Has anyone decided not to pursue an MBA after running an ROI calc?

Maybe I’m missing something, but even with a median comp out of HBS (top choice, ~$200k total comp), the payback period seems long and IRR seems low.

Totally understand that each person’s situation is unique, but it seems to make sense for people 1) with lower comp, 2) MBA scholarship or 3) desperate need of career pivot.

Any insight is greatly appreciated 🫡

likeupliftinghelpful

Looking for part time / evening MBA options around Boston . Any thoughts on of HBS extension vs UMass Amherst vs BU ? This will be self funded . Looking to add to resume but realistic about limited career growth / networking given the part time option . 15+ YoE all in tech and consulting

like

Does an MBA (US) make sense for me? Male, Indian, Age 32, Married working in tech consulting with 10 YOE. Base is $165 with steady increases and bonus is typically 15%. I eventually do want to cross the $300K threshold but I know stopping work for 2 years and getting and MBA probably won’t get me a $300K job right away. Becoming a manger in my current company/path will probably get me there in terms of TC. Also considering EMBA from a good school (Wharton Global, Duke, Kellogg, Booth).

like

Can I take out a full $200,000 in federal loans or is there a cap for mba/graduate programs?

like

What is BCG’s MBA sponsorship program?

like

Is a firm sponsored MBA worth it? I joined S& out of undergrad and will likely be promoted to MBA entry level (Senior Associate) in the summer.

like

Is MBB’s MBA hiring done? Trying to see if this is a good time to apply as an experience hire (post MBA level). Many thanks in advance!

like

Fortunate to have been admitted to Sloan ($), Kellogg ($$$), and Haas ($$$)! Engineer by background with pre-MBA experience in supply chain consulting and a post-MBA goal of tech PM. MIT has always been the dream so feeling conflicted with the scholarship offers and open to any advice! Also odds I can leverage Kellogg and Haas to negotiate with Sloan for more money?

like

Hi, I’m an MBA final year student. I’m desperately looking for a STEM designated job with 100k salary in Boston. What companies and job roles you recommend. I’m a multi tasking person with Data, Strategy, branding, marketing, management, product.

like

Hi Fishes,

I am an ITGC, SOX auditor working with EY.
Total yoe: 3.8. MBA from tier 2 college
CAN ANYONE PLEASE REFER ME IN PWC FOR THE SAME ROLE
Any leads would be appreciated
Thanks all!

like

If you were a first year MBA deciding on an internship/full time, which career path would you choose?

Bain Consulting - then pivot into FAANG strategy&ops in 3-4 years
Microsoft Product Marketing Manager (PMM) - then try to pivot into Product Management (PM) in 2 years

like

I got admitted to full-time MBA Program at Wharton and so excited to explore what Wharton has in store!

Asking tips from you fishes - if you were enrolled in Wharton MBA, what major would you pick, and why?

I just learned that picking the Health Care Management (HCM) as a major goes hand-in-hand with your MBA application, so that may already be a lost cause for me.

like

Does MIT randomly email people saying they’re “personally” inviting them to explore their MBA program. Got me excited for a bit then reality sunk in that it was a BAU marketing email 😂

like

What on earth is going on with me? My brainpower has significantly diminished over the past 3 years (started approaching 30.) It’s so low right now that I can’t even do basic math right, and I just keep getting stuck in my own mind. I draft an email and evaluate the ways it could go wrong in my head, until I realize its 1 hour later, the email hasn’t been sent and I’ve literally just sat and stared at a screen for an hour. Do I have early onset disease? Is this stress induced? 4 months post-MBA.

likefunny
Share this 🔥 post

Are there any great perks for MBA sponsorship? Stipends, cost of living, etc? Is there a difference for 1 year or 2 year programs?

like

Good current events to study up on for an applied Econ/international MBA interview?

like

Good current events to study up on for an applied Econ/international MBA interview?

like

Should I get a certificate in SQL/Tableau for $4k or an MBA for $60k? I already have student loans of $70k but I'm looking to gain some credentials that would help me excel into a bigger more reputable firm (I.e. Morgan Stanley or American Express). My company rn will not reimburse me for professional development so I'd have to either bite the bullet for the MBA or get the certification (eCornell) and satisfy some of the tech requirements for the job listings.

