed in her favor, and then he entered into a contract to sell the property to her again? Or did he quit claim it to her before being paid based on a contract that had previously been executed?

If he quit claimed it to her and then tried to sell it to her again under a subsequently executed contract, I think you have a significant issue. Seems like there is a failure of consideration on his part for the hundred thousand dollars.

If he executed a contract and then quit claimed it to her without being paid, I think you still may have some issues. But I’d rather be in a position of arguing that the provisions of the contract should not be merged into the deed (because I think this would be a doctor merger issue) than to deal with a total failure of consideration.

like

I’m not sure it’s an ironclad case for the bad actress. Based on my extensive knowledge on this issue - which is mostly some Google searching after my first post on this issue to make sure I wasn’t totally off base - it seems like the doctrine of merger may be being applied on a more limited basis than in the past and payment of consideration is so fundamental, that I’m not confident it’s a total bar. That feels intuitively right as you suggest - which is why I said in my first post that I’d prefer that position over the contract being signed after the quitclaim.

like

‘Quitclaim’ - and I thought we used more old fashioned words here in England! 😂

Related Posts

Recommendations on an exceptional career coach who can help my husband? He works with his brother at a startup his brother founded (my husband is in-house counsel) but often finds himself belittled by his brother, cut out of conference calls and emails and generally feeling like he has no skills. He's an ivy league graduate and went to a great law school but for many reasons cannot leave this job right now. Looking for someone to help w/his confidence level and ways to approach his brother. TIA!

like

Anyone work in NY state most specifically Jefferson County? I have a Q re: divorce case, but not sure if I can even private message on this thing.

like

When your also consulting boyfriend has to leave on Mondays.....

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

I'm not having children out of choice (I think, although the Mrs. and I haven't "tried"). Yet, I feel I have to hide that I don't WANT kids from clients and even some partners. Who feels the same?

like

Would you break up with your girlfriend if she doesn’t want kids and you do.... this has been weighing on my mind a lot recently...

like

I've been building a side project with my friend, but they're not putting in as much effort as I am. We've been friends since we entered college together, but it's starting to become too much. Should I talk to them about it?

like

Lawyer Couples:
I’m currently an associate (no kids) in a very busy corp group (think 50-60 billable weekly). My wife works significantly less (currently part time, 10-15, but hopefully will be full time soon). I find myself getting upset when asked to help with basic household things (trash, cooking etc.) when she’s been lounging around watching Netflix all day. Am I being reasonable or am I a misogynist? How do you deal with one person having significantly more free time than the other?

likehelpful

90 day fiancé (this needs its own bowl): Choose between marrying Angela or baby girl Lisa.

like

Am I horrible wife if I don’t get my husband anything for his bday. I have no idea what to get it’s too stressful. He always gets me stuff.

like

Hey everyone. Can someone please suggest different type of work in Accenture with less work pressure suitable for returning mother.

like

Well, I was the one who broke it off. I couldn’t get him to love me the way I needed or even respect me enough. It’s been 6 weeks of not seeing each other. We messaged this week. He doesn’t get it…. His messages show he still doesn’t know what he wants. Yet, if I am totally honest, I hate how part of me wishes he would do a grand gesture/finally decide to be a better man. It’s delusional. It’s crazy how love can be so rosy, sweet & blinding that the red flags seem surmountable.

like

Am I crazy or do women take pride in saying “my boyfriend/husband makes twice as much as me” or similar statements

Partners, how have you managed to balance the work, obviously substantial, and your family? I see many with stay-home SO, but wondering if it is possible to prioritize family if your SO has a demanding career

like

What are some of the best books you've read for relationship advice?

like

For anyone in this bowl. How crucial is it for you to have a formal dining room separated from the kitchen? My son and daughter-in-law are buying a house for their future family and I'm trying to convince them a formal dining room looks better and makes things less chaotic in the kitchen, especially with kids. Am I out of touch? Or is it still important?

like

Making this a bit more dynamic. I’d love to know everyone’s view on this. What are your 3 main dealbreakers when considering a relationship with someone?

It’s week 5 for me of the breakup and even though I had a full and fun weekend with friends and people I love, I woke up today so so sad because I wanted to text my ex. I just feel overall so defeated and exhausted from sadness and unmotivated at work :(

like

Help!! My bestfriend is doing two months abroad and was trying to fly into turkey when they told her she couldn't because her passport expired within three months.

She went to the US Embassay in Athens knowing she had a month left of traveling, and gave her an emergency passport and punched holes in her exsisting one. Now no country will let her in with her emergency passport.

Can her mom get her a passport in the US and ship it to her? Is there anyway around this?

Thank you!!

like

Thinking about moving from Seattle to San Diego, but don’t have any friends down there. Any advice for how to meet queer friends?

like

Anyone have a primer on working with children? From a business affairs perspective?

like

More Posts

Hi , Anyone who got interviewed in Infosys in last month? Any updates from HR after salary discussion? Tata Consultancy Infosys Wipro Capgemini IBM HCL Technologies

like

If you interested then contact with CV, akankshamajoristechnologies@gmail.com
Or DM me.

NP– Immediate and max 1 month
location – Bangalore/Pune/Noida/Bhubaneswar

Azure Data Engineer/ Lead/Architect (4-15 Yrs) –
Role: Azure Data Architect with streaming experience

Data Governance (5-10 Yrs)
Candidate should have experience in data management area Strong SQL and ETL knowledge

Data Strategy Consultant (5-10 Yrs)
For Sonora Quest Data Strategy & Assessment : 10+ years of exp

like

Any book or podcast recommendations for managing anger?

like

I’ve only lost ~5 pounds, but I’ve been working out daily for 4 months and getting much stronger and healthier (started working out intermittently for about a year before that). Yesterday I fit into a pair of shorts that haven’t fit in 4 years 🥳🥳

likeuplifting

Hi guys,

I switched 20 days back to Optum. I have 7 years of experience working as a full stack Engineer, who is passionate working on both front end and back end on latest technologies. But my project is working only on back end with 10 years old tech stack. There is no front end work at all. What should I do?
I don't like working here at all, but I am not sure whether moving out again in a month will give bad Impression on my resume. Hence please give me advice on this situation

like

Waddle or Theilen?

like

I hope you all are having a good day and looking forward to the weekend!

I would request all the members to respond to this.

List some of the major concerns of our day-to-day professional lives that are hampering the quality of our work and how support our stakeholders.

like

Anyone have any idea when the hiring freeze might end within AWS ProServ? I’m currently at Amazon and have a TS clearance, PMP & CSM. I come from a Big4 consulting firm with a background in Enterprise Performance. I’ll be honest and say I’m not feeling very safe in my current role with the ongoing layoffs. Instead of leaving, I’d love to go back to my “consulting roots” and join the ProServ team. I’m taking my AWS Certified Cloud Practitioner exam next weekend. Hoping this freeze is lifted soon.

like

Hi,

I am looking for opportunities in Data Science, ML Engineering, MLOps.

YOE - 12 Years
Current Designation - Senior Data Scientist
Serving Notice period.
Can you refer me in your organization for similar roles.

like

How to battle feelings of inadequacy in the workplace? Does anyone else ever feel this way

like

SPY 200 by year end

like

how is work culture in Encora ?

like

Good to have this bowl. Looking for some insightful conversations. Currently in the US, me & my wife are planning to move back to India.
Business Consultant here, 7 YOE.

like

Any company hiring for media sales & advertising in Mumbai?

Anyone with experience working for Bridgewater Associates, LP? Had a recruiter reach out for a BA/PM role. Associate level/experienced hire, on portfolio transformation team.

How’s the whole experience? Comp package, benefits, work life balance, etc.

like

Has anyone here considered leaving healthcare altogether? I am really drawn by a role in tech, but I know it's such a big leap. I have a friend who did this though, and she is making even more than I have made as a travel nurse. Is it an anomaly or a real possibility?

like

What would be the in-hand monthly salary for this Capgemini offer ? Can anyone pls tell, confused with 'Other Allowances and Reimbursement -1,2'.

Post Photo
like

I have to say EY FDD interview process was very scary lol a little nervous on if I will be getting it or not

like

How is the volume at RSM compared to the Big 4?

like

Can you recommend me a contracting agency? For temp work. I am based in NYC and a Product Manager

Additional Posts in Real Estate - Law

Looking to work at a title company? Do they pay well and how prestigious is it? Are there any that are “better” than others?

like

What happened to the ArentFox title policy limits? Is there an alternative?

like

Any recommendations for books/articles/other materials regarding development deals? I’ve been doing CRE transactions for years, but I just started a new role that includes a big development component. I’d love something that walks me through the major components of a development deal/explains when certain AIA forms get used, etc. (to supplement the training I’m getting from my boss)

like

Any recommendations on resources for a litigator lateraling into a real estate associate role? Books, guides, newsletters, etc. would all be helpful.

like

If a lien was placed in one persons name on a property held in joint tenancy with survivorship and the party who’s name was on the lien (one of the joint tenants) dies what is the status of the lien?

Over a year ago, I lateraled from a firm doing mostly land use/development to a volume lender debt finance practice. By volume I mean I’m on 15+ deals a day. I don’t think this is for me….anyone have any other CRE practices that they enjoy? I’m thinking about jumping back to a borrower side practice, but curious to hear about other CRE associate experiences. Thanks!

like

Where have people ended up after a stint (5 years or more) at big law? Would appreciate your responses - maybe in the form of: position, hours requirement, and salary. Thank you so much. ☺️

like

Do you use a series LLC for real estate holdings? Why or why not?

like

I have a lease with my landlord in NYC. He is selling the unit. Am I going to be pushed out by the new owner? I’m still ok till my lease termination date regardless right? I guess that’s all I care about.

likehelpful

Any real estate attorneys interested in exploring new opportunities?

like

Question for anyone who may be able to answer.

We are looking to file something like an injunction injunction to stop a property sale. The property is owned by a sister and brother. Brother is deceased so it passed down to his children. The heirs bad no idea the aunt is trying to sell. Can we file some type of injunction?

like

Best in house counsel gig for a real estate attorney? 4 toe

like

Just starting up a Airbnb Property Management business. I am located in New Jersey, wondering if corporate leasing townhomes , lofts, and or condos, (if accepted) would be well profitable in the water front area near the Hudson between New York and New Jersey. (Hoboken, edgewater, weehawken, etc)

like

Real estate help: Boyfriend and girlfriend buy a home together with a loan from bank. Boyfriend and girlfriend are now separated and both agree that girlfriend will live somewhere else. Both agree that they would like to take girlfriend off the deed but also off the hook with lender bank. What would you do in this situation as attorney for girlfriend?

like

Has anyone ever heard of this type of real estate private equity fund structure:

-One LLC, so only one PPM
-Multiple investors that can be onboarded anytime
-Multiple investments that investors can determine whether or not they want to invest in
-One K-1 per investor based on their investments and income
-Ability for the Sponsor/Fund to invest directly, indirectly and in equity, debt, Pref, etc.
To me this seems extremely cumbersome and would require multiple classes of (cont’d)

Any good books to help get you up to speed on real estate finance matters?

like

Conflicts check question: how much detail will I need to provide to (hopefully) new firm? I’ve been at the same place for a decade…so many transactions over the years! It will be easy enough to gather info by client matter number, but that doesn’t capture sub-entities and/or any other specifics.

like

When settling with a title company plaintiff on a subrogation claim, have any foreclosure defense counsel received settlements over and above policy limits? What is your typical settlement range? How has settling on your subrogation claim negatively affected your counterclaims against the mortgage lender if at all?

like

Hi All,

The real estate lateral hiring market remains hot across the US. If you are considering making a move or just wanting to understand the market opportunities in your city, please do reach out over PM.

Kind regards,

A specialist real estate legal headhunter happy to help.

likeuplifting

Any defenses to put in an answer regarding violation of the IL Residential Real Property Disclosure Act.? Buyer is suing client pro se after discovering mold in the property from a tenant after taking possession. Seller didn’t know but there was a leak issue in the past. Other advice is appreciated.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal