Related Posts
Fine day for crypto!
More Posts
Is this layoff?Amdocs

Hi can I have some likes for dms 👍
Additional Posts in Personal Finance Bowl
New to Fishbowl?
Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.




I’m genuinely curious to hear opinions as well, because this seems wild to me. As a 27 year old who went to an in-state university and got a BS and MS for $50k total(and clears $250k a year), I can’t imagine being “$300k short” for any college tuition.
I was planning to fund my kids for ~$70-100k in their accounts and call it there.
That cost for a degree sounds like highway robbery.
DA1 I knew all of my professors but that aside - is meeting your professors worth 100K+?
How much is the projected value based on the $1k by the time they go to college that Schwab tells you?
I’m have been putting $500/month since my kids were born and the projected value is around $200k. I’m approaching it from a way that this should be enough. If they need more they can either pay it themselves or if I have enough cash I can bridge the gap. But I’m not lowering my retirement contributions in order to up the 529 contributions now. The earlier contributions to retirement are so important in terms of compounded interest.
Getting there by 60% isn’t too bad.
It comes down to your priorities and what you have cash for. Personally I’d not reduce retirement over kids college especially with the amount you’re already contributing.
I know this is an extremely privileged question to ask - I didn't mean to offend. I am genuinely curious what others with similar means plan to do.
I’m running in to a similar scenario. I got to a certain level in in 529 that could be either way to high or way to low depending on where my kids go to school. I’ve now switched future month college savings to a taxable brokerage just earmarked for college if needed. If not, no big deal, I just have extra savings with no penalty
Pro
What return are you estimating? I have two kids in college now. My plan was to save $120k each which would pay for in state university. I stopped contributing when I calculated that the balance would hit that level by the time they were each 18 and pretty much hit that. Then one went out of state public and one went private. My cost for the two will be around $500k. Still I think that strategy was correct.
Rising Star
Are you planning having more kids, or relatives you wouldn’t mind transferring the 529 to if it isn’t spent.
If yes, and it won’t impact your retirement then sure, super-fund the 529.
Rising Star
Are you comfortable leaving it for grandkids?
Otherwise may be best to fund it to a reasonable estimate, and leave the rest in brokerage.
I could be wrong but I believe there is an option to roll over unused 529 funds to your 401K without a tax penalty.
Oh interesting — good to know! Thanks.
I went to public university and want my kid to go to public schools, but my wife went to private and saw benefits to that setting. However, outside of ivy leagues, I have not seen any studies or statistics correlating private education to higher salaries. Therefore, we are funding 529 assuming our kid will attend an in state public university. We are assuming we are going to fund 100% tuition and books. We plan to cash flow rent and living expenses. We have not accounted for graduate school. Not sure if that is a mistake or not.
We were doing $1k/month per kid but just switched to $2k/month per (they are 6 and 7) for this reason. I figure if they don’t use it they can just transfer to their own kids one day- basically an inheritance. And if they don’t have kids, then I guess they can just cash it out and take the penalty - free money basically.
Lot of interesting comments and observations.
OP - if you are confident about your retirement plan and you want to cover 100% of your kids tuition , go ahead and fund it. If you end up overfunding
- Changing beneficiary is very easy
- give it to grandkids
- in 15 years you can move 35k to your kids Roth (fyi this is a relatively new law)
On a personal note the first 4 years - we contributed to Roth IRA, primary for our retirements and as a proxy for kids college. Roth IRA contributions can be withdrawn after 5 years. This way you first save up for your future then your kids.
Our income has grown over time and we feel more secure and for the last three years we started contributing to a 529.