like

Turned down BB IB for MBB post-MBA. Did I majorly mess up?

likefunny

Is it possible to get into Consulting without going straight through out of underground or getting an MBA? I’m a Knowledge Management Specialist looking to break into the field. Any suggestions??

like

Wanted to get insight on where my compensation compares to others with similar experience. I’m a senior marketing analyst with 5+ years experience, most of it as a business analyst. 4 years experience with SQL, 1 year experience with Salesforce, 1-2 years experience with Power BI. I have an MBA. Reason I ask is current salary is $95k/year and being bumped to $105k/year at my new job after being identified as a high performer. job offers 10% discretionary bonus based on individual performance.

like

Hi. Wanted to know if anyone can refer me to PwC, EY, Deloitte, Siemens Advanta, Kearney please! Looking for post MBA entry opportunities (Associate, Consultant). Thanks!

likehelpful

34M, Currently a Manager2 in EY Tech Consulting, making $175 base. At this rate, I may make partner at the age of 42,43. Is it worth pursuing an MBA at an M7 for a better pay/growth trajectory?

like

Hello, Anyone here who’s working at Pfizer? I’d greatly appreciate a few minutes of your valuable time to speak about my profile and if possible get a referral for the same. I’m an MBA: Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods graduate (GPA-3.9). I’m a Biomedical Engineer from my undergraduate degree. I’d be more than happy to speak more about my projects and experiences. DM me! Thanks! @Pfizer

like

I have a 25K loan from my MBA. I paid off 100k whole, after graduation. 3 years ago, I moved my loan from federal to private ( SOFI) account. I recently lost my job. I have applied for unemployment, as the severance that I received will only cover for 2 months. Together my husband and I used to make less than 250k after tax. Now, with a loss of pay , we are going to make less. Do you think I will be eligible for Loan forgiveness?

like

Hello all, I’m a MBA graduate in Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods( GPA:3.9). I’m a Biomedical Engineer from my undergraduate degree. I recently came across a pharmaceutical marketing role I’m very interested in at Pfizer. I was looking for a referral. I’d be happy to speak more about my profile. @Pfizer

helpful

Got into Booth, Kellogg, and Columbia, no $ unfortunately but excited regardless. Which one should I go to if I want to transition into Tech PM. Did my undergrad and worked in Chicago hence wanted to diversify and move to NY for the tech scene there but potentially move to SF post-MBA. Pre-MBA experience is in consulting focused on data analytics (non MBB or traditional consulting firm). What are the tech opportunities and resources like at CBS? How does it compare against booth and Kellogg?

like

Didn’t get HSW. Interested in tech. Is another M7 MBA worth it? Have offers from a few of them but not sure if it’s worth the money/time.

like

Got dinged at W. Considering not even going to Booth. Really unsure of my MBA goals

like

I’m a bit emotional from my W rejection and may be jumping the gun too quick but need help deciding, so any constructive input is appreciated.
I got into Kellogg ($) and rejected post interview from the other 4 M7s applied to. Given my post mba goal of entrepreneurship:
- should I turn down/try to defer Kellogg and reapply next year? (Will be able to demonstrate plenty of growth from now until next year)
- Or, take Kellogg and forget about the rest.

like

McKinsey & Company Hello, what is the primary occupation to put in the DS-160 for a consultant ( non manger, non MBA, experienced hire) ? Can someone from McKinsey & Company help please ?

like

Best part time MBA program in the Charlotte area?

likesmart

might be a dumb question, but is it possible to negotiate scholarship if you only have the one acceptance from round 1?

phrased as: I want to explore MBA potentially without sponsorship so I have optionality, is it possible to reconsider a larger number?

like

Hi Fishes, i am an IT auditor working on ITGC, SOX audit with EY. I have an MBA from Sydenham Mumbai. Total yoe 3.9
Can anyone please refer me?
I am currently too saturated with my job and profile.

like

Hii folks, 2 yoe java developer here, i want to pursue MBA from distant learning, can you please tell me which is best institute for this.

like

Can I study a different 2 year MBA for the remaining years of my life?

I am 26 so I think I can still enroll in around 50 different MBA programs.

likefunny

Looking at PE Ops exit opportunities and getting some bites but it’s ALL been at the VP level. Is it possible to enter at a higher level? Tenured EM and 6 years of operating experience prior to MBA / McK

like

Hi Fishes !
I need help! I wish to get my MBA from an Ivey League college (2024 batch)

My current company will give opportunities as a lead/manager role, Onsite opportunity (global exposure) with lesser pay (18LPA)

I now have a job offer from a Fortune 25 bank, which will provide brand value, exposure to finance domain (MBA Interest), a glimpse to how big organisations work and Managers with great experience to look up to and with higher pay (23 LPA)

Which opportunity is better?

like

Any Goizueta MBA grads that can speak to the number of full-tuition scholarships that are given out each year? I read on their website 4, but have heard that 50% of applicants receive scholarships so would imagine there are more.

Looking to break into management consulting and hoping to apply for scholarships.

like

Hi. I am currently an MBA candidate at Carolina University. I am an international student and I am originally from Mauritius. I am graduating next July and I will be requiring a job for my OPT. I want to apply to companies which would help to sponsor my H1B visa or Green card. I have seen mostly Tech companies sponsoring these visas, but I really want to know from this network, which companies (and location) would truly want to sponsor these types of visas. Please help me on this.

like

Related Posts

1. How much is the 4% bonus in CTC of DEUTSCHE BANK considering 36LPA to be fixed(excluding PF and Gratuity).

2. Also, Is the fixed salary really like only Income Tax deduction or any other deduction as well? Note: Just had a offer discussion with HR, yet to receive my offer letter

YOE : 10 Skillset: AWS Devops Deutsche Bank Deloitte Accenture Tata Consultancy PwC Citi

like

Is the CPA designation worth it? For me it would take me 1 year of PREP courses and 2 years of PEP until i can write the CFE. And I am 27 years old right now. Also wondering if it would be crazy to pursue the CPA while learning how to code to be a developer as well?

like

Is it worth it to pay for your own certification ?

like

Hello everyone! My co-worker and I are preparing for the SHRM certification exam and Hoping to take it in December. I’m looking to purchase the SHRM learning system books from someone that has already taken the exam this year. Can someone point me in the right direction?

like

Anyone with US Trust as a PCA? Looking for additional details in terms of the culture, day to day type of things and how you’re doing there vs. what the recruiter stated was the average?

like

Hi fishes,
My sister is completed B. Com - 2022 passed out.

Which is the best domain for her, if she want to move to IT industry.

*Data science
*Aws, Devops
*Oracle SQL. PLSQL

like

Hi! I have 9yoe in startup, hyper growth environments. I have a strong customer Quality Assurance process improvement background. I want to shift into becoming more of an IC vs people manager. With that in mind, what steps would get me there? Should I consider a PMP or Lean Six Sigma certification? Any other ideas? I feel so stuck and need a change. Thank you!

like

If you have your PMP, was it worth it?

like

Hi all, I am a Google Cloud Solution Architect (Infra), with 8 years of experience in cloud and telecom presales. I am GCP ACE and PDE certified and working on PCA certification next. Looking for references in Google and possible roles I can get into. Please suggest!

like

Hi fishes, Need suggestion which one to join PwC India or Infosys YOE 3+ SAP functional Associate consultant role PwC offers me 9 LPA + variable pay Infosys offers total ctc 9.6 LPA

Which is better to join and in terms of WLB, hikes , bonus, Work culture etc..
As I'm shifting frm domain based company into full time consultant firm.

likehelpful

Anyone know how to get a position as an HRBP without HRPB experience? All positions I've looked at want previous experience. Would over 5 years of HR experience and a PHR suffice, or what skills should be added to that?

like

Anyone volunteering with the upcoming CFE exam this week?

like

I start my journey of being more technical today. I am giving myself 2 yrs. I started a role doing IT controls, Identity and Access Management work. I have prior experience in UAT, business process controls (A-123). I am planning on passing the Security plus and CISSP certs within 2 yrs. Have a TS clearance. Any advice or reality check is welcome.
I will like to do cyber work in the Intelligence Community.

like

I am currently a medical biller and coder that just graduated. I am currently in an entry level position because I am still studying to get certified. I will have a year's work of exp in July and will sign a contract for another year because my boss is training me in more I don't know.

I'm wondering what the pay is for someone in my position without certification. I live with family and want to afford to move out but I am single and only make $18/hr. Is that standard or am I being underpaid?

like

Hi fishes,
Yoe-7 techstack - .net,MVC,webapi,azure certification (az-204) but no hands on azure projects.

Unisys- 23 Lpa(fixed) ,LWD - 23 oct ,CCTC -14.5
Given number of interviews but no one are ready to give more than this even if I reach last rounds.
I am confused right now like should give some more interviews or join the unisys?

Is unisys good company to join and how about wlb and hikes in unisys?

TIA

like

What is the best package one can get in current market scenario in SAP FICO S4 HANA
YOE- TOTAL 7.2 YRS
RELEVANT- 5.2 YRS
SAP S4 HANA CERTIFIED
ALSO PURSUING CHARTERED ACCOUNTANCY ( ACCA ,UK)

PLEASE NEED SUGGESTIONS GENUINELY, PLEASE HELP

like

Currently in ibanking as an associate and want to see if I can make the move to PE. Is the CAIA viewed favorably at all?

like

Additional Posts

Whats your TC and YOE in Canada? I'm at 130k with 8 YOE

like

Anyone know anything about Samsara it is an IoT start up

like

Anyone at Deloitte Healthcare willing to refer?

like

Anyone have any experience with DoorDash s&o final round cases? Have a “problem solving” interview, “operational excellence” interview and a “critical thinking” case. Any tips?

like

Is it just me or do your white corporate colleagues act almost scared of you and unsure how to interact? I’m a medium sized woman, polite, introverted. Makes no sense

like

My boss (atty) is so disorganized! I’ve been with him 6 months and he’s having a hard time delegating, sharing info and managing deadlines. I’ve organized the caseload to manage the deadlines. He says he wants me to help with discovery but when I offer to start on one, he says he needs to do it. (Since he might have to present as evidence) When I give him deadlines and ask for the docs he says he’ll get to it. It’s a small 1 man firm, and I’m the first assistant besides his wife. Any advice?

like
like

Just started a new Data Analyst position in which I have constant meetings with senior leadership and executives. I have a bad habit of giving too much background info and not getting straight to the point. I just feel like every little detail is important (even though that’s not always the case). Any tips for breaking this habit or just become more efficient with advising?

like

I have two job offers, one as a waiter and one as a bartender. Which one would you take? I’m thinking bartender for the tips.

like

Is $68k a good salary for a tax Senior in NC? Industry job. Input much appreciated 😊

like

Hi Fishes,

Currently on notice period and looking for opportunities in analytics.
YOE - 8. Tech stack - SQL, tableau, R, python, Excel

like

Which one to choose between Optum and Tiger Analytics for Data Scientist position? Where can I expect better data science domain expertise (In my previous companies I found very less understanding of Data Science practices as team)? Heared good things about both of these. Also hearing Tiger is expanding rapidly and getting some crap projects as well in the name of data science. Could someone put light on these things?
YOE: 4.5 Years
Tiger: 18L Fixed + 1L JB
Optum: 21L Fixed + 1.5L JB

How do you get opportunities to speak on panels? Is it based on networking?

like

How much would an analyst can get in jp morgan?

YOE- 3.5
Tech- Python, SQL, Bigdata, Spark, AWS.

Offer in hand - 14ctc

like

Hi,
I have got an offer from JPMC and I have another counter offer . Just wanted to understand if there is any probability for the JPMC offer to be revoked if I am renegotiating with them? Also, how many days before my LWD should I ask for renegotiation?

like

Does anyone have experience with NYC’s cottage laws as they pertain to homemade food businesses (i.e., baked goods)? I’m looking hear your experience with it, and whether it’s overly restrictive to the point that it wasn’t worth the effort for a side hustle.

like

American Airline q - if I have Gold status and an American Airlines credit card - does that mean I get two free checked bags or one

like

What's a good agency to go through to do travel nursing in California?

like

Is HSBC or Credit Suisse or for matter of fact, any account in EY is asking EY employees to work from office or to work in hybrid manner. Any account in EY which offers permanent WFH?

like

Hello everyone. My joining date is 20/10/22 in natwest.But still i did’nt get any mail regarding my joining formalities.can anyone explain me that how many days it will take to complete my pes verification.

like
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal